Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Manners - am I living in the past?

221 replies

NellyDElephant · 27/01/2022 18:14

AIBU to expect my children to say, at the very minimum, thank you for dinner, please may I leave the table? Or something along those lines, after they have finished the meal I have just made them, straight after coming home from a long day at work?
Children are 7, 10, 12, 13.
Surely I’m not expecting the impossible here? Or am I living in the past and trying to help them to have the same manners I was expected to have at that age is just not going to happen?
12yr old is my DSD and it is evident these rules are not in place at her DM’s house - as there’s no evidence of any manners displayed here either. Now I’m questioning whether I’m BU!

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 27/01/2022 20:34

@NellyDElephant

Her DF is still at work during children’s mealtimes. So it’s just on me. I either mention it to her at the time, and get the ‘look’ from her, or mention it to him when he’s home from work and look like I’m stirring the pot, I suppose. I don’t want to be the evil SM! But equally, I want polite DSC and DC Confused
He never, ever eats with her?
givethatbabyaname · 27/01/2022 20:32

You're very reasonable to expect and want consideration and respect. But I think YABU to call for this in the way you've suggested.

Personally, I cringe when anyone - child, spouse, relative, guest - thanks me for the food I've cooked for them. It's food, everyone and anyone is welcome to it. I do a weekly shop for our food bank, we contribute to our school's free lunch scheme. Access to food is a basic human right.

However, I LOVE it when anyone says they're enjoying the food I prepared!

I cannot fathom asking permission to get off a chair. What's the alternative?!

Equally, I cannot fathom someone getting up from the table when others are still eating. Very rude.

Separately, I've noticed that the British are totally hung up on etiquette in a way the rest of the world really isn't. All cultures value respect and consideration (because all humans do). This manifests as manners, and is good. Etiquette is sometimes rooted in manners, but oftentimes in a deliberate effort to show social standing/class. I have no time for that.

NellyDElephant · 27/01/2022 20:31

Her DF is still at work during children’s mealtimes. So it’s just on me.
I either mention it to her at the time, and get the ‘look’ from her, or mention it to him when he’s home from work and look like I’m stirring the pot, I suppose. I don’t want to be the evil SM! But equally, I want polite DSC and DC Confused

OP posts:
Rosebyanothername19 · 27/01/2022 20:25

@NellyDElephant how long has this arrangement been in place? Is your DSD generally quite quiet/sullen? How does she get on with your children?

I dont think you're a dinosaur or and evil stepmother. Manners have to be taught.

Does your DP say thank you or does he leave the table without a word too? He should really be the one enforcing manners IMO

HeddaGarbled · 27/01/2022 20:24

I’d take one heartfelt “Thanks mum, that was yum” over a fortnight of drilled platitudes.

Pumperthepumper · 27/01/2022 20:23

@NellyDElephant

I suppose it’s quite hard to convey the full situation from two posts on MN. I love both my DSD and I love my DC - we try so hard to treat them all in a fair and equal manner, they all have a great (and probably pretty privileged) life, where every need is met, every possible need is anticipated, and we try very hard to make sure they are clothed, catered for and cared for. All I’d like is some manners, a thank you here and there, perhaps a couple of sentences spoken to us. If I ask “how was your day?” Instead of “fine” or “good” I’d love a “it was good thanks, how was yours?” Or again, am I expecting too much?

To the previous questions, DSD has been living with us, with this childcare arrangement, for just over a year now.

And what does her father think?
NellyDElephant · 27/01/2022 20:21

I suppose it’s quite hard to convey the full situation from two posts on MN. I love both my DSD and I love my DC - we try so hard to treat them all in a fair and equal manner, they all have a great (and probably pretty privileged) life, where every need is met, every possible need is anticipated, and we try very hard to make sure they are clothed, catered for and cared for.
All I’d like is some manners, a thank you here and there, perhaps a couple of sentences spoken to us. If I ask “how was your day?” Instead of “fine” or “good” I’d love a “it was good thanks, how was yours?” Or again, am I expecting too much?

To the previous questions, DSD has been living with us, with this childcare arrangement, for just over a year now.

OP posts:
cookiemonster2468 · 27/01/2022 20:20

@WonderfulYou

YABU I find it very controlling when adults make children ask permission for every small thing. A parents’ job is to feed their children - it shouldn’t come with conditions that they must thank them for doing it, you’re not doing them a favour you’re literally doing your job.

However most of the time myself and my child will say thanks when receiving the food but never afterwards as well unless we are a guest at someone else’s house.

Yes I'm inclined to agree with this really.

Manners are important, but it becomes a weird power dynamic when children are expected to be submissive and thankful and ask permission for every little thing.

You brought them into the world, they didn't choose to be here, so obviously you have to feed them. Do they really have to be thankful for that?

WelcomeHere · 27/01/2022 20:17

My kids say please, thank you, they thank me for dinner etc. They don't tend to ask to leave the table because they don't leave it until everyone has finished and we are all leaving the table, if you see what I mean.

