Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you can think of an excuse which will get 11yo off PE for the rest of term?

760 replies

HelloKittyGirl · 28/01/2022 19:55

Just that, basically. What would get her off games for a few weeks?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DaisyChains3 · 06/02/2022 18:04

We had group showers in my first year at secondary school. It really really traumatised me. I wore a swimming costume but everyone else was naked. i had started my periods just before secondary and was wearing a bra. Many others weren't . I dreaded PE the whole week. I moved to another area for second year and had nightmares all summer about whether the new school would force us to shower naked. Thankfully it didn't. My mother laughed when she saw my swimming costume. Instead of asking me about it and supporting me, she found it amusing.

blyn72 · 06/02/2022 17:18

You poor thing, RG2468. We never had showers at any school I attended but I would not have gone, bare naked, in front of my peers or teachers. I don't see why a person cannot shower in a bathing costume, you can still wash the necessaries.

However I do wish parents would empower their children to refuse such ritualistic humiliations; nobody has the right to make anyone have a shower in public, it's abusive to force such practices.

RG2468 · 06/02/2022 14:06

@GeraltsLastWish

I'm still traumatised being made to group shower where some girls would then berate your naked body and the PE teachers would stand at both entrances, watching you like a hawk, making sure you got good and clean shudders

I also got a full strength whack with a hockey stick in the head and they didn't even call my parents.

Not to mention a teacher hitting me in the back with a tennis racket because I stood on the changing bench.

PE was atrocious at my school.

The funny thing was I was relatively good at sports. I got picked on teams where they felt I had something to offer. It didn't stop the relentless bullying and humiliation from some peers and the teachers.

One thing it taught me is a lot of people are actually really horrible.

The group shower c1990 for me as the only one with thick Pubic hair as a ten year old and I was overweight - mortifying and scarred me
SaltySeaAir · 06/02/2022 13:18

I hated PE with an absolute passion at secondary school, hockey in particular. Taught me nothing at all, and I don't think I even got any exercise. So I have every sympathy for her. I would have hoped PE lessons might have improved since then, seems not. Not everyone likes team sports. I would have loved something like Zumba! Or even following something like a Joe Wicks class. Have no idea why teenagers are forced into team sports if they have no interest.

lioncitygirl · 06/02/2022 13:14

But you’re teaching her lying is ok? Yikes.

GeraltsLastWish · 06/02/2022 12:59

I'm still traumatised being made to group shower where some girls would then berate your naked body and the PE teachers would stand at both entrances, watching you like a hawk, making sure you got good and clean shudders

I also got a full strength whack with a hockey stick in the head and they didn't even call my parents.

Not to mention a teacher hitting me in the back with a tennis racket because I stood on the changing bench.

PE was atrocious at my school.

The funny thing was I was relatively good at sports. I got picked on teams where they felt I had something to offer. It didn't stop the relentless bullying and humiliation from some peers and the teachers.

One thing it taught me is a lot of people are actually really horrible.

mizzo · 06/02/2022 12:10

I had osgood-schlatter disease in high school and didn't do PE except swimming for about three years!

Laiste · 06/02/2022 12:03

@isntitisntit - ''@laiste there is a difference between bunking PE and even parents turning a blind eye, and the parent agreeing with their dc to make up a lie and the parent then lying to the teacher. Would you lie in this situation?''

That is a really good question!
And i'm thinking hard.

I think i would not lie for my kids on a long term basis. Blind eye long term yes.

However, if there was a particular one off event which one of them wanted to avoid i would do it for that event.

My 4th DD who is still in school loves PE (it takes all sorts i guess Grin) so personally i don't see myself having to deal with this again.

isntitisntit · 06/02/2022 11:56

@laiste there is a difference between bunking PE and even parents turning a blind eye, and the parent agreeing with their dc to make up a lie and the parent then lying to the teacher. Would you lie in this situation?

I am not usually a judgemental person, but people who lie a lot annoy the hell out of me because other people spend time investing in a relationship with them only to find out they have no idea what was truth and what wasn't. You may as well invest time in talking to a wall, you have no idea whether what is being said is what the person thinks, and it is a waste of time. I also think that where you have teachers putting time and effort into lesson planning and looking after children, lying to them is not on.

But I suppose to be fair it is a marmite situation, people feel strongly one way or the other. People who are straightforwardand mostly honest (bar the odd white lie for example) can hang out with people who are straightforward and honest, and people who think it is fine to lie habitually can hang out with each other too.

I think lying habitually, over day to day stuff, especially where it is unnecessary to lie, is generally seen as a symptom of a one of the cluster personality disorders though.

blyn72 · 06/02/2022 10:59

PS: Oh I get it, I googled and it means 'jump the queue'; I'd imagined 'cut in line' was something more complicated and even sinister :-).

Well I don't think she should be encouraged to push her way to the front at a supermarket check out but wouldn't blame anyone for trying to move up an NHS waiting list or even a housing list.

blyn72 · 06/02/2022 10:36

3Daddy31982

Op why don't you teach her to tax dodge and cut in line?

.................
I don't know what 'cut in line' means but your previous suggestion is not bad:-). That's what accountants are paid for.

Laiste, your children had the right idea, good for them. Hiding in the cloakroom or library is good too. However I understand one can just refuse to do PE nowadays.

Laiste · 06/02/2022 09:31

@3Daddy31982

Op why don't you teach her to tax dodge and cut in line?

Is she hefty?

Hefty ? Hmm

Anyway ...

I wish you'd enabled voting OP. It would have been really interesting to see opinions without the need to post.

2 of my 3 older ones hated PE. I knew they fibbed to get out of it and i turned a blind eye.

Are they now fat, dishonest, selfish non-team player types? Nope, funnily enough. Happy healthy well adjusted early 20 somethings with decent jobs.

I hated PE and bunked it from aged 14 onwards. I'm not a selfish ''hefty'' liar either.

TopsieGreenwood · 06/02/2022 09:17

Erm…isn’t the whole premise of originating a posting on an AIBU inviting/seeking others to judge your intentions/actions/thoughts??

Yes, I think some people are not understanding what AIBU stands for Grin

Ikeptgoing · 04/02/2022 23:26

It'll be a lie to make something up, but what's the actual PE lessons she wants to miss?. (So many of the girls hate rugby and hockey at our secondary. It's outside in ridiculous cold and they all get bashed. Our school does half term of each, so .. Confused)

Fractured finger (non dominant hand)

My DD has fractured a finger twice (ironically done in PE lessons!) . Google how they strap up finger visually - so DDs was strapped to another finger all the time for first week then it's gentle movement & taking finger sock/strapping off and only using when it aches- no carrying with that hand either) But for your purposes is also no sports for about 4 -6 weeks.

My DD was "not unhappy"
to miss rest of hockey season, bit sadder when it was basketball !

3Daddy31982 · 04/02/2022 23:01

Op why don't you teach her to tax dodge and cut in line?

Is she hefty?

LondonWolf · 03/02/2022 11:14

@rebeccachoc

Plantar Fasciitis gets my vote. It affects the bottom of your foot (Google it for writing a convincing letter) and can take weeks or months to heal (and can probably flare back up at convenient times). Tennis elbow would only excuse some sports but not running so I think a foot issue would be more helpful to get off all sports.

By the way I'm keeping my opinion to myself if this is the right or wrong thing to do, I'm just answering the question given as best as I can.

Good for you! If only more people would do so.
rebeccachoc · 03/02/2022 11:12

Plantar Fasciitis gets my vote. It affects the bottom of your foot (Google it for writing a convincing letter) and can take weeks or months to heal (and can probably flare back up at convenient times). Tennis elbow would only excuse some sports but not running so I think a foot issue would be more helpful to get off all sports.

By the way I'm keeping my opinion to myself if this is the right or wrong thing to do, I'm just answering the question given as best as I can.

