Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
Geppili · 28/01/2022 23:28

Meh. My mother privately educated us and considered that meant she could take us out of school every Friday to drive to a country manor house where we had horses.

Long term suspected labyrinthitis.

ConsiderablyRicherThanYow · 28/01/2022 23:24

It's a great example to set. As an adult your boss can tell you to do more calculations, ask you to rewrite your report. They can't tell you to do laps around the car park and play hockey with people that hate you. Adults aren't forced into exercise, secondary age children should also be given that dignity and autonomy.

amusedbush · 28/01/2022 23:24

People on this thread are crowing about the importance of exercise but I swear, my PE teachers had no interest in that. It was fucking humiliating being the slowest person in the class, trying your best while your teammates are aggressively screaming at you to hurry up because it's your fault the team is losing. I'm dyspraxic so I can't catch a ball, I can't jump over a hurdle, I can't throw straight and I can't remember a dance sequence, never mind execute it without tripping over my feet. Now I walk and I use my spin bike at home. Nothing complicated, no fancy movements or sequences or jumping around.

To the people frothing at the mouth about overweight children: have you never heard the phrase "you can't out-train a bad diet"? Exercise alone doesn't do much for weight. Even if you force all of these poor kids to suffer through PE, it will do absolutely fuck all if they are constantly overeating in between those one-hour lessons Hmm exercise should be about engaging in enjoyable movement for overall health (mental and physical) and nothing to do with weight.

Drunkpanda · 28/01/2022 23:23

@OhGingleBells

Sorry - meant to add that I actually did have a spell of regular migraines in year 7, assumed to be brought on by the combination of hormones and the stress of transitioning to secondary school!

Then proceeded to continue to suffer from migraines on convenient occasions the whole way through secondary…..

If she’s never had one just scroll through the NHS page and choose a combination of symptoms to describe if anyone asks. Doctors aren’t interested and anyone who has had one will definitely understand why she is trying to avoid ‘triggering’ one!

Ds recently saw a doctor with headaches - he was having an MRI in less than a week. I wouldn't make medical shit up.
TheOriginalEmu · 28/01/2022 23:23

@XelaM

Migranes are a ridiculous excuse out of PE, especially if your daughter is then sitting in the library reading and doing homework!

My dad has suffered with debilitating migraines his whole life and the eyes are the first to be affected so reading and working in the library when you have a real migraine would be impossible. And my dad is incredibly sporty and played team sports all his life despite migraines

Depends on how you’d migraines affect you. My dd also had debilitating migraines but they don’t affect her ability to read. Standing up makes her vomit, but sitting/lying down she can read. She is also very sporty, she rides competitively and plays team sports, but when she’s in a cluster attack they take her out of those things for a week or two at a time.
GeorgiaGirl52 · 28/01/2022 23:22

I skipped PE for two years by volunteering as a library aide one year and as an office aide for another year.

Other girls in my class used: Broken toe
Low blood pressure (causes dizziness)
Period cramps
Religious exemption (can't undress in public)

IrishMama2015 · 28/01/2022 23:22

OP I was overweight and PE ground my tiny bit of self esteem into the gutter. They weighed us regularly also. I was jeered by others when my turn was a wash out. I embarrassed myself routinely. Eventually my mom signed me out that god. I have a degree and a masters and never 'tried' this in any other subject. Being a teenager is hard enough. If PE is making them miserable sign them out

waterlego · 28/01/2022 23:22

@Teenylittlefella

"Not doing PE is not the same as not doing maths. It just isn't. Other lessons don't involve ritual humiliation"

Other lessons can and do involve ritual humiliation. If you can't read, or spell, how much fun do you think English is? Or history, geography, etc? If you are socially phobic, drama can be horrific. If you have memory problems, content heavy lessons are humiliating.

You were just lucky that the thing you found hard didn't underpin access to every subject.

Absolutely this!
MountainDweller · 28/01/2022 23:21

Give her crutches, tell her not to put any weight on one foot and say she has a cartilage tear in her ankle and is waiting for surgery. She can see what it's really like being incapacitated and make her future decision on PE based on that. She'll get plenty of exercise hauling herself around on the crutches!

XelaM · 28/01/2022 23:20

Migranes are a ridiculous excuse out of PE, especially if your daughter is then sitting in the library reading and doing homework!

My dad has suffered with debilitating migraines his whole life and the eyes are the first to be affected so reading and working in the library when you have a real migraine would be impossible. And my dad is incredibly sporty and played team sports all his life despite migraines

Asperula · 28/01/2022 23:19

My children go to an average local Comp and they don't have people on the staff who are sadistic bullies who enjoy humiliating kids. What sort of schools are these where they employ people like that?
How would you know?
Because I've got a dd in Year 13 and one in Year 10 and they talk about school to me?

TheOriginalEmu · 28/01/2022 23:18

@Asperula I meant to tag you in the above post, sorry.

