Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s daft to make big life decisions based on WFH without checking it’s permanent?

382 replies

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 17:13

My work used to be office-based. We’ve all been WFH since March 2020 because of government rules (not in England).

This week the government lifted that rule, and later that day our employers told us what the plans were to start bringing us back. This is pretty flexible - not starting for a month or two yet, will still allow a lot of WFH for people who want it (like 9 days a fortnight with one in the office). Most people are ok with this. Some people really aren’t.

Now we are having drama over email with a small but vocal group saying how angry/upset they are, because they have made big changes based around getting to WFH and it will now be difficult for them to go back at all. Even 1 day a fortnight starting in April. Changes like moving house far away from office; getting a dog and not wanting to leave the dog alone; selling car and not wanting to get public transport b/c germs (not just covid, all germs).

Work have ALWAYS said WFH was temporary though! I have some sympathy for how long it’s going to take you to commute from your new house in the middle of nowhere, but SURELY you’d factor that in when you bought it?

YABU - no, after 2 years of WFH working fairly well it was reasonable to expect it to continue without checking.

YANBU - yes, they should obviously have checked.

OP posts:
ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2022 22:08

The OP’s husband heard the exchange of words.

When my husband tells me what he has heard, I don’t think of it as ‘hearsay’.

So no, I don’t think this is a text book definition of it.

XingMing · 27/01/2022 22:07

It isn't genius for HR to make a rule that meetings, training, inductions all happen in one week each month. Do a deal with a local mid-market hotel (who won't have a huge number of bookings and might be glad of the certainty of xxx rooms let) to schedule meetings. The people dragged in to participate will make some kind of camaraderie.

PizzaCrust · 27/01/2022 22:07

Agree 100%. Too many people made decisions without fact checking first and unfortunately for them, the decisions tended to be difficult to reverse and financial.

Honestly, I don’t have any sympathy. If you decide to get a pet, you’re signing up to 10+ years of commitment, and it would be bonkers to think the pandemic would last that length of time. Alas, the dogs will be dumped and they’ll be someone else’s problem to deal with.

The moving house one bothers me less because ultimately, if you like the area so much then you can look for work that’s closer. You might have to make adjustments in other areas of life (less well paid job, change of sector), but if living there is so important to you, then that’s what you’ll have to do.

Honestly, though, I would be more understanding if people who are affected by this had an attitude of where they’re very much “ok, this is a problem but let’s try to fix it. If I can’t continue to WFH then I can do x, y or z”. Rather than throwing their toys out of them pram in a strop akin to a 2 year old who didn’t get a packet of sweets for the second time that day.

And, this is an unpopular opinion, but I think a lot of WFH workers need to realise that a huge volume of workers across the UK never had WFH as an option and being so bratty about WFH ending makes them look incredibly self absorbed. They had to go into work, for months when there was little to no safeguarding measures in place. They worked horrendous hours to keep the wheels of the country turning. They provided healthcare, they ensured your food retail stores were stocked, they delivered shopping and parcels to thousands of people every single day. I’m sure a lot of them would have loved the opportunity to earn money from the safety and comfort of their own home. So, maybe if you are one of those who is pissed off about having to commute to work a few days a week/your normal working week, maybe take a step back and reframe the entire thing in your mind- “hey well at least it was a good run. I like WFH so maybe for my next role I’ll see if I can find a role that has hybrid/WFH working”.

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 22:05

@dorkfink

No I don't think it's a big ask to come in 1 day out of 10 just seems a bit of a logistical nightmare trying to coordinate everyone for that same day.
yeah probably. I think they’re counting on most people being back more than that and therefore teams can rearrange around it.
OP posts:
GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 22:04

Maybe that’s past of the communication issue - work talked vaguely about flexibility and some people assumed flexibility = I get to pick the work pattern that fits me best, woohoo let’s move to Snowdonia. Whereas actually flexibility = we will be prepared to give you some of the things you want, but not necessarily everything.

If we’re ever in this situation again i hope employers are very VERY clear. Like explicitly saying “THIS IS TEMPORARY, we WILL be expecting you back in the office to some degree at some point, if you want to move/get a pet/whatever then bear that in mind.”