ArchibaldsDaddy · 03/02/2022 01:20

@Becky11

It is absolutely impossible to post anything on MN without being judged. Why can't people just reply to the question being asked. You don't have to agree. You have the control, as we all do, to keep scrolling. We all parent differently. And just because someone has different ideas on what is best for their own children does not make them wrong or an available target for vitriol just to make you feel better about your own parenting. I wish people would stop saying, posting and wearing Be Kind slogans and actually just do it.
Erm…isn’t the whole premise of originating a posting on an AIBU inviting/seeking others to judge your intentions/actions/thoughts??
JohnMcCainsDeathStare · 02/02/2022 21:58

willweevergetthere
Damn. I am embarresed for the school in that it is 2022 and apparently it STILL has no provision for disabled/injured students. Even studying PE or doing something else would be a better use of time than standing on the sidelines. I've never understood what exactly are 'standing on the sideline' or 'sitting on my butt watching other people exercise' workouts are supposed to achieve.

willweevergetthere · 02/02/2022 14:16

Resilience is about how you deal with adversity.
It starts early with learning that you can't always have what you want when you want it, loosing at games, dealing with disappointment, failing and trying again and again.

Personally I'd like my disabled daughter to be allowed to do another type of exercise rather than stand on the sidelines in PE during contact sports - why can she use the gym, go for a run etc. No she has to stand and watch in her full pe kit. Waste of time

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 02/02/2022 09:15

I don’t think not doing PE will have any affect on tolerance or resilience at all.

cocktailclub · 02/02/2022 05:33

@Excited101

Tolerance and resilience, 2 of the most important factors in mental health and you are actively teaching against them. Imagine how the teacher will feel to see a parent to actively working against you, disgraceful op.
I agree tolerance and resilience are important but I don't think they should be built through pointless issues like school PE. Some people can be put off exercise for life due to the poor handling of PE lessons. I think schools should wonder why some kids hate it so much and look at more choice so they don't cause damage to the perception of exercise as completely unenjoyable forever. My own school actually did think about some choices for less 'sporty' kids and it worked really well in cutting down on avoidance.
CrankyFrankie · 01/02/2022 11:31

@ddl1 @fairylightsandwaxmelts

Of course children shouldn't be forced to do things purely because they don't like them...!! (How exactly did you infer that from my comment(s)?!)

But it's P E! I hated PE. I forged the odd note to get out of it. I also have a few good memories of it and I love exercise today. My point is (other than the obviously moral one, which I already voiced) that there are much more challenging issues ahead of this girl (and her peers). If you're being shielded from PE because the weather is cold, then how are you going to cope with real life?

Resilience can be built up gradually. It doesn't necessarily come naturally for a parent to instil it in their child but it's about playing the long game. You need to talk to and reason with your children; not enable them to always take the easy path. They need help in eventually understanding that the world doesn't actually revolve around them.

Who wants to drop their baby at nursery and go to work? Nobody. What about when your baby screams and cries, begging you in their own way not to leave them? I have no option but to leave my child there. I'd say that's much harder and 'crueler' than a PE session. Yet it's a perfectly accepted (and actively encouraged) product of modern life, and the way I square it with myself is that it is building resilience. Of course I prefer the gentler approach - eg with my older child who is capable of reason. He's 4 and he's already solving problems for himself, noticing life's complexities, tackling obstacles head on, digging deep and developing grit. Even just choosing to eat the crusts of his sandwiches is a win in my eyes!

Apparently there has been an explosion of mental health issues in young adults since 2008. Are kids happier today, now that their parents enable them and excuse them? I don't think so.

Excited101 · 01/02/2022 10:37

Tolerance and resilience, 2 of the most important factors in mental health and you are actively teaching against them. Imagine how the teacher will feel to see a parent to actively working against you, disgraceful op.

usinon · 01/02/2022 10:23

Generally, you become resilient because you've been through shit and upsetting times

The resilience comes because you've suffered, it doesn't prevent it

I thought that resilience comes from having properly processed and dealt with difficult experiences from the past, not just to do with going through difficult experiences. Not everyone who has experienced upsetting things will have processed their feelings and recovered. I also thought that being resilient does prevent future suffering because it means you are able to process and deal with difficult things better and more quickly than people who are not resilient. So difficult things wouldn't hold you back or burden you or negatively effect your quality of life in the same way as they would a less resilient person.