Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s daft to make big life decisions based on WFH without checking it’s permanent?

382 replies

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 17:13

My work used to be office-based. We’ve all been WFH since March 2020 because of government rules (not in England).

This week the government lifted that rule, and later that day our employers told us what the plans were to start bringing us back. This is pretty flexible - not starting for a month or two yet, will still allow a lot of WFH for people who want it (like 9 days a fortnight with one in the office). Most people are ok with this. Some people really aren’t.

Now we are having drama over email with a small but vocal group saying how angry/upset they are, because they have made big changes based around getting to WFH and it will now be difficult for them to go back at all. Even 1 day a fortnight starting in April. Changes like moving house far away from office; getting a dog and not wanting to leave the dog alone; selling car and not wanting to get public transport b/c germs (not just covid, all germs).

Work have ALWAYS said WFH was temporary though! I have some sympathy for how long it’s going to take you to commute from your new house in the middle of nowhere, but SURELY you’d factor that in when you bought it?

YABU - no, after 2 years of WFH working fairly well it was reasonable to expect it to continue without checking.

YANBU - yes, they should obviously have checked.

OP posts:
MooSakah · 27/01/2022 19:06

I'm surprised it's taken this long for it to be a problem. A lot of places started going back last summer.

Figgygal · 27/01/2022 19:03

@Sunsetsupernova

I have a friend who is American and was allowed by her company to travel back home for several weeks during lockdowns to work from there with slightly different hours than she normally did. She had to ask and get permission every time.

Now they’ve said that for tax reasons they can’t have people working from abroad. My friend thinks this is absolutely outrageous and claims she is being unfairly disadvantaged over people from the U.K. who can easily travel to see their family on the weekends whereas she now has to use her annual leave allowance Hmm

Her company are right tax implications of overseas working are very complicated they were stupid to let her do it in the first place But shes having a laugh thinking its unreasonable for her to take leave in those circumstances. She needs to own her choices and her choice to move countries and all that that brings
Doggydarling · 27/01/2022 18:56

I'm guessing you are in Ireland like myself, yesterday I listened to a guy complaining on a radio programme that he and his family moved from Dublin to Donegal (where he is originally from) when his public service job started wfh and now he is expected to return to the office, he's fuming and when asked if it was enough to make him resign and look for another job he replied only if he could get another public service job. I am self employed so maybe I don't quite get the mindset that allows people decide to moved large distances, sell/buy houses, get pets, changed children's schools etc all based on decisions made urgently by employers during a pandemic, of course those decisions were going to be reviewed and altered.

HopefulProcrastinator · 27/01/2022 18:54

YANBU people don't seem to realise the businesses are allowed to make changes to their benefit at any time. Even if permanent was promised, that can be rescinded with a restructure/change to contractual terms.

My company goes through peaks and troughs with WFH (even pre-pandemic). In our last major restructure 4 years ago they removed all remote working jobs. Everyone had to be present in the office for at least 50% of their working week.

People who lived too far to commute within an hour were offered redundancy or the option to pay for their own travel to the nearest office.

We now find ourselves in a hybrid choice way of working, you only need to attend an office once a month if customer facing and whenever you fancy if not. But crucially nobody has had a contractual change to location so we're all still aligned to a local office.

Some have taken the plunge and moved to their dream location and have factored in occasional travel to their budget. I'd be surprised if anyone in my company trusts that the office not being compulsory is set in stone after previous treatment. Frankly people who do are either naive or entitled.

Doubleraspberry · 27/01/2022 18:53

Selfishly I'm hoping this means we can finally sell our house in London that no one wanted last year (because people were busy moving to Cornwall) to someone having to come back sharpish.

ZoeTheThornyDevil · 27/01/2022 18:51

Yes, you absolutely cannot just fuck off to a country other than the one you're legally employed in and work from there. The tax implications are horrendous. In the US you may not even be able to move states if your company doesn't have a presence in the state you moved to. That one has caused my company a lot of headaches.

Justkeeppedaling · 27/01/2022 18:50

Ha! This is an issue currently kicking off where I work too.
HR are backtracking from the original "live and work from anywhere you like" message to one where we should think about being in the office a couple of days a week at least, and be available for F2F team meetings etc.

People are v angry because "I've bought a puppy" or "I've got rid of the childminder" and so on.

I'm enjoying the comments at the bottom of the HR statement on the intranet 😀

Sunsetsupernova · 27/01/2022 18:49

I have a friend who is American and was allowed by her company to travel back home for several weeks during lockdowns to work from there with slightly different hours than she normally did. She had to ask and get permission every time.

Now they’ve said that for tax reasons they can’t have people working from abroad. My friend thinks this is absolutely outrageous and claims she is being unfairly disadvantaged over people from the U.K. who can easily travel to see their family on the weekends whereas she now has to use her annual leave allowance Hmm

TillyTopper · 27/01/2022 18:49

YANBU! I work in London, and will go back 2d/w in the office (used to be 5d/w) when they are ready to have us which will be in 1-2 month's time. A colleague has kicked off because she has moved to Derby and can't commute that far! Obviously her case is not my business but it's crazy that people have made decisions like that without checking.

