Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an inheritance one, who is right here?

679 replies

anotherinheritanceq · 27/01/2022 21:14

This one is more about what's morally right than legalities iyswim, hence why I'm posting here.

So someone I know has assets over half a million, not sure on figure but I know she owns her big house outright and has money in the bank etc. She has children from previous marriage, and she is engaged to her partner who also has children. He can't work and doesn't have any assets, he's on disability benefits. Obviously when marrying what's hers is his, fair enough.

However they've been talking about things including wills, and basically it's come up that if she were to die first (and naturally he would inherit the whole lot), once he dies he would pass everything including the house onto his children and not a penny for his wife's children. Of course she says that's not fair that her children would get nothing if she happens to die first, all her children grew up in that home etc. He argues that everyone puts their own children first and it'll be the only opportunity of giving anything to his children because of his disability/not being able to work.

Who is being unreasonable? What's the done thing in these situations?

I know she is now on about writing a will to leave something to her kids but obviously she can't leave her partner homeless and penniless!

OP posts:
Nanof8 · 29/01/2022 16:48

Big red flag. If she is going to go through with the marriage,she needs to have it so the house is only his to live in until his death or he moves somewhere else then it reverts to her kids. All other assets should be divided as she wishes them to be amongst her children, her husband, and even his kids if she wants.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/01/2022 16:40

What happens if they marry then divorce? He could potentially walk off with half the money anyway, and he sounds like the kind of man who would, particularly being a twat and having to income of his own.

For all we know, divorce could well be his actual plan for getting his hands on half of her money (or more, if he seeks more, claiming that his disability leaves him in need of a greater share). This could all be part of his plan in lining up the divorce even before the marriage – eventually leading her to instigate divorce proceedings when the penny finally drops, years down the line, that she’s been taken for a ride all along. He can claim that he’s always been honest about his financial perspectives since before the marriage and that she is the ‘unreasonable’ one who has ‘suddenly changed and has started to resent him for being disabled’. He could try to paint her as quite the nasty character.

For all I know the OP and her siblings are all billionaires, and the husband to be's children live in poverty with the same disability as him.

It’s already been made clear that OP’s DM is comfortably off, but by no means extremely rich, and that OP and siblings are not at all well-off.

But even if they were all billionaires, money left in a will isn’t just a financial transaction, but also a statement of the family love and bond. This man isn’t even saying that he’d leave the proceeds equally between his and her children, so that they could all benefit from the assets brought into the marriage – he wants his kids to scoop the lot and those morally entitled to it to get nothing at all.

His kids aren't even in the picture by the way, none of us have met them.

He is intending to buy his children with his fiancee’s money when his fiancée dies because his children dont have anything to do with him is disgraceful.

Exactly what I was thinking, but you said it much more eloquently. In fact, he might not even intend to buy them with the money – he could be trying to buy them with the promise of the money long-term, and then end up spending it all himself beforehand anyway. I can’t believe that somebody deliberately targeting a meal-ticket bride would only want the money for his children eventually, without expecting to royally fill his own boots throughout the marriage.

Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 16:26

@Soapoperafamily this is awful! Were thet married for long? The concern is if she has done well out of this that she may marry someone else with money and put another family though the same thing !

soapoperafamily · 29/01/2022 16:17

[quote Thehouseofmarvels]@soapoperafamily If your father died with no will only the first 270 k goes to your father's wife in England and wales. Different rules for scotland. [/quote]
The first £270k plus 50% of everything else. As he left no proper will, his wife is entitled to take on the role of administrator. Where it becomes complicated is that he owned a share of family assets which were spread across various of his other contemporary relatives. He was also a professional valuer of the kind of assets his family dealt in which formed the large majority of his estate, and his wife - in administering the estate - is attempting to downvalue most of the assets and is offering to keep the best of it for herself so that she may sell them on later at a profit. As I have said, she is a real piece of work. The amount she is attempting to take is really quite eyewatering. We will get something, but it is nowhere near the amount my dad intended, and a good chunk has been eaten up by legal fees. I am acutely aware of the rules of intestacy, and am also acutely aware of the lack of value of a pre-nup, having learnt about them by going through the process of my family between us losing a substantial 7-figure sum. Believe me, if there was a way I could have made an unsigned will, a pre-nup, and my dad’s word stick, I would have by now.

“Does your father's wife have children ? I know of a similar situation where the spouse has no children, and no contact with their sibling so the estate could well end up going to charity.”

Firstly, I don’t think this is the case, and secondly unfortunately, she has 4 different children by at least 3 different dads (none of them by my dad - and we know this for sure) as well as 7 very close siblings and numerous cousins. According to Facebook they have all suddenly been doing really well for themselves 🤨.

It is possible, through lack of a clearly drawn up will, to really, really fuck your children up. Any parent who leaves such a mess for their children, even inadvertently through incompetently failing to make correctly drawn up arrangements is frankly a very poor parent. As I said earlier - it would have been easier for us emotionally (although it would still have been a bitter pill to swallow) if he had just written a will giving it all to her, we would not have had to endure the shitshow not signing an otherwise fully written will left us in. He will forever be known in our family a Xxx the Idiot.

Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 16:02

@anotherinhearitanceq. Ok sorry. Could be good to do another thread about this. You might get interesting resonses from some first wives whose kids do not see their Dad.

anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:54

@Thehouseofmarvels

Look, I've already said I don't want to get into that here! We are already aware of the reasons.

OP posts:
Ireolu · 29/01/2022 15:52

Not read it all just yet but I pray she rethinks marrying this man.

babyjellyfish · 29/01/2022 15:51

He sounds like a real catch, OP.

Caplin · 29/01/2022 15:51

I think someone mentioned it, but she can leave everything (including the house) in trust for her kids, with a provision that he can stay in the house until he dies in the event she dies before him. That is what my Mum is doing with her husband. ALthough we are under Scottish law, so technoically he can claim everything. But under English law this solution works.

But he sounds like a pig and she shouldn't marry him.

Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:50

@anotherinhearitanceq If he did go to court and did not even get supervised contact there will be a reason why. I think it would be sensible for your mum to find out why a judge did not even award supervised contact. I thibk there is something called Sarah's law?

anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:49

I do have concerns about that, about his history with his ex partner and his kids etc, but that is a whole other post and I do not want to go into that.

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:47

@anotherinhearitanceq My concern would be that your mother's partner did not fight for custody or did not fight hard enough as even men with a history of abuse can get at least supervised contact. My concern like that if the poster below is that he is wondering who will look after him when he is old after bring a deadbeat dad and things the lure of inhearitance will mean his kids will have a relationship with him and look after him... if they don't dance to his tune he can disinhearit them !

I0NA · 29/01/2022 15:44

@Anotherinheritanceq

Ah well Swoopingdown is new to Mn, I believe they only joined today. So they may not understand how chat boards and social media work.

TracyMosby · 29/01/2022 15:42

But it's the fact that my mum wants her assets to go to her children, and this man is saying if she dies first everything's going to his kids.
She should absolutely not marry him. I wouldnt be letting him move in either with that attitude towards my children.

His kids aren't even in the picture by the way, none of us have met them.
He is intending to buy his children with his fiancee’s money when his fiancée dies because his children dont have anything to do with him is disgraceful.

anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:42

This is really detracting from the point of this post I think. His kids are not allowed to see him, it's been to court and everything, simple as that. He can't just reach out to them. I really don't want to get into this, this is like a whole other can of worms and I'd be writing about it forever.

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:38

@anotherinhearitanceq do his parents or siblinhs have contact with his kids ? Does your mother get on with his family ?

Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:37

@Anotherinhearitanceq unless he was dangerous he would normally get either 50 50 custody or every other weekend ? Did the mother refuse to make them avaliable ? How old are they now ? If teenages could he contact them directly to sort out a relationship ?

anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:35

He has fought for custody for years but can't even see them... take that as you will.

OP posts:
anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:34

No, it's not that they're refusing to meet her. They just don't know their own dad essentially. And he has zero custody or visiting rights.

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:34

@anotherinhearitanceq oh. So he is a deadbeat dad ?

Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:33

@anotherinhearitanceq I am so sorry his kids are refusing to meet your mother and her family, this must be so upsetting for her, I am sure she would be an amazing stepmum/ stepgran to his kids and grandkids if he has any.

anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:32

His kids have nothing to do with him, he hasn't seen them for many years since they were tiny...

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:30

@Anotherinhearitanceq why are his children refusing to meet their future stepmother ? Have they decided they will deffinately never meet her or are they greiving the death of their mother, or struggling emotionally after a divorce ? Surely he will make sure everyone is a happy blended family and his kids get on with their stepmother before tge wedding ? Could your mother try reaching out to his kids when they are ready? If their mother died it must be hard seeing another woman in her place but hopefully they will accept her in time. Does your mother get on welk with his parents, siblings, cousins and their families ? Maybe they can help fix the relationship.

anotherinheritanceq · 29/01/2022 15:23

@SwoopingDown

Also since when does ANYONE have to ask permission from the relevant parties to post on AIBU!? You are ridiculous!

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 15:23

With people living so long these days and house prices so high, people may have inhearited a good chunk. If one of my parents died and the other left everything to a second spouse that person could easily walk of with several hundred thousand from my grandparents.. so I see why the Italians have this rule. People who don't like their kids can spend it before they go, which means the money goes back into the economy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread