Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
Ireolu · 28/01/2022 21:52

We rented a 3 bed new build with 2 bathrooms and a downstairs loo for 2k a month. The garden was north facing and it was tiny. Could only fit a bedside table on one side in the 'master'. It really helped us to know what not to even look at when buying.

RedToothBrush · 28/01/2022 21:44

I once did a cost break down of the reality for anyone who bought in 'less desirable areas' in the north in 2007 or after in terms of wages v affordability.

For the generation or those living in the south who had benefited from equity gain through house prices going up, it was a shocker.

Anyone who has seen my figures has gone wtf and then promptly said 'i wouldn't have been able to buy around here faced with that'. Which proves me point.

They then all went back to classic nimby comments after doing faux sympathy talking about their kids and grandkids.

At this point i decided they were all a bunch of fucking selfish fuckers who were pointless trying to engage with because the underlying problem was they simply didn't give a shit as they had their house and their kids had inheritance so fuck all else was important.

AhThisAgain · 28/01/2022 21:21

@KeepYaHeadUp

Land cost is massively an issue but you are correct that the volume housebuilders are making huge profits. The issue is that due to their economies of scale they can build much cheaper than the smaller developers - and that's keeping the quality that same. Imagine how hard to compete to buy land if you're a smaller developer who wants to build something GOOD. The poorest quality, cheapest development is the one which allows the developer to buy the land and build.

NIMBYism and our discretionary planning system doesn't help this though. A smaller house builder with some more innovative, higher quality designs can't often shoulder the burden of trying to secure planning permission whereas a volume house builder with a pattern book of tried and tested (secured planning permission!) houses has much more certainty and can absorb the risk and cost of submitting schemes, appealing refusals, etc. If the public were more on board with development the good stuff would be easier to achieve.

The design code and planing system overhaul which was being discussed could have gone some way to achieving this but NIMBYs are usually homeowners who are usually Conservative voters so chances of any meaningful change happening are slim to none.

Yep, also very much true. The proposed planning changes have been watered down too much to change things.
FurbleSocks · 28/01/2022 20:34

@Otherpeoplesteens

The vast majority of new build plots have zero side return and minimal gardens so you can't add value and you can't extend.

If they were built to a size and design fit for purpose, you wouldn't have to.

But we were talking about being able to stay in a house from first time buyer through to with children them growing up etc but staying in the same house because it has potential.
MaybeHeIsMyCat · 28/01/2022 20:19

I'm not allowed to dry washing, in my own garden Confused
Oh and there's no space for a tumble dryer

KeepYaHeadUp · 28/01/2022 20:17

Land cost is massively an issue but you are correct that the volume housebuilders are making huge profits. The issue is that due to their economies of scale they can build much cheaper than the smaller developers - and that's keeping the quality that same. Imagine how hard to compete to buy land if you're a smaller developer who wants to build something GOOD. The poorest quality, cheapest development is the one which allows the developer to buy the land and build.

NIMBYism and our discretionary planning system doesn't help this though. A smaller house builder with some more innovative, higher quality designs can't often shoulder the burden of trying to secure planning permission whereas a volume house builder with a pattern book of tried and tested (secured planning permission!) houses has much more certainty and can absorb the risk and cost of submitting schemes, appealing refusals, etc. If the public were more on board with development the good stuff would be easier to achieve.

The design code and planing system overhaul which was being discussed could have gone some way to achieving this but NIMBYs are usually homeowners who are usually Conservative voters so chances of any meaningful change happening are slim to none.

KeepYaHeadUp · 28/01/2022 20:12

YANBU. There are nationally prescribed space standards which planning authorities can elect to adopt for new builds on their area. As a consequences a new build in London (where they're adopted) now will have more internal space than an average new build in Yorkshire.

I think aside from space standards we should think about new builds that are adaptable / accessible for wheelchairs, other disabilities and general old age, and storage should be included (ironing board, vacuum cleaner). We talk a lot about design standards for the outside but agree we need higher standards for inside

Otherpeoplesteens · 28/01/2022 20:08

The vast majority of new build plots have zero side return and minimal gardens so you can't add value and you can't extend.

