Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
sashh · 29/01/2022 07:37

@motherrunner

My husband is a PE teacher. He will wax lyrical about the benefits of PE on the curriculum from improved physical and mental health to resilience and working as a team.

you may think your child is slim and fit but if they don’t have at least 30 minutes a day cardio then they aren’t improving their fitness and will encourage them to be sedentary their whole lives.

My DCs (10 and 7) play football for outside teams, run 5k 3 times a week, swim, play tennis in the summer. If your DC is doing that outside of school I could see your point. Waking to school and back - not cardio!

I bet your DH enjoyed PE at school?

I also bet he wasn't forced to do PE in what is basically underwear, most girls seem to have to wear tiny shorts or skorts.

You need 30 mins exercise 3 times a week, not every day to keep fit. And that exercise is anything that gets you out of breath.

AnneofRedGables · 29/01/2022 07:10

School Librarian here. Can’t abide this attitude of ‘stick them in the library, they’ll be no trouble in there.’ Actually, yes, it’s a blooming nuisance because any time I get between having classes in the library I need to spend running around school getting my printing and copying done, taking my orders to the finance office, collecting orders that have arrived, dealing with post, phoning parents in privacy away from little ears, the list goes on… when students are unexpectedly placed with me it means I’m tied to supervising them and all my other work gets put on hold when my ‘free’ periods are already few and far between. So yes, you ARE asking for extra support and supervision and frankly being a pain in the posterior because school worth it’s salt would let a child sit unsupervised for a whole lesson. But as long as daughter dearest is ok, eh?

N0va · 29/01/2022 07:00

Mine was ongoing colicky hips that were painful, then progressed to requesting as a free period instead of watching everyone else do pe while I sat in a pe kit (school imagined I would revise/do homework). Occasional excuses were: period pain, migraines that could be triggered, stomach ache, body confidence/self esteem, general trauma/depression/stress. There were a few more too, some genuine, some not!

Youngstreet · 29/01/2022 06:55

[quote worriedatthemoment]@mummykel16 really how
Use threatening behaviour yourself ?
If you seriously know of a teacher bullying your report it so that its dealt with and that person no longer bulies [/quote]
How lovely to live in your naive world.

Piglet89 · 29/01/2022 06:47

I didn’t like PE either OP - but (just food for thought) you can make lifelong friends doing sport and once I got to Cambridge, loads and loads of people were extremely sporty, but I was useless at most of it.

I really regret my parents not emphasising sport from a young age. Even now, my mum has the warped idea that you can’t actually be academic and sporty.

Aside from which, it’s disrespectful to a teacher to lie for your daughter to get out of that subject.

Life isn’t all academics.

BABAHOTEL · 29/01/2022 06:44

It won't be for a few weeks, she'll want the same next term.

She should be attending, it's not a pick and mix with school lessons!

Grasping · 29/01/2022 06:43

It’s part of the curriculum, you can’t just opt out because you feel like it. What would happen if everyone did that?

Allycott · 29/01/2022 06:38

You know, there are lots of things in life that we have to do without particularly wanting to which seem unfair: paying taxes, getting up at 6.00 to get the bus to work in the rain, picking up the workload of a sick colleague, the list is endless. But carry on mom, set the tone. Then when in a few years your child's manager at work asks her to take part in a project/allocates an assignment or just to work a bit later you can bail her out of that as well.

motherrunner · 29/01/2022 06:20

My husband is a PE teacher. He will wax lyrical about the benefits of PE on the curriculum from improved physical and mental health to resilience and working as a team.

you may think your child is slim and fit but if they don’t have at least 30 minutes a day cardio then they aren’t improving their fitness and will encourage them to be sedentary their whole lives.

My DCs (10 and 7) play football for outside teams, run 5k 3 times a week, swim, play tennis in the summer. If your DC is doing that outside of school I could see your point. Waking to school and back - not cardio!

