Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - do you ever regret a second child?

58 replies

Thatwassurreal · 28/01/2022 11:35

I’m totally on the fence about having a second child. Some days it’s all I can think about and some days I feel like I’ll never have the strength to do it all over again. My mind wanders and I think I have one happy healthy DD and shouldn’t wish for more. What if there were complications etc

Is this normal? I would hate to go for it and wish I hadn’t but then also would hate to regret not going for it. I guess maybe I’ll have regrets either way.

People say things like you only regret the children you don’t have.

YABU - of course you never regret a child
YANBU - I have regretted having more children

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thatwassurreal · 30/01/2022 08:27

Thank you again for the balanced and kind comments. It is so interesting to hear all your experiences.

I guess as one poster said you only feel regret in hindsight after you have made the decision (to stick at 1 or have another). So there is no guarantee either way about how I will feel.

I think before having children I never fully appreciated the absolute lottery having a baby is, the infinite outcomes that could arise and throw you life off in a different direction.

I think I need to really analyse my feeling on the days I’m broody and work out exactly what it is I’m yearning for. Is it truly a new baby? Or is it my Dd as a baby? Or perhaps feeling needed?

Lots to unpack. Thank you all x

OP posts:
Bibbitybobbityboo86 · 29/01/2022 20:29

I had this dilemma about 4 years ago. I decided to stick with one.
I grew up poor and went without a lot. I’m fortunate now to be comfortable and I don’t want my dd to go without. She is slightly spoilt but I think it’s the outcome of the trauma being so poor growing up.
We also don’t rely on other people for child care except nursery so didn’t want to fork out 2 lots of nursery fees.
We only had to go through the horrible stages once- pregnancy, child birth, lack of sleep, teething, potty training.

I also had very bad PND/anxiety. I couldn’t go through that again.

Siblings don’t always get on. My brothers a jerk and my husband doesn’t like his siblings either.

Also I think once me and my husband pass away my dd with inherite our house and £ so hopefully she’ll always be somewhat financially comfortable in the end

I love my family of 3. Small but perfectly manageable!

autienotnaughty · 29/01/2022 20:11

Didn't regret second but regretted the third until he was about four and started to get easier. With second it was like there was a space waiting for her.

Anotherboy · 29/01/2022 19:04

I also had terrible PND after my first, got it with the second but because we knew the signs and I had a plan in place it was no where near as bad. DC2 is 14 months now and the sibling relationship is amazing. Love it so much I'm currently expecting DC3! Not looking forward to the first 6 months, but once they're a year I just know everything will be brilliant, and it's such a short time compared to the rest of our lives.

Toloveandtowork · 29/01/2022 18:57

I had a second to provide a sibling. Not a good decision as they don't get on, and I had a loving and close relationship with my first, and missed that so much as it's a completely different dynamic when your attention is split.
Also, more personal freedom with one, and a lot less work.

merrygoround23 · 29/01/2022 18:49

Nope, mine fitted right in perfectly. I wasn't planning a second, we needs lots of ivf for my first. I then fell pregnant naturally 8 months after having my son. I lost the second pregnancy, I then was a woman on a mission to get pregnant naturally again. It worked and he's the best thing that's ever happened to us as a
Family

myyellowcar · 29/01/2022 18:46

Interesting discussion OP, mine is two and a half and I feel like since he turned two life has got easier. I hardly have to take any stuff out with us, he’s good company and although his sleep has got worse recently I still get many full nights sleep.

I enjoyed him as a baby, I loved the cuddles, proudly pushed my pram and embraced the ‘baby life’. But in hindsight I did find it very hard because honestly it just does not suit me and does not allow me time to do things that make me happy. The lack of me time and lack of sleep. I found the relentlessness made life really unenjoyable.

If you handed me a two year old, I’d say yes. But I don’t want to go back to square one again. I’d love two children and for DS to have a sibling though.

Just the one damaged my body and I’m worried about the impact of a second. I also don’t yet feel quite myself and my marriage is shaken.

So in all likelihood I won’t have another but I do think about it a lot.

Spudina · 29/01/2022 17:28

I think having two is actually easier, once you get past the baby/toddler stage. I have two DDs7 and 10. They play together, entertain each other (with some squabbling). My friends who have only children have much more exhausting lives than me, constantly having to play with and entertain their child. The love they have for each other is also really lovely to see. Though sometimes well hidden!!

UserBotTrending · 29/01/2022 17:23

@GhoulWithADragonTattoo

I suspect most of the people saying they do regret having one of their children probably wasn't going from 1 to 2. 1 to 2 is not too much more work, especially if they do mostly the same clubs, and the kids are natual playmates for each other.
i went from 1 to 2.

The reason I regret it is it made my life SO MUCH HARDER

Love isn't enough.

cptartapp · 29/01/2022 15:28

Never, despite having no urge for a second. Now 19 and 16 and watching the sibling relationship grow and develop and share family experiences has been the single best part of parenting.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 29/01/2022 15:27

I suspect most of the people saying they do regret having one of their children probably wasn't going from 1 to 2. 1 to 2 is not too much more work, especially if they do mostly the same clubs, and the kids are natual playmates for each other.

Caterina99 · 29/01/2022 15:18

With a 2 year age gap and a challenging toddler and sleep avoiding baby there were definitely dark early days, where I was jealous of friends with just one child. But now (age 6 and 4) I genuinely can’t imagine our life without DC2, she absolutely is a joy.

However there’s no way I’m going for DC3. Lots of friends have 3 and sometimes I do daydream about another baby, but I just know I can’t do it all again. And like you say, I have 2 healthy kids, I’m not rolling the dice a third time.

hangrylady · 29/01/2022 12:28

No and I don't know anybody who does.

UserBotTrending · 29/01/2022 11:50

Honestly honestly I do sometimes briefly ''run a tape'' in my head where I only had the one dc, where I got away from my abusive x earlier, where I could get back in to the workplace younger, with just the one child, where I got a place for just two of us sooner, and it was more affordable. This doesn't matter to me now, I'm at peace with being single but perhaps I would have either met somebody new if I hadn't had so much responsibility and so little freedom. Perhaps I'd have a wider circle of friends. I'm 51 and I feel like I made a few bad choices. That doesn't mean I don't love dc2. But you can just have this other tape in your head where you have the awareness of the easier life you could have had, with less responsibility, more money, more time to nurture relationships and friendships ....

DontWantTheRivalry · 29/01/2022 11:47

I can’t click YABUor YANBU because of course some people regret having a second whereas others won’t regret it.

Sadly though, the way you feel only comes with hindsight once the second baby has arrived.

It’s a risk that a woman has to choose to take.

My DH didn’t want a second whereas I was desperate for one and it took about 12 months of me asking him before he agreed to TTC#2.

Neither of us have ever regretted it, it was the best thing we did for us as a family and also the best thing we did for our first child.

I imagine the risk of regretting a second child is much more likely if a woman is on the fence about having one in the first place, so it’s a hard decision to make.

UserBotTrending · 29/01/2022 11:47

I think a lot of living situations, bank balances, careers, relationships and social circles can survive one child but not two. I literally had to relocate and start again when I left my x with two DC.

I know I'm supposed to say I love him so much how could I ever say I regret having had a second child but although he was an adorable child, he was harder work than dc1, he had some issues. After relocating and starting again in a new location and going for 18 milestone checks in a new country, they thought he had autism and we were instantly flung in to assessment process for that. Now, he's 15 and he refuses to go to school. It affects my relationship with DC1 who can't understand why I don't just give up on Dc2, obviously you can't do that, when the child is here you have to do your best for them even if it causes your DC1 to lose some attention.

SapphosRock · 29/01/2022 11:40

I was in exactly the same boat as you OP. Had one DD and we were a happy unit of 3. Was on the fence for ages about having another.

Truthfully, knowing what I know now, I would have stuck with one child. Had a terrible pregnancy, lockdown baby, postnatal anxiety. I love him to bits and he's a good boy but fuck me the toddler stage is hard. Teething. Constant illness. Sleepless nights, waking up night after night. They currently share a room so we will have to move.

We have no family support, that makes a big difference. With one child you get a break every time they have a play date, not so with two.

With one child I managed to hold down a decent job and built a good career. That's all gone out the window now, I'm too exhausted.

