Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To use benefits to put down a deposit for a house

435 replies

Bringinglightandpeace · 28/01/2022 14:08

Hello all,

This thread is not about me.

I have a friend who is feeling incredibly guilty. This is how it goes... so she applied for benefits, she has children and a husband,,, well technically partner but anyway she received a huge backlog of benefits. She confided in me that she would like to use the money to to put down a deposit for a help to buy scheme or shared ownership. I told her "well you have to use every opportunity that you can get" but in my conscience, I was thinking, is this right? I am on benefits myself so not judging at all. She feels a bit down about it as it's not her hard on money that she used to put a deposit down..but then again some parents give their children money for a deposit... so I guess it's similar.

However, I feel a bit of itch and thought to myself that I don't think what she is doing is right. But then again, I don't want to come across as jealous. What do you all think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cuddlemequick · 30/01/2022 20:23

@lollipoprainbow anyone can apply, however as you are currently housed you will be lowest priority. You may never be high priority enough to bid on a house. You may also end up being offered somewhere in a grotty area. It's not quite as simple as applying...but yes, anyone can apply.

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 30/01/2022 08:15

The most important advice would be for her to leave this "partner" who she is funding to get out of debt. He is a leech and will cause no end of trouble for her if she stays with him. Don't wait for him to spend every penny she has and run up more debt before you speak up.

Next she needs to announce to the DWP that he was living there for X period and has now left, but she's realised that might impact the benefit rebate so can they please recalculate. With a large sum it isn't worth the prosecution risk, because she's only got to irritate or make jealous one person like you to end up in trouble. Depending on how long he was there, she may still have some money due. She can then use that money for anything she likes including buying a house. Hopefully she'll then have higher standards for the next "partner" as someone who brings value to her and her children's lives.

JustLyra · 30/01/2022 07:34

[quote lollipoprainbow]@Waxonwaxoff0 Is it true that anyone can apply for a council house? I'm contemplating it as rent in my area has sky rocketed and we are desperate for somewhere bigger which I can't afford. My daughter is stuck in a tiny box room and she's 10 with asd. I'm a single working mum. You said you didn't get anywhere though so doubt I will either !! [/quote]
Anyone can apply. It entirely depends where you live how successful you’ll be. Where I live there are huge waiting lists even for emergency situations. Whereas where I spent my teens has some available immediately, now obviously there are reasons they are available immediately and they are not in the nicest bit at all, but for anyone used to the area they’re ok.

So it totally depends.

Flsh · 29/01/2022 22:48

lollipoprainbow They can but if you have multiple children under 10 or two kids if the same gender they will be expected to share so might not be able to get a bigger place anyway. With one or two children it will most likely be a two bed flat that you’d be offered.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 29/01/2022 13:57

[quote lollipoprainbow]@Waxonwaxoff0 Is it true that anyone can apply for a council house? I'm contemplating it as rent in my area has sky rocketed and we are desperate for somewhere bigger which I can't afford. My daughter is stuck in a tiny box room and she's 10 with asd. I'm a single working mum. You said you didn't get anywhere though so doubt I will either !! [/quote]
Yes anyone can apply, they assess people in order of need though.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 13:47

@lordloveadog

1 She obtained the money fraudulently.

2 That has absolutely nothing to do with what she should do with it. Your concern that she's using it to buy a house rather than something else is confused. The wrongness, if any, was in how she acquired it. Not what she's proposing to do with it.

3 She has allowed a man who has multiple debts to move in with her, which is stupid.

4 She is proposing to hand over her large sum of money to this man, to whom she has no legal connection, which is really stupid.

5 She is giving it to him so that he can buy a house in his name, which makes me despair of my sex.

This, all day long.
lordloveadog · 29/01/2022 13:45

1 She obtained the money fraudulently.

2 That has absolutely nothing to do with what she should do with it. Your concern that she's using it to buy a house rather than something else is confused. The wrongness, if any, was in how she acquired it. Not what she's proposing to do with it.

3 She has allowed a man who has multiple debts to move in with her, which is stupid.

4 She is proposing to hand over her large sum of money to this man, to whom she has no legal connection, which is really stupid.

5 She is giving it to him so that he can buy a house in his name, which makes me despair of my sex.

Discustard · 29/01/2022 13:39

She is being very stupid, first with the fraud (she will be the one taken to court, not him) and second with trusting him to pay a mortgage.

Dishwashersaurous · 29/01/2022 13:36

Anyone can apply. But depending on demand in an area you may never ever get on the list high enough to bid

lollipoprainbow · 29/01/2022 13:35

@Waxonwaxoff0 Is it true that anyone can apply for a council house? I'm contemplating it as rent in my area has sky rocketed and we are desperate for somewhere bigger which I can't afford. My daughter is stuck in a tiny box room and she's 10 with asd. I'm a single working mum. You said you didn't get anywhere though so doubt I will either !!

girlmom21 · 29/01/2022 13:14

Can I ask the government to give me a cheap place to rent just for me DH and the kids??? I would love that. But I can't, because DH gets a reasonable pay from his job. So the only options for me is either expensive private rent and never having our house or throw our privacy to the wind and live with inlaws for 4 years and counting......

What about your job? Why didnt you buy before you had kids if you feel that strongly? Why do you think that people who aren't fortunate enough to have family to live with don't deserve the same opportunity as you?

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 13:01
  • caringcarer The reason the government cannot pay legitimate claimants more money is because scummy people make fraudulent claims and effectively steal from the pot of money for genuine claimants. I would have no hesitation in reporting her.*

Sorry, but this is rubbish. Keeping benefit rates low and imposing harsh eligibility criteria for disability/sickness benefits is a choice, not a necessity. The Tories - this government in particular - want small state and small state means less benefits/public services.

Back in 2010 the coalition government made it very clear that they believed fraudulent claims of disability benefits were significantly pushing up the benefits bill. They used this to mount a campaign branding disability benefit claimants as workshy fraudsters so they could introduce ‘cost saving’ measures such as replacing DLA with PIP, as they believed that DLA was too easy to claim. They also changed the work capability assessment to make the conditions harder to meet.

What they actually found was that fraud in disability benefits was less than 1% - and this included figures on DWP error. The system of assessment introduced as a result of the changes - as anyone who has been through it will know - is harsh, unfair and put in the hands of private companies who employ ‘disability analysts’. These analysts are not doctors but mostly nurses with no experience of the disabilities they are being asked to assess and no skills to do that beyond the few days training they receive. These companies also routinely use physiotherapists, occupational therapists and paramedics to carry out these assessments.

In the end the disability benefits bill was pushed up, not by fraud, but by the cost of genuine claimants being denied the benefits to which they were entitled and having to go through an expensive appeals/tribunal process to establish their entitlement. Medical evidence is routinely dismissed or ignored and claimants who don’t provide their own medical evidence end up having their claim being decided solely on the report produced by the assessor - flaws and inaccuracies included.

There are more changes being considered, and these will inevitably bring more hardship - a consultation has just ended and a green paper will be introduced next year, and one of the proposals is to merge PIP, which is an un means tested benefit, with Universal Credit. This will effectively end entitlement to PIP support for anyone who doesn’t qualify for UC, so they will have effectively means tested PIP. They realised a long time ago that it’s not fraudulent claimants that cost the most money - it’s the most severely disabled who require the most support - and as far as I can see, efforts are now being concentrated on ways to make such claimants ineligible for support. You have been warned.

Babyghirl · 29/01/2022 12:54

@Bringinglightandpeace
Sorry but it's frued, yet again us tax payers are paying for 😠😠😠😠😠😠😠😠.

If she does not think she is entitled to it why doesn't she own up and tell the truth. Hope she's caught out.

FailureToLurk · 29/01/2022 12:49

@liveforsummer

They only need one letter to go to the house on his name, and that's it game over.

How on earth would they know what name is on the post op receives?

Sorry I should have clarified, if it's a government linked letter, like a tax letter/DWP. I dealt with one when I worked in citizens advice and it was actually a court invitation for jury service that linked the claimants, so perhaps court/probation are also linked somehow.

The addresses "ping" on the DWP system as matching and then the "claim is opened for investigation". UC is now linked to NI number now, due to how they calculate employment income. So say single claimants secret partner gets a new job, obviously needs a NI number, tax office get the address via the new employer and that's it, match is made.

liveforsummer · 29/01/2022 12:43

They only need one letter to go to the house on his name, and that's it game over.

How on earth would they know what name is on the post op receives?

sst1234 · 29/01/2022 12:37

[quote misssunshine4040]@Fr0thandBubble what a repugnant attitude.

You belong in the Victorian era.

It's not your (top rate tax payers) hard earned money is it. It's everyone's.

Repulsive privileged attitude [/quote]
Huh? Top 1% or earners pay something like 28% of tax and top 10% pay way more than half. You either don’t understand the math or how the system works. Anyone on an average wage is a net recipient. Its a fact whether you like or not. Your outrage doesn’t change facts unfortunately.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 12:32

@FailureToLurk

Sounds like she's had a big PIP back payment. These can be in the thousands especially if she is entitled to the higher rate on both mobility and Care.

When you apply for PIP that's when the payment is backdated to. If it takes months/years to sort out and appeals, you get a hefty backdated payment.

If it is the case she's using a PIP back payment, she is legally entitled to this money. PIP is not a income based benefit and makes no difference of you are a single or in a partnerships.

The not being technically being single and not updating the council and UC however is a whole other minefield, and by not reporting the change in circumstances she is committing benefit fraud, this will catch up with her. They only need one letter to go to the house on his name, and that's it game over.

Yep, and even if the back payment is PIP, if she has fraudulently claimed other benefits, she will still have to pay them back, so it still doesn’t make any sense to use the money to buy a house - as you say, it will catch up with her in the end, and in most cases it’s the claimants’ own behaviour that stitches them up - confiding in a friend that you have claimed dishonestly and then that friend posting it on MN, for example !!
Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 12:18

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@misssunshine4040 Eh? To whom do you want me to be grateful for my ability to earn a decent salary? I did it all off my own bat - I had no more opportunity than anyone else (in fact, quite the reverse).