Cofifeefee · 27/01/2022 18:41

Yes, lots of people not able to come into work because of childcare - why did they give up childcare? And it's just said as a statement of fact, no apology, no expectation of repercussions for not attending.

I'm also hearing a lot of chat from people that say they have proven they can do the job from home. Yes, you may have but if company policy is everyone will attend the office 3 days a week, why do you think that you will be exempt from that policy?

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 18:40

@KeyErro

I voted YABU because your company might have been clear but others weren't. Some companies have also changed their minds.
Yes, I have heard of that and it’s really unfair. I personally still wouldn’t have made any life changes without an updated contract, but can’t blame people for believing management who told them it’d be permanently remote.
OP posts:
Theblacksheepandme · 27/01/2022 18:40

forcedfun
We will be doing 2 days in the office (minimum). I am finding the people who are most insistent that they couldn't possibly work from home are the same people where I have a real question mark over their output and performance generally, and who tend to never seem to be available when you need them at short notice...

I think if people's output and performance is not up to standard due to working from home they should be made work in the office. It is not fair on people like me working really hard from home.

SeeminglyOblivious · 27/01/2022 18:38

Yes we also have a few London weighting moaners. They've chosen to WFH and have moved miles away from London - so they've lost the 15% uplift.

Too bad. Feel free to keep it and attend the office 🤷🏻‍♀️

LadyCatStark · 27/01/2022 18:38

It’s ridiculous! It was only meant to be temporary and now people are stamping their feet because they can’t have it all their own way! If WFH was so productive how come everything has a backlog?

Gilly12345 · 27/01/2022 18:36

These people are cf and are being unreasonable with what was a temporary arrangement.

If people aren’t happy with this proposal then move jobs or suck it up, they should be lucky they still have a job.

KeyErro · 27/01/2022 18:34

I voted YABU because your company might have been clear but others weren't. Some companies have also changed their minds.

PenStation · 27/01/2022 18:33

YANBU - I used to commute 3 hours by train once a week years ago (not UK). It’s completely doable, if expensive.

Doubleraspberry · 27/01/2022 18:32

I am also a long term champion of flexible working, and even after the last two years, am having to argue with some senior managers about the principles of working from home/part time working etc. BUT I agree that making a full on life change based on no guarantee of permanence is a big risk.

I also totally agree on the childcare point. My current role is 100% remote and my children still go to after school club. I've been really firm with people that children at home while they work is OK in an emergency/very short term thing, but really can't be the norm. School holidays still require childcare if your child is too young to be left to their own devices for much of the day. People trying to work AND care for small children really will be less productive, and it gives working from home a bad reputation.

APurpleSquirrel · 27/01/2022 18:29

YANBU
I've become permanently WFH - my boss gave up the lease on our office & is herself moving from Somerset to Glasgow, so yes I will be WFH for the foreseeable future. DHs is wfh pretty much permanently too (civil service) with the odd day in the office as needed. Mainly because they've reduced the office size & now there aren't enough desks for all staff permanently anyway, so they've moved to permanent hybrid.
We got rid of one car but where fully prepared to get another if needed. We're now looking to get a bigger house so we can have our own office spaces but in the same area.
I do feel sorry for those who were told WFH was permanent & then the company has changed its mind but, yes, they shouldn't have moved etc before it was in writing.

ThePlumVan · 27/01/2022 18:28

YANBU and I’m the biggest wfh fan !

They seriously lack judgment or any common sense.

Fair enough asking for it officially to continue, but why make permanent decisions on temporary arrangements.

forcedfun · 27/01/2022 18:28

(that should say "who say they couldn't possibly return to the office")

forcedfun · 27/01/2022 18:27

We will be doing 2 days in the office (minimum). I am finding the people who are most insistent that they couldn't possibly work from home are the same people where I have a real question mark over their output and performance generally, and who tend to never seem to be available when you need them at short notice...

ZoeTheThornyDevil · 27/01/2022 18:25

Just because work can be done completely remotely in the face of a crisis and/or very pressing reason why it must be, doesn't mean work should be done completely remotely forever. I've been running the numbers for my organisation and virtual working has had a real, persistent drag effect on a number of important soft metrics. We won't go back to permanent in-office, but physical time together matters.

YANBU.

psychomath · 27/01/2022 18:19

I mean, I can see people getting lulled into a situation where getting to pick their kids up every day goes from a temporary bonus to feeling like a normal part of life, but I don't see how you can be slowly lulled over time into moving house!

psychomath · 27/01/2022 18:14

@PleasantBirthday

I think you're right but wfh has been going on so long and consistently that I think people have been lulled into a sense of security. Two years is a long time for people to not have made changes that are now very inconvenient to reverse.
I can understand this with something like getting a dog, where people maybe don't think through the ramifications completely and assume they'll work something out when the time comes to go back, only to discover it's more complicated than they expected. Although finding someone to walk your dog one day a fortnight can't be that hard. But moving hundreds of miles away isn't really something you do on impulse without thinking it through - surely?
Swipe left for the next trending thread