Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
OhWhyNot · 29/01/2022 09:59

So many on here are talking about how much they hated PE. I hated PE so what we had to get on with it we were not allowed the excuse im on my period unless it was swimming. And this is only temporary until the weather improves …

In life we will often come across things we do not like, do not want to do, not want to engage in. Few children will love every single class at school. My family is never going to be an artist finds art boring and a waste of time should I pull him out so he can do what he would prefer Hmm How many children love doing their homework. Not many …

This entitled attitude is awful and who are the first parents to complain about others acting entitled usually the ones that allow their children to be. So many parents have this attitude it’s shocking if there is real concerns then discuss with the school but they should still have to participate in some way not wonder off to do something they prefer (homework in class time)

teatime9999 · 29/01/2022 09:51

She's old enough to try to come up with her own ideas for getting out of PE. Tell her to get creative, and see what happens!

Gonnagetgoing · 29/01/2022 09:50

[quote FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman]@MermaidEyes me too - I was bullied incessantly in PE by teachers and students, due to my lack of coordination and clumsiness. I suppose nowadays I'd be diagnosed with dyspraxia or similar.
I also had horrendous periods and any form of movement was torture.
Unfortunately, on our first day of school we were addressed by the head of PE in the changing rooms and told that periods were not an excuse for missing a lesson, exercise was good for period pain, letters from parents wouldn't be accepted etc.
She was an absolute, utter bitch who made my life hell for the whole five years.[/quote]
@FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman - my teacher was only one for a year when I was 9 and she also was my form teacher who taught and loved maths which I disliked (preferred English). Because she was so nasty re maths and PE I had real issues with them after this but luckily played rounders with friends. Unsurprisingly she’s a sad lonely old woman whom I sometimes see round my old local area but never say hello to.

In my secondary school one was rough as hell so PE could be challenging but I liked and enjoyed dance lessons (Fame! on tv had just started airing) and we also did volleyball a few times which I liked too. In my private school we had nice PE teachers who could see I didn’t like it but encouraged me and I got better at rounders but hated netball. Once we did meditation in class and I used to do this at home and I recall teacher being impressed I could do it,

I sort of wish my parents had encouraged me (DF was a champion runner and hurdler and played for England and Arsenal schoolboys but he divorced my mum when I was young and then didn’t see him til
I was 13) but mum hated PE as no good at school and they only encouraged us in walking, tennis and swimming. Though did pay for horse riding etc. A very sporty friend from primary school (netball Queen etc) doesn’t play it at all now, neither does her friend). The two sporty pin up boys one joined army and is a part time personal trainer and the other played tennis for years in local courts. Other local very sporty boy got out of condition in 20s, had back issue and got very overweight until he lost loads recently.

inheritancetrack · 29/01/2022 09:49

A walk to school isn't adequate and PE is about team work, different sports and exercise is important for younger people. She doesn't need a library and can do work at home. It's a really odd request tbh

CouncilHousedAndViolentBaby · 29/01/2022 09:47

Doctors note if it's affecting her mental health
Mine had one for drama

JohnMcCainsDeathStare · 29/01/2022 09:46

To those people who go on about getting out of Maths and English - do you have to take your clothes off and put other clothes on in those lessons?
And what exactly happens in Maths that could make you blow a kneecap?

Answers please.

northumberlandavenue · 29/01/2022 09:45

I offer no suggestions because I think it is wrong. What I think you should be doing OP is finding out why your DD does not like or want to do PE. One thing where I think schools should improve is in the range of sport/exercise offered, and in the clothing worn.

Intheopinionofourexpert · 29/01/2022 09:44

[quote worriedatthemoment]@5foot5 why would a verucca swing it , its not bare foot
Pretty sure they don't do waltzing now
Most of the ones complaining are comparing to pe 30/40 years ago
They do so much more now in schools
Trampolining , badminton, wheelchair basketball all sorts [/quote]
Trampolining and badminton are no better. In fact making a child who struggles with coordination exercise on a trampoline in front of everyone else would be awful. And any racquet/bat sport can be just about impossible for these children.