BritishDesiGirl · 29/01/2022 05:50

@HelloKittyGirl

I don’t have a problem with it to be honest. I never liked PE either and she already gets plenty of exercise walking to and from school everyday. I’m not worried about her fitness levels. If she’d rather spend the time in the library doing homework, I’m happy with that.
Wow. Your going to lie to get your child out of something just because you don't have a problem with it?

Is that the life lesson you want to teach her?

What makes you feel she is more special than other kids who have other actual problems but don't get to skip a subject because of it.

Shame on you, OP

doorornottodoor · 29/01/2022 05:23

@Joystir59 but you were doing plenty of exercise anyway by the sounds of things? So at least you were getting all those benefits. Also, PE teaching has changed hugely over the years.

Joystir59 · 29/01/2022 05:15

I loathed PE at school, would have loved extra time in the library with my books. I walked approx 6 miles a day and sea swim, am slim fit active and in my sixties now so I don't think ducking out of PE at every available opportunity did me any harm.

doorornottodoor · 29/01/2022 04:56

I think it’s a shame that people are projecting their hatred of PE onto their children. Things have changed so much. I’m a teacher and our PE staff are lovely, really approachable and want the best for for the children. It’s not just about sport it’s about the mental and physical health boost of exercise. Setting up good habits. There should be something for everyone in this day and age.

whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 04:54

I probably should've been honest with my PE teachers and gave them a performance review that basically they were lazy (putting on a Cindy Crawford dvd is not a PE lesson) they needed to consider different students needs and capabilities - one size doesn't always fit all, yes mixed PE may make your job easier but it's scarring me and also you're putting off [from exercise] a whole section of teenage girls

doorornottodoor · 29/01/2022 04:50

@Nat6999 is your son not doing any sport at all? All children should be doing some form of exercise for health reasons.

Nat6999 · 29/01/2022 04:47

I stopped doing PE after Y9, just never took my kit & the teachers never bothered. Ds didn't do any PE from the end of Y8, he has a problem with his legs & I just sent a note at the beginning of the year to excuse him. He probably could have done some of it but he hated it like I did. It's time schools accepted some pupils just aren't interested in sport & let them not waste the time but attend other subjects.

Subbaxeo · 29/01/2022 04:37

I was shit at sports with anything to do with a ball and loathed PE due to poor eyesight. Never being picked, the humiliation! I thought I hated exercise. It took me years to realise I just don’t enjoy sport-there are loads of other was to e physically active and if schools maybe encouraged this in their Physical Education lessons, they wouldn’t have problems with people wanting to drop out.
And skiving PE never hurt my career!
Maybe get your daughter to talk to an approachable PE teacher. They surely want their pupils to have reasonable engagement with the lessons?

namechangedforthisoneok · 29/01/2022 04:36

Don't teach your child that it's ok to lie!

Teach them that sometimes in life they have to do things that they don't want to!

whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 04:34

Absolutely agree that kids need to be taught sometimes to get on with it but if my kids came to me in adulthood and said they were doing something they hated, felt humiliated in, caused deep anxiety I would tell them to make changes and not to keep on with it.

Not everything you're taught in school or the way you're treated in school is healthy and good for you.

Poppins2016 · 29/01/2022 04:15

To clarify:

*sick and shaky due to anxiety

(If only there was an edit button...)

Poppins2016 · 29/01/2022 04:11

[quote randomchap]Why doesn't she want to do it? I understand preferring to do something else, but getting your mum to lie to the teachers is a bit much.

It'd be far better for her for you to get to the bottom of her issues than giving her an excuse to avoid it.

Too many girls drop out of PE, this can have negative effects for them in the long term. A good article here

www.theguardian.com/sport/2017/nov/08/girls-engaging-school-sports-solution[/quote]
That article was interesting.

PE was very much 'pink' and 'blue' at my secondary school. Girls never played rugby or cricket and boys never played netball. Girls were predominantly made to play team sports with no free choice and boys were allowed free choice, e.g. rugby or athletics. Boys were coached and told how they could achieve more (without discriminating), whereas girls only received coaching if they appeared to have talent (so the gap widened further between talented pupils and the weaker participants).

