Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
echt · 28/01/2022 02:03

@LadyinRead

I have an average-sized 2-bed maisonette and my friends from Hong Kong visited and said their entire flat would fit inside my front room. They have 2 kids too.

It's all relative.

The thread is about UK standards and expectations.
Rememberallball · 28/01/2022 02:02

One of the big issues we’re facing with bidding for housing on local social housing website is the number of new build properties that are 2 beds/max 3 occupants (1 double, 1 single). We’re a family of 4 with 2 same sex twins so can only bid on 2 bed properties but very few are currently being built for families of 4. The options seem to be 2 bed/3 occupants or 3 bed/5 occupants (2 doubles and a single). And it’s not just social housing, in local private developments that have rental properties the second bedroom is often no bigger than a small single bed and chest of drawers and the double rooms in a lot are 10ft x 7ft 9in (again minimal space for actual furniture!!)

And don’t get me started on the open plan living idea where you get a row of 3/4 cupboards, an oven and hob and a breakfast bar with a 10ftx15ft lounge diner attached and that’s the only living space downstairs - often with the staircase to one side. One I saw the floor plan for recently, had the front door with a small ‘Entrance hall’ and staircase then an angled door into the open plan living space with a wc halfway along the room and being used as the demarcation between lounge and kitchen/diner areas (carpet stopped at doorway to toilet and replaced by vinyl flooring and a breakfast bar the other side of the doorway). We dismissed it as a viable option immediately as I’d rather not be able to hear people in the loo while I’m sat having a meal at the breakfast bar (minimal space for an actual table and chairs!! Instead we’re in the process of applying to rent a 3 double bed ex 1960’s council house with separate lounge & dining rooms, small utility off the hall (some houses on the estate have made that a downstairs cloakroom) and an entrance hallway with space for a coat rack, shoe box and to leave the children’s double buggy inside. Plus it has doors so you can close a room you’re not in and keep the rest warm without having to heat the whole upstairs or downstairs!

LadyinRead · 28/01/2022 01:52

I have an average-sized 2-bed maisonette and my friends from Hong Kong visited and said their entire flat would fit inside my front room.
They have 2 kids too.

It's all relative.

LakieLady · 28/01/2022 01:10

@Andante57

Insead of selling land to the highest bidder to developers that build cheap, poorly finished homes they should invest more in long lasting homes that are built to last

I agree and I don’t understand why there isn’t government legislation forcing developers to build decent homes.

House building companies donate a lot of money to the Conservatives, that might have something to do with it.
sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 28/01/2022 01:06

@ChiefWiggumsBoy

I can't lie, I absolutely love the idea of a huge block of flats with shops and gardens and all the rest around it. I don't know why, I've never lived in one, can't even remember if I've ever been in one, I just love the thought of it!

Mind you, future dystopian fiction is my favourite so maybe that's why Grin

If you're ever near me, you're welcome to pop round to see for yourself! I absolutely LOVE my council estate. It's low rise (only six floors), but it was so well designed. 1, 2, & 3 bed flats/maisonettes, a huge green square in the middle with a huge community garden, off road parking & garages, tons of storage space in our house, and a parade of shops built into the fabric of our square. I've got a chemist, post office, cafe, chippy, laundrette, mini supermarket and two charity shops less than five minutes away. We have a lovely caretaker who keeps all of the communal areas clean & maintained, and people genuinely do feel proud to live here.

From the outside it looks absolutely grim (1960s concrete), but it's genuinely the only place I've ever lived in that feels like a community. They even organise day trips out for the estate Grin

DerAlteMann · 28/01/2022 00:50

I agree. I've never lived in a house built after 1935 and from what I've seen of friends' post-1935 houses I never will.

MintJulia · 28/01/2022 00:27

@chaosrabbitland

yep , im in an end of bed terraced council house which i am of course extemely grateful for , i know it could be much worse , but its a 1950s build pretty small , but the garden is the size of a tennis court out back , its huge and i dont know what they were thinking when they built it , if only they had built the house out to the end of where the garden patio is id have just that wee bit more space a bigger kitchen ,as it is if two people are in in you cant move , my bedroom at the back would be better as it is i have 2 foot of space between the window and my bed , all the houses on my street are the same these huge gardens and not very big inside
The gardens were that large to provide large veggie beds. The 1930s house I grew up in was the same, but my df used it to grow enough veg for a family of 7, all year round.
Peoniesandpeaches · 28/01/2022 00:26

All the new builds we’ve looked at had no space for bin storage and the garages were too small to fit a car. One had no room for a fridge freezer in the kitchen and we were told we could just pay extra for a door into the adjoining garage to store it there!