If they were built to a size and design fit for purpose, you wouldn't have to.

FurbleSocks · 28/01/2022 19:52

@Sceptre86

We have a 4 bed new build built over 10 years ago. We saw many more newbuilds built more recently but the one we ended up buying had better sized bedrooms and a separate dining room which works for the way we live. It doesn't have a playroom but the bedrooms are large enough to accommodate all of the kids toys. The garden is a nice size but not huge. My mum had a 3 bed semi with a huge garden and space at the rear. They were able to extend outwards and up and keep the garden size (got rid of the patio). Mum's house had an original kitchen that was no bigger than my utility room but they made it work till they could afford to extend it (a good 10 years). I would have loved to have bought a 3 bed semi with space to extend over time and when we could afford it but they don't have those type of houses where we live. If I ever moved back to where my parents live that is the type of house I would like to buy one with potential. Yanbu.
I agree with this logic. I would have loved to have bought a house with room to extend over time as we have the money. The vast majority of new build plots have zero side return and minimal gardens so you can't add value and you can't extend.
breakdown19 · 28/01/2022 19:03

I was talking to my Dh about this and he was saying its also because of our pensions system
I need him to rephrase what he was saying and I will
Come back and post but I was pretty depressed afterward

tinkywinkyshandbag · 28/01/2022 18:52

I agree. Ex council houses post war are so much more spacious than new builds.

Sceptre86 · 28/01/2022 18:47

We have a 4 bed new build built over 10 years ago. We saw many more newbuilds built more recently but the one we ended up buying had better sized bedrooms and a separate dining room which works for the way we live. It doesn't have a playroom but the bedrooms are large enough to accommodate all of the kids toys. The garden is a nice size but not huge. My mum had a 3 bed semi with a huge garden and space at the rear. They were able to extend outwards and up and keep the garden size (got rid of the patio). Mum's house had an original kitchen that was no bigger than my utility room but they made it work till they could afford to extend it (a good 10 years). I would have loved to have bought a 3 bed semi with space to extend over time and when we could afford it but they don't have those type of houses where we live. If I ever moved back to where my parents live that is the type of house I would like to buy one with potential.
Yanbu.

AhThisAgain · 28/01/2022 17:42

@RincewindsHat

Sure, it could partially explain it. It even sounds like it makes sense UNTIL you look at the extremely healthy profit margins and revenues of companies like Barratt Homes and realise there's actually no good excuse for churning out estates and homes with poor design and not making adequate parking provisions. Land cost is in no way an issue.
Land cost is massively an issue but you are correct that the volume housebuilders are making huge profits. The issue is that due to their economies of scale they can build much cheaper than the smaller developers - and that's keeping the quality that same. Imagine how hard to compete to buy land if you're a smaller developer who wants to build something GOOD. The poorest quality, cheapest development is the one which allows the developer to buy the land and build.
CHIRIBAYA · 28/01/2022 16:44

Of course 'living' spaces in homes are so small because our culture doesn't really prioritise 'living', it expects us all to be on the constantly revolving hamster wheel of work. The concentration of land ownership in the hands of relatively few people is a significant driver of land costs and hence house prices in this country. Instead we have pitched battles between those priced out of the housing market and those who paid inredibly high interest rates back in the 80's. Both of these are unacceptable yet we buy into this narrative while the peope who are really creaming off this system stay conveniently off radar.

prettyteapotsplease · 28/01/2022 16:34

You're damn right Notcontent, we put up with houses which are too small because that's what's on offer and we can't afford anything larger. My new build has little storage and my vacuum cleaner when not in use is either in the spare bedroom or on the landing. Not ideal.

I'm in my 6th (probably last) house as I downsized, 'losing' a garage, conservatory and - what really irks me, a kitchen which was large enough to fit a dining table. I knew what I was letting myself in for and it was out of necessity but it will always rankle. In over half the houses I've lived in the kitchens were too small. I wonder what type of houses millionaire building firm bosses live in? Not shoe boxes, that's for sure.