If people have never felt the humiliation that PE brings to those who can't do it, they will never understand how it feels, nor the damage it does.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 09:43

PE is important

Uh, why, exactly?

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 09:42

@Momicrone

Aren't you building her up to be the sort of person who just takes sick days off work willy nilly
Yeah, because everyone who skives PE in year 7 goes on to be a lazy good for nothing who never turns up for work and takes the day off to watch This Morning Wink
GreenWhiteViolet · 29/01/2022 09:31

@Momicrone

Aren't you building her up to be the sort of person who just takes sick days off work willy nilly
When someone posts about their workplace having some kind of shitty 'team building' day involving physical activities or something else the poster would find very difficult or embarrassing and which is completely unrelated to the job they've been hired to do, general MN consensus is that avoiding it is okay.

Avoiding your actual job is different, and unrelated, because you wouldn't apply for a job if the role included physical activities you hated.

FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman · 29/01/2022 09:30

@MermaidEyes me too - I was bullied incessantly in PE by teachers and students, due to my lack of coordination and clumsiness. I suppose nowadays I'd be diagnosed with dyspraxia or similar.
I also had horrendous periods and any form of movement was torture.
Unfortunately, on our first day of school we were addressed by the head of PE in the changing rooms and told that periods were not an excuse for missing a lesson, exercise was good for period pain, letters from parents wouldn't be accepted etc.
She was an absolute, utter bitch who made my life hell for the whole five years.

Momicrone · 29/01/2022 09:21

Aren't you building her up to be the sort of person who just takes sick days off work willy nilly

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 29/01/2022 09:08

@Hercisback

It's not about whether you have a problem with it, or if she'd rather be in the library. You're reinforcing the message that if she doesn't like a subject she doesn't have to do it. You wouldn't write a note to get her out of maths lessons. PE is exactly the same.

In our school you don't get to sit in the library if you aren't participating. You are a ref, or score keeper, or line judge. Funnily enough not many kids don't do it, because they know they'll be doing part of the lesson anyway.

All of this^

Life sucks and sometimes you have to do things you don't like. Better to learn it now than when you've quit your 5th job in a row after a couple of weeks because you don't like it. Better now than not going to lectures at uni because you don't like it and then failing the exam.
PE is important.

SusanBland · 29/01/2022 08:42

This thread has brought back so many funny memories for me of how I dodged PE for years. I remember in junior school writing a note from my nan (was too scared to do one from my dad in case I got found out) and signing it from 'Betty' 😂. I used to hide in various places around the school until I was sure they had all left the changing rooms then just have a wander around. I don't think you should lie for her though OP, she needs to come up with her own methods to avoid it, it's a good opportunity to build problem solving and handwriting forgery skills.

clpsmum · 29/01/2022 08:26

@HelloKittyGirl

Bandaging up a limb or even finger for weeks is going a bit far though.

I’ll have a look into tennis elbow…. Thank you.

Telling her it's ok to lie to avoid something she doesn't like doing at school is going a bit far tbh
Maray1967 · 29/01/2022 08:26

I would have loved it if my mum had got me off PE as I hated it.
But it taught me a valuable lesson which academic kids need to learn - other people are better at things than you are. My DC2 would love it too but there is no way I would do this. All you are doing is letting her think that she can opt out of things she doesn’t like. As an adult she’ll be able to opt out of many things but not all. Best she learns now and knuckles down and does her best and gets the exercise. I learned to view it as exercise and a lesson in self control as I was being useless on the netball pitch and shouted at by the teacher.

Nomorefuckstogive · 29/01/2022 08:20

I also hated P-E at school, but now love exercising. P-E shouldn’t be awful - at our school we have a dance studio and bikes. If the weather is decent, a group will go for a walk. There’s no excuse for making it unbearable. However, I really disagree with you allowing your DD to opt out - she’s likely to become entitled and a real snowflake, if she avoids what she doesn’t like constantly. She never develop resilience, confidence and grit, IMO.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 08:10

Oh, and as an adult I now dog walk for a living so I'm outside for 5-6 hours a day in all weathers Wink

I love my job and exercise but school PE was a special kind of torture, especially hockey and swimming. I regularly had very long periods to get me out of swimming lessons too Grin

whiteroseredrose · 29/01/2022 08:10

@SheilaWilcox

This has to be a joke, so I am going to assume you're an 11yr old looking for ideas.

