Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
avamiah · 29/01/2022 03:08

@blyn72

Can a pupil just refuse to do PE at school nowadays?
Not in my daughters secondary school .
blyn72 · 29/01/2022 03:05

Can a pupil just refuse to do PE at school nowadays?

doorornottodoor · 29/01/2022 02:58

I hated PE too at school.

But I think teaching your daughter to lie to get out of something she doesn’t want to do is terrible parenting. Surely it would be better for her to go and speak to the teacher?

ttpco · 29/01/2022 02:58

What ever you go for just be careful the school don't end up asking for a letter from her doctor as proof, say if you said it was tennis elbow.

CharlotteRose90 · 29/01/2022 02:54

Asthma and vertigo were mine but I actually have them.

expat101 · 29/01/2022 02:54

I have read your replies HelloKittyGirl and I'm going to tell you this.

My Uncle says as a child, their DM got his sister, my DM, off from doing PE at school and my DM used to spend the time in the library, which she ''preferred'' to be doing...

Fast forward to today, my DM is well into her 80's and wheel chair bound. The hospital where she lives has to use a medical hoist to be able to get her to stand, move from the WC to toilet and back again, and also to assist with getting her in and out of bed.

Ever since I can remember, Doctors have been telling her to exercise more, which she didn't. The Doctor was always wrong!

I have sat with her in one of our major hospitals after a fall, to hear specialists say she needs to exercise more. Once back at the hospital where she lives, she ''forgets'' this advice and if reminded of it, says they are wrong! These are specialists who have spent years studying to get where they are career wise.

I have also experienced DM, getting craftier as she gets older and if she doesn't want to do something, she out right will not do it. So at a young age, Mum was taught by my Grandmother by letting off her PE, that if she didn't want to do something, she didn't have too. And that has stuck with her for her entire life!

My DM won't even move her feet to put her slippers on, she expects that I, or a nurse, will bend over and do it for her while she looks on. However, while getting herself along in the wheelchair, she is quite capable of using her feet to ''walk'' the chair along.

She now has a permanent sore on one of her ankles so is now wearing a pressure stocking. It's not healing and her lower leg is slowly turning purple. I suggested to her she needs to start exercising, and the hospital agrees. However with the chair-based cycle device, she could use, she will not try to turn the pedals...

So before you start making excuses for your Daughter to get out of PE, think about what else you are setting up for her to avoid long term. Sometimes you have to accept that some things are done for more than one reason, and its not always obvious why.

Participation, engagement and social cooperation for starters.

Kgutdfn · 29/01/2022 02:49

I hated PE but I was a good student and worked hard. Doing PE in the last year gave me a lot of stress and a get out of PE letter helped me to focus on my subjects and not dread the days that we had PE. My mum just wrote a note for sore knee problems and that did the trick.

DragonMovie · 29/01/2022 02:38

@WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly was that how you found PE at school? You might find it’s changed now.

Love the name.

I agree with everyone else - kids who can freely access parental excuses for subjects they don’t like, detentions end up being a bit of a nightmare and very unresilient

cocktailclub · 29/01/2022 02:37

Some of the responses here are ridiculous.
I think schools need to do better with PE lessons so pupils don't feel anxious about them if they seriously want everyone to develop a habit of physical activity.
Because I don't agree that skipping PE will ruin your daughters future career, chances of getting a degree, or place an unnecessary burden on the teaching staff I'm suggesting she has some soft tissue damage to her knee that requires rest from anything more strenuous than walking.
Also some posters need to relax a bit.

Pixxie7 · 29/01/2022 02:36

PE is an essential part of the curriculum so why would you want to encourage her to miss it. Let alone think of the message you are sending her, if she doesn’t want to do it let her sort it out.

whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 02:25

Sorry for the typos

*cindy Crawford

I still remember the summer I tried to break my leg to get out of mixed PE trampolining where all the boys stood round the trampoline watching you. The fear ruined my summer.

whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 02:22

I remember being 14 doing mixed PE and the teacher putting on coney Crawfords aerobics dvd (lots of boob shots) for us to do. Boys behind the cheerleader/gymnastic girls ogling them whilst we slightly bigger girls stood at the back in our horrific unflattering PE gear clock watching.

Cross country running, again mixed, where the boys would ogle the girls boobs.

The girls who seed to have a period every week to get out PE

The poor showers with no curtains

Put me off PE for life.

