Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider using a crate for puppy

67 replies

Barnybrown · 27/01/2022 22:29

We are buying a miniature golden doodle puppy who will join our family in March. We lost our much loved 16 year old dog just after Christmas and never used a crate for him - he was just given the run of the house. A few people have recommended using a crate with the puppy but I feel reluctant- I don’t like the idea of putting him in a cage. Can you share your experience of using a crate - was it good for the puppy ?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 28/01/2022 10:29

I used a crate for my 2 Lhassa Apso until they were about 17 months. They slept in their crates. They used them as a retreat from cats and child. Doors were mostly open and they could run in and out of them but I closed them for 1 hour twice a week when cleaner came as she not keen on dogs and so she could get on without them under her feet. By about 17 months they were properly trained and so moved to large baskets. I only use crate for visiting vet for annual jabs now.

jowly · 28/01/2022 10:23

*they're

jowly · 28/01/2022 10:22

@Giraffesandbottoms

Isn’t a dog’s “safe space” their bed? It’s somewhere my dog goes when he wants to be alone but he isn’t shut in there…I don’t I understand crating at all. To me it’s something people do for their own convenience and then bizarrely dress up as being “for the dog” 🤦🏻‍♀️
I agree. 'Crate' is just a euphemism for cage. I can completely agree with a bed, or any open covered thing, but the minute you lock them in there caged.

Just awful.

3teens2cats · 28/01/2022 10:04

Puppies need somewhere they can be put for a short while to keep them safe while they are still learning, much like a baby or toddler. That could be a crate or a gate on a puppy proofed room, play pen etc.

Chely · 28/01/2022 09:56

Crates are fantastic for puppies and adult dogs. We have kept the crate for our now 6 year old dog, it is her safe space where the kids are not allowed to bother her.

Spidey66 · 28/01/2022 09:43

We used it for a year, for sleep and house training. They won't pee where they sleep on the whole though if desparate may do. It was useful but we graduated to a bed after about a year.

I think in our heads we were comparing it to a cot!

queenMab99 · 28/01/2022 09:37

I started off by using a gate to keep my pup in the kitchen overnight, to stop him chewing wires etc. in the dining room, but after a couple of weeks he could jump the gate! I then resorted to a crate for nights to keep him and my furniture safe. It proved very useful as it enabled forced rest when he needed it, like a small over excited child, he would fall asleep without stimulation. It was also useful to crate train him for travelling, he was always happy and relaxed in his crate in the car, and the car stayed clean.

Giraffesandbottoms · 28/01/2022 09:25

Isn’t a dog’s “safe space” their bed? It’s somewhere my dog goes when he wants to be alone but he isn’t shut in there…I don’t I understand crating at all. To me it’s something people do for their own convenience and then bizarrely dress up as being “for the dog” 🤦🏻‍♀️

GiveMeNovocain · 28/01/2022 09:10

Our dog sleeps in a crate but with the door open. It's a lovely cosy safe space for her and we only shut her in when we have visitors who are scared of dogs or back door and gate open to do garden work that needs electricity so rare and never for more than an hour. It's been useful for very specific circumstances but not necessary as we could probably shut her in a room/lead her in these situations but it's been nice to have this as an option. If she's not in the mood she lets me know by barking so I find an alternative. I hate the idea of crating for long periods. They're not a cage animal

alpinia · 28/01/2022 09:03

Crates really do have their place, and some puppies really love them. Especially with a blanket over 3 sides it becomes a sort of safe nest to retreat to.

It also depends how in to things they are. Our current dog did use his crate when young but we left the door open all night from a very young age as he was not a bitey or chewy dog, and didn't like the door to be closed. The previous puppy was a hurricane when left alone but settled down to nap as soon as the door was closed. They are all a bit different!

Barnybrown · 28/01/2022 08:57

Thank you all for your comments - I have read them all and really appreciate them. I am slightly nervous about taking on a puppy after all these years - our gorgeous old dog was 16 years old when he died and really just wanted to sleep and be warm in his bed with us all around him. Lockdown was a blessing for him as we never had to really leave him alone and he loved just chilling with us. I have tried to warn the kids that a puppy is going to be a different creature entirely !

OP posts:
AlwaysLatte · 28/01/2022 00:37

I never liked the idea of crates previously but out latest 24 week old pup Is a Labrador and he's so much more into everything than our last pup. We're both home so he gets a lot of attention and likes to take himself voluntarily off for some quiet time. He's in it at night 12.00-6.30 then again for a nap at around 11 for an hour then again at about 2.30. It's the one place he can totally relax and he takes himself in there every day.

LakieLady · 28/01/2022 00:03

I used a crate for both mine when they were puppies, but only overnight or when we were out.

It worked a treat for puppy no1, but puppy no2 never took to it. She was a breeze though, housetrained in 3 days and hardly chewed a thing, so it wasn't a problem.

