Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use benefits to put down a deposit for a house

435 replies

Bringinglightandpeace · 28/01/2022 14:08

Hello all,

This thread is not about me.

I have a friend who is feeling incredibly guilty. This is how it goes... so she applied for benefits, she has children and a husband,,, well technically partner but anyway she received a huge backlog of benefits. She confided in me that she would like to use the money to to put down a deposit for a help to buy scheme or shared ownership. I told her "well you have to use every opportunity that you can get" but in my conscience, I was thinking, is this right? I am on benefits myself so not judging at all. She feels a bit down about it as it's not her hard on money that she used to put a deposit down..but then again some parents give their children money for a deposit... so I guess it's similar.

However, I feel a bit of itch and thought to myself that I don't think what she is doing is right. But then again, I don't want to come across as jealous. What do you all think?

OP posts:
Adylans · 29/01/2022 09:14

I mean better that than it go into a landlord, she’s going to be paying someone’s mortgage then it may as well be her own

ShallWeTalkAboutBruno · 29/01/2022 09:12

Fucking hell. We’re ‘higher’ earners (six figures) and if I think about it (rarely) I’m glad our tax helps to provide a safety net for those who need it. Sounds like @Fr0thandBubble has a messiah complex going on.

Fr0thandBubble · 29/01/2022 09:04

[quote Waxonwaxoff0]@Fr0thandBubble you think poor people should be "appreciative" to rich people? Have a word with yourself. And you are deluded if you think they all work hard for that money.[/quote]
Yes I absolutely do. If you’re on benefits, fine. But you should bloody well be grateful for it because other people are literally working to provide for you.

But you’re not grateful are you? You just think they should pay you even more. And, yes, there are some rich people who don’t have to work that hard - maybe they inherited or just got extremely lucky - but let me tell you that the vast majority work bloody hard.

I work 60 hours every week - that doesn’t include commuting time - and I come from a very poor, working class family. So I am not some rich “elite”. I have worked extremely hard for everything I have, and I’m fed up of paying for people who just can’t be arsed and feel that everyone else should pay for them and complain when they think it’s not enough.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 29/01/2022 08:50

@Fr0thandBubble you think poor people should be "appreciative" to rich people? Have a word with yourself. And you are deluded if you think they all work hard for that money.

Fr0thandBubble · 29/01/2022 08:48

[quote misssunshine4040]@frothandbubble.

No I'm not ridiculous. Maybe we should live in a system that was fairer and you didn't work a 60 hour week and barely saw your children?

[/quote]
I wouldn’t have to I didn’t have to give 45% of my salary in income tax. The “rich” aren’t to blame - they are the ones who provide for everyone else (you seem to have no gratitude or appreciation for that though, you seem to just think you are entitled to even more of their hard-earned money). It’s thieves like this woman that are the problem.

Bringsexyback · 29/01/2022 08:33

They won’t be able to buy a house using that money when they go to apply for the mortgage still have to account for where the deposit comes from and if they don’t believe the story, which they won’t because it doesn’t add up whoever they apply to the mortgage for has to report them to the Dwp.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 29/01/2022 08:32

@Yants

At least it puts to bed the myth that choosing to live a lifestyle supported by benefits will result in penury and poverty.

And for the majority of able bodied claimants it very much is a deliberate lifestyle choice... choosing to have children they can't afford and then deliberately limiting the number of hours they choose to work to the minimal/optimal for claiming maximum benefit entitlement even when permanent full time hours are available to them.

Nonsense.
Willyoujustbequiet · 29/01/2022 08:25

@yants

Don't be so ridiculous. The vast majority of those on benefits live in poverty.

Yants · 29/01/2022 07:23

At least it puts to bed the myth that choosing to live a lifestyle supported by benefits will result in penury and poverty.

And for the majority of able bodied claimants it very much is a deliberate lifestyle choice... choosing to have children they can't afford and then deliberately limiting the number of hours they choose to work to the minimal/optimal for claiming maximum benefit entitlement even when permanent full time hours are available to them.

Aomame · 29/01/2022 06:21

It sounds like it's a big backdate of PIP that's then resulted in a big backdate of a disability premium on her JSA/ESA. The thing is though, she should only be entitled to the disability premium if she has no other adults living with her.

grey12 · 29/01/2022 05:52

She's entitled to the money Wink

I find it terrible is when people are allowed to buy for dirt cheap council housing though Envy if they can afford it, they need to move out and leave it for someone else who is in a bad situation

lborgia · 29/01/2022 05:12

The partner is not paying off his debts, the tax payer is. I'm sorry, I've not read the last page, but this is where I'm up to.

She is committing fraud by pretending to live alone. How can the 3 of you be so stupid that you think this is OK?

Some of the first questions on forms is about your living arrangements. At some point she has physically written on a piece of paper that he does not exist.

It also does not matter if it's a house share with a housing association, or a private mortgage, she will still have to declare exactly their circumstances, and I honestly don't know what she could say that would make this ok.

Meanwhile, one phrase you used leapt right out at me.

She will give him the money, and he will use it as the deposit?

Given his history with money I would bet my house that the money will not end up with the solicitor, he'll say "why do we even need a house?" and he'll gradually work his way through that money as well.

