Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s daft to make big life decisions based on WFH without checking it’s permanent?

382 replies

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 17:13

My work used to be office-based. We’ve all been WFH since March 2020 because of government rules (not in England).

This week the government lifted that rule, and later that day our employers told us what the plans were to start bringing us back. This is pretty flexible - not starting for a month or two yet, will still allow a lot of WFH for people who want it (like 9 days a fortnight with one in the office). Most people are ok with this. Some people really aren’t.

Now we are having drama over email with a small but vocal group saying how angry/upset they are, because they have made big changes based around getting to WFH and it will now be difficult for them to go back at all. Even 1 day a fortnight starting in April. Changes like moving house far away from office; getting a dog and not wanting to leave the dog alone; selling car and not wanting to get public transport b/c germs (not just covid, all germs).

Work have ALWAYS said WFH was temporary though! I have some sympathy for how long it’s going to take you to commute from your new house in the middle of nowhere, but SURELY you’d factor that in when you bought it?

YABU - no, after 2 years of WFH working fairly well it was reasonable to expect it to continue without checking.

YANBU - yes, they should obviously have checked.

OP posts:
gwenneh · 27/01/2022 19:52

It's been a permanent change in my company -- all but a few key personnel are free to choose what suits them best. I have two direct reports working entirely remotely and one working from the office. I work a hybrid schedule.

I also know of companies who have let their real estate go and have definitely made the switch permanent. DH works for one; he'd prefer a hybrid schedule but the offices closed last year and they decentralised the organisation. Their new hires are from all over the country, so no one is being recruited with the expectation of needing to go in.

Toottooot · 27/01/2022 19:52

The company I work for on any new vacancies explicitly state the location of the post and if the post qualifies for home working the successful candidate must be available to work on site at least 2 days a week. There is also something in our policy that staff working from home must do so from within the UK. How this can be policed I don’t know as I’m aware of people working from holiday homes etc.

CaptainMerica · 27/01/2022 19:49

I do think employers should try to be understanding, and realise that the world has changed for a lot of people.

E.g. a lot of public transport links have cut their timetables, and a commute that was perfectly doable when buses were every hour might be much less so now they are every 2 hours, or stop at 5pm.

My after school club has shut down, and a lot of childminders in the area have found other jobs because the demand hasn't been there. Similar with dog walkers. These things will not suddenly reappear when people need them.

A lot of examples given are of people taking the piss. But there are other cases where a bit of flexibility while things ramp up again would be fair, I think.

Crikeyalmighty · 27/01/2022 19:49

WFH is one thing but making huge moves and ditching childcare arrangements presuming it’s going to be the norm is another. All good and fine if you are confident of getting another fully WFH role at similar levels of pay should a hybrid model not suit or be prepared to do the train/hotel arrangement along with the appropriate expense involved. I think many did it because it meant they could actually buy in a cheaper area which is fine but they have to be prepared to work round this if employer wants it or find something else. Employers arent being unreasonable, unless they stated the job would now be 100% WFH and contracted accordingly

tectonicplates · 27/01/2022 19:48

I'd just like to remind everyone that the ability to work from home is a very privileged position. Millions of people still do jobs that can't be done from home.

PrincessPaws · 27/01/2022 19:47

I think people were caught up in the 'this will change the society works forever' narrative, and seemed to take this as gospel without any consideration of what their own workplaces were saying.

It's very naive and frankly people were utterly stupid to make big moves without having a new contract/contract amendment in their hands.

We've had similar arguments, and the answer is 'not our problem, you are contracted to work in the office and we told you it wouldn't be forever so we expect back you in the office on x date'

lljkk · 27/01/2022 19:47

Friend is doing this... just assuming WFH will be permanent. I keep my lips sealed.

I had a F2F meeting this week -- was great! sometimes so much more productive

MarshaBradyo · 27/01/2022 19:41

On the why would you move house I remember a few threads where people were adamant it was a permanent change

There were some of us saying maybe not

Rainbowqueeen · 27/01/2022 19:41

It’s certainly something that I would take into account when considering someone for promotion - anyone with such poor judgement to make a life altering decision without checking the terms of their contract would be off the list

SirChenjins · 27/01/2022 19:40

‘Custom and practice’ is used by employers to get employees to do things when it suits them…it’s quite nice to see those employees digging their heels in and saying ‘no, I’ve worked very effectively at home for two years, my productivity has increased, and unless you can show me good reason why I have to be in x physical location as opposed to y physical location to do my job to the same level then I’ll continue to wfh’.

That being said, one day a week in the office (or even 2 or 3 days) is not unreasonable imo.

Savoury · 27/01/2022 19:38

I know a few people moving back to the cities they left because a) the countryside wasn’t what they expected or b) the commutes on packed trains aren’t ideal.

While WFH works great for the employee, you do miss the human touch and we’ve been at our most innovative when in groups in the office. That’s clearly not needed for every job but what about training others/supporting colleagues/sharing cultural experiences? It’s going to be a poor world if people don’t want to meet.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:35

Pret are certainly buying into it, they are planning to open 100 plus outlets in regional/suburban markets.

