Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
OnwardsAndSideways1 · 28/01/2022 14:37

Agreed, I live in a less than fashionable ex-council 50's semi which is fantastic size-wise compared with newer builds, have viewed both, also great room in the roof, big garden (for two sheds), just built sensibly. My previous house was similar, with communal as well as individual gardens and it's lovely to live somewhere like that. I drive onto some of the newer more expensive estates just built in the last year or two and I'm horrified at how squashed up they are and there isn't even enough parking for the cars, so no-one can pass each other and it's like a maze. But they keep being built and someone is buying them, through lack of other options I guess.

GizmosEveningBath · 28/01/2022 14:33

YANBU, we took a tape measure with us on a second viewing in a new build show home. The bed in the 'third bedroom' was much smaller than a standard single. I also couldn't find a place to keep the Hoover or even our towels as there were no cupboards, even the under stairs cupboard had a loo shoved in it.
In the end we bought a 1950s semi, unlike a new build it's not pretty and it needed some TLC but we have so much space, a lovely garden and storage!

Otherpeoplesteens · 28/01/2022 14:24

The only real attempt there has ever been to dictate minimum standards for housing size in the UK was the Parker Morris Committee in 1961 which laid down minimum floor space requirements based on average furniture sizes (of the time) and the space needed to move around it and perform ordinary household activities.

Given that since then households have acquired things like washing machines, dishwashers, computers and desks, many more clothes and toys than a typical household had 60 years ago, and average furniture itself has grown larger (as, indeed, have Brits) you'd have thought there might sensibly been an attempt to revise the "Parker Morris standards" but they were only ever mandatory in the public sector, and scrapped in 1980 anyway. In reality, for much private housebuilding Parker Morris was effectively a maximum guidance rather than a minimum requirement and whereas a family home in the UK averaged 153 square metres in the 1920s that had fallen to under 97 m2 in 2014.

Minimum space standards, of course, are entirely normal in the rest of Europe, even in much more densely populated countries than this.

Cuck00soup · 28/01/2022 14:22

Yanbu. We were recently looking at a new build as we are planning to downsize - but it was a step too far.

Now looking at an older property that needs work, but has a much bigger downstairs, front & back gardens parking and a garage.

It wouldn't be so bad if we lived in warmer climate and spent less time indoors.

PermanentTemporary · 28/01/2022 14:20

Agreed with other posters that small homes are understandable but terrible design that wastes space, zero storage, awful insulation standards etc less so.

I do agree though that people will buy houses with multiple toilets whereas I've accepted I will never get back the money I spent on my roof - I think probably the original tiles from 1885, could see the sky through it, now well insulated and ready for the next 100 years, but no buyer will care.

Nat6999 · 28/01/2022 14:16

My council flat hasn't got room in the kitchen for a fridge freezer, Mine is in a tiny room at the other end of the flat which when you are disabled doesn't help. The house I owned when I was married was a 3 bed ex council & was massive with a downstairs toilet, utility room, understairs cupboard for coats & vacuum, fitted wardrobes & airing cupboard in one bedroom, fitted wardrobes in the smallest room. It was insulated so well we had to have the upstairs windows open right through the winter & the fuel bills were very low. Compared to my flat where the heating needs to be on the highest setting from September to April it was great to live in .

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/01/2022 14:15

Well, okay: land, in the places where most people want to live, is limited and expensive. I don’t think there’s any point talking about how much of the UK isn’t actually built on, when it’s the built on land where people want to be. For a variety of reasons, some of them solveable with enough political will, some of them solveable by an attitudinal shift in how we live - which I think has to include a reduction in space provided for parking multiple vehicles per household, not an increase.

Otherpeoplesteens · 28/01/2022 14:07

Land is limited and expensive.

No. No, no, no, no, no. I was born in Macau (population density c.21,000 per square kilometre) and grew up in Hong Kong (comparatively empty at 6,700/km2). There are regular posters here who come from Singapore (8,000/km2). Even the Dutch and Israelis (457/km2 and 380/km2 respectively) would howl at the idea that the 277 folk crammed on to each square kilometre of the UK are somehow struggling with limited land.