TheOriginalEmu · 28/01/2022 23:18

Asperula

WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly
Team sportsmanship my arse 😂

Bullying, public humiliation, a lifetime of psychological issues. I wouldn’t care if my dc never did PE again.
That's awful that there's so much bullying and public humiliation at your dcs' school. I'd probably try and move them to another school if I were you

*the trouble is asperula, it’s the case in many many schools. I had undiagnosed disabilities that I actually fought against in order to do PE for as long as I could, but when I was subluxating a joint every other day I had to give in and stop playing netball and then my PE teacher turned on me and made my life hell. Then when I couldn’t do PE at all anymore she just called me lazy and fat and vain (with 5 layers of make up on her face).

PE can be hell and pretending otherwise helps no one.

blyn72 · 28/01/2022 23:18

I don't blame anyone for getting out of PE. I hated it, found it humiliating and scary, was completely useless, except for swimming which I quite enjoyed. Like your daughter, I walked a lot - miles sometimes - and grew up to be a fit person.

PE teachers had no sympathy, seemed unable to understand that some kids just can not.

My son also didn't like games but he is a more laid back person than I and didn't feel the panic, he just learned how to skive. He walked, cycled and swam, no problems.

Teenylittlefella · 28/01/2022 23:17

"Not doing PE is not the same as not doing maths. It just isn't. Other lessons don't involve ritual humiliation"

Other lessons can and do involve ritual humiliation. If you can't read, or spell, how much fun do you think English is? Or history, geography, etc? If you are socially phobic, drama can be horrific. If you have memory problems, content heavy lessons are humiliating.

You were just lucky that the thing you found hard didn't underpin access to every subject.

Katya213 · 28/01/2022 23:16

I used to ask my dad to write me a note to get off PE, he never would. I just hated the shame of always being picked last or the girl doing the picking turning to the teacher and saying”do we have to have her?” 😂

Foolsrule · 28/01/2022 23:16

All school PE did was put me off exercise! Everyone used to say they had polycistic ovaries in my day. Not sure if that would still fly?!

TheFairyCaravan · 28/01/2022 23:16

I think it’s an awful message to send to your daughter. She’s going to have to do tasks that she doesn’t like when she goes to work, she won’t be able to get you to come up with an excuse to get out of that. The teachers aren’t daft either and will cotton on that it’s bullshit. Don’t teach her to lie.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 28/01/2022 23:15

And if it was maths. Or English?

downbythewoods · 28/01/2022 23:13

@SenselessUbiquity

I am really curious as to why there is such a strong view that it's a terrible lesson that kids learn that they have some choice in what they do, and they don't have to do things they don't enjoy that have no value to them.

One of the worst lessons I ever learnt, and I learnt it far too well, is that you have to do everything other people want you to do. I have stuck at shit jobs and shit relationships far too long in my life. I am 50 now, and gosh life is short. I wish to god I'd wasted less of it on
this defeatist attitude that you just have to get on with things.

This x a million. Thank god, sense at last.
Fetchthevet · 28/01/2022 23:12

I was that child who was never picked too 😥 I'm in my 40s and can still remember the humiliation and how upset I felt. I was too short for netball, rubbish at hockey, couldn't throw anything far enough in athletics, always came last in races. I remember being forced to finish running around the school field even though I felt like I was dying. Soon after that I was diagnosed with severe anaemia and needed a blood transfusion- no wonder I was too knackered to run around a field. Left me with a life long hatred of exercise.

bearfood · 28/01/2022 23:12

Think you're getting a hard time here OP. You are teaching your child that you're on her side...I'm sure there's a very good reason she doesn't want to do PE.
I've given notes getting my girls out of PE and I work in a school! Sometimes it's needed.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 28/01/2022 23:11

I fucking hated PE and when I badly broke my arm the idea of getting out of PE really cheered me up.

However despite several fractures and a partial dislocation, which wasn't in plaster, I didn't get to sit in the library. Even though it would have been useful to catch up on work I was struggling with due to being one handed and having to leave lessons early to avoid crowds. I had to go to PE every lesson and stay with the class. I didn't have to change (I couldn't have done) but I had to keep score, time things, measure stuff, help get out and put away equipment etc. Thank god it was spring/summer so the weather was ok or it would have been even more awful.

It is not worth it.

ElEmEnOhPee · 28/01/2022 23:11

What sort of schools are these where they employ people like that?

My old local comp for one. I remember skiving from PE one day and I passed by the boys in the gym. The male PE teacher was yelling at them (as usual) and I'll never forget what that evil prick did. He made the biggest boy in the class take his top off in front of all the other boys and told yelled "Do you want to end up looking like Billy? Well do you!?" I almost burst into tears, Billy (not real name) was bright red and how he didn't cry I don't know, I wish I'd done something about it at the time but I just made an effort to be extra nice to Billy and stick up for him when he was picked on. Billy had no idea I'd seen it and I'd never have told him for fear of adding to his humiliation.

The PE teacher still works there now.

Anonymouseposter · 28/01/2022 23:10

..and it's not unusual for them to be attached to the P.E. department.