Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
Giggorata · 27/01/2022 21:15

I agree wholeheartedly about the basements. That wonderful huge space for washing machine, tools, stuff and extra play space would make such a difference to living. And solve some of the problems of the tiny footprint new builds tend to have.
I recall with great fondness the basements and cellars we've had in the past, but where I’ve lived for the last twenty five years, the water table is high and they're unusual.
Tanking a cellar would probably cost a bomb and I don’t know how long it would last before leaking.

WotsitMum · 27/01/2022 21:12

The energy ratings standards need to be lifted! I currently live in a rented flat that is at the lowest living engergy standard and some windows are single glazed and there is no reported instulation in the roof or walls. It gets frezzing, within an hour of the heating beeing off its cold again, my gas bill is so high, i worry for next winter after the prices go up again! We try to get out and visit grandparents most of my days off to make use of there warm houses, if we are in during the day we will tend to sit in LO's bedroom with the door shut and electric heater on as its cheaper than having central heating on or sat cuddled on the sofa under blankets, im allways wearing my dressing gown, may as well call it a house coat😂 we cant afford to move, stuck in a long private rent tenancy agreement and theres not much out there to move into within our budget!

PermanentTemporary · 27/01/2022 21:05

Yy to your post midsomermadness. The housing builders may not give large bungs in brown envelopes to councillors any more, but they donate hugely to all political parties and control the supply of land and building to keep prices as high as possible. They're usually uninterested in brownfield and conversion, and get the definition of 'affordable' altered repeatedly plus the number of 'affordable' units they have to include reduced.

nordica · 27/01/2022 21:04

The lack of storage space is definitely an issue. One of the things I miss the most from my one bed flat in another European country is the storage it had in the entrance hall - 3 deep cupboards and an alcove of a sort so there was plenty of space for shoes, coats, gym stuff, even the hoover lived in one of those cupboards. My Victorian terrace in London has the narrowest entrance ever with no space for coats at all.

toppkatz · 27/01/2022 21:01

The problem is that the plot of land a house stands on can cost considerably more than the materials used to actually build the house.

There's a plot of land for sale near me. It covers around a quarter of an acre and is up for sale for £1.5 million. Planning permission is for nine houses on that. Nine houses on a quarter of an acre. Madness.

midsomermurderess · 27/01/2022 21:00

I live in Scotland which has a lot of 19th century flats in its cities which tend to have high ceilings, often pretty decent size rooms, traditionally a ceiling pulley for clothes drying (in modern times often taken down but I still have one), and a box room. The insulation, sound and heat, isn't that good though. I think a major issue with poor quality housing lies with the volume builders. They often do build mean spaces and seem quite resistant to new eco technologies because they eat into profits. They are major donors to political parties and wield huge power when it comes to housing. And they have very little interest in building communities, which should be central to housing policy. Houses dumped with nothing else there so the people who live in them have to drive everywhere to get their needs met.

PermanentTemporary · 27/01/2022 21:00

YANBU.

I find it incredible that it is legal to build flats in the UK without decent lift access - a lift big enough for furniture, a person in a wheelchair and a carer, that kind of thing. It is so so rare to find a block with lifts in it. There are hardly any flats i could even consider for my mother.

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 27/01/2022 20:57

Yanbu someone I know got a 3 bed 3 storey new build ha property but the proportions were way off. Postage stamp sized front and back gardens. No driveway. Tiny pavements (I dont think they are actually classified as pavements)
Huge downstairs bathroom. Bigish lounge.
Tiny kitchen. First floor 1 massive bedroom. 1 massive (stand alone shower and bath in there) 1 bedroom so small a single bed would only fit in one way!
3rd floor an ok sized master with ensuite.
So so odd.
I'm in a 1930s semi and I love it decent sized rooms. Decent sized front and back gardens. Best is I only hear next door shutting a drawer in their kitchen and plugging something in in the bedroom.
I also hear their dog bark if someone knocks their door.

gogohm · 27/01/2022 20:56

It's an issue in all countries. Average sizes can be deceptive because people want to live in certain places and that land then becomes super valuable. Apartments are town houses make sense but it's not what most want

namechangetheworld · 27/01/2022 20:53

Completely agree OP. We were in a rush to buy when I was pregnant and made the horrible mistake of going for a new-ish build house (12 years old I think).
It's made me unbelievably depressed over the past few years, to the point where I'm too embarassed to have anybody come to the house, including tradesmen, and can't stand to be here for more than an hour at a time. A "master" bedroom that is so small that we can only open one of our wardrobe doors fully because the other hits the end of the bed - there's literally no other way of having the furniture, and we only own a small double bed, a chest of drawers and a slim double wardrobe. A pointless (and windowless) ensuite crammed into the master bedroom but no built in storage anywhere. The third "bedroom" that can only just fit a toddler bed and a chest of drawers in it - if we had a wardrobe, it would block either the window or the door, and there's no hope of fitting a single bed in there, so we're praying DD2 doesnt grow too much. One small built in cupboard in the entire house that needs to house shoes, wellies, coats, children's toys, hats and scarves, boxes of Playdoh and craft stuff, the hoover, the mop, and the ironing board. A "kitchen/diner" where we have to shift the (small!) kitchen table every time we want to open the washing machine. Walls so thin that our neighbour can hear every conversation we have in our bedroom (which she regularly comments on). I can hand on heart say this house has ruined my life. I loathe everything about it.

