Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 00:17

[quote RosesAndHellebores]@Drunkpanda what precisely shoukd I be ashamed about. I never bullied anyone or made them cry or humiliated them. They did that to me. One thing I'll say is that it built my resilience at work and to think of the feelings of others.

I never said at the till "bra haa, you've turned into a fatso - couldn't you have done better? Perhaps they ended up with stodgy, pedestrian lives because they were just plain nasty and didn't deblvelop appropriate life skills.[/quote]
Possibly

DiddyHeck · 29/01/2022 00:16

@Maestoso

PE is part of body autonomy. It's absolutely not like maths or history. If your child is so unhappy that they've asked you to get them out of it then do it. PE is a humiliating pile of shit and breeding ground for bullies, it leaves long lasting emotional scars in many children and the sooner that's recognised the better. 40 years ago I got out of it by simply getting changed, walking out to whatever pitch and standing still for the duration. Literally refusing to move until the lesson ended. There's nothing they can do to make you move. Saddest time of my life.
See? More projection.

Honestly it makes me wonder how some people manage to raise well rounded, open minded kids when parents have this sort of attitude. You could say the same about absolutely any school lesson that the parents state was the 'saddest time of their lives'.

Your school days are over now. Stop re-living them through children.

oviraptor21 · 29/01/2022 00:16

If sport isn't exercise what is it? Hmm

The PE curriculum is much more varied than it used to be and includes non-competive exercise.
However, competition is not to be sneered at. Whether you're good or bad at whatever you're competing in (sporting/academic/artistic) there are life lessons to be learned which you won't get in a maths lesson, no matter how valuable the maths lesson may be.
And that is the point of having a balanced curriculum with a variety of subjects and learning types, so that our DC develop a variety of skills.

Finally, and bizarrely if mumsnet is anything to go by, most PE teachers are not bullies

Pinkstegosaurus · 29/01/2022 00:15

[quote RosesAndHellebores]@Drunkpanda what precisely shoukd I be ashamed about. I never bullied anyone or made them cry or humiliated them. They did that to me. One thing I'll say is that it built my resilience at work and to think of the feelings of others.

I never said at the till "bra haa, you've turned into a fatso - couldn't you have done better? Perhaps they ended up with stodgy, pedestrian lives because they were just plain nasty and didn't deblvelop appropriate life skills.[/quote]
I too find your comments quite upsetting, I was reasonably good at some sports when I was in school, never talented particularly but I took part in most things, I have also worked a variety of jobs including behind a till and feel quite sad that someone like you would look down on me because of it (I also put weight on after I left school, so glad you’d also take delight in that too) I am also of the opinion that having a go at everything at least gives you the opportunity to rule out what you don’t like!

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 00:13

@Asperula

Which tells you that they are not the ones getting stick, says nothing about others, guarantee some kids are being bullied by some staff and pupils without a shadow of a doubt No they would mention if they'd seen that.
If
RosesAndHellebores · 29/01/2022 00:13

@Asperula my apologies. I didn't mean to upset you or anyone else personally vi's a vi's weight or working in a supermarket. However, I do think there's a parallel between what affords success at school and what actually matters later in life. PE certainly does not represent cutting edge life skills later on. I am sorry if I put that in sensitively and I do understand dd has adhd and keeping her on the straight and narrow has not been easy. It certainly wasn't helped by school PE culture and I fought very hard against that.

BeaLola · 29/01/2022 00:13
  • obesity and never ended up working behind a till.

But sport is so very very important. No it isn't, exercising is. Eating well is. Being kind is. Being empathetic is.*

Well you don't come across as very kind and what is wrong with working behind a till ?

Maestoso · 29/01/2022 00:12

PE is part of body autonomy. It's absolutely not like maths or history. If your child is so unhappy that they've asked you to get them out of it then do it. PE is a humiliating pile of shit and
breeding ground for bullies, it leaves long lasting emotional scars in many children and the sooner that's recognised the better. 40 years ago I got out of it by simply getting changed, walking out to whatever pitch and standing still for the duration. Literally refusing to move until the lesson ended. There's nothing they can do to make you move. Saddest time of my life.

CJsGoldfish · 29/01/2022 00:12

I didn't like PE. My dd doesn't particularly like PE. I'd never lie for her though and I'd never devalue subjects as you have just because I don't think they are important. If she wants out, she can figure it out herself 🤷‍♀️

Rather than asking randoms for excuses you can use to lie why not go with the truth. Tell them your snowflake doesn't like it, you don't think it's important and she won't be participating when it's cold? Surely that's a better way to go, not to mention a better lesson?

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 00:10

@Asperula

I'm surprised at a school letting kids sit in the library if they are missing PE. It's practically encouraging kids to skip PE so they can hang out with their friends there rather than attend a lesson. They could end up with hardly any doing PE and most getting a note from their parents to have time out of lessons
Save the school some money then when they no longer need a pet
DiddyHeck · 29/01/2022 00:09

@RosesAndHellebores

I've said it all before on her op and can't be bothered tonsay it again. You have my full and absolute support.