TurquoiseDress · 28/01/2022 00:01

YANBU!

ComtesseDeSpair · 27/01/2022 23:53

@Andante57

We could build solid, spacious, generously proportioned apartment blocks with communal garden areas, laundries, gyms and services, as is more the norm and popular in many other cities around the world. It would be a much more effective use of land and home footprints could be much bigger. Perhaps too big an attitudinal change for too many people, though

I thought when tower blocks were all the rage in the 1960s and 70s they had communal gardens and laundries etc but you can’t blame people for not wanting to live in them.

The failure of high rise estates is more about social housing policy, how social housing allocation changed over time, the creation of ghettos, urban decay, lack of investment, poverty, marginalised people becoming further marginalised through the architecture etc rather than an inherent problem with apartment living in itself. Well designed communities with adequate investment and maintenance will be successful; badly designed ones where buildings and people are left to rot will fail regardless of how high off the ground your home is.
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/01/2022 23:46

I can't lie, I absolutely love the idea of a huge block of flats with shops and gardens and all the rest around it. I don't know why, I've never lived in one, can't even remember if I've ever been in one, I just love the thought of it!

Mind you, future dystopian fiction is my favourite so maybe that's why Grin

Andante57 · 27/01/2022 23:41

We could build solid, spacious, generously proportioned apartment blocks with communal garden areas, laundries, gyms and services, as is more the norm and popular in many other cities around the world. It would be a much more effective use of land and home footprints could be much bigger. Perhaps too big an attitudinal change for too many people, though

I thought when tower blocks were all the rage in the 1960s and 70s they had communal gardens and laundries etc but you can’t blame people for not wanting to live in them.

gelatodipistacchio · 27/01/2022 23:29

Correct.

AmberLynn1536 · 27/01/2022 23:27

@HighlandPony

Let’s be honest. This is only really a problem in new builds. I’m in a 1963 ex council house and I’ve got a 23x11ft living room. master bedroom is 19ft by 9ft. Double room is 14ft by 12.5ft and single room is 9ft by 8.5ft. I’ve got two huge cupboards upstairs, one downstairs and a pantry. Tiny bathroom and small kitchenette mind you but really big rooms compared to new builds. Half the price too
Don’t be ridiculous, there are swathes upon swathes of tiny terraced old houses across the nation with tiny backyards, no hallways, one bathroom off the kitchen and the street full of cars because they don’t have off street parking let alone garages. A lot of old houses are tiny.
astorsback · 27/01/2022 23:27

@ComtesseDeSpair

A lot of it is the British obsession with living in a house, which puts pressure on land, and results in undersized, boxy homes with often almost completely uselessly sized gardens and no storage space.

We could build solid, spacious, generously proportioned apartment blocks with communal garden areas, laundries, gyms and services, as is more the norm and popular in many other cities around the world. It would be a much more effective use of land and home footprints could be much bigger. Perhaps too big an attitudinal change for too many people, though.

People in other countries tend to be better behaved than we do though. We're too fond of pettiness and fighting, littering and other anti-social behaviour to live communally. Ask anyone who's had to put up with communal gardens, communal entries, communal stairs and worst of all, communal parking. Nine times out of ten, the loud, brash, bullying types ruin it for everyone else.
Stookeen · 27/01/2022 23:10

@parietal

Agents & Builders should be forced to advertise houses in terms of the sqm of space that you get and should list the price per sqm. That would show of the difference between a spacious old 2 bed and a mini new 2 bed. At the moment, people often only look by the number of bedrooms, so builders have learnt to squeeze in tiny bedrooms and hope people don't notice.
Yes, my continental friends find it baffling that in the UK homes are advertised with a focus on number of bedrooms, rather than square footage/metrage.
red30505 · 27/01/2022 22:56

It's the reason we're in the process of buying a house which needs quite a lot of modernising - 80's build, but got a kitchen diner, a living room and 3 bedrooms (one box) plus an office. A bit apprehensive about the updating work needed, but the space is lovely.