Lolamento · 27/01/2022 20:49

@HighlandPony

Let’s be honest. This is only really a problem in new builds. I’m in a 1963 ex council house and I’ve got a 23x11ft living room. master bedroom is 19ft by 9ft. Double room is 14ft by 12.5ft and single room is 9ft by 8.5ft. I’ve got two huge cupboards upstairs, one downstairs and a pantry. Tiny bathroom and small kitchenette mind you but really big rooms compared to new builds. Half the price too
This

New buildings are a missed opportunity. Such a shame I went to visit a few to buy but there is not way I do it. They are tiny.

4pmwinetimebebeh · 27/01/2022 20:48

I agree, I absolutely hate new builds. We went to visit a friends and it was lovely- straight lines and very white and clean. But it was so painfully small and had absolutely no storage. It was marketed as a detached and there is honestly about 3cm between it and the neighbour. Why not just be a semi and have a bit more space inside?! Honestly it was bizarre. They had upgraded from a period terrace and despite having one more bedroom in the new build it was significantly smaller and felt cramped.

NB I would never in a million years say this to them I just said it was gorgeous. And it cost a hell of a lot of money so it wasn’t a case of all they could afford!

MintJulia · 27/01/2022 20:47

Half our housing stock is Victorian or older. The houses are great, well built but need maintaining against a damp cold environment. Lots of people don't seem to take that into account

I paid £100k less than asking price for my house because all the windows needed replacing, an old extension needed demolishing & rebuilding, new kitchen, new boiler, complete rewire, new roof, new exterior doors. The previous owners had done as little as possible, let it deteriorate. Over the last decade I have gradually done the work. Recently I repointed the foundations to replace crumbling damp mortar and cure damp. They'd filled the outside gaps with decorators caulk!

My house is warm, spacious, well insulated and maintained, but it's taken a decade of hard work to get it there. Demolishing buildings is hugely damaging for the environment, we have to be better at maintaining what we have.

Mumofsend · 27/01/2022 20:45

I live in a 3 bed massive HA home. It wasn't until we moved from our tiny 2 bed flat that I realised how having such limited space had such a detrimental impact on my MH

FTEngineerM · 27/01/2022 20:45

@Woodlandarchitect no you’re correct there. Whilst saving for our current old a f house we rented a tiny 2 bed that was 3m wide 😂. Oh one of us could be in the kitchen at any one time. Grim.

To be honest, I think that’s a thing of the past because we’ve been looking at all sorts of houses new and old, various new build developments and anything purchased privately without any ‘scheme’ to help is adequate and some even generous.

HeddaGarbled · 27/01/2022 20:45

I can think of lots of reasons why our homes are small:

It’s a small country

We’d like to keep some land free from buildings

The majority of the population expect houses with gardens, rather than apartments

Young people expect to be independent from their parents early in life

Indecisivelurcher · 27/01/2022 20:40

It would have been better if we'd stuck with the code for sustainable homes that Labour published in about 2006 I think. But 2016 I think it was, all the houses being built would have been zero carbon - think well insulated, well ventilated, orientated well, grounds source heat pumps, generating their own electricity, ... But conservatwats don't like regulation so scrapped it.

TallTrees78 · 27/01/2022 20:40

I live in a 1950s ex council house. Rooms aren't huge but bigger than a new build council house, with same number of bedrooms, a family member moved in to last year. I have a big back garden and front garden too. Family members house has small back and no front garden. However it does have solar panels, a downstairs toilet and a small utility area which I don't. I thought it was quite well designed, except the living room size has been compromised to make way for the downstairs toilet and utility.

Woodlandarchitect · 27/01/2022 20:38

The style of house that annoys me the most are the new builds that are 2 or 3 bed but only 3.33metres wide (give or take a few cm)….

If you know, you know!

I obviously need some chocolate and need to calm down Blush

BooseysMom · 27/01/2022 20:35

I can't move because my 1970s 3 bed mid terrace has a bigger floorplan and garden than 4 bed detached new builds in my local area.

We are stuck in a 2 bed new build and would kill for a 3 bed 70s place! We have a tiny lounge dining room you can barely fit 3 of us in.

Solasum · 27/01/2022 20:34

I live in a late 60s development, which is high density but cleverly done in such a way that sound rarely carries and you are never looking through someone else’s windows, with plenty of green. There is lots of clever storage built in. I think older council-built stock is often much more spacious than newer

FTEngineerM · 27/01/2022 20:33

Lots*

Rubyupbeat · 27/01/2022 20:33

Does it not depend on the quality and price of the new build?
My son owns a new build, detached, 3 bed all en suite, smallest bed has a king size, wardrobes etc... main bedroom has a dressing room. Also a main bathroom. Downstairs is huge, on quarter of an acre. There are 4 built like this. Probably builder could only get planning for 4 houses?

Woodlandarchitect · 27/01/2022 20:33

YANBU. I literally spend my whole career trying to fix this problem….

Noise, space and storage are my absolute focus!

a client of mine recently suggested building 12 properties. No parking, no gardens and no communal gardens - each property was a family home (3 bed). I told him he was selfish and to find another architect (and good luck with getting planning permission because he’ll need it!) Blush I won’t have my name associated with shit like that!

Grrrr!

FTEngineerM · 27/01/2022 20:33

Hmm.. not sure I agree.

I live in a 120 year old solid stone constructed wonky 4 bed 2 bath house. It’s got a massive garden and loss of character. I’m selling it and moving to a new build 3 bed semi with a garage and a large garden. The total squarefoot is the same (without the extra garage space) the garden is half the size but flat and can be totally utilised. Both houses are ‘fit for purpose’ but those purposes are different.. I don’t think we can blame new builds as being ‘tiny’ and having shit gardens because it’s not always the case.

Swipe left for the next trending thread