OP posts:
venusandmars · 27/01/2022 22:04

My dh's company have asked everyone to return 2 days per week. Funnily enough everyone one wants to work Tuesday / Wednesday. No-one wants to work Monday or Friday. The business needs cover every day of the week. Also some people wanted to interpret a hybrid return as coming into the office at 10.30am and leaving at 3pm. That's not hybrid, it's part time!

SirChenjins · 27/01/2022 22:04

@Pluvia

Can they work just as effectively though? I've certainly received very lax, second-class service from a formerly excellent company whose staff are working from home. Friends had been successfully using a letting agent for years until the staff started working from home, at which point it all fell apart.

I'm currently in dispute with a solicitor who told me should could complete a job in a month and five months later is stuttering into the closing straight. No outside agencies or delays involved, but she has had children at home with her (I can hear them) and can be impossible to contact for a week at a time. If she was in the office I might me able to speak to a colleague or assistant, but it's been a disaster for me. There will ne a number of suppliers/ agents/ companies I won't use again.

I had a completely different experience with the solicitor that was dealing with my dad’s estate who was wfh and very efficient - I can’t rate him highly enough.

Let’s not be under any illusions - we’ve all had poor service from office-based companies. Location does not determine service level.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 22:02

No I don't think it's a big ask to come in 1 day out of 10 just seems a bit of a logistical nightmare trying to coordinate everyone for that same day.

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 22:01

so everyone on the same team needs to come in on the same day?

I guess? I’m not the boss. Given they are no longer expected to come in on the other 9 out of 10 days (or whatever) though it doesn’t seem that inflexible to me.

OP posts:
dorkfink · 27/01/2022 21:59

Can coordinate meetings, training, new staff induction etc. that works best in person for that day I suppose?

so everyone on the same team needs to come in on the same day?

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 21:57

what difference to the office will 1 day out of 10 make?

Can coordinate meetings, training, new staff induction etc. that works best in person for that day I suppose?

OP posts:
Foolsrule · 27/01/2022 21:54

@jessieminto - agree. People are assuming that things are like they were two years ago. As you say, the after school clubs and the childminders no longer exist. Bus services have been cut, as have trains. An employee can’t use childcare if there isn’t any childcare provision!

XingMing · 27/01/2022 21:53

I have worked from home since 1990, but freelance. The onus was always on me to get up at 3.00 am to reach a breakfast meeting at 0800, perhaps having driven 250 miles to wherever. I didn't have to do it more than two or three times a month, except Jan to April, when it was often twice a week . It was the price I paid willingly, because I went to very few meetings between June and September. All of life is about trade-offs.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 21:53

Can they work just as effectively though?

Personally I'm not sure wfh due & during a pandemic is a true representation of remote working.

MidgeKiller1 · 27/01/2022 21:51

YANBU even though I wish to carry on WFH!

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 21:50

Well, it's not a 'better way of working' for the organisation as a whole, is the organisation's point. So they're saying they're fine with some flexibility for us staff, up to and including 1 day a fortnight in the office and the rest at home for those who'd want that, but not changing people's formal arrangements so they're permanently WFH.

what difference to the office will 1 day out of 10 make?

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 27/01/2022 21:50

I think the pandemic has led to a change in work practices and a shift to more flexible and remote working. I haven’t moved since the pandemic hit but I like the idea that people could have more flexibility to live where they want to for example.

Pluvia · 27/01/2022 21:49

Can they work just as effectively though? I've certainly received very lax, second-class service from a formerly excellent company whose staff are working from home. Friends had been successfully using a letting agent for years until the staff started working from home, at which point it all fell apart.

I'm currently in dispute with a solicitor who told me should could complete a job in a month and five months later is stuttering into the closing straight. No outside agencies or delays involved, but she has had children at home with her (I can hear them) and can be impossible to contact for a week at a time. If she was in the office I might me able to speak to a colleague or assistant, but it's been a disaster for me. There will ne a number of suppliers/ agents/ companies I won't use again.