RedToothBrush · 28/01/2022 16:23

@Guacamole001

My home is an extended two bed semi. Nowhere has a cupboard to hide away either the Hoover or the ironing board. The slightly taller kitchen cupboard still isn't big enough. Why kitchens do not get designed with all this in mind is baffling.
Whats an iron? Ive not used one in 20 years.

(slight exaggeration but my point is that is having a dedicated space for an ironing board something that reflects lifestyles in 2022?)

RedToothBrush · 28/01/2022 16:20

@RobotValkyrie

What baffles me most is the lack of basements/cellars in British houses. You could still build the same number of houses on the same land, and every house would get extra storage space + a utility room. But no, no basements.
Im not convinced that the uk is an ideal place for cellars. I have friends who live near the top of a hill and after heavy rain, their cellar prone to flash flooding. Its not a damp problem. Buildings at the bottom of the same hill have had flash flooding from surface run off on the ground floors.

The big problem here is the number of people paving drive ways, removal of trees, everything paved on top of the clay soil which once its saturated, means there's no where for the water to go.

We live in an 'ugly' 60s build, but wow the quality of the building puts our old new build to shame and the proportion of the rooms is good. All the two bed 1950s council houses got bought out and extended to twice the size because the plots were big. Those that are unconverted are sought after. Meanwhile the new builds are pitched at an overpriced rate and are tiny by comparison.

I am pretty sure the average family are living in smaller homes than a generation ago.

2bazookas · 28/01/2022 16:11

I can only think the OP has very limited knowledge or experience of houses in the UK.

Otherpeoplesteens · 28/01/2022 16:11

The population density figures for the UK are a misleading average- they don’t reflect the pressure on London and the SE.

London and the SE is really nothing special!

ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-eurostat-news/-/DDN-20170406-1

Babdoc · 28/01/2022 15:57

PPs who say the UK has lots of available land that is unbuilt on, may not realise that they are talking about large areas such as Scottish mountains, where it would be
a) impractical to build at all and
b) 500 miles away from where people need to work and live.
The population density figures for the UK are a misleading average- they don’t reflect the pressure on London and the SE.
Secondly, you can obviously have much bigger homes on the same footprint if you stack them up as high rise blocks - but these are v unpopular in the UK. Brits want a fantasy house and garden with roses round the door etc, not an upstairs neighbour banging about on their ceiling. Apartments are much more the norm in European cities.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 28/01/2022 15:27

As for Nimbyism, I think it's chicken and egg. Most of the time people do appreciate there is a need for some new homes (not as many as claimed, as we have so many disused ones which should be renovated and brought back into use and so many second homes too) but know that they will be expensive, crammed together and low quality.

I think where developments are well thought out they attract much less opposition especially if also on brownfield sites.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 28/01/2022 15:25

@SE123

I'm not a big fan of new builds but I'd say they have much better use of space than older houses. Older houses have kitchens and bathrooms added in where they werent before and often ill thought-out extensions.
I would agree with that - our last house was a new build and really packed things in - downstairs loo and an en-suite shower upstairs in what was quite a small house.

Our current house is 1960s and has quite small rooms but is built on a wide road with lots of space. We have quite a small garden but some of the other plots are quite generous.

The thing I really don't like about new build estates is how close the houses are to one another and how narrow the roads are. I don't need a big garden because I don't like gardening, but a bit of space between houses is a must!

Guacamole001 · 28/01/2022 15:21

My home is an extended two bed semi. Nowhere has a cupboard to hide away either the Hoover or the ironing board. The slightly taller kitchen cupboard still isn't big enough. Why kitchens do not get designed with all this in mind is baffling.

SE123 · 28/01/2022 14:45

I'm not a big fan of new builds but I'd say they have much better use of space than older houses. Older houses have kitchens and bathrooms added in where they werent before and often ill thought-out extensions.

Otherpeoplesteens · 28/01/2022 14:40

Interesting article here, suggesting that if you fix housing then it unlocks a lot of potential elsewhere in the economy. We really need to tackle the insidious British Nimbyism disease.

www.theguardian.com/books/2022/jan/17/the-big-idea-could-fixing-housing-fix-everything-else-too