Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Please help - vulnerable adult and social services, GP failings

115 replies

soworriedaboutthis · 27/01/2022 17:20

Hi, posting for traffic.

My dad is a type 1 diabetic and has mobility issues that came on quite suddenly last year. He was self-neglecting, refusing all help from family, basically hiding himself away at home. He's very reclusive.

We took him to the GP regarding his lack of mobility and issues at home (he's not managing basic self care) and they didn't really do much. Suggested he wait for a neurology appointment that he'd already been waiting months for but did order some blood tests to be done by the district nurse at home.

A few days later the district nurse arrived at his home to find him unresponsive on the sofa. Firemen had to be called to force entry to the home and an ambulance. He was having a serious hypo and was taken to hospital.

At this point we contacted social services to raise a safeguarding concern and the paramedics said they would also raise a safeguarding concern. We discovered he wasn't buying food, eating properly, washing, showering. Totally self-neglecting. Social services said that because he was in hospital, his needs were being met so they could log it but not do anything at that time.

Throughout his hospital stay he took his insulin incorrectly (though insisted he was taking it right) and had numerous hypos. He had various scans and tests to uncover the reason for his sudden mobility problems and nothing serious was found. He was diagnosed with peripheral neuropathy but the drs said they didn't understand why he couldn't walk as he should be able to.

He was discharged home and given a care package to help him. He refused them entry to his house once he went home and that was the end of it. He's deemed as having capacity to make his own decisions and so was entitled to refuse care.

In December he had another serious hypo, unresponsive in bed. This time he was found by a district nurse who had come to review how he was getting on with his diabetes. Again, the firemen had to force entry to his home and an ambulance was called. Again he went to hospital. He continued to mismanage his insulin and was difficult with staff.

This time he was discharged in January this year with a reablement care package meaning that he would have a lunch and dinner time carer to assist with meals. He allowed them in for the most part although wouldn't have food in for them to cook. The care company don't relay information to us reliably so we don't always know what's going on.

On Saturday my dad turned his lunch time carer away - he can't explain why and thinks he was already in the early stages of a hypo. We weren't informed by the care company. The dinner time carer found him unresponsive in bed later that day and called an ambulance (she had access to the house because he now has a key safe installed) This time was the worst he's been. His blood sugar was 1.4 which is extremely low. Previous times it was around 2.

He refused to go to hospital against paramedics advice and then was left at home. I called the emergency social services on Sunday and was told I needed to call back on Monday. On Monday I called Social services again and was told I needed to contact his care worker that had been assigned after his hospital stay - she's in charge of his reablement package. I wasn't able to get hold of her until Wednesday despite numerous calls and messages but she said she's looking into it. Whatever that means.

GP was also contacted on Monday morning in an urgent request as we wanted to request that district nurses visit him every day to help him check his blood sugar, help him administer his insulin and check that he's eaten as the carers aren't able to do any medical care. GP said she would visit him the next day to speak to him about a way to move forward.

She never came back to us to update us. We have no idea what was discussed at that appointment as my dad is extremely difficult to speak to and he frequently lies/gets confused.

Contacted the GP surgery on Wednesday for an update - no response.

Today, I messaged my dad to check in and he informed me that he'd had another serious hypo, ambulance called etc. Found out from the care company after calling them that he'd been found by his lunch time carer unresponsive in bed again. Extremely low blood sugar. The care company didn't inform us until we called them.

We've contacted the GP again to explain that something isn't right with his health, he's complaining that he's hypoing in his sleep because he's too tired to wake up and eat and she's unavailable but the receptionist relayed a message to us that there's nothing she can do yet because she's waiting on advice from the diabetic team.

The care worker in charge is kicking off with the care agency about their lack of communication with us but other than that, she's not done anything. She said he still hasn't been allocated an actual social worker - I'm not sure what the difference is between her and a social worker.

I'm at an absolute loss as to where to go from here. The GP has described him as a ticking time bomb and it's only a matter of time before he has his next serious hypo but nothing really seems to be happening. No one is standing up and taking charge of the situation, it's just me and my sister desperately trying to call around everyone to find out what we can do.

If anyone has any experience with social services or is a GP and can advise what we can do it would be really appreciated. This latest hypo is only 5 days after his last one and I'm so worried about him. These aren't minor episodes, each time he is completely unresponsive, very close to death with no way of helping himself or communicating to someone that he's unwell.

My sister and I both have a very strained relationship with him and he's awful to us both but I just can't leave him to deal with this alone. He's so reluctant for help and we don't know if he's abusing his insulin or not eating on purpose to make himself unwell or if he's genuinely struggling to manage his diabetes alone. It's all such a mess.

