Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
AfterSchoolWorry · 27/01/2022 22:01

@RobotValkyrie

What baffles me most is the lack of basements/cellars in British houses. You could still build the same number of houses on the same land, and every house would get extra storage space + a utility room. But no, no basements.
Water table
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 22:00

I agree and I don’t understand why there isn’t government legislation forcing developers to build decent homes.
That would be due to the small matter of extensive donations to Tory funds and lots of paid lobbying

CuteOrangeElephant · 27/01/2022 21:58

It's not just the houses itself, the planning around it is atrocious as well.

I moved to a new build estate in the Netherlands last year and the estate has it's own supermarkt, shops (bakery, book shop, fish mongers, chemist), doctor's surgery, pharmacy, 2 primary schools, nurseries and many, many playgrounds.

Meanwhile the town I where I lived in the UK had a massive housing estate planned without any thoughts about services.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 27/01/2022 21:58

This puts me in mind of the thing that Rosie Jones did about how hard it is to find accessible accommodation, I think it was on Joe Lycett's peculiar consumer advice type programme. Really bloody depressing. The house building industry has a lot to answer for - packing them all in without a thought to whether they're actually appropriate for use, without any regard for the environment they're destroying or the consequences for the local area. Obviously the planning departments share that responsibility, but they just don't seem to give a fuck.

FelicityFlops · 27/01/2022 21:49

Another question is, why are new houses not automatically built with solar panels and heat pumps?
That is, of course, in addition to effective insulation and triple-glazed windows.

VioletOcean · 27/01/2022 21:45

I live sweeping statements

parietal · 27/01/2022 21:40

Agents & Builders should be forced to advertise houses in terms of the sqm of space that you get and should list the price per sqm. That would show of the difference between a spacious old 2 bed and a mini new 2 bed. At the moment, people often only look by the number of bedrooms, so builders have learnt to squeeze in tiny bedrooms and hope people don't notice.

Biminibon · 27/01/2022 21:40

@midsomermurderess

I live in Scotland which has a lot of 19th century flats in its cities which tend to have high ceilings, often pretty decent size rooms, traditionally a ceiling pulley for clothes drying (in modern times often taken down but I still have one), and a box room. The insulation, sound and heat, isn't that good though. I think a major issue with poor quality housing lies with the volume builders. They often do build mean spaces and seem quite resistant to new eco technologies because they eat into profits. They are major donors to political parties and wield huge power when it comes to housing. And they have very little interest in building communities, which should be central to housing policy. Houses dumped with nothing else there so the people who live in them have to drive everywhere to get their needs met.
I came here to say the same! My friends in London can’t believe how spacious and beautiful the tenement flats are up here.
Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 21:39

@Handsnotwands

The government got rid of CABE and with it went any hope for accountability and minimum standards in U.K. architecture
Yes this is a worry.
ComtesseDeSpair · 27/01/2022 21:37

@PermanentTemporary

Hard to know Comtesse because hardly any flats in the UK do look like that. If my choice is a north facing 2 bed overlooking a car park and without so much as a Juliet balcony, with no lift, versus an actual house with even a small amount of outdoor space, of course I will want the house. Mansion flats in London sell well enough.
I think that’s part of the problem: apart from e.g. central and west London mansion blocks which are desirable for all the obvious reasons, flats in the UK are seen as very much second rate to a house, what you buy when you can’t afford a house - even if that house is actually smaller in terms of square footage with less generously proportioned rooms. So developers aren’t minded to build flats to the sort of standard they could if they were viewed as an equally desirable choice.
Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 21:35

Some pp mention living in ex council homes. The right to buy is a major part of the problem. Reducing the pool of genuinely affordable homes. There's only limited land to build on (we need our green spaces - for farming, for wildlife, and to breathe). So the new builds (and flat conversions in older houses) are of reduced size and quality.

Regarding the new builds. Round my way there are several developments.

One is being marketed as affordable Help to Buy. It's not. Not for the average income, let alone low earners.

The other development (in an area with very long - years long - waiting lists for social housing) is for 'luxury' apartments. It's not needed. For anybody with money, there is already plenty of choice round here.

The majority of new builds need to be genuinely affordable for lower earners and people too disabled to work (will be an increase due to Long Covid).

And, like you say, they also need to be of acceptable standard. To live in. Quality of life hugely impacts on health - both physical and mental.

I've pointed out on WFH threads, how WFH is only good for people privileged enough to have a home suitable to work from.

mistermagpie · 27/01/2022 21:32

I live in a tiny new build shoe box. You're not wrong OP, the build is very poor quality and for a three bedroom house the storage is non existent and the rooms are tiny.

My brother also lives in a new build 'town house' which has four bedrooms spread of three floors. The layout of his house is ridiculous (the living room is on the first floor, it's weird) and his garden is tiny and triangular.

