Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
Adhdbrainhereagain · 28/01/2022 11:55

I don't think houses here are fit for purpose but I don't think this problem is unique to the UK.

What I really don't understand is why people really want to buy draughty old houses built many decades ago because they have 'character' and then moan about how expensive they are to maintain and heat.

People might be snobby about my new(ish) build, but it's lovely and warm!

Ski4130 · 28/01/2022 11:44

I've only experienced living in houses in France, the UK and NZ, and yes the UK houses are smaller, but our house in NZ was literally an uninsulated shed with no heating or double glazing. We managed one winter in it before we had to have the whole place insulated and a fire and heat pump installed. Couldn't do much about the windows, so we lived with condensation pouring down the windows for 2 months of the year, a dehumidifier constantly running and our youngest had ear infections and coughs every single winter for the 5 years we lived there. Moved back to the UK into a new build rental and the rooms were smaller, but man did I appreciate the central heating and double glazing in that tiny house!!

We lived in 2 houses in NZ, and visited friends houses and this was perfectly normal. Never have I ever been so cold inside as I was in NZ buildings in winter, so I'm not sure build quality is just a UK issue!

AhThisAgain · 28/01/2022 11:33

I work in this area.

It comes down to land value.
Plenty of developers would prefer to build large, high quality and sustainable homes.

However, this does not create the most profit. The developers who can create the most profit can afford to pay the most for the land, and so are the ones who can buy and build their crap tiny boxes.

We have a shortage so they sell anyway.

The same goes for everything else you would like to see - large gardens, more light, more affordable housing and amenities. All adds to cost which reduces the amount you can pay for land which means you can't buy or build anything at all.

Take less profit then? It's a very risky business and construction costs are getting higher. A decent level of profitability needs to balance out the risk. Your investor and the bank providing the debt also need to see this profitability otherwise they won't lend/invest you any money.

What's the solution?

The government should put stricter planning requirements on size, level of affordable housing, quality. Crucially authorites should stick to these and not agree to flex them just because too much has been paid to secure the land. Result, land prices come down and better housing is built.

Obviously its not really as straightforward as that.

Local authority planning departments are hugely underfunded and can't deal with the existing workload let alone put together proper strategies for where and what should be built. And if they don't have these it's a free for all.

Also doesn't work in lower value areas where cost of land is low and grant funding required just to make it possible to build.

So, that's why we don't have enough space to dry our clothes.

thereisonlyoneofme · 28/01/2022 11:15

I think our tiny housing and density is why there is so much anger and general unhappiness in the population, we are all living on top of one another

Dishwashersaurous · 28/01/2022 10:34

And the new build obsession with toilets. A tiny three bed new build with three toilets in it, and no where to actually store anything or put a decent wardrobe

Sartre · 28/01/2022 10:28

It’s a very small country with a huge population so small homes aren’t really a choice, more a necessity.

mugandspoon · 28/01/2022 09:47

Completely agree on how impractical UK houses are, generally speaking. Have never understood why people don't demand to know sq metres of a house, that's the main thing that matters really. It's not even listed on floor plans all the time.

When it comes to heating etc, at the time of COP26 I listened to an interview with an architect/surveyor/something person who is also lobbying for better insulated homes in Britain and she said 'British people don't know what it is like to live in a warm home'. That really struck a chord with me, I'm not originally from Britain and I've never seen damp houses like I do here. It's not an issue in many other colder countries, bathrooms and houses are not damp because there's good insulation.

So someone wrote 'Windows are small but that means less likely to get rot / mould / damp and waste heat.' Windows can be massive if houses are well insulated!

There was quite an interesting thread last year about what standard houses in other countries look like, there were lots of links to estate agents that are probably outdated but maybe interesting for someone else too anyway: www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4153522-Houses-in-other-countries-inspired-by-what-baffles-you-about-other-countries

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 28/01/2022 09:14

Our first home as a couple was a German apartment. 3beds. We had a good size bathroom, plus additional toilet room. Storage cupboard. Full kitchen which some people put a little table in. Living/dining room. Main bedroom had fitted wardrobes with shelves, then we had space for two sets of drawers, dressing table, plus a full size cot bed 10 months later. The second bedroom, which we used as a dining room, also had a massive built in wardrobe. The smallest bedroom easily fit a double bed. Nice wide hallway throughout.

There were 8 apartments on four floors in each half of the block. Then in the cellar we had the laundry (with stations fir 8 washing rooms, they were our own), and drying room. We had our own cellar room too. There was a room for bike and pram storage in the cellar too, although folded prams could be kept in the foyer. Outside we we had a massive communal garden for the 16 apartments, where you could put stuff like trampolines and paddling pools if you had indemnity insurance, plus a play park. We also had a private balcony.

It was a lovely home. Well built and thought out.

Incidentally we had the 'pleasure' of a New build house in a different part of Germany few years later and it wasn't as good. Well built, and the attic space was good. But the house itself was lacking in light, space and was very claustrophobic. Tried to incorporate things like the laundry room, ensuite etc without having the floor space so the actual living space was limited. So small new builds is not just a UK phenomenon.

onedayoranother · 28/01/2022 09:06

I don't think it's unique to the UK. While it's so depressing to see acres of identikit red brick houses with boxy rooms and tiny garden, I've seen similar elsewhere. And looking at those 'Flip or Flop' type programs from the US and it looks like a stiff breeze would knock those over - though they are more spacious and to call a room a bedroom it must have a closet.
I did live on an ex council estate built in the 30s. All had long gardens and were built around greens for communal play (though now all have 'no ball games' signs). The houses were very solid but tiny - two doubles and a box room with bathroom downstairs, galley kitchen and one reception totalling less than 900sq ft. My council neighbour said she had raised four boys and a girl in hers! So small council housing is nothing new, but the new home builders for private ownership seem to be shrinking the house footprints daily.
There are minimum space rules now but they are not fit for purpose. Getting architects involved and proper independent town planners may help, but of course it all comes down to the money.

CounsellorTroi · 28/01/2022 08:59

@SE123

basements are great but expensive to build and very expensive to guarantee
And not practical in areas prone to flooding.
LittleMG · 28/01/2022 08:54

I don’t think the way that houses are built in this country is at all adequate in terms of insulation and heating. They need far too much, expensive heating.

Singlebutmarried · 28/01/2022 08:51

Ex council 1950s semi here, and we’ve decent sized rooms, each bedroom can fit a double in it.

Extension plans are underfoot though to reconfigure, and maximise the living space downstairs.

OfstedOffred · 28/01/2022 08:22

the term 'density' takes the country's size into account...and other countries like netherlands or belgium have an even higher density than uk but still manage to have bigger average properties.

This....

purplesequins · 28/01/2022 07:28

@Giraffesandbottoms

Yanbu. Our population density isnt much higher than germany yet our average new property is 76sqm, theirs is 109sqm. Its s massive difference

Germany is a significantly larger country.

the term 'density' takes the country's size into account... and other countries like netherlands or belgium have an even higher density than uk but still manage to have bigger average properties.
Giraffesandbottoms · 28/01/2022 07:21

Yanbu. Our population density isnt much higher than germany yet our average new property is 76sqm, theirs is 109sqm. Its s massive difference

Germany is a significantly larger country.

purplesequins · 28/01/2022 06:31

I live in forrin now and here a flat has to have outside space. either a balcony/roof terrace or access to a garden.

purplesequins · 28/01/2022 06:28

I also hate the fact that 3 bedroom often mean one of them is tiny.

that is so unpractical if you have children. the tiny room is often too small to take a double bed and the 'master' (another ridiculous concept imo) has an ensuite and walk in wardrobe. so you cannot easily swap so dc can get similar size rooms.

TeacupDrama · 28/01/2022 06:21

It's not just a density problem , they build the same way in Scotland, if Scotland had the same population density as England over 30 million people would live here not the current 5.5 million. Old tenements vary though some are huge spacious three beds in West end, some were poky single ends and everything in between

Goatinthegarden · 28/01/2022 05:54

DH and I bought a three bed 1930s semi with one bathroom and no utility. It was easily 50% bigger than the 2008 4-bed, 3-bathroom, detached house my parents bought.

We’ve also since added a massive wrap around extension and still have twice the garden and driveway of the new build.

When my parents bought their four bed new build, it was more expensive than the 6 bed Victorian villa that they were downsizing from (both equivalently nice areas about five mins apart). Where they live, everyone seems to favour the new build estates.

sashh · 28/01/2022 04:59

I once said, aged about 9 that architects should be forced to live in the houses they design.