If you do end up with a house, and then the fraud is discovered, it will by that stage be a prison issue, because they'll be looking at benefit fraud, mortgage fraud, and bank fraud at the least.

You do know that just because it all involves council money, and government money, it still counts, right? You still can't " just, sort of, well I thought it would be ok" about it?

Would you walk into the bank of England and expect them to overlook this shit?

I don't care WHAT she was trying to achieve, and I'm surprised I'm saying that, but this idea that the benefits office will look on you benignly like a cosy mum and dad ages me want to smack someone.

Wrinklefree · 29/01/2022 05:10

Of course she can, if she is currently getting help with rent, she will not be entitled to that once she has a mortgage.

misssunshine4040 · 29/01/2022 04:43

@frothandbubble.

No I'm not ridiculous. Maybe we should live in a system that was fairer and you didn't work a 60 hour week and barely saw your children?

blyn72 · 29/01/2022 03:16

I don't see any point in you telling your friend how you feel about this and I note you say it will only be for a couple of months anyway. She may be caught, she may not but she really should not be telling anyone, no matter how close she is to them. Walls have ears.

sst1234 · 29/01/2022 00:55

[quote thecatsinthecradle]@Fr0thandBubble I've just read the updates. Talk about a drip feed, OP 🙄

I'd probs report her tbh. She's stolen this money[/quote]
It’s a drip feed because like someone else upthread said, OP is the friend and is sounding people out about whether should would get caught. And did a runner as soon as she got answers she did not like.

sst1234 · 29/01/2022 00:54

@jb7445

I'm coming at this from a different angle.

OP has stated that her friend can't work currently due to childcare issues. So her options appear to be -

  • partner moves out. She continues to claim the same level of benefits. Partner possibly also claims top up HB and WTC. This continues for the foreseeable future as friend has just had a baby and cannot get a job that pays enough to cover childcare. Result - increased cost to taxpayer.
  • partner stays, friend ceases fraudulent claim (and pays back overpaid benefit?). Couple make a joint claim which (unless the partner is on a very good wage) will probably still be substantial. Result - short term gain for the taxpayer, but long term they will never be able to pay off the debts and will probably be stuck in a rut claiming what they can and living in miserable conditions for a very long time (if not forever).
  • friend uses the money for a house. Partner pays off his debt. Friend gets a job. Result - couple are now largely independent (maybe with some top up benefits eg WTC like many families) and able to build a decent future for themselves and their kids without being a long term burden on the taxpayer.

To me it's a no-brainer Confused

Your angle is about 180 degrees off. Try again.
thecatsinthecradle · 29/01/2022 00:50

@Fr0thandBubble I've just read the updates. Talk about a drip feed, OP 🙄

I'd probs report her tbh. She's stolen this money

sst1234 · 29/01/2022 00:50

OP is the ‘friend’ and is committing fraud, ripping off the taxpayer and now trying to justify it by asking random strangers on the internet. And people wonder why the general public’s attitude towards welfare has hardened so much in the last decade or so. Even anecdotes like this one show how easy it is to rip off the system.

Fr0thandBubble · 29/01/2022 00:48

@thecatsinthecradle

This is a remarkably sensible way to spend money she is entitled to. What else would you suggest she does with it??
She is NOT entitled to it, she is committing benefit fraud.

OP shop her. I have reported two people I know who have committed benefit fraud, and I wouldn’t hesitate to do it again.

thecatsinthecradle · 29/01/2022 00:43

This is a remarkably sensible way to spend money she is entitled to. What else would you suggest she does with it??

Fr0thandBubble · 29/01/2022 00:40

@misssunshine4040

Shame there's not as much outrage at the government defrauding our taxes everyday than moaning about joe bloggs and a few grand. It's not right of course not but all this "my taxes pay for there house" and there are less public services because of fraudulent claimants... Its not true, the welfare bill is small. The tiny minority defraud it and those who do are usually in poverty. The rich elites shaft you over a million times more
Oh for fuck’s sake. You’re ridiculous.
Fr0thandBubble · 29/01/2022 00:34

@GivenchyDahhling

Do you think people on benefits don’t deserve to own their own homes OP?
People like this fuck me off. I’ve just finished a 60 hour week, have barely seen my children, all to fund fuckers like this. You should shop her OP, and tell her that what she is doing is completely wrong.
JustLyra · 29/01/2022 00:06

[quote LifesABotch]@Bringinglightandpeace benefits don't typically pay a massive 'backlog', it's sometimes backdated a month or so, but no more than that so wouldn't ever be a massive amount? There's no such thing as a massive amount of benefit payments anyway! Hence why people are dying, waiting for decisions on PIP etc.[/quote]
If it’s PIP it can be massive. I know someone who waited 15 months for their tribunal - their backdated award was almost 10k as they were (correctly) awarded the higher rate for both parts.

For anyone who was then entitled to backdated element amounts of other benefits that could rack up.

LifesABotch · 28/01/2022 22:38

@Cherrybomb197

Ahhhh... so she is claiming as a single parent but she is not actually a single parent. To be honest growing up I knew lots of people doing that. She might as well save it towards a deposit. But remember that she won’t get housing benefit for a mortgage iirc!
I know of someone who went to jail for this. It's very, very serious