His is supposedly quite posh and cost almost twice what line did but I couldn't live in it. There are THREE horrible en suites without a window between them.

My shoebox isn't much better but at least it was cheap and we do have a big, normal shaped, garden I suppose.

PermanentTemporary · 27/01/2022 21:30

Hard to know Comtesse because hardly any flats in the UK do look like that. If my choice is a north facing 2 bed overlooking a car park and without so much as a Juliet balcony, with no lift, versus an actual house with even a small amount of outdoor space, of course I will want the house. Mansion flats in London sell well enough.

SE123 · 27/01/2022 21:30

basements are great but expensive to build and very expensive to guarantee

Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 21:30

know that there is a housing shortage

You're right OP, but also there isn't really a housing shortage.

Like you say, lots of homes are being built. They're just not genuinely affordable ones.

The public health housing and homelessness emergency is because of increased demand for affordable homes and that need is not being met.

HauntedPencil · 27/01/2022 21:28

@endlesssighing

WHAT’S THE OBSESSION WITH BATHROOMS IN NEW BUILDS?!

We went to view a show home and there was always at least two more toilets than there were bedrooms.

We saw a five bed that was four small doubles all with en-suites, a tiny little box room that you couldn’t have fit a chest of drawers in, a family bathroom upstairs, a downstairs shower room plus a hallway cloak room. Why so many bathrooms?!

Yes this is so true - my friend has four loos. It's a lot of loos!!
Handsnotwands · 27/01/2022 21:26

The government got rid of CABE and with it went any hope for accountability and minimum standards in U.K. architecture

StellaGibs · 27/01/2022 21:25

YANBU. I live in a semi-detached council house thats probably 1950s. I have a decent sized front and back garden. Two double bedrooms and a single bedroom but decent sized not a box room. The living room and kitchen are large and there's outhouses. I pay less than £500 a month for it including water.

My friend lives in a council house that's a newbuild and it's absolutely tiny downstairs and she pays £100 more with one less bedroom too. No front garden and her back garden is smaller than mine.

foxgoosefinch · 27/01/2022 21:21

Yanbu our house was built in 2015 and all I deal with at the moment is plumbing leaks in the house, roof leaks, ventilation issues, water tank breakdowns, kitchen falling apart etc etc. It’s shoddily and cheaply built and teeny tiny despite in other ways actually being quite nice. To buy it new on the current market would be over 500k which makes my mind boggle, it’s supposed to be a tiny starter house.

Housing in this country has been fucked by two decades of an immoral property boom which will distort our economy for decades to come.

midsomermurderess · 27/01/2022 21:21

And the Help to Buy scheme only helped the volume builders, it had to be a new build. No help to buy and refurbish an old house, do that, you also get clobbered with VAT,no VAT on new builds. Help to Buy my arse, help Barratt, Persimmon at al, yes.

So much of the country is in a stranglehold to these outfits it's no wonder there is little joined-up strategic planning around housing or looking to achieve carbon neutral homes, something I think Germany has been pursuing hard for years.

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/01/2022 21:21

A lot of it is the British obsession with living in a house, which puts pressure on land, and results in undersized, boxy homes with often almost completely uselessly sized gardens and no storage space.

We could build solid, spacious, generously proportioned apartment blocks with communal garden areas, laundries, gyms and services, as is more the norm and popular in many other cities around the world. It would be a much more effective use of land and home footprints could be much bigger. Perhaps too big an attitudinal change for too many people, though.

RaoulDufysCat · 27/01/2022 21:19

I don't know about anywhere else in the UK, but basements are very hard to build where I live in London because there is a whacking great river right next to us and wet clay instead of soil.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 27/01/2022 21:17

I live in a 3 bed semi, one of the bedrooms is too small to fit a bed both ways. A friend lives in a similar sized house and when they were built , they took about 20cms from the bigger bedroom , slightly bigger than the width of a double bed out, so all bedrooms were doubles. Such a little thing, won't have cost the builders more and yet makes so much better use of the available space.

endlesssighing · 27/01/2022 21:17

WHAT’S THE OBSESSION WITH BATHROOMS IN NEW BUILDS?!

We went to view a show home and there was always at least two more toilets than there were bedrooms.

We saw a five bed that was four small doubles all with en-suites, a tiny little box room that you couldn’t have fit a chest of drawers in, a family bathroom upstairs, a downstairs shower room plus a hallway cloak room. Why so many bathrooms?!

SE123 · 27/01/2022 21:16

@OfstedOffred

Yanbu. Our population density isnt much higher than germany yet our average new property is 76sqm, theirs is 109sqm. Its s massive difference.

Not sure if it's because we need to build more apartments vs houses, or if it's because our planning and housing sector is geared around corporates extracting bumper profits, but either way it's terrible.

Interestingly england has nearly double the density as germany
Swipe left for the next trending thread