Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think U.K. houses and flats are not fit for purpose?

236 replies

Notcontent · 27/01/2022 19:28

So - I know that there is a housing shortage - but I think too much forces is on getting houses and flats built no matter how small/inadequate, which can cause huge problems for the people living there.

The U.K. has some of the smallest houses in Europe. I am not saying people need huge houses - far from it actually. But homes should have:

  • adequate heat and sound insulation
  • rooms that are big enough for storage, etc
  • somewhere for people to dry their clothes
  • etc

I am not an architect but I am interested in this as I have lived in a few different countries, in different houses and flats, and have experienced first hand how small things in house design can make a huge difference to people’s quality of life.

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 29/01/2022 13:19

Our 3 bed 1930s semi has two really good sized high ceilinged reception rooms and we built a good sized garden room on the back which we felt was preferable to a conservatory. Two cupboards under the stairs. Small utility for the dishwasher, washing machine and broom cupboard. Downstairs loo. Long kitchen not big enough for an island but plenty big enough for units both sides. Huge cupboard on the landing, airing cupboard in the bathroom. Detached garage which we’ve converted. I know someone with a 4bed 1970s house that feels poky in comparison.

BrokenUmbrella · 29/01/2022 11:09

It isn't just an issue in New builds.
Our 1940s 3 bedroom council house is 740 square feet. Quite a squeeze with 6 of us!
Although we do have a lovely garden, so I wouldn't trade it for a new build. But quite often they look bigger than our older council house.

Tumbleweed101 · 29/01/2022 10:17

One thing I have noticed looking a new builds is how many toilets and bathrooms they have. A tiny two bed had a toilet downstairs in what could have then made a more sensible sized living room and a bathroom and toilet upstairs. Slightly larger houses have a toilet downstairs, an ensuite and a family bathroom. All the living space in these houses was tiny so it seems odd having so many bathrooms/toilets.

My own house is a three bed old council property with one bathroom and separate toilet but it has cupboard space instead.

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 29/01/2022 10:13

- why would you want to dry clothes inside? Use the garden 🤷🏻‍♀️

Because I live in Enland where it pisses down with rain for 10 months of the year 🤦‍♀️

Otherpeoplesteens · 29/01/2022 10:10

- why would you want to dry clothes inside? Use the garden 🤷🏻‍♀️

Because where I live in the North West it it not out of the ordinary for it to rain every single day for three or four months in a row.

purplesequins · 29/01/2022 09:12

@bonetiredwithtwins

Some of the comments on This thread are hilarious
  • we don't build basements because they are expensive with invariably long term maintenance issues and the ground conditions aren't suitable
  • not every developer makes loads of profit - many new build sites are built with very very low profit margins some years
  • land is expensive - nothing to do with the house builder who is the one who is demonised and everything to do with land owners capitalising on fact land is a finite resource
  • new builds are built to much tighter building regs than ever before in term of materials and heat insulation and sound insulation
  • housing association properties do have minimum space requirements for bedrooms and storage but private does not and that's does need addressing
  • houses in Europe are valued on size ie m2. But In the U.K. the convention has always been value based on number of bedrooms - hence why builders try and get as many bedrooms in as possible
  • a desire for en-suites means less storage and smaller bedrooms as builders try and get it all in on one footprint
  • why would you want to dry clothes inside? Use the garden 🤷🏻‍♀️
CounsellorTroi · 29/01/2022 07:35

@Fimofriend

Went to see a new built show home. Were very impressed with design, size, garden. Then I wanted an extra look in the kitchen while my husband wanted an extra look upstairs. The lamp in the ceiling in the kitchen moved around so much I thought it would fall down. The ceiling moved several centimetres just by him walking around. I have never seen anything like it.
Show homes are often made to seem bigger than they are because they remove the internal doors, and put a two seater sofa in the living room for example
trunktoes · 29/01/2022 07:22

@LakieLady sure houses were so much bigger under a Labour government Hmm

bonetiredwithtwins · 29/01/2022 05:19

Some of the comments on This thread are hilarious

  • we don't build basements because they are expensive with invariably long term maintenance issues and the ground conditions aren't suitable
  • not every developer makes loads of profit - many new build sites are built with very very low profit margins some years
  • land is expensive - nothing to do with the house builder who is the one who is demonised and everything to do with land owners capitalising on fact land is a finite resource
  • new builds are built to much tighter building regs than ever before in term of materials and heat insulation and sound insulation
  • housing association properties do have minimum space requirements for bedrooms and storage but private does not and that's does need addressing
  • houses in Europe are valued on size ie m2. But In the U.K. the convention has always been value based on number of bedrooms - hence why builders try and get as many bedrooms in as possible
  • a desire for en-suites means less storage and smaller bedrooms as builders try and get it all in on one footprint
  • why would you want to dry clothes inside? Use the garden 🤷🏻‍♀️
nalabae · 29/01/2022 04:38

Agree

KeepYaHeadUp · 29/01/2022 03:17

@Elaine2468

The blanket hate for new builds makes me a bit sad. We have a new build, 4 bed, 3 bathroom property. All bedrooms are decent sized doubles. It's split over three floors which helps to make it more spacious. Our old house was a 70s 3 bed and it had plenty of storage space but that was really all it had going for it. The layout made it feel cramped. Our new house has a coat/storage cupboard in a big entrance hallway, a large cupboard in the kitchen. Built in appliances with lots of cupboard space left. Wide landings to allow for cabinets to be added. We have front and back gardens, a driveway, a garage... But it took us bloody ages to find it. We searched through plenty of houses that wouldn't have been big enough. Some of them built in the 60's, 70's, 80's.some new.... They had size issues in the bedrooms mainly, as pp have mwntioned. But surely those houses that wouldn't have been right for us would have been great for someone else? A starter home for one person/a couple? An empty nester?
We also own a new build which has 4 good size bedrooms, high ceilings, walk in storage in hallway and on both landings (townhouse). No utility sadly as we couldn't afford that one (had an extra bedroom too). The point is it's possible to get a decent new build bjt it's not the norm, and a lot of people (on a budget, requiring shared ownership, etc) simply don't have the choice/buying power to be picky
sst1234 · 29/01/2022 01:11

Completely agree OP. When you see 1100-1500 sq.ft boxes with 3-4 bedrooms, it’s just crazy. As though a bedroom only needs a double bed - which is not big enough for two people to sleep in anyway. Where are people expected to put their clothes and other belongings? Under the floorboards?

shortsaint · 28/01/2022 23:50

To be contrary I live in a 20 year old (bought new)house and it is spacious with great storage - built in wardrobes, under stairs / airing cupboards. It is a town house with living room on first floor though which not everyone likes and I'd prefer a larger garden.

My brother lives in the most hideous 70s badly designed, no storage or insulation house. I'd have mine any day.

ohfook · 28/01/2022 23:40

Yanbu I've moved from a brand new new build to an ex-council house and the ex-council is much better thought out in terms of storage, layout and room size. My new house also has a useable garden as opposed to the 3x2 lawn I had in the new build. that wouldn't drain properly.

YukoandHiro · 28/01/2022 23:31

This is so true. I stayed in an air bnb apartment in a tower block in Bucharest once and it was so well designed for living.
European design puts our rabbit hutches to shame

HappyDays40 · 28/01/2022 23:29

K think q lit of UK housing has been built with he purpose just to house people. So much of where I lived was use for coal mining. I lived in a pit cottage that had previously been lived in by miners. Stone built so cold, close together at front and back to very little natural light, jammed in on both sides and tiny back yard. There were two bedrooms and bathroom. I didn't see how hemmed in I felt trying to work from home with no space while my husband was also working from home and doing a degree. We overlooked from all angles. Lively when juts us two but awful with a child.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/01/2022 23:17

@LakeShoreD

I’m not sure my Victorian terrace ticks any of those boxes, it’s not just a new build issue. I’ve lived in other countries too and I’ve never had clothes drying space unless you count the tumble dryer. When I lived in the US every place we had banned line drying laundry. Lovely big closets though!
My sister who’s lived in the US for decades, says that line drying there is seen as a sign of either poverty or madness.
Tealightsandd · 28/01/2022 22:59

people moving up north having benefitted from equity gain in the south is a real issue and causes real resentment

Why do you think many many Londoners have been socially cleansed out of London? For years.

For the last two decades, huge numbers of people (including many from the north) have moved to London.... pricing out Londoners.

People cannot complain when the traffic becomes two ways.

And as for second homes. London has suffered dreadfully from this problem for years and years. Investors snapping up homes to lie empty all year round, second home "bolt holes', air bnbs.

It's awful wherever it happens, but one of the reasons why it's started to spread out of London is because for years nobody cared when it was happening to Londoners.

Hard fact very clearly shows that, whilst becoming an issue elsewhere, London is the very worse hit. In England, at least. Two thirds of all of England's homeless families are in London.

Of course the solution - nationwide - is a mass social housing build.

inpixiehollow · 28/01/2022 22:33

I completely agree with you, a lot of the new builds now are not only very cramped but also have issues from being built so hastily, and rushing to get people moved in.
Also there seems to be LOADS of flats in my area. Both new & old and no tenants for them? The older flats are run down and the newer ones are small, and I live in a small town there isn't much demand for flats.

TheFnozwhowasmirage · 28/01/2022 22:32

When we put in for pp for our new house,it was refused,and ,I kid you not,one of the reasons for refusal was that a 12sq metre bathroom was 'too big'. Apparently I might divide it up in the future and make an extra bedroom,and that was reason enough to refuse pp.
Never mind that part of it was in the eaves,and I'm not breeding hobbits.Never mind that planners can't tell you what you can and can't do internally with your house in future. It took me 11 months of arguing and getting our local councillor involved,to get it passed.
Years back,my family applied for pp to build two modest 3 bed semis on our farm,for the families working on it. The council refused,saying that only one large house could be built on the plot. Since we couldn't build for one family and not the other,the land was sold and the developer built a huge house on it.The whole planning and building system needs overhauling.

Elaine2468 · 28/01/2022 22:21

The blanket hate for new builds makes me a bit sad. We have a new build, 4 bed, 3 bathroom property. All bedrooms are decent sized doubles. It's split over three floors which helps to make it more spacious.
Our old house was a 70s 3 bed and it had plenty of storage space but that was really all it had going for it. The layout made it feel cramped.
Our new house has a coat/storage cupboard in a big entrance hallway, a large cupboard in the kitchen. Built in appliances with lots of cupboard space left. Wide landings to allow for cabinets to be added. We have front and back gardens, a driveway, a garage... But it took us bloody ages to find it. We searched through plenty of houses that wouldn't have been big enough. Some of them built in the 60's, 70's, 80's.some new.... They had size issues in the bedrooms mainly, as pp have mwntioned. But surely those houses that wouldn't have been right for us would have been great for someone else? A starter home for one person/a couple? An empty nester?

RedToothBrush · 28/01/2022 22:07

@Tealightsandd

For the generation or those living in the south who had benefited from equity gain through house prices going up, it was a shocker

It's been the very opposite of benefiting from for the huge numbers of people in the south who are low waged or too disabled or ill to work. Particularly those from the epicentre of the public health housing and homelessness emergency - London. And it is the epicentre. Two thirds of all homeless families in England are in London.

There's not much more deprived than being without a home.

And no it's not so simple as "just move somewhere cheaper". Aside from the somewhere cheaper not staying somewhere cheaper for long if everybody moves there (see the complaints on here about priced out Londoners moving elsewhere), there's also the fact that for many people, particularly the more vulnerable (eg. disabled) there is a need to stay close to their families, support networks, and communities.

Talking of sympathy. There's been little to none for all the Londoners who have been socially cleansed from their local areas over the last 10-20 years.

Oh i have plenty of sympathy for those socially cleaned and priced out of where they grew up. Its not restrictioned to london.

But people moving up north having benefitted from equity gain in the south is a real issue and causes real resentment.

Acknowledging it does not take away from problems in london. A quarter of the population lives in the SE. You should EXPECT the majority of the problem to be in the SE for that reason alone.

Affordability issues are certainly not the preserve of London though. Places in the SW and Wales and the Lakes have particularly acute problems with affordability - largely driven by second homes and air b and b.

I am very aware that someone in Swansea can't just take a job in Huddersfield. Or someone in Kendal can't just work in Brighton.

Tealightsandd · 28/01/2022 22:05

citymonitor.ai/government/why-aren-t-working-class-people-living-cities-also-left-behind-4694

This excellent article by Omar Khan looks at, as he says, The lazy and reductive “London is cosmopolitan elite” narrative

One particular casualty is our understanding of working-class communities. This is particularly striking in the presentation of London as being a Remain stronghold inhabited by metropolitan elites.

In fact, the reality is that working class communities, especially in cities, have been just as “left behind” as those elsewhere in the UK. Even 72 people dying in the Grenfell Tower tragedy, a preventable fire which happened within sight of Parliament, hasn’t dislodged the dominant narrative of London as a leafy cosmopolitan elite bubble.

RedToothBrush · 28/01/2022 22:01

Remember that lots of large companies 'landbank' in order to keep the price of land artificially high...

Tealightsandd · 28/01/2022 22:00

For the generation or those living in the south who had benefited from equity gain through house prices going up, it was a shocker

It's been the very opposite of benefiting from for the huge numbers of people in the south who are low waged or too disabled or ill to work. Particularly those from the epicentre of the public health housing and homelessness emergency - London. And it is the epicentre. Two thirds of all homeless families in England are in London.

There's not much more deprived than being without a home.

And no it's not so simple as "just move somewhere cheaper". Aside from the somewhere cheaper not staying somewhere cheaper for long if everybody moves there (see the complaints on here about priced out Londoners moving elsewhere), there's also the fact that for many people, particularly the more vulnerable (eg. disabled) there is a need to stay close to their families, support networks, and communities.

Talking of sympathy. There's been little to none for all the Londoners who have been socially cleansed from their local areas over the last 10-20 years.