Please if anyone can help in any way, it would mean a lot. Where do we go from here?

OP posts:
Potatopotate · 28/01/2022 00:09

I have no good advice but have been through similar with a family member who was self neglecting, very unwell and unable to look after them, with very patchy care. Just wanted to say I know how hard this is to deal with and it sounds like he is lucky to have you looking out for him.

WildPoinsettia · 28/01/2022 00:06

There is a huge issue with health v social care and diabetes

There's a huge issue with health Vs social care full stop. Both have stretched budgets, or claim to anyway, with all the waste I see in some departments I'm not convinced. But they'll both say it is the other one's job to sort xyz. They'll essentially lie to families and patients saying there's nothing they can do, or you don't have a choice about something, anything to get you to go away and be one less job on their list.

Straysocks · 27/01/2022 23:56

Sorry, one more thing. Our GP Practice Manager has been way more helpful than the actual GP as they know what duties of care & responsibilities the Practice holds.

Straysocks · 27/01/2022 23:53

Reading this with interest and some experience as a family member. OP, do you know there is a disc your Dad can wear on his arm called a Freestyle Libre? All Type 1 diabetics are eligible for them on prescription, perhaps needing one hypo now & then - clearly no problem evidencing that. I'm still learning but there are ways of getting a device privately that can call you when blood sugar is too low. Have you spoken to the Helpline at Diabetes UK? They can take cases up too.

I wouldn't put great faith in the key/care worker. They are just a lead within a business. The business is contracted to Social Care and there will have been a SW involved at some point to allocate this.

There is a huge issue with health v social care and diabetes. District Nurses are often suggested from all sides but this is not a real solution for staying at home long term. The GP surgery can ask them to check in the very short-term - glucose level and insulin injections but only as it is a crisis. I'm not to familiar with capacity arguments but wonder whether the fact he can't manage changes/adaptations to his diabetes - understandably after managing himself for so long and now being in crisis - then what actual capacity does he have? Capacity to do an injection that could kill him is no capacity at all.

I'll keep watching this post and will add anything I know. If you ring the council's main number and ask for Adult Social Care, they should be able to tell you who his SW is.

Autumnalblooms · 27/01/2022 23:31

I am a community carer , just in regards to the care that has so far tried or has been in .Has it been the same carers our a multitude of different ones .Having carers come into your home is a huge thing and for a lot of people it is admitting that they need help and that can be really hard to take so you get carers turned away .Ideally if it is not already happening it needs to be a small set group that can try build up a working trust with your dad .I have seen it happen sometimes people are just scared to admit they need help it is a loss of indepence or sometimes it is just pure self neglect but even with capacity it will hit a point it willl be taken out of his hands because it will become worse than it already is.

jacks11 · 27/01/2022 23:29

I understand the frustration, but declaring someone lacks capacity is not straightforward, nor is it done lightly. You are potentially removing a person’s liberty and right to make decisions. And as others have said this can be tricky to be absolute/definitive about and can be variable. Patients can and do make bad decisions for themselves.

Even if he was declared to lack capacity, it’s not as simple as you getting to decide what happens. Without power of attorney you have no legal powers (though imagine you would be consulted)- it will have to go to guardianship order via the court of protection (not quick, nor cheap). Whether you or social work would be appointed guardian(s) is totally situation dependent.

However, in the short-term if he lacks capacity and cannot be persuaded to care for himself/ allow carers in/ move to a suitable residential placement voluntarily, or to be admitted to hospital (if necessary), I would point out that the GP (or nurse or social worker) have limited abilities to actually enforce change. In fact, it could be that the only way anyone could force him to do something/go somewhere if he refuses/resists would be to detain him under the mental health act- it’s not a straightforward “right, he lacks capacity- take him to x, force him into a car/ambulance” or “y will come do z, whether he likes it or not”. You can take the decision against the persons wishes once incapacity is declared, but physically enforcing things is less straightforward and would require legal process to be started.

With regards to the GP- they have referred to diabetic team, which seems entirely reasonable. If there is to be a change of type of insulin, for example, then it’s not the GP’s role to do that. They can advise a reduction in dose (or increase)/slight tweaks but if he decides to ignore it (or can’t remember the changes), they can’t really solve that. If they feel capacity is not clear cut it is absolutely right that they seek a second opinion from psychiatry/ memory clinic.