Less than 10% of the UK is built on and almost all of that is not housing anyway: just 2% of England's land surface is covered in buildings of all types - houses, shops, offices, factories, greenhouses - and that falls to 1.4% for the whole UK. We gain more than that much land every day when the tide goes out.

Facts here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-41901297

The problem is that building land is rationed by the government through the planning system and scarcity of planning permission translates fairly directly into smaller homes. There are any number of reasons why this might be the case, but the most obvious one to me is that the UK's education system and economy is now so poor that for decades successive governments have deliberately opted to use house price inflation to deliver 'increasing wealth' because labour productivity certainly doesn't.

rifling · 28/01/2022 13:59

We live in a 4 bed flat in Italy. It is not very beautiful (outside!) but all the bedrooms are good-sized doubles and there is plenty of storage as well as a cellar for each flat for bikes, luggage etc. When we were looking it was clear that even here rooms have got smaller over the last few decades and ceilings lower. (Ours are 3 metres which really makes it seem more spacious plus we have cupboards in the hall that go up to the ceiling). The only thing I would change* is the bathroom size - both are tiny but I guess that wasn't a priority.

*well, I would also love a utility room and a garden but that would be a completely different place!

DiDonk · 28/01/2022 13:59

Amazing people keep saying UK is a tiny country with no space, it's just not true. Countries like Belgium and Holland are much smaller and have greater population density. About 7% of the UK is built on.

The problem isn't space it's the will to improve ordinary homes.

thegiftrift · 28/01/2022 13:49

Agree. We had to store our bikes in our bedroom when we lived in our 2 bed flat, which was actually very large compared to the one we had before. It was annoying because there was a massive communal hallway type space which would not have blocked any entrance or whatever if we left our bikes there but we weren't allowed to because of fire risks

Builders were allowed to leave their wood and building materials there though.

Also Windows
Sony houses i went to view had 0 windows on the whole side of the house or just a tiny one.
we didn't actually have a window in our flat bathroom so a few times we had power cuts in the bath and it was completely black. very tricky to get the children out so I could find a torch
we ended up keeping candles and a lighter in there.

LovesColourGreen · 28/01/2022 13:43

New builds are far too small. I live in an old ex-coal board house, as there is no way I could ever afford a new build, and the rooms are quite spacious. I have viewed new out of curiosity and the rooms and garden are tiny. However, we simply just don't have enough land available in the UK. We are a tiny island so desperately over populated. Land is precious and very expensive. Other countries have bigger houses because they have the land.

RincewindsHat · 28/01/2022 13:15

Sure, it could partially explain it. It even sounds like it makes sense UNTIL you look at the extremely healthy profit margins and revenues of companies like Barratt Homes and realise there's actually no good excuse for churning out estates and homes with poor design and not making adequate parking provisions. Land cost is in no way an issue.

whywouldntyou · 28/01/2022 13:11

I live in a small 4 bed semi. My parents live in a large 4 bed detached. We have no storage, they have one cupboard in a bedroom. My son has just bought a 3 bed end terrace ex council house it has 5 (yep, FIVE) cupboards off the hallway. All built with a few years of each other. Go figure!!

Chipsahoy · 28/01/2022 13:10

People want the new builds with tiny gardens though.
Took us months to sell out four bed semi with large rooms. Large kitchen diner. Larger living room. Medium size dining room and large utility. Upstairs had two bathrooms, downstairs wc.
Everyone said how lovely it was to have large rooms and new builds don’t but they wouldn’t touch it due to the very large garden.