Coffeepot72 · 27/01/2022 21:49

We are going back 2 days per week. This is the perfect compromise for me, but a few people have “lost their confidence” and are resisting any sort of return. But I don’t know anyone who has made changes which mean they can’t attend 2 days per week, as some sort of return was always on the cards

jessieminto · 27/01/2022 21:49

@DorothyZbornakIsAQueen

Agree OP. People who have moved house, or say, I can't go back to the office cos childcare, I pick the kids up everyday now etc. .
Our childcare is completely screwed now and we genuinely cannot go back to the after school club. They have changed the entrance criteria to give priority to NHS workers who want a full 5 day wrap around care place first, then other key workers for full place, then non-key workers. And the priority is also for the younger children from nursery age and up, then their siblings. They won't offer less than 5 days am and pm as they have had to cut the number of children due to social distancing and the bonkers bubbles. They have got enough parents paying the full whack, even if not every session is used, that they don't need to go back to a more flexible approach.

Meanwhile - so many local childminders went out of business during lockdown when parents could wfh that there is a serious shortage and again, they prioritise full time places first and youngest children over older ones.

DS is in year 5 and DH has been wfh but has to return to the office 2 days per week. I've always been in the office as a key worker. I'm having to cut my hours now to finish in time for DS 2 days a week as there is literally no other option. I'm the higher earner and it's costing us so much more than a childminder would, there just aren't any for his age let alone 2 evenings a week.

Theblacksheepandme · 27/01/2022 21:48

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase
That's terrible and I'm so sorry you had to go through that.

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 21:47

@CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory

I dunno. I think the world of work is changing. The last two years have proven that plenty of people can work just as effectively from home as they can from an office. They are now making that point. Isn't is better to push for a better way of working than just to submissively go back to being a slave to the office? I think you're all being quite old fashioned, tbh. Not wrong, exactly, but old fashioned and timid. If people don't push for change based on everything we've learned then things will just slip back to where they were. Is that what we want?
Well, it's not a 'better way of working' for the organisation as a whole, is the organisation's point. So they're saying they're fine with some flexibility for us staff, up to and including 1 day a fortnight in the office and the rest at home for those who'd want that, but not changing people's formal arrangements so they're permanently WFH.

Plus I'm not sure what difference it would make. The permanently WFH people would still be expected in sometimes for in-person meetings, training etc (this does happen in many pre-pandemic WFH jobs too) - except then work would have to pay for their travel to the normal office location.

I'm mainly hoping that the angry/upset people don't cause SO much of a fuss that the organisation goes "fuck it, being flexible is clearly not going to work so everyone work your contracted hours at your contracted location" and everyone else loses out.

OP posts:
BigYellowHat · 27/01/2022 21:44

Personally, I think that employers are being bonkers for insisting that people go back into the office. Companies must be missing out on so much talent just because the perfect person for the job can’t upsticks and move 400 miles. Given how well Teams and Zoom works, office work in the main is needless.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 27/01/2022 21:43

@CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory

I dunno. I think the world of work is changing. The last two years have proven that plenty of people can work just as effectively from home as they can from an office. They are now making that point. Isn't is better to push for a better way of working than just to submissively go back to being a slave to the office? I think you're all being quite old fashioned, tbh. Not wrong, exactly, but old fashioned and timid. If people don't push for change based on everything we've learned then things will just slip back to where they were. Is that what we want?
My employer has actually stated that productivity has gone up since we’ve been working from home. I think there will always be the ones who take advantage of it and perhaps not pull their weight but it will become apparent over time if they don’t get tasks done
Darley368 · 27/01/2022 21:43

IMO the employers calling people back into the office are just trying to resist inevitable change. It is more comfortable for them to actually see the workers working than to trust them. I hope those days are dying now and I will not work for an employer who does not offer me fully remote working. Hopefully employers will see the strength of feeling amongst their staff and move with the times.

I am much more productive WFH because my job involves a lot of thinking and I now don't lose an hour commuting, arrive frazzled and need to calm down for half an hour before I can work. Now I just go downstairs (usually earlier than I would have started previously) log on and get on with it with a clear brain. My productivity is sky high. Frankly everyone in my area could do the same and I'm aware there is a lot of push for it. We all spend our days on email and Teams anyway so where you plug in your laptop makes no difference. And the new joiners thing is crap too. We have onboarded several new people over the last two years with no problems at all. The value of the watercooler discussion is hugely overrated.

I WFH before covid but by concession. I have just accepted a new fully remote job. I would not have even applied had it not been remote.

Swipe left for the next trending thread