I wouldn't be without him though! And I'm hoping it gets easier.

Thatwassurreal · 28/01/2022 18:36

Wow blown away by all these responses. It is so good to hear all your experiences.

My heart says have another, dd would love a sibling, you might not have PND again, the baby stage is short etc

My head is saying stop at one. What if there are complications for me and the baby, a million what ifs that would disrupt our happy trio.

I think I am also hesitant as 2 close friends have had big issues (baby needing kidney transplant and another friends baby had a stroke). It has planted a massive seed of what if.

It’s almost like if I look to the future I can easily imagine lots of children sitting round the dinner table, big family christmases, but the thought of another newborn is a bit terrifying.

I really appreciate all your responses. It certainly gives me a lot to consider x

OP posts:
Devo1818 · 28/01/2022 18:34

Never. But I never doubted I wanted one either.

leavingthispoohole · 28/01/2022 18:26

Very happily one and done! Having 2 looks like absolute carnage. I love the freedom having one gives me (shes 2 years old). I like money and lie ins and i also like being able to work full time. Shes a wonderful addition to our family but i just couldnt imagine adding another one, feel like i have hit the jackpot already!

neverbeenskiing · 28/01/2022 17:58

I have definitely had moments of regret...maybe sometimes more than a moment, but there are also moments of joy watching the two of them together. I found going from one to two incredibly hard. All that stuff about how second DC are easy and just slot in...ha! Our second DC didn't sleep and has suspected SEN so it hasn't been easy. I also had PND with my second which came as a shock as I didn't have it first time around. Youngest is 3.5 now and it feels like there is light at the end of the tunnel. Life would definitely be much easier if we'd stopped at one but would I make a different choice if I could turn back the clock? Probably depends which day you ask me to be honest.

mishmased · 28/01/2022 17:48

I don't regret any of mine thankfully. I had two with a 30 month gap and when they were 5.5 and 8 had a third baby.
My first was a tough baby due to having eczema, reflux, allergies and undiagnosed tongue tie. A friend asked if second was planned when I told her about being pregnant with second.
We decided on number two quickly because I felt if we left it to over two years I will not want to have another. Being an only child I never wanted to have just one. I don't enjoy the baby phase until just about age 1 which was why we waited to see if I really wanted another. This baby has made me enjoy having a baby again and hopefully we're getting through the tough baby stages. I love seeing them playing with each other and the baby and after I had the third I just felt complete. So maybe you don't want to have another.

Rebelmcstreettuff · 28/01/2022 17:47

Never...love my 2nd to bits,he's so loving and caring,much more so than the 1st!
4 years between them,kept each other company growing up on holidays,Christmas etc,so glad we had another.

WhatAWasteOfOranges · 28/01/2022 17:42

As an only child and mother of two I have zero regrets (though sometimes think longingly with rose tinted glasses about how simple life was with none!)
My second has actually been a much harder child but it’s so much easier second time around and you’re already in the swing of it. They love each other to pieces. Though I know two is my limit 100%, we can give two the time, attention, love and financial security that would be harder than three.

RedToothBrush · 28/01/2022 16:52

Friends of mine had one and wanted two. Very much wanted. They love him to bits. But do regret having a second. He was diagnosed with a life long illness, which means their lives and the life of their older daughter revolve around hospital appointments. They can't leave him and they cant travel far. The whole situation is just shit. He is doing well but its traumatic for them to see him unwell or in pain and obviously its not a lot of fun for their son. It also has a massive effect on the life they had mapped out for their daughter. Its really not the dream they thought they were signed up for.

The little boy is loved to the moon and back but yeah, they regret that life really hasn't served them a good deck of cards. At times i believe its threatened their marriage and going through everything has cost them their mental well being.

Maybe in time things will improve but yeah they've expressed regret, particularly at moments when they've felt at rock bottom.

The dad has said that he wished he'd thought more about the possibility that a second child might have a health problem, before they made the decision to have a second because he lost his 'perfect' life and everything became so much more complicated.

I only wanted one but i occasionally have a wobble. I just have to look around and siblings that do not get on and my friends situation to think 'why take that gamble?' We are happy and grateful for what we have and id rather be that. You can't miss what you don't have.