I think you also need to clarify whether the district nurses in your dad’s area will accept a referral for giving insulin every day/monitoring blood sugars- especially if he is on a basal-bolus regime (which is usually three times a day). In our area this would not be offered as a long- term solution (and certainly not for insulin given three times daily)- the nurses don’t have the capacity to visit three times a day (at meal-times) long-term. This might be different in other areas and maybe some district nurse teams do offer this service. GP’s refer to district nurses but cannot instruct them to do anything. Carers can prompt him to check blood sugars but cannot do them for him, nor can they administer medication for him.

If you think there is a visual problem you need to take him to an optician, if you can, or arrange an optician to do a home assessment if he can’t leave the house. GP’s are not best places to do full eye tests.

It’s an invidious position to be in- you want the best for your Dad but he either can’t or won’t help himself. I hope it gets easier for you. I’m not trying to be negative but there is no point banging your head of a brick wall trying to get people to do things they can’t do. In my experience asking for something that can be delivered gets further than demanding something that can’t be done.

RB68 · 27/01/2022 23:11

btw you don't want him shown without capacity till LPAs in place - life can become even more difficult then in terms of knowing whats going on and what happens to Dad e.g.they can independently decide he needs to go i a care home and thats that you gt no choice or part of the decision nor does Dad

RB68 · 27/01/2022 23:08

Memory test can show dementia or Altzheimers but not capacity, you can also have dementia and capacity until you just don't.

You really could do with LPAs in place and dad may be difficult about this as whilst he has some capacity he needs to sign them - but you need to be clear what he is signing and that may put him off. The health one is often the easiest as that allows you to have a "What the medics say" and also as he has been in and out of consciousness when poorly its esy to get across that if he tells you what he wants then you can then officially communicate with the medics etc.

If you don't have an LPA it can be granted by court but usually is to a social worker rather than family member.

In terms of a whole care package he needs a home assessment and it is social services that should be doing this - either to leave hospital and come home or once home the emergency team should be doing this and providing any care before the none emergency ones take over. In trms of liasing between GPs, District Nurses, Hospital and other medics the District Nurses are actually the ones that do this but will need to be refered from GP to DN to put him in this sort of loop.

What might be worth considering for the diabetes is a pump so he is not in charge of the insulin the pump is based on readings it does via the arm unit. Although its often difficult to get these prescribed depending on your postcode basically

MatildaTheCat · 27/01/2022 22:51

@soworriedaboutthis I’ve sent you a pm

SafeguardingSocialWorker · 27/01/2022 22:42

with capacity though the there is a shift in understanding away from just accepting what someone says to really testing that what they say matches up with their functional capacity to carry out a task.

Its all well and good someone being able to sit and tell you that they need to take their insulin and them understanding that to the reality of functionally being able to remember to do it when it needs to be done and executing it properly.

OP has enough evidence to suggest that despite what her dad says he isn't managing it, when previously he did.

Welshmaenad · 27/01/2022 22:26

Re: capacity - legally, unless he has a diagnosed "disorder of the mind or brain" there are no grounds to even proceed with a capacity assessment. That is why everyone is saying he has capacity - legally they must assume he does.

Care workers can only prompt medication in pre-doses blister packs, they can't get involved with insulin or blood glucose monitoring as they aren't medically trained to interpret the outcome. It would need to be a district nurse - this is the angle I'd be pushing with the GP if this was my case.

soworriedaboutthis · 27/01/2022 22:14

@MayThePawsBeWithYou

clearly he is unable to safely monitor his glucose levels, administer his own insulin in syringes or eat properly. I am surprised if this wasn't picked up on in hospital by his diabetic team and would expect him to have a full diabetic review, insulin review to see if it needs altering and given pens not syringes. I would also expect a d.n to administer the insulin as he obviously does not understand it at all and has been hospitalised many many times with severe hypos.
The GP did mention on Monday when we called her about his recent hypo that he's overdue a diabetic review. My dad would definitely not arrange any appointments himself and family weren't aware he was overdue so we have now arranged for this to take place as soon as possible.

We contacted the diabetic team today and they said they'd probably just reduce his insulin prescription so he can't overmedicate but I don't think this is the answer as he'd still take the same amount, he'd just run out faster. I'm hoping it was just a throwaway comment though and it can be discussed properly at his review. My sister will go with him to this and we'll raise the suggestion of district nurses with them. I just know he's likely to refuse and say he doesn't need any help with his insulin. So frustrating. When he's given the choice, he turns everything down and acts like he's fine but say if we text him to say 'the district nurse is coming today to do a review' he'd typically co operate. It's just getting him to agree to having them come multiple times a day, every day. I think a Dr or someone similar could possibly persuade him though but it would need to come from them and not us. Here's hoping.

