Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s disingenuous to say breastfeeding is free?

673 replies

Jerrui · 28/01/2022 02:09

When pregnant encountered lots and lots of breastfeeding promotion- often it’s cited it being free as a benefit.

I have personally found as soon as you actually have a baby and are feeding it there is absolutely zero support. In my area there is no infant feeding team etc just community midwife who told me to substitute BF with FF at two weeks old when baby failed to regain birth weight.

I have spent hundreds of pounds on lactation consultant, double electric pump, milk storage, trying to keep breastfeeding going.

I have added formula top up and was shocked how cheap it is. We got bottles for free in those Emma’s diary type packs, and Aldi formula costs £2 a week.

I think trying to promote breastfeeding as a more economic option to pregnant women is stupid.
I feel actually public funds would be much better spend on training and recruiting to provide actual support to mothers trying to breastfeed, rather than health promotion with misleading, simplistic and dumbed down messages.
I feel it’s no wonder breastfeeding is mainly the preserve of the middle classes when you have to invest so much money to get any help!

OP posts:
StopStartStop · 28/01/2022 08:17

I was very lucky to have a supportive counsellor, for free, through the Association of Breastfeeding Mothers. I showed my gratitude by being a volunteer counsellor myself, for eleven years.

The ABM are unconscionable now, as they use the term 'chestfeeding' - anti-woman nonsense - but the principle holds true that if women support each other breastfeeding is usually possible, usually rewarding and usually inexpensive.

Phos · 28/01/2022 08:14

I guess it can be free if you’re one of those people who has no issues whatsoever.

JugglingJanuary · 28/01/2022 08:12

[quote NumberTheory]@Mrbob
EmiliaAirheart

I’ve also heard: breastfeeding is only free if a woman’s time is worth nothing.

That’s a pretty depressing view of your child

It has nothing to do with how anyone views any children. It simply points out, as with so much that women do, that people frequently ignore the labour involved.[/quote]
Well, if you're going to count the cost of untiring your child (whether that breast feeding/bottle feeding - you still need to hold the bottle while they feed, nappy changing or cuddles) you probably should have children.

Summerfun54321 · 28/01/2022 08:12

Sorry to hear you haven’t had support but you are talking shite. I breastfed 1 DC and bottle fed the other and there’s a very obvious cost difference.

NinaDefoe · 28/01/2022 08:12

@Mustreadabook

But presumably somebody is going to feed the baby? And sterilising bottles, making fresh formula each feed with hot water, cooling it,( as per guidelines) and feeding isn’t going to take less time, once baby has got the hang of breastfeeding. I admit I did sometimes wish someone else could feed baby, but it would have used their time as much as mine.
Bottle prepping, cleaning, feeding can be a shared job. Definitely takes the pressure off the woman when both parents take responsibility.
WhatNoRaisins · 28/01/2022 08:09

It's a bit simplistic to say free though I'd assume the average cost of EBF is going to be less than the average cost of EFF. There's such a wide range of experiences though and I don't think we get realistic information on breastfeeding antenatally, it's very best case scenario.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 28/01/2022 08:09

@UpDownRound

Unless all the women who breastfed and are saying its free had massive amounts of weight to lose or ended up underweight, it literally cannot have been free. Food costs money. You need to eat more when you are breastfeeding. Breast milk takes extra calories to produce - this cannot be disputed.

I'm not saying it's not cheaper than ff but it cannot be true that it is free!

You just have to eat properly -maybe an extra 3-400 calories when fully breastfeeding- so hardly a major expense.
Mustreadabook · 28/01/2022 08:09

But presumably somebody is going to feed the baby? And sterilising bottles, making fresh formula each feed with hot water, cooling it,( as per guidelines) and feeding isn’t going to take less time, once baby has got the hang of breastfeeding. I admit I did sometimes wish someone else could feed baby, but it would have used their time as much as mine.

NinaDefoe · 28/01/2022 08:08

DietrichandDiMaggio
Other than feed 24/7?
I can think of many things!