I was poo at PE. It made my life a misery, as it made dd's a misery.

Funny how all the uber sporty PE favourites at my school were also the school bullies. What was even better was bumping into them in their size 18 M&S uniforms at the checkout in their mid thirties. They looked knackered as well.

It really helped my self esteem. Having been crap at sport I'm delighted to say I maintained a size 10 until my 30's and even now in my 60s have never reached the heights of an 18 or obesity and never ended up working behind a till.

But sport is so very very important. No it isn't, exercising is. Eating well is. Being kind is. Being empathetic is.

But sport is so very very important. No it isn't, exercising is. Eating well is. Being kind is. Being empathetic is.

Well you appear to have missed out on at least the last two things there, according to this post. At least you might've been good at netball if you gave it a chance...

Theluggage15 · 29/01/2022 00:09

What the hell is wrong with working behind a till @RosesAndHellebores. You just sound nasty.

DiddyHeck · 29/01/2022 00:06

@HelloKittyGirl

Those asking what will change in a few weeks time…

The weather!

(Although yes, I do realise there’ll be other years before anyone points that out. The PE requirement at her school drops quite considerably though after Year 9)

The weather???

Poor diddums. I'm now going to assume she's wrapped in bubble wrap and driven everywhere in case she dissolves in the rain. In which case the last thing this kid needs is a mother trying to get her out of physical exercise because 'weather' Hmm

FrownedUpon · 29/01/2022 00:06

That’s so pathetic-sorry. She doesn’t want to do PE because of the weather?? Seriously, you need to parent your child and support the school. I feel so sorry for teachers these days.

Asperula · 29/01/2022 00:05

Which tells you that they are not the ones getting stick, says nothing about others, guarantee some kids are being bullied by some staff and pupils without a shadow of a doubt
No they would mention if they'd seen that.

yummumto3girls · 29/01/2022 00:02

I’ve heard it all, what terrible parenting, no wonder they get called the snowflake generation!

Asperula · 29/01/2022 00:02

RosesAndHellebores. I'm guessing you are not too bothered about how people who work on a till feel reading your post. It's obviously something you really look down onConfused

RosesAndHellebores · 29/01/2022 00:01

@Drunkpanda what precisely shoukd I be ashamed about. I never bullied anyone or made them cry or humiliated them. They did that to me. One thing I'll say is that it built my resilience at work and to think of the feelings of others.

I never said at the till "bra haa, you've turned into a fatso - couldn't you have done better? Perhaps they ended up with stodgy, pedestrian lives because they were just plain nasty and didn't deblvelop appropriate life skills.

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 00:01

@Asperula

My children go to an average local Comp and they don't have people on the staff who are sadistic bullies who enjoy humiliating kids. What sort of schools are these where they employ people like that? How would you know? Because I've got a dd in Year 13 and one in Year 10 and they talk about school to me?
Which tells you that they are not the ones getting stick, says nothing about others, guarantee some kids are being bullied by some staff and pupils without a shadow of a doubt
RJnomore1 · 29/01/2022 00:00

It is utter shit. I hated it abd went on to compete at national level in my chosen sport as an adult

amusedbush · 28/01/2022 23:59

[quote RosesAndHellebores]@amusedbush you said that so.much better than I just did.[/quote]
Thank you for the compliment, though in response to your own comment, I’m afraid I actually am a size 18. My weight has yo-yoed by several stones by whole life due to binge eating secondary to undiagnosed ADHD.

Being fat isn’t a moral failing. In fact, I was horrifically bullied throughout school (search my name and find my posts if you like). My school bully was at my brother’s wedding last year and she is still a size 8.

I find your post really upsetting, judgemental and fatphobic. Being thin isn’t a victory and it doesn’t make you better than anyone else.

Thatsplentyjack · 28/01/2022 23:58

Oh I love how worked up people are getting about this. P.E is fucking shit. I dreaded it everytime. I was always "forgetting my stuff".
My ds loved P.E in primary school. He did athletics for the school team, he never forgot his P.E kit. Went to high school and that all changed quickly. Now he's always trying to get out of it because it's utter shit.

Sux2Buthen · 28/01/2022 23:57

@Drunkpanda

Lying isn't something I'd want to teach my dc to be honest
Don't worry, they will learn it themselves
summersun22 · 28/01/2022 23:56

You're brave posting this OP!

I must have had a terrible mother too, she often wrote me notes to get out of swim class Grin Did me no harm, and I have two degrees!

safclass · 28/01/2022 23:55

I dont get theat everyone gets changed even if they can't do pe. Our Ddil had a catastrophic accident as a teenager, could have died. Was taken into crash team at A&E. Her injuries (with scarring) meant she physically could not do pe but she was made to change into pe kit 'to be part of it'. Mentally that caused major issues of having others seeing her scars / seeing her 'broken body' . Cruel and totally unnecessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread