Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an inheritance one, who is right here?

679 replies

anotherinheritanceq · 27/01/2022 21:14

This one is more about what's morally right than legalities iyswim, hence why I'm posting here.

So someone I know has assets over half a million, not sure on figure but I know she owns her big house outright and has money in the bank etc. She has children from previous marriage, and she is engaged to her partner who also has children. He can't work and doesn't have any assets, he's on disability benefits. Obviously when marrying what's hers is his, fair enough.

However they've been talking about things including wills, and basically it's come up that if she were to die first (and naturally he would inherit the whole lot), once he dies he would pass everything including the house onto his children and not a penny for his wife's children. Of course she says that's not fair that her children would get nothing if she happens to die first, all her children grew up in that home etc. He argues that everyone puts their own children first and it'll be the only opportunity of giving anything to his children because of his disability/not being able to work.

Who is being unreasonable? What's the done thing in these situations?

I know she is now on about writing a will to leave something to her kids but obviously she can't leave her partner homeless and penniless!

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 30/01/2022 11:33

In the past, before house prices soared when this happened people had less to leave, and people had shorter lives so the step parent was more likely to have contributed to wealth. Now people live long past retirement age and rises in house prices have created lots of unearned wealth. The cost of living is high and inhearitance can secure a comfortable future in many cases. As well as remarriage after divorce being more common these days. I honestly think that as the cost of living rises and wages stagnate wealth will become more reliant on inhearitance. This bloke probably realises this. I would not be surprised if people marrying strategically to secure their kids an inhearitance becomes more common. Even if inhearitamce is not his end goal as Op's mum is not that old divorce may be.
Ultimately it's parents who leave everything to a new spouse or partner but it's a shame when someone directs inhearitance so it will end up with someone elses kids rather than their own.

Technonan · 30/01/2022 11:20

My late DH and I were in this situation when we married. I owned the house and had bought it and lived in some pretty dire conditions as I had to do it up while my DS and I lived there - think no hot water, no electricity, limited heating.

But my late DS was a lovely man - when we married, we legally became joint owners, but we changed this to tenants in common so we each owned half of the property. We made wills leaving our share of the house to my DS, and the other assets to be split equally among my DS and his DD.

He recognised from the word go that morally, the house was mine. He waived his rights to the assets of the house from his previous marriage, and this went to his DD after the death of his ExP.

The arrangement described above sounds terrible, unfair and immoral, and this woman should not marry a man who would want to do this, not trust him not to renege on any agreement they make to redress this balance.

BlueJag · 30/01/2022 10:52

I wouldn't marry a man that has nothing and decides my wealth should go to his children. Also allowing a disable man to live in my house with nothing to his name?
I wouldn't.

SwoopingDown · 29/01/2022 21:46

[quote anotherinheritanceq]@SwoopingDown

Also since when does ANYONE have to ask permission from the relevant parties to post on AIBU!? You are ridiculous![/quote]
To put it in context, that was a reaction to your first post when you seemed to be a third party 'busybody' posting about someone else's private matters. I don't like gossips, and the damage they do.

IvorCutler · 29/01/2022 21:43

He sounds nice. Hope he dies first.

SwoopingDown · 29/01/2022 21:43

[quote anotherinheritanceq]@SwoopingDown

Oh my gosh, who do you think you are? Are you the bloke engaged to my mum??

No I'm not a fucking billionaire, I'm on a low income topped up by universal credit. I do not feel entitled to any inheritance at all, since when did I say that? My mum could leave it to a cat shelter if she so wished. But it's the fact that my mum wants her assets to go to her children, and this man is saying if she dies first everything's going to his kids. His kids aren't even in the picture by the way, none of us have met them. My mum was really upset by this and absolutely does not want this to happen, but she's quite naïve and vulnerable but I don't want to go into that.

Basically I want the best for my mum and to ensure her wishes are met following her death, whatever those wishes may be. For all I know there could be nothing left by the end of it, if she has to go into a care home (although I'd rather take care of her myself if possible), or if she decides to sell her house and spend all her money travelling or whatever. I expect nothing. But if there is still something, i.e. my childhood home, my mum would be rolling in her grave to if it's gone to some random kids who she doesn't know rather than her own flesh and blood! By the way I have lots of siblings, so it's unlikely I'd even have much by the end.[/quote]
You posted on a public forum and I think I'm someone entitled to post views. No I am not him, and don't know you, him, or your mum, but you asked for opinions, and I posted mine. Just because it wasn't what you wanted to hear doesn't make it invalid or wrong.
I was, however shocked at the other posters leaping to conclusions on scant information and making vile comments about someone they don't know.
I'm suprised that if your mum has such strong feelings that you're still in the position of hoping to persuade her to see a solicitor.
If those are her feelings I hope you do, and that measures are put in place to ensure her wishes are met.
The fact that this man has clearly stated his views before the marriage, and they both seemingly have many years life expectancy, leads me to believe he's not one of the abominable people that prey on rich single people, and only marry for money.

Isaidnomorecrisps · 29/01/2022 21:31

It’s great that she recognises this isn’t what she wants. Let’s see what he says about the life interest.
But I would be more worried about a divorce. If they’re married long enough (and he may have worked it out) she may well lose the house and have to support him. English law splits all assets 50/50 if broadly they’ve been used in the joint life. Then considers support needed for either party afterwards: him.
Her entire life could be wrecked. And as I understand it there’s not much that can be put in place to protect against that. It is so unwise it would be sensible for her to see a solicitor about both the will and protecting her assets on divorce.

Scotland32 · 29/01/2022 21:19

Oh my god. Do not let your friend marry this gold digger.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/01/2022 21:05

Keeping everything crossed for you that he dies first!

Absolutely! I'm actually kind of surprised that he's clearly targeted her in this. It seems like a lot of effort and calculating when he still has to bank on somebody a similar age dying before him for it all to work. I'd have thought he'd be looking for somebody very well-off and over 70 at an absolute minimum - probably more like 85+.

That way, you don't have to stay married to somebody you likely don't find particularly attractive purely for who they are for too long, nor do you have to wait a long time for 'your' money. Unless you're relying on 'something' other than old-age-related natural causes as the reason for their demise....

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 29/01/2022 20:58

My DF has just died - everything is going to his wife. Me and my brother are getting nothing and when she dies all of his money will be split between her children. It's heartbreaking - please don't let this happen to your mum.

This seems alarmingly common. I'd love to know if the people who do this genuinely believe that it's a fair progression - that they inherit it from their new spouse, subsequently pass it on to their own children and don't give a second thought to the children who have been robbed of their inheritance; or whether they fully realise how disgraceful they're being, but figure they can get away with it and simply don't care that they've stiffed the loved ones of their deceased loved one?

cheeseontoastandbrownsauce · 29/01/2022 20:30

Keeping everything crossed for you that he dies first!

Mrstamborineman · 29/01/2022 19:06

Tell your friend to have a name change and party, (pretend wedding) if it’s that important to her. Her children dont deserve to be disinherited for a free loading cock lodging lazy lollygagger.

Mrstamborineman · 29/01/2022 19:04

Omg what the fuck has he got offer? No job. No intention of working. Being on disability doesn’t mean useless. Only thing he’s working is her! No way, she’d be a fool to marry a blood sucker like that.

Sudoku88 · 29/01/2022 19:01

She is absolutely crazy. If my husband were to die first, there is absolutely no way I would ever get married as everything we have is going to our kids.

This guy is an absolute CF, freeloader. He’s brought nothing to the table yet wants a share (if not all of it) of the spoils to pass onto his kids,

If your friend is having to think twice about what is best to do, she needs her head examined.

I have heard horror of stories exactly like this one where 1 spouse dies (the one who brought all the property with them into the marriage) which then ends up being given to the children of of the person who contributed nothing, with the rightful heirs being completely cut out.

HappySonHappyMum · 29/01/2022 18:42

@StressedOutMumBex I'm sorry this happened to your husband as well. It makes the worst of times even harder. You struggle to talk about it when your family members are alive because it seem so innappropriate and 'grabby' but OP you must talk to her. Show her this thread - she needs proper legal advice for her own peace of mind.

babyjellyfish · 29/01/2022 18:29

As a PP suggested, it might be worth making Sarah's Law and Clare's Law requests just in case there are major skeletons in his closet.

saraclara · 29/01/2022 18:07

[quote ChickenStripper]@Blossomtoes women always say that when they are married. You possibly have no idea what it is like to live alone esp when you are older.[/quote]
I know what it's like to live alone. I was widowed ten years ago, and I'm in the second half of my 60s.

I absolutely don't need or want another partner. I've not been tempted even once in the last decade. And I honestly don't understand why anyone in my position would marry again. It just adds so many complications.

LaChanticleer · 29/01/2022 18:05

Any parent who leaves such a mess for their children, even inadvertently through incompetently failing to make correctly drawn up arrangements is frankly a very poor parent

It’s an excellent point @soapoperafamily It’s easy to focus on the grabbiness of the second wife or husband, but it’s the PARENT who leaves this mess who demonstrates their lack of care for their children.

LaChanticleer · 29/01/2022 18:01

His kids are not allowed to see him, it's been to court and everything, simple as that. He can't just reach out to them.

Gosh, it gets worse. I assume he is abusive or unsafe in some way.

I really really hope your mother doesn’t marry this man @Anotherinheritanceq

StressedOutMumBex · 29/01/2022 17:52

@HappySonHappyMum, sorry when i wrote this I was replying to you.

I'm so sorry to hear this happened to you. This also happened to my husband. It really is a terrible thing.

StressedOutMumBex · 29/01/2022 17:49

I'm so sorry to hear this happened to you. This also happened to my husband. It really is a terrible thing.

StressedOutMumBex · 29/01/2022 17:47

She should not marry this man, what kind of person would even say that it's fair because its his only chance of giving his kids anything ? what about her kids ? . He is a selfish untrustworthy man who has basically told her he has no intention of considering her children in the unhappy event that she dies. Please dump him now. What is she thinking.

feistymumma · 29/01/2022 17:39

I wouldn't be with someone like that. He sounds like a freeloader

HappySonHappyMum · 29/01/2022 17:38

My DF has just died - everything is going to his wife. Me and my brother are getting nothing and when she dies all of his money will be split between her children. It's heartbreaking - please don't let this happen to your mum.

Thehouseofmarvels · 29/01/2022 16:56

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll this bloke could remarry after the death or divorce from @anotherinhearitanceq's mother. He may really want the assets for his kids or he may want to look as attractive as possible to a new younger partner. Also as he is disabled I would imagine he could aim for more than 50 percent of the marriage assets ? Maybe 60 percent ? If he is not working though disability and op's mother is he would deffinately be seen as needing support.

Swipe left for the next trending thread