FinallySomeNormality · 28/01/2022 08:08

@LimeSegment

Totally agree OP, breastfeeding is like anything, you can spend as much as you want. Some bfers end up with a pump (even 2-3 pumps if the first one doesn't suit), full set of bottles, nursing bras and clothes, lactation consultant, extra food, etc, etc).

In addition, some pro bf threads on here go on about how formula feeding/formula is so so expensive as a deterrant. That just isn't true, it's quite cheap compared to other foods. £5-10 to feed one human for a week! It's by far the least you will spend on your kids food for the next 18 years.

Don't get me wrong, I love bf and fully support it, but it's promotion should be based on science, not on half truths someone thinks will appeal to women. Also see - "bf will make you lose weight".

I agree with this.

I think BF can be free. But reality is that it's not likely to be totally free.

For DS1 I FF from birth and all I spent is £25 on bottle set and then it's £10 per week for formula (could get cheaper if got Aldi own but we prefer Hipp which is £10). That was at the height of milk intake. Now on solids it's less as we don't even get through a box a week. Yes, that's more than Bf so FF is likely more expensive overall - but it's not the massively, exaggerated expensive outlay that my antenatal classes seemed to suggest!

I think what people sometimes overlook too is the cost of clothing. Many end up having to spend on button down shirts etc as their original wardrobe might not have enough Bf friendly clothes.

Dreambigger · 28/01/2022 08:07

Think if it goes well it is a lot cheaper than bottle feeding.... We have no Aldi in NI and I have never found formula to be cheap..at least £10 / week . Think its not a very helpful narrative for choosing to.breastfeed though and of course the support is non existent in many areas.

Motherhippo · 28/01/2022 08:06

I struggled with breastfeeding for the first few months of DDs life. Struggles with latching, a preference for only one boob and three bouts of mastitis. Other than buying formula and bottles to top up if I felt she wasn't getting enough I didn't spend any other money on "specialists" and point blank refused to spend extortionate money on an electronic pump.
I also had little/no support. None of my friends had children and I live in a rural area and don't drive so even if their was breastfeeding support I was unable to access it. I agree more needs to be spent in supporting new mums, especially since the hospital tends to favour breastfeeding over formula.
In the end I cracked it through the support of others on MN and YouTube videos made by mums, and pure blood, sweat and tears.
It was a right slog but we eventually got it and she was breastfed until about 14 months old.
I am not middle class, in any way shape or form. 😊

NinaDefoe · 28/01/2022 08:06

@EmiliaAirheart

I’ve also heard: breastfeeding is only free if a woman’s time is worth nothing.
Just about to say this very thing.

I value time and contentment over money.
I was a very happy bottle feeder and my DC were very content little babies. Worked very well all round and wouldn’t change a thing.

AlbusSeverusMalfoy · 28/01/2022 08:05

Bottle feeding is not cheap if it's you're only option. Lots of bottles coz you're too tired to keep washing up and sterilising every 2/3/4 hours. Tubs of formula £9-£10 a pop. If your baby is hungry or needs different milk that's about £50 plus a month. Decent sterilisers are cheap. If your on a low income and can't breast feed it's expensive and undrunk formula can't be kept or frozen

monkeysox · 28/01/2022 08:05

@youngstreet so I could go for keep in touch days with work, to the shops for a couple hours on my own occasionally. Or even out for dinner with my husband. She just cried and waited until I got back which was awful and why we didn't do it until she was much older (almost 1)

Goldenbear · 28/01/2022 08:05

Breastfeeding was free to me but I switched to formula at 3 months with my first as my DS just stopped and turned away. I wish I had found a way to continue. My DD breast fed until nearly 2. We didn't have as much money when we had DS and we certainly noticed how much more it was to FF compared to say more cake!

I don't know how you can put a monetary spin on it - maybe i have unusual maternal instinct but it is no way valueless

Giggorata · 28/01/2022 08:04

Breastfeeding was free for me x2. I was a SAHM and really skint, so I bought none of the bras, clothes or paraphernalia that people have now.