OP posts:
soworriedaboutthis · 27/01/2022 22:01

@Yellowspottysocks

As stated by *@Countytee* capacity is decision and time specific. I’d be very wary of anyone bandying round that he has capacity and ask them capacity for what. Family members with regular input should have their views sought for a mca.

Sorry if I have missed this but has he had a Care act 2014 assessment? If not I’d be asking for one and as a family member involved in his life you should also be consulted for this unless he objected. If he did he should have been referred for an advocate to act in his best interests.

I don't know if he's had a care act assessment, I will make a note to ask. Who would have this information? The key worker or the GP? The problem has been the lack of communication and I don't think anyone has any real idea of what's going on/what the plan is moving forward. If they do, the certainly haven't communicated it with us.

I only received details of his key worker on Monday and she wasn't contactable until Wednesday. It's really difficult to get through to anyone on the phones although I do now have his key workers email address.

OP posts:
Mossstitch · 27/01/2022 21:51

I think you need to attack this one problem at a time. The main issue is obviously his diabetic control. From his own admission he cannot see clearly to administer it and he does not want to go into hospital again. Can you persuade him that having the District Nurses come in daily to administer his medication will stop him needing to keep going into hospital. At least you would then know he had somebody coming into him twice daily.
He will be deemed to have capacity for the decision to do his own insulin based on his ability to verbalize what will be the consequences to him of not having the correct amount of insulin, which it sounds like he would be able to say, but the gentle persuasion of allowing help with this reducing his need for hospital admissions may be enough to get him to agree to this. Then lean on the GP to refer into DN service based on his inability to see to give himself the correct doses. I've had patients who have this service based on poor vision.

TheWatersofMarch · 27/01/2022 21:22

@cptartapp you can't "get LPof A" for anyone. Someone can choose to GIVE LPofA. It's an important distinction - certificators should spot relatives who are being pressured.

soworriedaboutthis · 27/01/2022 21:14

I'm taking my time to read all of the responses and make notes as there's been some really useful information here, thank you.

I know a few have mentioned about how much professionals can do if he won't co operate but in my experience of dealing with him, he co operates a LOT more with others than he does with my sister and I. He disregards a lot of what we say and becomes very argumentative but then will often take it on board if it comes from a Dr or other professional. That being said, he can still be reluctant and withdraw from help but in his case I really think having the right support in place is the best chance of getting a resolution for him.

I did see that someone mentioned eyesight and this has flagged up with me as he often says he can't read his messages and loses his glasses. Maybe he's also struggling to administer the correct dose because he can't see properly? Something I will raise with his GP.

With regards to patient confidentiality, he's given consent for his medical information to be shared with my sister so the GP is able to share information with us.

I can't concentrate for worry as he's messaged to say his blood sugar is now really high and he can't read his text messages properly as the words are all jumbled up so he's taken a bunch of insulin and is going to bed. He's point blank refused to go to the hospital even though he really does need medical attention. Feel like my hands are tied. I'm just hoping he gets through until the morning until his lunch time carer can check on him.

OP posts:
SafeguardingSocialWorker · 27/01/2022 20:53

@WhenTheyComeForYou

I used to work in management for a reablement service.

You need to make a complaint to your Local Authority Adult Social Care leader. Go to the top and complain. It's sad, but it really is the most effective way to get a better service.

It's difficult because if your dad is deemed to have mental capacity (remembering this isn't a permanent status - the assessment can change in different circumstances and times) then he is within his rights to refuse care/medical treatment.

But there are some obvious failings here

  • our team would have referred your dad to a complex social worker very early on when it was apparent he needed support but was refusing it.
  • our team would have chased the social worker until a plan was in place
  • our team would have bought food for your dad (with his funds) if he allowed them
  • him having no food would trigger an instant referral to social services and if deemed useful, something like meals on wheels organised (hot meal delivery)

Complain to the top of the council. And complain to PALS.

Keep complaining and making a fuss. The loudest (and rudest) families would get resolutions where others wouldn't.

This would be my experience as well but I'm pretty sure I know which local authority the OP is talking about due to some of her terminology and I know that particular area do reablement slightly differently.
SafeguardingSocialWorker · 27/01/2022 20:50

Reablement is a period of assessment - usually around 6 weeks. If at the end of the reablement period its felt that the person is going to require ongoing support then it will be passed to a social worker for further assessment. I suspect he is still in that system and a care act assessment is imminent.

