Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel childish but want to tell PILS they backed the wrong horse?

158 replies

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 21:24

I feel like a petulant child writing this but, its true. When I first met DH about 16 years ago - sil had also started to date someone. He moved into pils large house quite quickly as he was from a different country working in banking and was saving money, I dont know if he paid rent at all.

I met DH and DH stayed a lot with me and my DM in a really small cramped cottage and she never batted an eye, happily fed him etc he was quite miserable when I first met him and her attitude to life, the way she was and I really helped him. it was no big deal at all to use to house him, take him to dinner, feed him at home,...very much muck in sitation.

After about 10 months I had an awful tradgey happen and ended up living on peoples sofas. One lot of people was pils. About two or three nights a week I asked persmission or he did for me to stay over. It was made clear that was all I was allowed. whether that was MIl or fil I was never sure.
At the time and I still am to a degree extremely grateful they let me stay. But they treated me and sils partner then husband very differently. So at this time I was moving from place to place a few nights a week with a bag, essentially homeless and sils BF was staying there full time.

Then sil married him to keep him in the UK and pils gave her a deposit to buy a flat. They just gave it to her with no strings or contracts. They did the same for Dh my Bf at the time but he had to have a contract drawn up, I was not allowed to contribute and it had to be done legally I guess to protect him from me.

Yet sils BF /husband had no such protections? (Apparently her DH essentially being her lodger was the cause of huge arguments and they divorced after a few years. )

DH and I are still together but I always feel like they treat me like I am shifty.

They have always treated SIl differently from dh. like they dont trust dh with a house key but sil has one, sil treats pils like ahome from home and yet dh is closey montired by mil and cant move freely around the house.
Sil never ended up having dc but we do, and we dont really want to see pils, dh doesnt feel comfortable around them, etc etc. They have been rude about our house , mil has cried over our house whilst saying what sil can afford, said my degree is useless etc.
Its sad for me that we dont have a great relatinship with them, they are not good with the dc and sometimes i want to scream...you backed the wrong horses! They gave everything to sil and her then partner whilst treating me like a tramp. NOw ai am the mother of the grandchildren - they have done many things in betweeen. No one ever mentioned sils ex - or even that they divorced no one told DH I just noticed her wedding ring missing once. I wouldnt be ableto say he was a nice person in any way - he was a banker though and they hold that in high regard.

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 27/01/2022 23:09

What age were you when you found yourself homeless - what age was your then boyfriend?

I wouldn’t expect my boyfriends parents to put me up. Why didn’t your boyfriend help you?

They don’t sound like particularly nice people, but you need to let it go.

And as others have said, you haven’t won anything by staying married and having kids. Your aren’t better or worse than your siL. Your I. Laws just didn’t like you for some reason: their loss

Cleanbedlinen12 · 27/01/2022 22:58

Hello op. I get totally how you mean so just wanted to give hugs. His mum and dad revere his sister. She’s a drama queen that can do no wrong whereas we are critiscised for every little thing. Yes it rankles, because somehow we are in a competition and everyone knows thee rules except us. Yes we are adults etc etc, but it’s still just, unjust. We have to listen to MIL telling us how hard SIL has it when she patently doesn’t and it’s all crated to get maximum drama/ attention. I’m with you OP!

bossybloss · 27/01/2022 22:56

Yes, they did back the wrong horse.You reap what you sow etc etc.

They did not invest in their relationship with you and now you are not beholden to them.I would just concentrate on your own family with any regret or remorse.

DiddyHeck · 27/01/2022 22:56

Maybe your PIL backed the right horse after all, in that they focussed more on which son or daughter in law was kinder?

This, with bells on.

Hshuznw · 27/01/2022 22:53

@JanuaryBluehoo

Well hsh yes!! Thankfully unlike sil with her dh my husband never treated me like a lodger!! Paying him rent. And we ddint marry under pressure to keep me here .

Who knows what will happen in future?

You being married with children doesn’t make you the better person, and your belief that it does reflects poorly on you.

Maybe your PIL backed the right horse after all, in that they focussed more on which son or daughter in law was kinder?

DiddyHeck · 27/01/2022 22:53

@JanuaryBluehoo

They treated dh as less. They treated me as less but revered sils dh.

They could have said I could stay like sils bf but it was made clear I wasn't that welcome. At that time I was literally homeless and desperate. So I was grateful for any help but looking back I realised hang on....sils bf was living there full time and I was having to ask dh was every week.

It went on for about three months until I rented a room.

Sils bf was there for at least a year until pil gave them a deposit

At this point they were probably pig sick of running a hotel for their kids partners. You keep saying you were grateful for any help but because they took on in permanently you're basically saying they should've done the same for you.

Why?? What makes you think you were entitled to live in their house? They sound like lovely people, opening their home and dishing out money to their adult kids.

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 22:47

Married people have more claim on each other's asset

OP posts:
FoamBurst · 27/01/2022 22:46

I get what you mean.
I'd go. NC with them. They sound horrible.
They can't treat their daughter differently to their son. Which is essentially what they did.
Gave their dd a no strings attached deposit. Not their son.
And other things

My fil had a similar upbringing I've hear the stories of how a him and his sister were treated differently and still are even in their 60s. It's so sad

Feedingthebirds1 · 27/01/2022 22:44

@JanuaryBluehoo

* which is fine...I don't expect everyone to like me but I can't help feel now are have dc...They expect to see them more but neither of us particularly want to spend anytime with then
Then don't spend any time with them. It's not mandatory. You have two DCs - imagine how you'd feel if the ILs decided that one of them was their golden DGC and the other was the scapegoat?

I don't think you worded your opening post (or thread title) very well, but your explanations have made it clearer. What you mean is that they were very unfair in their treatment of you and DH compared to SIL and her husband and it rankles.

I hope you didn't mean that you feel you are morally superior to SIL just because you have children and are still married.

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 22:44

Well hsh yes!!
Thankfully unlike sil with her dh my husband never treated me like a lodger!! Paying him rent. And we ddint marry under pressure to keep me here .

Who knows what will happen in future?

OP posts:
Toomuch2do · 27/01/2022 22:43

But they did treat their DC equally in giving them both deposits. You are presumably benefiting from that now?

MrsTimRiggins · 27/01/2022 22:42

@Hshuznw

Backed the wrong horse? Because SIL got divorced and doesn’t have children? So that makes her lesser and you guys have won?

Well don’t you sound a peach!

Honestly this. You dwelling on things that happened in the dim and distant past is so unhealthy. Choose to not see your PIL, by all means, it sounds as though that would benefit you, but the hold this toxic past has on you isn’t something I’d be giving headspace to.
Tsuni · 27/01/2022 22:41

You’ve worded this very strangely.

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 22:41

They invested so much in the relationship with bil and zilch with me.
Bil was extremely important for them because he had a good career. But he didn't contribute when sil brought her first house .
They were given the deposit no strings attached.

I offered to top up dh and was turned down and even through I was only a gf he had to sign legal stuff.

OP posts:
Hshuznw · 27/01/2022 22:34

@VodselForDinner

Congratulations, OP, you won. What a silly SIL you had, marrying a man she’d later divorce. The fool!! If only she was as smart and clever and amazing as you!!

You’re amazing OP. AMAZING.

This! So amazing!

Well done on still being married OP! Bravo!

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 22:34

Covid I do feel very bitter ...i forget about them ...then they start to pressure dh.

OP posts:
Georgeskitchen · 27/01/2022 22:33

Your PIL sound horrible and not the kind of people I would want in my DCs lives

Lolamento · 27/01/2022 22:33

May be they did not like you to marry their son? Who knows but I think the fact that you are still concern about this is a bit unhealthy for you. Move on and be grateful you have a family.

Hshuznw · 27/01/2022 22:33

Backed the wrong horse? Because SIL got divorced and doesn’t have children? So that makes her lesser and you guys have won?

Well don’t you sound a peach!

CovidForChristmas · 27/01/2022 22:31

You sound very bitter.

Letting go of resentment like this is incredibly liberating.

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 22:29

@VodselForDinner

What have I won?

I was homeless and desperate sleeping on people's sofas and asking permission each week to stay with dh in an extremely large and spacious house .I was in absolute crisis.

Yet sils bf was just living there?

My one family had happily housed fed entertained dh with far fewer resources
..so it wasn't a totally loaded deficit when pils then housed me ..for a few nights a week for three months.

OP posts:
HalfSiblingsMadeContact · 27/01/2022 22:24

I understand what you mean too. You and your family would have had a lot of love and care to share with them had you had any love shown to you.

Posting because it put me in mind of the very uneven situation my mother found herself in, middle child with both her brothers heavily favoured. Her younger brother was also a banker, and responsibility for his mother's affairs was happily handed over. Not handled well at all and when she died there was a lot to untangle. Very mixed up family dynamics all along.

JanuaryBluehoo · 27/01/2022 22:23

Current as her husband he would have potentially had more than me as then a mere gf
Legally I had less rights not more than sils dh but they again treated US differently!!

Trunk toes it happened about ten months after meeting dh. He was then my bf. But the timing was coincidental as sil met her btw just before

OP posts:
VodselForDinner · 27/01/2022 22:21

Congratulations, OP, you won. What a silly SIL you had, marrying a man she’d later divorce. The fool!! If only she was as smart and clever and amazing as you!!

You’re amazing OP. AMAZING.

NYnewstart · 27/01/2022 22:19

A lot of posters have got completely the wrong end of the stick.

I’d feel the same as you op.

Definite golden child/scapegoat situation.