In those days, mothers and babies stayed in hospital a lot longer, around ten days, and the nurses worked to help those of us that were BF get it well established and things like bathing and nappy changing.
So I went home reasonably confident with BF, etc.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 28/01/2022 08:03

@EmiliaAirheart

I’ve also heard: breastfeeding is only free if a woman’s time is worth nothing.
What else should the mother of a newborn be doing with her time?
HeadNorth · 28/01/2022 08:03

It was free for me - never needed any special help, never pumped, never gave bottles. Totally free.

Couchbettato · 28/01/2022 08:03

When breastfeeding doesn't work, whether that's because it becomes costly to resolve, or whether there's no support, it's not the fault of the mother.

It's a woeful systematic let down.

Breastfeeding is free, being able to breastfeed isn't.

It being "free" is not the reason most people choose to pursue it though.

I know Mumsnet likes to downplay the benefits of breastfeeding, but to some people those benefits are really important to them.

Services that should be offered on the NHS like lactation consultation are privatised because the NHS hardly see it as a necessity.

The cost of fixing breastfeeding issues unfortunately at the moment outweighs the benefits of breastfeeding.

It's a broken system, and it leaves new mums feeling guilty, like failures, like they haven't done enough, grieving this preconceived notion of their perfect first few years and it's largely out of their hands! It's awful, and I really feel for those mother's.

I'm fortunate to live in an area that's had its 10 year UNICEF baby friendly accreditation and offers community support for breastfeeding but LA across the country have cut funding for it and peer support is not offered in lots of areas so the windows where common breastfeeding issues could be caught and resolved is being missed.

Nothing in life is free, but support to do a human bodily function should be realistic and achievable. Sadly, for a growing number, it's not.

JugglingJanuary · 28/01/2022 08:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Lalliella · 28/01/2022 08:03

@EmiliaAirheart

I’ve also heard: breastfeeding is only free if a woman’s time is worth nothing.
What a totally depressing materialistic view of life. So everything should have a monetary value should it? What an awful world.
FKATondelayo · 28/01/2022 08:03

I’ve also heard: breastfeeding is only free if a woman’s time is worth nothing.

Yes, because FF babies can prepare, make and wash their own bottles. What an absolutely stupid comment.

BogRollBOGOF · 28/01/2022 08:01

Running is a "free" sport too Grin

Baby 1:
Nursing bras- already bought in 5 sizes as I grew through pregnancy
BFing tops- I had to buy new tops anyway as my 5 cups bigger breasts did not fit in standard clothes. I also had to buy a new set of over the bump maternity trousers post-CS as my under the bumps rubbed the wound, and a couple of sets in declining sizes to get me back to normal size.
Breast pads- a few boxes for the early days, had some given
Bottles/steriliser- had to be bought anyway. Went cheaper as I intended light use.
Breast pump- tried a £10 manual, then a £50 electric when he was 10m, but he staunchly refused to take bottles and my body didn't like expressing. Another flurry of useless bottles that he had no interest in.
Support- muddled by on the initial help in HDU and a bit from HVs. Mainly from online discussion. I didn't hear much about lactation consultants (2010)
Prescriptions- free

Baby 2:
Washable breast pads- supply was far higher
Medela breast pump- it did get something out, not that this one took bottles either.
Tube of lansinoh
Everything else was reusable from baby 1.

It turned out that DS1 had cows milk and soya allergies/ intolerances so if BFing hadn't worked, he'd have ended up on neocate, which buying additional quanities off prescription was incredibly expensive.

Over BFing for 13m and 20m, BFing was the cheaper option and the vast quantity of the outlay from baby 1 covered the needs with baby 2.
Truely free? No, but many of those start up costs would have had to be covered if I'd FFed anyway.

RussianSpy101 · 28/01/2022 08:01

@solbunny no, it’s fine! I haven’t read the full thread so hadn’t seen many other comments on them to be honest.
Definitely a postcode lottery when it comes to maternity services.