I would just ask her to sit down until everyone has finished. Doesn't have to be a big thing- children are quite capable of understanding that different people have different rules. I would try to avoid thinking of it as you versus her mum as that isn't relevant or helpful.

interferingma · 27/01/2022 20:17

@Wendybyrdesmissingconscience

It’s vital to keep encouraging manners. The number of times I hear young people saying “can I get” in a shop, with no please, thank you, kiss my arse or anything, drive me mad.
Not just young people. It began with Friends. That's fiftysomethings who have been influenced by that
strawberrydonuts · 27/01/2022 20:17

Manners are important but by 12/13 they should be behaving similarly to the adults, it seems strange for a child of that age to be asking permission to leave the table.

By that age I'd expect them to know that they don't just leave when everyone else is still eating. If she needs to leave early then I'd assume it was for some legitimate reason (not just because she's fed up) and that she'd just say "excuse me" or something, not to ask permission.

Another thing to consider is she might be seeing it as a power trip and be feeling resentful/ rebellious about it. You have to take the time to explain to her the reasons why manners are important to you and not just expect blind compliance.

refraction · 27/01/2022 20:15

@TheGoldenWolfFleece

Very outdated to ask permission to leave the table imo.
Absolutely ridiculous. Thank you yes but thats a bit much.
ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 27/01/2022 20:14

I must be really honest here and say , without a word of a lie, everyone in my house ALWAYS says thanks to the person who had made their meal. Every single night. Whether it’s bolognese, toast and beans, or a Christmas feast, they always say thank you. And so do I if someone else cooks for me. So no, yanbu. Manners cost nothing.

Pumperthepumper · 27/01/2022 20:14

Also, have I read that properly - she’s only at her mums house two days out of fourteen? Surely it’s her fathers fault that she’s not doing as she’s asked then?

esloquehay · 27/01/2022 20:13

So, just ask her to please sit down until the rest of you have finished?
You sound pretty controlling and like you don't have too high an opinion of your DSD.
I'd be working on including her within the family dynamic, rather than concentrating on the 'otherness'.
Is she generally a good kid? If so, cut her some slack. Having 2 homes isn't quite as much fun as it sounds.

Traumdeuter · 27/01/2022 20:12

Although most houses don’t have dinner tables so it probably died out when homes got smaller.

Most houses? Really?

Pumperthepumper · 27/01/2022 20:07

Why does it matter so much to you?

pinkyredrose · 27/01/2022 20:07

Why didn't you tell her not to leave the table?

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 27/01/2022 20:06

My kids are very polite (generally) as I've drilled into them the importance of it, but every time (for instance) they say thank you for the lovely meal to my MIL she loses it afterwards with me and DP that they shouldn't say thanks for what is expected and so on. Drives me nuts. Of course they should. She has cooked for them.

WonderfulYou · 27/01/2022 20:04

I’ve never heard of anyone asking permission to leave the table apart from in Victorian films.

Although most houses don’t have dinner tables so it probably died out when homes got smaller.

SeasonFinale · 27/01/2022 20:03

@NellyDElephant

Tonight’s example has just illustrated it all really. They were all called down for dinner, together, DSD finished first, got up, put her empty plate by the sink and left the kitchen without a word. My children were still eating, and when they had finished, asked to leave the table, and said thank you for dinner. It grates on me every time, but it’s clear these manners are not being pushed/insisted upon at DSD’s Mum’s house. (DSD lives with us during week and sees DM EOW, her younger sister does the opposite, lives with DM during week and sees us EOW - their weekends are together at either household. Her manners are no better, we have to give constant reminders of ‘please’ and ‘thank you’ when she’s here too. I can’t blame them at all - they just haven’t been taught)

Wondering if I’m a dinosaur though! Or just evil stepmother? Or both?!

Why do you not just say Excuse me (dsd) we haven't finished yet? Come and sit back down.
WonderfulYou · 27/01/2022 20:03

YABU
I find it very controlling when adults make children ask permission for every small thing. A parents’ job is to feed their children - it shouldn’t come with conditions that they must thank them for doing it, you’re not doing them a favour you’re literally doing your job.

However most of the time myself and my child will say thanks when receiving the food but never afterwards as well unless we are a guest at someone else’s house.

Momicrone · 27/01/2022 19:59

Can't her dad deal with her

Fairylightsongs · 27/01/2022 19:54

As do me and dh if we need to leave mid-meal or before someone else has finished

You and your husband say please may I leave the table if you need to leave the table?

I’m sorry that’s not actually good manners it’s just quite odd, even when it was perceived as good manners to say it, it was always just for young children who couldn’t understand if they should or not, adults say excuse me.

I’ve never heard of grown adults, nt ones anyway, who say please may I leave the table.

Fairylightsongs · 27/01/2022 19:50

If you have to leave the table (for a good reason) and you are a child, say 'please may I leave the table'. An adult shouldn't need to leave the table while eating, but if they must, they should just say 'excuse me' and leave with the minimum of fuss

I’d agree on if a child is very young they should ask if they can leave the table, so below six or so, becayse they may not understand at that age or younger . Past that they are old enough to know They should stay till the end and do so, or say excuse me if they need to leave and should be taught proper manners.