It’s so strange

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/01/2022 13:00

@RincewindsHat

Yes. I would never contemplate a new build as they tend to be dreadful quality, tiny, no adequate parking (surely every house 2 beds and up should have 2 off road parking spaces as a minimum standard?) and almost all of them have windows looking directly into someone else's house. Don't even get me started on the scam that is shared ownership.
Surely this partially explains why new builds are so small inside? Land is limited and expensive. So if everyone wants to live in a house rather than a flat and have off road parking for multiple cars on their property and to ideally have a detached house and for the outlook to be away from any other property; the actual size and inside of the house has to be seriously compromised to accommodate all that?
Guacamole001 · 28/01/2022 12:50

I love a nice cellar too but over here this is fairly rare. In Belgium many people have an attic and cellar in full everyday use (the cellar being an excellent storage option). Plus a place for the wine for those who indulge regularly!

skybluee · 28/01/2022 12:46

Apartments are often too small and I agree about the lack of outdoor space especially. Interesting to read that some places require flats to have access to outdoor space. However, people also have way, way too much stuff/possessions. A small flat done well is liveable and you can be happy there, a small flat crammed with stuff just makes you feel unwell.

Guacamole001 · 28/01/2022 12:46

I think you have a point op. I have lived in many addresses over the years and rarely is there sufficient storage.

I am constantly throwing crap away and despite fitted wardrobes in both bedrooms am always facing an uphill struggle. I throw and recycle huge amounts yet still feel no further forward.

Going off on a slightly different tangent I am half Belgian. Their houses have fantastic thick wooden doors. Really high quality. They make most houses look like Micky Mouse over here!

CanofCant · 28/01/2022 12:41

@BiscuitLover3678

I completely agree. They build so many tiny spaced one bedroom flats, all to much smaller proportions. Family homes do not have enough storage space and no place for a proper dinner table. It’s awful.
Only on the first page but YANBU OP. Regarding the dinner table issue, I was watching a piece on TV about the 'death of the dining table' and how it is terrible that families don't use one anymore, instead preferring to eat on the sofa and completely missing the fact that a lot of homes just don't have the space for one.
RincewindsHat · 28/01/2022 12:30

Yes. I would never contemplate a new build as they tend to be dreadful quality, tiny, no adequate parking (surely every house 2 beds and up should have 2 off road parking spaces as a minimum standard?) and almost all of them have windows looking directly into someone else's house. Don't even get me started on the scam that is shared ownership.

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/01/2022 12:21

@Dishwashersaurous

And the new build obsession with toilets. A tiny three bed new build with three toilets in it, and no where to actually store anything or put a decent wardrobe
Yes, I found this utterly bizarre when we looked at a couple of new builds prior to the house we bought. Tiny two bedroom houses with a main bathroom, an en-suite, and a WC downstairs. But no space to fit proper wardrobes in bedrooms because they’d used that for the en suite and no built in understairs cupboards because that was filled with a toilet. Why on Earth would I need three places to poop but nowhere to hang my clothes or put the vacuum cleaner??
Fimofriend · 28/01/2022 12:19

Went to see a new built show home. Were very impressed with design, size, garden. Then I wanted an extra look in the kitchen while my husband wanted an extra look upstairs. The lamp in the ceiling in the kitchen moved around so much I thought it would fall down. The ceiling moved several centimetres just by him walking around. I have never seen anything like it.

MilduraS · 28/01/2022 12:10

@Dishwashersaurous

And the new build obsession with toilets. A tiny three bed new build with three toilets in it, and no where to actually store anything or put a decent wardrobe
Yes! I've been looking at new builds and some of the bedrooms are very cramped because they've insisted on adding an en suite. The kitchens are also small with very little worktop space. Not sure if that's just a "me problem" because DH and I usually cook together. I assume a lot of people do.
Everydaydayisaschoolday · 28/01/2022 12:06

@ParsleySageRosemary

And light. Council house design concerned itself with creating fit places to live for all, to maximise health and well-being. Modern design seems to ignore all of that, preferring the ethos of money-making instead. The plots also included gardens to be used for veg growing, and estates were originally designed to be pleasant.

The modern practice of putting great big 5 or 6 bedroom houses on tiny gardens befuddles me completely.

I have a great big house in a tiny garden. It's probably equivalent to the ground floor of the house. It suits me fine. There is enough room for bbq/table/chairs/gazebo so we can have a party. Theres a bird feeder to keep things interesting. There's space to put out an airer in the summer. There is a minute lawn and a couple of flower beds. Sa few planters and a solar powered water feature. That's all I want. I HATE gardening.