By making me attend it didn't make me fitter or get me into PE. I just stood at the back resenting the whole thing. If there was a team sport I'd purposely hit the ball to be out immediately and sit on the bench.

Teachers had no awareness at all of teenage girls.

Google an ailment any ailment and write that note

Marcipex · 29/01/2022 01:49

One of our pe teachers wasn’t a sadist, but she didn’t stay for very long. Others were.

I was slim and reasonably good at games until I developed a dodgy knee, but I hated the showers where we had to strip off, walking gingerly on the slimy wooden slats, and leaving our towels in the changing area.
The teacher would stand in the doorway eyeing us up, while we slid sideways past trying not to touch her.
She didn’t fancy bony little me, it was the well-developed girls she was keen on.

How we hated her. My dodgy knee came in very useful.

skeptile · 29/01/2022 01:46

I hated PE at school. I was much happier sitting and watching. Outside of school, I was training heavily in my individual sport and competing at state and national level. I just loathed school sport.

Aria999 · 29/01/2022 01:41

DH as a child got out of cross country running by simply refusing to do it on the grounds that detention was preferable.

Changechangychange · 29/01/2022 01:35

@LethargicActress

You really want to be that parent?
OP is quite clearly already 100% “that parent”
lolololloo · 29/01/2022 01:23

Honestly, I never did PE when I went to senior school. Couldn't be bothered and it never actually did me any harm. Not overweight, still did plenty of exercise. My DD loves sport but if she didn't want to do it I wouldn't force her either. Maths, English etc are important subjects but PE can be achieved other ways such as extra curricular activities. I honestly don't think it's a big deal.

StopStartStop · 29/01/2022 01:23

OP, get her out of PE if you can find a way. I was about to day the teachers are sadists, but someone beat me to it.

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 01:22

@Rollingwiththehomies

I loved P.E until I was 14 and the teacher non discreetly said I need to go and get a well fitted sports bra. The whole class heard and I was laughed at and jeered as I walked back from just doing the hurdles. Pure humiliation and I never took part again - ever! Some of the stories I hear coming from my dd’s school aren’t too far removed. I don’t think people really understand how demeaning P.E can be for some pupils.
Or care
nocoolnamesleft · 29/01/2022 01:19

I don't think anyone's saying every single PE teacher is a sadistic bully. I can only say that every PE teacher I ever met at school was a sadistic bully. That may be a statistical blip...

Rollingwiththehomies · 29/01/2022 01:16

I loved P.E until I was 14 and the teacher non discreetly said I need to go and get a well fitted sports bra. The whole class heard and I was laughed at and jeered as I walked back from just doing the hurdles. Pure humiliation and I never took part again - ever! Some of the stories I hear coming from my dd’s school aren’t too far removed. I don’t think people really understand how demeaning P.E can be for some pupils.

Flynnqwer · 29/01/2022 00:58

I had a lovely maths teacher (who was also my Head of Year) who wrote a note getting me out of PE for the last term of Year 9. I sat in the library or an empty maths classroom unsupervised and it was bloody marvellous.

I don’t know why people are bothered about OP’s DD missing PE. She gets enough exercise so what is she actually going to miss out on? It doesn’t teach children anything.

tolerable · 29/01/2022 00:56

hahahaha! selective ciriculum!!
i favour honesty.id write requesting excused from pe replaced by permitted time libuary as ongoing sensitive issue you guaranteed her wont be discussed

Maestoso · 29/01/2022 00:55

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Maestoso I am not a teacher so het of your high horse
Your throwing accusations around which if true you should be reporting
Your basically saying all pe teachers are bullies , [/quote]
Think you've referred to the wrong person. I'm not on a high horse and haven't said or inferred that all PE teachers are bullies.

Topseyt · 29/01/2022 00:49

I do empathise with your DD.

I hated school PE. It was a lesson in abject misery and humiliation. I couldn't wait to drop it, which I did at the age of 13 (this was the late seventies). If I had been forced to carry it on then it is the only lesson I would have truanted from, and I was not otherwise that way inclined.

I don't see any harm in saying that you would prefer her to spend her time in the library doing more useful things such as working on her other subjects. Provided that that is absolutely what she does.

I wish that could have been done for me, rather than having to endure the ritual horror and bullying that was secondary school PE.

Swipe left for the next trending thread