If you think universities ONLY look at results then you are very naive. Lots of kids from selective schools will get A's. What will set them apart will be their character, integrity, extra curricular activities, testimonials from teachers.

Money can't buy you health. No matter what high-flying career you envisage she will do, her health and wellbeing will be important for her entire life. The time to get good habits and priorities in life is now.

I think you'd be really letting her down by letting her 'wimp out' of things she doesn't want to do.

So hating football / rugby / competitive sport will prevent you getting onto a physics degree course? What tosh.

Extra curriculars such as volunteering, charity work, and physics reading were just fine thanks.

And as for long term well being, tell that to my super sporty (overly sporty) dad who died of a heart attack at 46, and one of his brothers who struggled to walk from his 40s as his ankles were damaged from playing football. The healthiest one now is the one who spent his teens smoking behind the bike sheds!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 08:09

I managed to skip hockey every winter from Y8-Y11 by having a headache or a cold every single week Grin

I went to a private school but they never contacted my parents and I would just sit in the library and read.

I'm so surprised by all these posters who apparently never ever skipped PE and who think it's all lovely and wholesome and full of team spirit Hmm

PE at my school was the same group of girls being picked for everything while everyone else was stuck on the sidelines doing shit all.

dingledanglewoowoo · 29/01/2022 08:07

@Joystir59

I loathed PE at school, would have loved extra time in the library with my books. I walked approx 6 miles a day and sea swim, am slim fit active and in my sixties now so I don't think ducking out of PE at every available opportunity did me any harm.
I'm guessing the OPs daughter isn't walking that far, or sea swimming. It's a rubbish precedent to set in year 7, and I agree with others that the DD will likely ask for excuses next term too.
whiteroseredrose · 29/01/2022 07:56

@ivykaty44

There are reasons that PE is really important

better academic performance
increased student physical health
It teaches children key life skills
It offers the chance for them to relax, release pent up emotions and to spend time having fun with their friends
Students who play sports are better able to concentrate and maintain focus
Students who exercise regularly have a better quality of sleep
Physical exercise helps children relieve stress and anxiety
improve their teamwork and leadership skills.

Utter bobbins.

Looking back at my classmates the bitchy sporty girls were not particularly successful academically nor in later life.

And I've never been angrier than after gym and exercise classes. None of these endorphins, i came out wanting to smash plates and punch people. Anything but relaxing. Decided it was best, and safer for those around me, to give it a miss!

PE was never 'fun with friends' until my friend and I realised that we didn't actually have to do anything. Fielding in rounders was an excellent chance for a catch up chat as was being Goal Keeper and Goal Defence in hockey. Just because there is a ball flying towards you doesn't mean you have to chase it. You can duck and / or ignore it. Sorry miss, didn't see it, it was too fast.

A long country hike is a completely different matter, but they don't offer that at school.

I think the endless team sports are the problem at school. I read a report donkeys years ago re girls and sport in schools. Some had the option to dump hockey, netball etc in favour of individual stuff like dance, and Jane Fonda type classes. Five years after leaving school much higher %ages of girls were still active.

My friend's son is awful at team sports and hates school PE but is an excellent skier, surfer and dingy sailor. He also runs.

OP, I got out of swimming for a 'chlorine allergy' - school swimming was as bad as the rest of school sport.

My DM would also let me miss some Fridays later in school when it was double art and double PE in the afternoon.

In your DD's shoes I'd have taken the detention for a forgotten PE kit if I could also miss PE.

I'm with the others though, i wouldn't make up an illness for fear of tempting fate.

OhWhyNot · 29/01/2022 07:53

I’m sure many pupils would prefer to miss a class they don’t like so they can do their homework … ds certainly would prefer homework was done in class time

onedayoranother · 29/01/2022 07:51

My daughter sprained her ankle and was on crutches for three or four weeks. They didn't let her go to the library - she had to go to games and keep score or whatever.
Walking isn't enough exercise, and allowing her to not go just because is setting a bad precedent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread