Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's an inheritance one, who is right here?

679 replies

anotherinheritanceq · 27/01/2022 21:14

This one is more about what's morally right than legalities iyswim, hence why I'm posting here.

So someone I know has assets over half a million, not sure on figure but I know she owns her big house outright and has money in the bank etc. She has children from previous marriage, and she is engaged to her partner who also has children. He can't work and doesn't have any assets, he's on disability benefits. Obviously when marrying what's hers is his, fair enough.

However they've been talking about things including wills, and basically it's come up that if she were to die first (and naturally he would inherit the whole lot), once he dies he would pass everything including the house onto his children and not a penny for his wife's children. Of course she says that's not fair that her children would get nothing if she happens to die first, all her children grew up in that home etc. He argues that everyone puts their own children first and it'll be the only opportunity of giving anything to his children because of his disability/not being able to work.

Who is being unreasonable? What's the done thing in these situations?

I know she is now on about writing a will to leave something to her kids but obviously she can't leave her partner homeless and penniless!

OP posts:
I0NA · 28/01/2022 14:27

@Sundayrain

My DH and I have recently done our wills and left each of our halves in trust to our children. The surviving partner can stay in the house but the deceased half would be owned by our children, if that makes sense. It's really easy to do. We trust each other but you just never know how things can work out. Just as you describe, my mum's family home ended up going to her stepmother's children after her mum died first then her dad.
How does that actually work?

So if for example you die next week , your husband owns one half of the house and your children own the other half. If your husband then remarries and your children grow up and leave home, they can’t use their half of the house to eg use as a deposit on a flat.

But they still have to pay for half of the repairs and maintenance on the house. Will your widower and his second wife pay rent to the children for half of the house ?

What if your former husband and his second wife live there until her he dies in 40 years time ? Do your children have to wait for 40 year to get their money.

And what if he leaves his half of the house to her with the same rules - that she can live there until she dies ? Do your children have to wait until her death until they get their money ? Will she continue to pay them rent of their half ?

What if the house becomes run down because she’s not willing to maintain it and it decreases in value?

Sorry for so many questions but I see this plan mentioned often on MN and I can’t get my head around it .

SamphiretheStickerist · 28/01/2022 14:27

You know that term 'gold digger'? Well, he's told her in plain terms that this would be the effect of marrying him.

If she must carry on in a relationship with him she shouldn't marry him. Let him fend for himself when she dies. After all, he is right and she would only be putting her children first.

LolliSm1 · 28/01/2022 14:12

She shouldn't leave that man a penny in my eyes especially if after having the conversation he hasn't even reassured her that he would split everything equally with her children and cares more himself and his kids.

What if they broke up and she suddenly passed before changing the will?! Her kids would be left with nothing.

Even if it's her husband he had no entitlement to anything unless she didn't have a will - it would all go him. But if she wrote a will and left it to her kids he wouldn't have a leg to stand on.

Tbh it's a major red flag they way he has responded to the situation!

filka · 28/01/2022 14:07

Also your friend should not rely on any promise from him that he will leave something to her children - that's not a legal commitment and there are countless threads on MN where that kind of promise has been broken.

Lemonyfuckit · 28/01/2022 13:57

If that's his attitude think she would do well to seriously question why she's with him. Obviously she can do what she wants in that she can leave everything in her will to her own children, but the very fact he thinks like that would put me completely off being with someone full stop let alone marrying them (let alone considering leaving them my assets in my will...).

NewPapaGuinea · 28/01/2022 13:54

With that attitude I’d be rethinking the whole relationship let alone marrying him!

Sundayrain · 28/01/2022 13:52

My DH and I have recently done our wills and left each of our halves in trust to our children. The surviving partner can stay in the house but the deceased half would be owned by our children, if that makes sense. It's really easy to do. We trust each other but you just never know how things can work out. Just as you describe, my mum's family home ended up going to her stepmother's children after her mum died first then her dad.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 28/01/2022 13:51

Also warn your friend that marriage negates ay pre-existing wills.

So she needs to have a new will drawn up ready to sign literally the day after the wedding.

User57327259 · 28/01/2022 13:51

I feel a bit sorry for the OP mum. She has a partner who is trying to get his hands on her assets and a DC who is scared of losing out on inheritance.
Another scenario to consider. If the OP mum was (hopefully not) was to become ill. Would her DC be 24 hour carers for her or would that fall to the partner/husband as he might become.
If he was the carer he really ought to be acknowledged after her death or if the DC gave her every attention they should be similarly acknowledged.
Not all DC turn out to be considerate when their parents age.

comingintomyown · 28/01/2022 13:51

This is the sort of reason why I will never so much as cohabit again never mind marry, my kids have been through enough with an albeit amicable divorce they will get the lot when I go whatever my romantic position

celiamary · 28/01/2022 13:48

She needs to make a will now. Leave assets in trust for children. Need a solicitor because law on trusts is always changing.
Then see if bloke is so keen to go ahead with marriage.
Get new advice when marrying to take into account new circumstances.
A solicitor now is the best defence.

lljkk · 28/01/2022 13:47

This happens all the time & I fully expect similar to happen to me (my step-mum will outlive Dad who brought most the wealth to the marriage, & she will fritter the money away on her blood kin if not formally change her will to exclude me). I know it happened to my cousins, their dad died, married to 2nd wife. Other side of my family, My dad's youngest half siblings got all the wealth even before their mother died, which really shafted some of my older cousins on that side who were very skint and would have loved even a small inheritance.

I can't make myself comment on morality... I don't like my own situation and I think my dad is very naive to expect I'll get anything which is what the current joint wills say would happen eventually ... but oh well.

theemmadilemma · 28/01/2022 13:45

She can effectively write a will which allows him to stay in the property for x number of years while it is inherited by the children.

My mother has done this for her Partner. He will have 3 years in the property before he needs to vacate. A friends father did this for him as he was the child living in the home and providing care. He had a year in the house before it could be sold etc.

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 28/01/2022 13:40

Haven't read the full thread but Can she write a will that says everything she has go to her children but her husband can stay in the house until he dies?
That's what DHs aunts husband did. She stays in the house and when she dies his daughter inherits it.
I think your stuff only goes to your spouse if you don't have a will or obviously if they actually jointly own it. If she owned it before him and he obviously isn't contributing if he's not working then he doesn't have a claim. But she can let him stay and even leave him some money if she wants or set up a trust even so he gets a set amount to live on a month.

theremustonlybeone · 28/01/2022 13:36

Your friend is a fool. Why is she not ensuring she protects her assests? She is planning to marry a bloke who doesnt work, isnt bringing anything to the table but has told her if she dies before him all of the inheritance will go to his DC. I mean what else is there to say? She shouldnt marry the man.. Simple as that..

Londongent · 28/01/2022 13:27

If she does marry him, she must do everything she can to outlive him

MadinMarch · 28/01/2022 13:13

Also, if she does end up marrying him, she needs to be aware that any will made before the marriage is invalid.
She REALLY needs legal advice before she marries!

MadinMarch · 28/01/2022 13:10

I haven't read the whole thread here, but why on Earth would she consider marrying this man knowing his greedy and unscrupulous attitudes towards her children?
Knowing what she does now, it's not financially safe for her to marry him. He could divorce her fairly quickly and lay claim on her assets, including her pension. As he's disabled and unable to work, he could also possibly
claim spousal support from her too!
He's unlikely to be kind or fatherly towards her children during any marriage given that only his kids are important to him.
It's a recipe for disaster for her! He stands to gain hugely.
Drag her to a solicitor if necessary

ChampagneLassie · 28/01/2022 13:08

I'm sure others have said this. I'd be encouraging her to do the following:
1 - consider couples counselling - they don't sound at all on same page and this doesn't sound a good grounding to get married IF she still wants to get married then
2 - Family solicitor and a pre-nup to protect her assets - they are taken into consideration by courts - it is based circumstances - if they have a short marriage and no children then he'd be unlikely to be able to claim much of her assets she amassed pre-marriage.
3 - Private client solicitor for will who can explain options in detail. As others have pointed out she could give him right to live in the house whilst he's alive but leave it to children.
Moreover I'd be very concerned about his motives in all of this

Blackberrybunnet · 28/01/2022 13:03

His attitude is terrible. She needs to split her will among her husband-to-be (if it gets that far) and her children.

Clementine8 · 28/01/2022 12:57

I am married to the father of my kids. We have our will set up so that who ever does first they can stay in the house but on the second persons death the first persons share goes to the kids. Just incase the 2nd person remarries and something like this happens. Speak to a solicitor as there are loads of options.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 28/01/2022 12:53

In English and Welsh law, the spouse isn't entitled to anything when the other partner dies. If the will says that the kids get it, then the kids get it.

Obviously any joint assets, like anything in a joint bank account (or a house if bought as a joint tenancy) will go to the spouse.

It is advised to leave a spouse a token amount in the will, as it makes it harder to contest.

user1493494961 · 28/01/2022 12:52

Kick him out.

CaptainMal · 28/01/2022 12:51

This gave me shivers of the worst kind. She should not he marrying him. Is she sure he isn't just marrying her to give his kids 'the best chance' ?

Regina70 · 28/01/2022 12:50

It is to me slightly irrelevant what the "fiance" might want to do with the inheritance or what the "children" might want to do with theirs. What matter are the wishes of your friend. She should speak with a solicitor and reflect what it is she wants to happen once she has passed. Taking care of her husband, her children, her grand children, donate to a favourite charity .... having your affair in order gives peace of mind & saves big fall outs down the line. Why put your family through this when you can plan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread