Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
Chickychoccyegg · 29/01/2022 12:49

I think you'd be setting her a really bad example if you did this.
I'm surprised to hear the dc van go to the library instead, I've only ever heard of still having to get changed and sit on the sidelines/ref/collect equipment, depending on reason for sitting out.
Not sure what excuse would cover several weeks anyway

pastypirate · 29/01/2022 12:29

Also I tell my dds - who are fine with pe - that I'm grateful daily as an adult that pe is no longer compulsory!

pastypirate · 29/01/2022 12:28

Pulled ligament in knee. Worked perfectly for me when I was 11. No judgement from me.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 29/01/2022 12:27

@Mamamia7962

Surely this can't be real. No parent would pander to their child this much would they? She doesn't want to do PE for a few weeks because it's too cold! You can buy thermal base layers to wear under PE tops, most sports people wear them. Doesn't the school have a PE tracksuit they can wear for colder weather. Most secondary schools have them.
I'm sure they do. I've seen the results of such pandering in the workplace and they really aren't doing their kids any favours.
Mamamia7962 · 29/01/2022 12:24

Surely this can't be real. No parent would pander to their child this much would they? She doesn't want to do PE for a few weeks because it's too cold! You can buy thermal base layers to wear under PE tops, most sports people wear them. Doesn't the school have a PE tracksuit they can wear for colder weather. Most secondary schools have them.

loobylou10 · 29/01/2022 12:15

God, you are 'that parent' aren't you? Is mummy always going to be around to get her out of things she doesn't like?

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 29/01/2022 12:10

As for whether I’d let her skip maths, I don’t see that as comparable. Most further education courses, degrees, jobs etc. will want to see a good GCSE maths pass. Not so PE.

Most further education courses and jobs will have elements she doesn't enjoy, detests even. Enabling her to wriggle out of things she doesn't enjoy now isn't preparing her well for the future, even if it is 'just PE'.

whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 12:04

I suspect that if secondary schools carried out an anonymous survey especially with girls on their views on PE it wouldn't be overwhelmingly positive so I don't think it's all projection.

CatRamsey · 29/01/2022 12:03

Judging by the comments here my mum must be an awful parent as she wrote me a note every week excusing me from PE. No reason given in the note. She knew what it was like to hate PE. Granted I was probably more like 15 then not 11. But I personally think people here are taking it too seriously.

shouldistop · 29/01/2022 12:02

Walking to and from school isn't plenty of exercise unless it's a couple of mile hike.

raspberrymuffin · 29/01/2022 11:54

Good for you OP. My mum would never have tolerated me skipping something actually important but she was willing to get me out of PE when I just couldn't face it and I will never forget that kindness at a time when we otherwise struggled to get on. Of course it's not equivalent to skipping maths. The only thing I ever learnt in PE was that however hard I worked academically I was a waste of space if I couldn't hit a fucking rounders ball. Oh and that I was disgusting for not shaving my legs. If that's what teamwork is, kids are far better learning self sufficiency.

Nospringchix · 29/01/2022 11:39

Chaosrabbitland, totally agree. Weight is more influenced by diet than physical activity.

Intheopinionofourexpert · 29/01/2022 11:38

@usinon

Trampolining and badminton are no better. In fact making a child who struggles with coordination exercise on a trampoline in front of everyone else would be awful. And any racquet/bat sport can be just about impossible for these children

If people have never felt the humiliation that PE brings to those who can't do it, they will never understand how it feels, nor the damage it does

It is practice that is all. It is easier for kids whose parents did coordination things with them from a young age, or for people who have inherited the aptitude from parents, but everyone NT is capable of learning to a standard which would be enjoyable and beneficial. Practice makes a huge difference and people who are put off at the beginning because it is hard and seemingly impossible can be encouraged to keep trying, until they see progress. Or could be encouraged to not even try, as you say.

Benefits of exercise, trampolining, running are significant for brain health, mental health, other aptitudes

It really isn't just practise. I played tennis at school for years. I was no better in the 6th form than I was in the first. Some people just aren't able to coordinate their bodies in the way others can. Unless you are one of those people, it simply isn't possible to understand.

And I didn't say that children shouldn't be encouraged to try. There is some form of exercise that every child will be able to participate in and enjoy, that's what needs to be worked on more by schools. I listed some upthread.

There are reasons so few girls engage with sport, and telling them to just practise more won't improve that figure.

heartonthetyne · 29/01/2022 11:31

@MrsSkylerWhite

doorornottodoor

I think it’s a shame that people are projecting their hatred of PE onto their children. Things have changed so much. I’m a teacher and our PE staff are lovely, really approachable and want the best for for the children. It’s not just about sport it’s about the mental and physical health boost of exercise. Setting up good habits. There should be something for everyone in this day and age“

You’re right, an awful lot of projecting on this thread.
As a PP said, PE really isn’t like Kes any more.
I have the late middle aged memories of serge knickers and having to “country dance” in the baking sun until my feet were blistered but it’s just not like that anymore.
Our two otherwise pretty lazy kids really enjoyed their PE lessons because of a wide choice of activities and really engaging teachers who made it fun. They set up good habits for life.

This. I'm amazed at the range of sports that my DCs got to try at their (state) primary, and secondary is working out to be pretty awesome too. Girl's especially need should be encouraged to participate in exercise and activity. If the OP had said her DD was doing XYZ activity outside of school I may be every so slightly more to understanding, but just walking to school is not enough!
usinon · 29/01/2022 11:18

Trampolining and badminton are no better. In fact making a child who struggles with coordination exercise on a trampoline in front of everyone else would be awful. And any racquet/bat sport can be just about impossible for these children

If people have never felt the humiliation that PE brings to those who can't do it, they will never understand how it feels, nor the damage it does

It is practice that is all. It is easier for kids whose parents did coordination things with them from a young age, or for people who have inherited the aptitude from parents, but everyone NT is capable of learning to a standard which would be enjoyable and beneficial. Practice makes a huge difference and people who are put off at the beginning because it is hard and seemingly impossible can be encouraged to keep trying, until they see progress. Or could be encouraged to not even try, as you say.

Benefits of exercise, trampolining, running are significant for brain health, mental health, other aptitudes

MrsSkylerWhite · 29/01/2022 10:35

doorornottodoor

I think it’s a shame that people are projecting their hatred of PE onto their children. Things have changed so much. I’m a teacher and our PE staff are lovely, really approachable and want the best for for the children. It’s not just about sport it’s about the mental and physical health boost of exercise. Setting up good habits. There should be something for everyone in this day and age“

You’re right, an awful lot of projecting on this thread.
As a PP said, PE really isn’t like Kes any more.
I have the late middle aged memories of serge knickers and having to “country dance” in the baking sun until my feet were blistered but it’s just not like that anymore.
Our two otherwise pretty lazy kids really enjoyed their PE lessons because of a wide choice of activities and really engaging teachers who made it fun. They set up good habits for life.

VickyEadieofThigh · 29/01/2022 10:30

@HelloKittyGirl

Those asking what will change in a few weeks time…

The weather!

(Although yes, I do realise there’ll be other years before anyone points that out. The PE requirement at her school drops quite considerably though after Year 9)

She's in Y7 and doesn't like PE because of - apparently - "the weather" in winter.

What are you planning for Y8, 9, 10 and 11, @HelloKittyGirl ?

Moreover, you're teaching your child at a young age that lying to evade something you don't much like but are obliged to do is acceptable.

Exhausteddog · 29/01/2022 10:22

@Piglet89 I really regret my parents not emphasising sport from a young age. Even now, my mum has the warped idea that you can’t actually be academic and sporty.

My parents thought the same. I would complain I was crap at sport (I was!!) and they would say "never mind, you're good at English and Maths, we're not a sporty family" and that would be it. I was quite good at running but by the time I discovered that, my PE teachers had written me off because I was shit at ball games and my parents were not very interested.

With my own kids I encourage them to try different things and always say that with practise there is always the chance to be better than how you started. Lots of people expect them to be good at running because that's my hobby but thats not their thing and I'm ok with that. I want them to find something they enjoy.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 29/01/2022 10:14

@Tabitha888

Anyone else think the OP is being a bit of a joke. It's shocking that she's willing to lie and teach her daughter to fake an illness 😞
I really can't decide if you're being serious or not.

Loads of kids skive PE and yes, their parents often help them Grin

northumberlandavenue · 29/01/2022 10:09

@Intheopinionofourexpert I agree, hence my suggestion to the OP to find out why her DD wants to miss PE. Things such as team selection can be changed.

Tabitha888 · 29/01/2022 10:07

Anyone else think the OP is being a bit of a joke. It's shocking that she's willing to lie and teach her daughter to fake an illness 😞

Intheopinionofourexpert · 29/01/2022 10:02

@inheritancetrack

A walk to school isn't adequate and PE is about team work, different sports and exercise is important for younger people. She doesn't need a library and can do work at home. It's a really odd request tbh
Not this again. You don't learn a thing about teamwork if you're the child who is last to be chosen for a team every single week, the child no-one wants in their team, the child who is worse than everyone else at whatever game they are playing, and who lives in dread of PE lessons every week.
Yerroblemom1923 · 29/01/2022 10:01

We just used to hide in the toilets if there was a lesson we couldn't face - usually PE! I'm not sure if you could get away with this these days.
I think children do need to know that you can't just avoid anything you don't fancy doing because life's not like that.
PE might not be her bag but it's all good exercise and I think it's sad so many girls start losing interest in sports at secondary school. I appreciate it's usually because of becoming more cost-conscious and having insecurities about their size/shape - but the kit today is a thousand times better than the silly little netball skirts we had to wear (we weren't allowed to wear shorts underneath either! Remember feeling so self-conscious and paranoid at certain times of the month)
Nowadays girls can wear shorts, leggings, jogging pants etc which is so much better.
I'd want to get to the bottom of the problem with her to find out why she doesn't want to do it.

Theluggage15 · 29/01/2022 10:01

You’re not even saying she doesn’t like sport or that she’s terrible at it, you said she’ll deign to do it when the weather gets better. All these people going on about the trauma of PE is irrelevant, she just doesn’t like the cold. Just tell her to get on with it.

OhWhyNot · 29/01/2022 10:01

My ds not family (have no idea why that changed to my family..)

Swipe left for the next trending thread