The people designing and building houses/flats are not interested in people actually living.

Eg Japan has tiny one room apartments but the bathroom will have some sort or rail and a heater so you can use it to dry clothes.

I watch a lot of YouTube and one was about student housing in Finland, they were small apartments but there were communal areas, a laundry a sauna and some designated storage in the basement.

Part of the problem is the rental market, unless you can get a council / HA property you don't have any security. Even if you do the cost of renting is the same as buying so people are forced to buy.

If you could rent a decent sized property on a 10 year lease with strict laws for landlords to obey with regards to maintenance and rent control, renting would become a choice.

If you could rent a decent home for less than buying then young families would not feel the need to buy and when they did they would not be buying a shoe box because that is all they can afford.

cuddlywuddly · 28/01/2022 04:41

Whenever my relatives visited from Germany, Netherlands and France to my parents home, I always used to feel embarrassed having them come over showing my tiny box room with a bunk that I shared with my sibling to my cousins which literally had a prison cell window whilst my cousins literally had a floor to themselves! Despite my parents being on similar incomes with them, my relatives lived in far better habitable conditions. It was always our home that seemed to be deprived from the normal stuff they had in their homes which was space, high ceilings, storage, large bathrooms, laundry rooms and a modern looking airy interior. We had carpets throughout ffs when they had underfloor heating this was something like 20-25 years ago lol

cuddlywuddly · 28/01/2022 04:26

I currently rent a new build 100sqm 2 bed flat and I'm quiet happy actually and would buy it if they actually held value after a decade! For the same price it was either a rodent infested with toilet paper thin wall flat or this new shiny luxury apartment that has a lift, private amenities including parking space. My bedroom is literally like a hotel room where it has a walk in wardrobe and en-suite. The flat is surrounded by floor to ceiling windows allowing as much light in as possible during a typical overcast London day. The flat is heat and sound insulated and after experiencing this kind of living, honestly I cannot believe the shit holes I've lived in paying the same money. Honestly every single brick that is standing upright in the UK needs to be demolished and rebuilt. 1930's, 1800's or whatever houses are also not fit for purpose unless you have spent thousands doing it up. It's like a ticking time bomb accident waiting to happen with its electrical, gas and crooked problems not to mention the wasted heating energy that doesn't heat.

Ozanj · 28/01/2022 02:57

British people can’t afford big housing in the places most want to live, that’s why houses have become smaller. Unlike most Europe countries we have far far more limited useable landspace and as such house prices are and will always be high. Add to this zero inflation for most industries for the past 20-30 years and you can see why developers are mostly only producing the small stuff. That doesn’t mean it’s bad - these newbuilds are designed with small families where both parents work. So limited garden space means limited maintenance. Access to schools and other amenities is important but can be a short drive away. Windows are small but that means less likely to get rot / mould / damp and waste heat. Internal spaces are more useable and so you don’t have 30 sqm wasted as corridor space in the middle of a house like some older places do. And older houses are rarely accessible unless you happen to own a mansion - newer builds have lowered wider doors / downstairs loos / potential to create good downstairs bedrooms while older houses were designed to hide the infirm away upstairs only to emerge again at the funeral.

Andouillette · 28/01/2022 02:46

There's a problem that hasn't been mentioned (or not that I saw anyway) that some sectors of the population are completely hung up on new and shiny. One of my DC and spouse nearly fell for it, "Oh we want a new build, everything is so clean and fresh!" Yeah, also over priced and tiny rooms. I persuaded them to go and look at a 1950s ex police house. It needs a bit of work, the two bathrooms needed doing up and some of the windows are less than perfect but it cost them 100k less than a smaller new build! They love it and say they are never moving again. There are loads of houses like that, flats too but you have to track them down. Another DC has bought a Victorian semi which again needs work but the bones of it are great, lovely original ceilings, good sized rooms and space to extend later if they want. They too were tempted by new builds until they saw the price difference!

BadLad · 28/01/2022 02:06

if you look at Japan the way they design the interiors of small properties is great, so space saving and convenient I love Japanese bathrooms, our homes are stuck in the 1800s.

Japanese housing is absolutely terrible.