Theluggage15 · 27/01/2022 23:59

We were the same, our old springer spaniel died a couple of years ago and we now have a 10 month old springer. We’d never used a crate before but decided to give it a go. We only shut it at night and spent a few weeks sleeping beside him and slowly moving away to get him confident about sleeping on his own. He does go in it during the day sometimes just for a rest or with a toy and when it gets late in the evening he sometimes takes himself off to bed.

We’re thinking of getting rid of it in a couple of months starting by leaving the door open at night and seeing how he gets on.

If he’d been upset in the crate we would not have bothered, all dogs are different, maybe just see how he goes.

Booklover3 · 27/01/2022 23:51
  • I should add that we’ve only actually used it as a proper crate at night when we can’t watch her. In the daytime she has the run of the diningroom and kitchen when we are out.

She’s a lab. We have the largest crate. Think it was an extra, extra large one.

Booklover3 · 27/01/2022 23:49

Our puppy cried when she was originally put in the crate. She stopped crying when we slept on the sofa next to her… the next month or so we then slowly moved away till she was perfectly happy sleeping in there on her own. She’s now 9 months and when it’s bed time or she wants some peace she takes herself off to her crate. The kids know that when she does it’s because she wants quiet time. She’s got a lovely bed in there and it’s like a
mini bedroom for her.

I think crates are great for some dogs if used appropriately. Not great for others. Trial and error. Try one and see. If you don’t get on with it then at least you tried.

jowly · 27/01/2022 23:39

@Huntswomanonthemove

Dogs don’t see a crate as a cage, they see it as their bed and place of safety. We’ve trained three puppies with a crate and we thoroughly recommend them.
Puppies who become distressed and cry when locked in a metal cage but are instantly ok when allowed out might disagree.

The only time ours cried and was clearly very distressed was when we (naively) put her in one. The only time. It went straight in the loft.

Huntswomanonthemove · 27/01/2022 23:35

Dogs don’t see a crate as a cage, they see it as their bed and place of safety. We’ve trained three puppies with a crate and we thoroughly recommend them.

TheSecretaryBird · 27/01/2022 23:32

Both my dogs are crate trained and it gives them a safe space where they can retreat to. The nearly 2 year old collie has his closed at night as he can’t be trusted with the cat but he is calm and happy, and loves his bed!
The 8 y/o JRT sleeps in hers without the door being closed although it has been closed at night in the past.
At one point we had a crate in the living room for the collie so that he could learn to chill out but that is partly due to the breed - he had to be taught how to be calm and chill.
Crate training can be really positive for your dog and your family - it’s not just a case of locking the dog away

Mo1911 · 27/01/2022 23:19

I've got a 9 month old German Shepherd cross and he's never been caged. It's a pretty new phenomenon and I'm really not sure why it's almost as much as a must have as a collar and lead!!

There's a lot of talk of dogs needing a "safe place" etc but my son put it perfectly when he said, their home with their family is their safe place, why would they need a safe place within their safe place. Makes sense to me!! 😄

Brigante9 · 27/01/2022 23:19

Mine are in separate crates, otherwise they’d be playfighting constantly and chewing through cables. They’re puppies, it’s what they do. The place is puppy proofed, but then they start chewing the corner of the tv cabinet.

It’s a nice safe dark place to pop them in for an hour for a nap. They’re in overnight. It keeps them safe, plus gives the older dog a break. Due to m6 DH’s shifts, they’re rarely in there during the day unless he needs to pop out to the shops. They’re happy to go in, they scamper into the correct crate when I ask them, smart boys.

Allaboutyou222 · 27/01/2022 23:18

We have one. It’s covered. The dog sleeps in there and goes in there when we eat. We never lock it.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 27/01/2022 23:17

I've never crate trained my dog and he's four now. He has the run of downstairs while we're out and he's never once been destructive.

I suspect it's down to the original dog as much as anything else.

Fedupsotired · 27/01/2022 23:15

We use a crate but our dog has dementia and was struggling at night getting distressed, being locked in the crate has actually stopped this as I think he now feels safe.
They definitely have a place and can help keep your dog and belongs safe

MatildaTheCat · 27/01/2022 23:14

I have a miniature golden doodle and believed a crate was what you had to use. He hated it and we had various problems until we ditched it at around 5 months. Taking the door off might have helped but honestly he just wanted to be with us.

I’ve never allowed him to sleep with us unless he’s I’ll but he has free reign of the house and doesn’t have a set place to sleep. I depends on your views and lifestyle but works for us. I always thought my dog would never be allowed upstairs. That was before I had a dog that cried when I was away from him.

Try to allow yourself to think flexibly about the whole puppy thing. It’s a lot like having a baby. You can’t really know what you are getting.

Enjoy.😊