This isn't a safeguarding issue, its a case management issue with lots of risks.

Safeguarding means something different under the Care Act than it does in other settings. It doesn't mean 'managing all risks' it means safeguarding people from abuse and neglect. Sometimes people who are very severely self neglecting can come under that too if everything else has failed to address it, but again, this sounds like a poorly managed health need and something that potentially can be managed with a stable care package / DN support and a risk management plan.

I hear your frustration but social services can't do anything about the poor management of his diabetes, that does have to come from his GP/ Diabetes Nurse/ District nurses.

Ask the reablement worker how long he has left on reablement and insist on a social work referral at the end.

If all else fails remind the local authority that section 11 of the care act may allow the local authority to continue to try and engage with people who appear to be self neglecting if despite any refusal to engage they may still have eligible care needs.

WhenTheyComeForYou · 27/01/2022 20:49

I used to work in management for a reablement service.

You need to make a complaint to your Local Authority Adult Social Care leader. Go to the top and complain. It's sad, but it really is the most effective way to get a better service.

It's difficult because if your dad is deemed to have mental capacity (remembering this isn't a permanent status - the assessment can change in different circumstances and times) then he is within his rights to refuse care/medical treatment.

But there are some obvious failings here

  • our team would have referred your dad to a complex social worker very early on when it was apparent he needed support but was refusing it.
  • our team would have chased the social worker until a plan was in place
  • our team would have bought food for your dad (with his funds) if he allowed them
  • him having no food would trigger an instant referral to social services and if deemed useful, something like meals on wheels organised (hot meal delivery)

Complain to the top of the council. And complain to PALS.

Keep complaining and making a fuss. The loudest (and rudest) families would get resolutions where others wouldn't.

Mummapenguin20 · 27/01/2022 20:39

As a carer we can give meds but not injections. Sorry havent read the full thread so may have been mentioned already

User2638483 · 27/01/2022 20:37

I feel like we’re mirroring what OP is experiencing in real life in terms of which service should take the lead responsibility and how hard it is to know how to move forward 😔

Bagamoyo1 · 27/01/2022 20:30

@User2638483

First battle I would fight is with the GP/district nurses. Yes maybe he can physically administer his insulin his diabetes is clearly not being well managed.

everyone wants to, or should want to avoid hospital admission.

Therefore I would push again for DNs (not via the local authority social care worker, they can’t instruct them as easily as GPs can).

In my area I believe someone in his position (and I have known someone similar) would get daily DN input around diabetes even if it’s short term.

This to me is primarily a health issue rather than social care one, but all should work together.

GPs have no control over what DNs will do. GPs can refer to DNs, and DNs can say yes or no. I sympathise OP, but you are are attacking the wrong people. If you and your sister can’t persuade your Dad to look after himself, what powers do you think the GP has? If, and it’s a big “if” , the DN service actually had the capacity to go and check your Dad’s blood sugar, what would that achieve? He could inject insulin again 5 minutes after they left. DNs can’t keep the insulin themselves, so your Dad would have it in his house. It could be put in a safe, but if he wanted access to it, no one could prevent that. This is a social problem. You and your sister need to spend time with him, possibly 24-7, to help him, and try and persuade him to either take better care of himself, or go into some sort of care facility. It’s not the responsibility of medical services to coax a cantankerous man to do things he doesn’t want to do. The only other thing I can think of is referral to a diabetes specialist nurse to consider GLP-1 treatment. It’s a weekly injectable that isn’t insulin. But he’d have to meet the criteria, and one is being overweight.
User2638483 · 27/01/2022 20:17

There isn’t a requirement to involve family in an MCA (although it might be good practice and you might need to to get the context but not for the actual 4 part test itself).

There is a requirement to involve them when considering what is in someone’s best interests after you have determined that capacity is lacking for a particular decision.

Yellowspottysocks · 27/01/2022 20:09

As stated by @Countytee capacity is decision and time specific. I’d be very wary of anyone bandying round that he has capacity and ask them capacity for what. Family members with regular input should have their views sought for a mca.

Sorry if I have missed this but has he had a Care act 2014 assessment? If not I’d be asking for one and as a family member involved in his life you should also be consulted for this unless he objected. If he did he should have been referred for an advocate to act in his best interests.

User2638483 · 27/01/2022 20:06

Please all bear in mind that with capacity, even if someone is found to lack capacity, their stated wishes and feelings are given a lot of weight and it is still very difficult to ‘force’ someone to do what they don’t want to do even if you think it’s what’s best for them.