I said I’m grateful for my state education, but I’m not sure who else you want me to be grateful to.

If I were receiving benefits then I would be very grateful because I would actually be receiving money that someone else had earned. Why wouldn’t someone feel grateful for that?[/quote]
Benefits are not ‘money that someone else has earned’. The welfare system is a safety net and recipients may have worked themselves before circumstances forced them to claim the benefits they are entitled to and have contributed to via National Insurance contributions. You may have heard of them !! Those who have not, have their contributions made for them via the NI system and are eligible for benefits that way - most people pay taxes and NI to fund a safety net they hope they will never have to use. I think gratitude is not so much for the individual benefit claimants to feel, but for us all to feel for the fact that we live in a civilised country with a system which aims to care for all - it’s not perfect, as evidenced by the prevalence of food banks, but in the main, it works.

And you may not think you had any more opportunity than anyone else, but think about those people who are trapped in difficult circumstances - where is their opportunity ? Take poverty, for example. Male children from poorer white working class are the least likely to go to university for example. Then there’s victims of discrimination because of disability, race, religion or sexual orientation. I’m very happy that you’re doing well, but if benefit recipients should be grateful for their lot, then maybe you should be too.

FailureToLurk · 29/01/2022 12:18

Sounds like she's had a big PIP back payment. These can be in the thousands especially if she is entitled to the higher rate on both mobility and Care.

When you apply for PIP that's when the payment is backdated to. If it takes months/years to sort out and appeals, you get a hefty backdated payment.

If it is the case she's using a PIP back payment, she is legally entitled to this money. PIP is not a income based benefit and makes no difference of you are a single or in a partnerships.

The not being technically being single and not updating the council and UC however is a whole other minefield, and by not reporting the change in circumstances she is committing benefit fraud, this will catch up with her. They only need one letter to go to the house on his name, and that's it game over.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/01/2022 12:10

@grey12

Can I ask the government to give me a cheap place to rent just for me DH and the kids??? I would love that. But I can't, because DH gets a reasonable pay from his job. So the only options for me is either expensive private rent and never having our house or throw our privacy to the wind and live with inlaws for 4 years and counting......

You're able to save because 1. His family are allowing you to live in their home (which you sound incredibly ungrateful for) and 2. Your husband has a reasonably paid job.

For many people the only option is expensive private rent and no saving, if they don't have in laws willing to put them up or the ability to earn well.

You have kids. That's an expense you've chosen too, one you have every right to choose IMO, but one that has stretched your finances further.

As to your first question... yes, anyone can apply. And as you've pointed out you would be unsuccessful as you have enough income as a family to rent.

You also have enough income to save. Because your in laws letting you live in their home is subsidising your living costs hugely. Maybe be thankful for that.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 29/01/2022 12:02

@grey12 anyone can apply for council housing. My work colleague lives in HA with her husband and kids. I am a single mum on a low wage and I never got a council place, I had to private rent. Everyone is assessed based on individual circumstances.

Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 12:00

@nomoneytree

Absolutely she should. Benefits are meant to be a short term thing. She will have gone without previously against what she was entitled to. You have to take every opportunity in life and this is a great opportunity for her.
RTFT - fairly obvious the friend has been committing benefit fraud and part of the back payment will inevitably be an overpayment due to that fraud.
Rosscameasdoody · 29/01/2022 11:58

@girlmom21

It is my money! I earned it and I give it to the government who distribute a large portion of it to people on benefits! As do other net contributors!

If it's your money does that mean I pay for your NHS treatment and your elderly parents social care?

It's not your money. It's a tax you pay. You don't go and buy a new pair of shoes then insist the company has to invest that money how you want because that's your money being invested.

And in many cases benefit claimants are tax payers themselves. A lot of benefits are taxable - off the top of my head, contributory ESA, carers allowance, UC, JSA, widowed parents allowance, bereavement allowance and state pension. In some circumstances child benefit is also taxable if you exceed the threshold.
Fr0thandBubble · 29/01/2022 11:58

@misssunshine4040 Eh? To whom do you want me to be grateful for my ability to earn a decent salary? I did it all off my own bat - I had no more opportunity than anyone else (in fact, quite the reverse).

I said I’m grateful for my state education, but I’m not sure who else you want me to be grateful to.

If I were receiving benefits then I would be very grateful because I would actually be receiving money that someone else had earned. Why wouldn’t someone feel grateful for that?

grey12 · 29/01/2022 11:54

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@grey12

Trust me I don't exactly LOVE living with my inlaws in order to save for a deposit

So you are also living somewhere free / subsidised in order to save... it just happens to be with relatives?

You realise not everyone is lucky enough to be able to have family who will house them for free / less than market rate?

What a hypocrite you are. [/quote]
Can I ask the government to give me a cheap place to rent just for me DH and the kids??? I would love that. But I can't, because DH gets a reasonable pay from his job. So the only options for me is either expensive private rent and never having our house or throw our privacy to the wind and live with inlaws for 4 years and counting......

Swipe left for the next trending thread