OfstedOffred · 27/01/2022 19:34

I think employers should be flexible where they without it impacting business need (presenteeism has always been ridiculous). But I think anyone who upped and moved house 3 hours from work etc was mad!

housemaus · 27/01/2022 19:34

I'm a huge supporter of WFH where people want it, am fighting hard with my business partners to allow people to work almost entirely remotely if they want post-restrictions (or any combination of in office/WFH that suits them), and it's absolutely changed our business for the better.

BUT.

Currently we're back to 1/2 days a week in the office.

If someone had just decided to move 100 miles away and complained it wasn't fair, I'd have been pissed off.

It's not about the WFH specifically, it's the assuming - I'd feel the same if they assumed they could bring their dog to the office, or assumed they could work 4pm - midnight instead of 9-5, or anything else.

If they'd said, "look, my circumstances have changed and I want to move but I want to keep my job, can we make it work even if we go back to hybrid working?", I'd have fought tooth and nail to make that work for them.

But assuming it'd be fine is ridiculous and people kicking off they now have to go back (unless their work deliberately implied it'd be permanent) have played shit games and won shit prizes.

Bunnycat101 · 27/01/2022 19:32

The difficulty is that it has become the new normal in lots of places. My husband’s office were back in as soon as possible and it feels like they ripped off the plaster a long time ago. If you’ve been somewhere where you’ve exclusively worked from home for nearly 2 years that does change how you perceive things.

MissAmbrosia · 27/01/2022 19:32

I WFH 40% before covid, currently on 100% but my employer does regular updates. It seems like the new plan will be a permanent 50% from home, but we haven't been given the full details on how this will work.

givethatbabyaname · 27/01/2022 19:31

I think they're posturing as steadfastly as they can in the hope that their employer might cave. It's a negotiating tactic.

Remains to be seen how successful it will be. There are so many vested interests in getting people back into offices.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:31

Not an easy transition for anyone but it’s good, ultimately, that the so-called norm has been disrupted and employers are that little bit less powerful.

absolutely

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:29

they should be lucky they still have a job.

I hate this attitude, it's so regressive. Where does it come from? Companies also saved millions having staff wfh.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:27

I very much doubt if many London-based businesses are going to employ people living in Northern Scotland.

See I think a huge benefit of remote working is the reverse brain drain, rather than everyone flocking to cities. More FTBs left London than ever before to buy last yr but a large part of this will be affordability.

Remember we have a skills shortage in certain areas & a coming shift in population demographics so certain employees are going to have to offer more flexibility (if that's what workers want) to attract workers.

Theblacksheepandme · 27/01/2022 19:19

Cofifeefee
I'm also hearing a lot of chat from people that say they have proven they can do the job from home. Yes, you may have but if company policy is everyone will attend the office 3 days a week, why do you think that you will be exempt from that policy?

I think the policy needs to be reviewed then. I am one of those people that say that I have proven my output and performance has not changed. Don't get me wrong as I have previously said that I have no problem attending the office a day a week but see no reason why it should be more.

Foolsrule · 27/01/2022 19:18

Agree with @PleasantBirthday - 2 years could be the total length of time you’ve done your job and so you’re not ‘going back’ to the office if you’ve never worked there…

I’ve worked in my current job for 3 years. Almost 2 of those have been from home. I’ve been to the office for fewer than 10 days in the last 2 years! My workplace has predominantly been my home, not the office, and so to talk about ‘going back’ as though it’s the norm - well, it isn’t the norm for me!

I wouldn’t have made major life changes without a change in contract to permanent WFH but employers can’t have it both ways either. They were more than happy to make people give up their living space/bedroom/kids’ bedrooms in order to keep their jobs, making homes offices and all the hassle that comes with it. Not they’re clicking their fingers and wanting people to shift back when the workers have gone native. Not an easy transition for anyone but it’s good, ultimately, that the so-called norm has been disrupted and employers are that little bit less powerful.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:17

think not honk! 😆

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:17

so sure of themselves and speaking a bit too arrogantly about how working from home is the future and how those of us staying in London are so behind the times etc.

But remote working was a thing pre covid & it certainly has increased & will stay hybrid for most companies so I don't honk the future is less remote working.

tectonicplates · 27/01/2022 19:10

Too bloody right, OP. And you know what's really pissed me off about the whole thing is the number of people on here who've been so sure of themselves and speaking a bit too arrogantly about how working from home is the future and how those of us staying in London are so behind the times etc. A lot of these people are going to get a rude awakening.

I've heard about a few small and medium companies who've given up their office altogether and everyone has become permanently work from home - however, they are still meeting up in person once a week or fortnight, at a hired meeting room or wherever, so the employees still need to be able to get there.

And even if some people really have been promised permanent WFH, they're going to have problems next time they look for a new job. Considering that in the past I've been turned down for jobs on the basis that I lived in zone 4 which was "too far away", I very much doubt if many London-based businesses are going to employ people living in Northern Scotland.

Swipe left for the next trending thread