There was very little theory or training given. I thought I was terrible at everything (although I enjoyed having a go when we had the rare chance to do athletics), however it turns out that I'm actually quite good at things like running, etc. as long as I build up stamina. We were thrown into activities like running cross country without working up to it, so many of us ended up dropping out, feeling sick, having stitches, walking and ending the lesson late, etc... you'd have thought this would flag the need for buulding up stamina but the staff didn't seem to learn. Due to this approach, I ended up assuming that everyone should naturally be able to run 2k easily without training, therefore I and many other girls 'couldn't run'.
Bullying of people (me) who were no good at PE, especially at team sports, was the norm and teachers just turned a blind eye.

I ended up feeling physically sick and shaky on PE days and I'd say it tainted my entire experience of secondary school education... In no other area of education would you be thrown in the deep end and expected to either sink or swim. If you struggled with maths or science, for example, the teacher would focus on areas of struggle and coach you through it. With PE, the teachers seemed to adopt a 'no good = don't bother' approach.

Anyway, I've gone off on a bit of a tangent, but I thought I'd add my experience as a bit of insight into a) why many girls don't 'like' PE and b) what needs to change in order to get girls to participate with enjoyment. I realise it's just the view of one person, but others I've spoken to have expressed similar views.

sashh · 29/01/2022 04:02

[quote SE13Mummy]@catchingzzzeds "Our school have a good system where they must still get changed into kit and be wherever the lesson is taking place"

My DC2 with their broken limb has just said a new PE teacher is bringing in this rule and the consequence for not getting changed is a detention. Getting dressed is really hard for DC2 at the moment as it is. Walking to school carrying a PE kit, and then carrying it around all day (no lockers or anywhere to leave the kit) is going to make a difficult, painful time all the more difficult and painful. DC2 wants to be able to join in with PE but can't because of the broken limb. To be made to get changed into their kit doesn't feel helpful or kind. They've attended PE lessons without being able to join in and it's pretty obvious the injury hasn't been made up! Whilst I understand that requiring students to get changed if it's believed that they are trying to be elsewhere is one strategy, I can't see its benefits to children with broken limbs![/quote]
School has a 'duty of care' to your child. Forcing a child to do something that causes pain is not in their or the school's interests.

Ask the school for the risk assessment the PE teacher has carried out for your child. Until then your child will not be taking in a PE kit due to the difficulties and pain caused. Your child will also not be attending any detentions or other sanctions.

OP

Something that needs investigations is a good option.

Back in the days of riding dinosaurs to school when we took options we were supposed to include a PE session but in the PE teacher's words, "If you are going to forget your kit one week, be ill the next etc don't pick it as an option".

SquirrelG · 29/01/2022 03:58

Are you serious? What sort of mother are you????

This! Bloody hell! I didn't like PE either, but didn't ask my mother to help me get out of it as I knew what her reaction would be. We all have to do things we don't want to do and don't like, and it's better to learn that as a child than as an adult.

1forAll74 · 29/01/2022 03:42

You would not have been able to skip PE in the oldie days in my case, such as the 1950 era, unless you had a broken leg and the like. We simply had to do inside and outside stuff, Outside was net ball, and rounders,and hockey, whatever the weather, Inside was leaping over the horse,that it was called, and junping over a high box thing, and walking along a wooden plank thing for balance training,.. I personally hated all this stuff, but you just had to do it, but I am not sporty at all. My late mum would never have written to the school,to get me off at all. She would have said,, if this is what you have to do at school, just do it. and that was that.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 29/01/2022 03:21

I think you are wrong to pander to your daughter in this way.
She needs to learn that, in life, we frequently have to do things we would prefer not to.
So long as your DD is not being bullied by the sport teacher or actively incapable of doing sport, then she should just suck it up as a life lesson and get on with it.

It's appalling to teach her that she can lie to get out of doing things - what kind of moral code is that to give your child?!