Other places we've seen have barely 2x3m kitchens (or less) and then one room which isn't quite big enough for living and dining.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/01/2022 22:42

YANBU. New builds - unless you pay £££ for them - are laid out poorly, have not nearly enough storage, and are quite poorly made.

One of the things I do like about American houses is that bedrooms have to have a closet to be marketed as a bedroom. I'd love to see that here. They can keep most of the rest of their building code though Grin

DrNo007 · 27/01/2022 22:35

Totally agree with you OP. I heard that developers stage their show homes by having special short beds made for bedrooms so viewers don’t notice how tiny the bedrooms are. And friends of mine lived in a new build where the kitchen cupboards were too shallow to fit normal size dinner plates in. In many houses there is nowhere the dry clothes and no storage space. I simply do not know how people manage in these crap houses and flats.

The first house I bought with ex partner was a former council house built in the 1950s. What a contrast with modern new builds! Big rooms, high ceilings, tons of light and a nice big garden where we grew veg and had apple trees, which were planted by the people who built the estate. The house was very cheap too compared with the tiny new builds going up in the area.

I think in respect to houses, as with so many other areas of life, Brits accept being shat on and fleeced in return for for substandard products.

chaosrabbitland · 27/01/2022 22:26

yep , im in an end of bed terraced council house which i am of course extemely grateful for , i know it could be much worse , but its a 1950s build pretty small , but the garden is the size of a tennis court out back , its huge and i dont know what they were thinking when they built it , if only they had built the house out to the end of where the garden patio is id have just that wee bit more space a bigger kitchen ,as it is if two people are in in you cant move , my bedroom at the back would be better as it is i have 2 foot of space between the window and my bed , all the houses on my street are the same these huge gardens and not very big inside

Timeyime · 27/01/2022 22:20

Yanbu. This is a long standing issue in the UK though. There has really only been a few post war decades when we built decent quality housing on a big scale. The old Victorian houses I've lived in that were for the workers ie the two up two downs or back to backs all had big issues with damp, underfloor water, bad roofs etc. They were still supposedly "worth" a quarter of a bloody million though. But houses aren't about housing people, not now we've been printing money for a decade and a half. They're about asset ownership.

BeKind2022 · 27/01/2022 22:15

We live in Europe but are British. Detached houses here have to be a minimum of 6 meters apart. It used to be 10 when our home was built in the 80s. We have a basement under the house which gives us a laundry room, pantry, bonus room and large garage. The storage is awesome. All new homes have to meet strict building rules here. Our homes are also built with much thicker external walls which means they don’t get cold in winter and stay cool in summer despite us having much colder winters and hotter summers than the UK.

The internal walls are also think concrete which gives amazing soundproofing within the home.

Minimum standards for UK new builds could help stop developers building such tiny bedrooms at least.

We always planned to return to the UK at some point but the lack of affordable well constructed and spacious homes puts me off to be honest.

elbea · 27/01/2022 22:10

We live in a four bed new build town house, I hate it. We are lucky in a way as they are army married quarters in a mixed neighbourhood so we pay nominal rent but it’s so poorly thought out. The actual living space is tiny, there is art room for one three seater sofa. The kitchen table has to be pushed up against the wall when it isn’t in use. It is so poorly though out for a family despite being advertised as a family home. I feel sorry for the people who have paid £400+ for them!

Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 22:05

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

I agree and I don’t understand why there isn’t government legislation forcing developers to build decent homes. That would be due to the small matter of extensive donations to Tory funds and lots of paid lobbying
Not just Tory.

Tony Blair and his family, for example, have made millions out of property.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 22:03

@CuteOrangeElephant

It's not just the houses itself, the planning around it is atrocious as well.

I moved to a new build estate in the Netherlands last year and the estate has it's own supermarkt, shops (bakery, book shop, fish mongers, chemist), doctor's surgery, pharmacy, 2 primary schools, nurseries and many, many playgrounds.

Meanwhile the town I where I lived in the UK had a massive housing estate planned without any thoughts about services.

The planners are strangled - they have no real power. Around her the developers do what the fuck they like - they either ignore conditions or get them set aside.