Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s daft to make big life decisions based on WFH without checking it’s permanent?

382 replies

GoldenOmber · 27/01/2022 17:13

My work used to be office-based. We’ve all been WFH since March 2020 because of government rules (not in England).

This week the government lifted that rule, and later that day our employers told us what the plans were to start bringing us back. This is pretty flexible - not starting for a month or two yet, will still allow a lot of WFH for people who want it (like 9 days a fortnight with one in the office). Most people are ok with this. Some people really aren’t.

Now we are having drama over email with a small but vocal group saying how angry/upset they are, because they have made big changes based around getting to WFH and it will now be difficult for them to go back at all. Even 1 day a fortnight starting in April. Changes like moving house far away from office; getting a dog and not wanting to leave the dog alone; selling car and not wanting to get public transport b/c germs (not just covid, all germs).

Work have ALWAYS said WFH was temporary though! I have some sympathy for how long it’s going to take you to commute from your new house in the middle of nowhere, but SURELY you’d factor that in when you bought it?

YABU - no, after 2 years of WFH working fairly well it was reasonable to expect it to continue without checking.

YANBU - yes, they should obviously have checked.

OP posts:
Leftbutcameback · 27/01/2022 20:25

We've had the same. People have moved away, said they'd make arrangements if they needed to come in occasionally, and now they actually might have to do that they are finding it too hard. I think most of them will be looking for new roles (esp as I work for a national organization which pays the same anywhere in the country)

PrincessPaws · 27/01/2022 20:23

@dorkfink

they should be lucky they still have a job.

I hate this attitude, it's so regressive. Where does it come from? Companies also saved millions having staff wfh.

Not necessarily. If you are in the middle of a 10 year office lease you are still paying for the office so the government decision to make people wfh where they can has not necessarily saved businesses money.
chaosrabbitland · 27/01/2022 20:23

i so agree , the bottom line is they have got all nice and cosy wfh and now any hint of a change and they are up in arms , there was a thread on this last week , only 3 days a week going in and she wants to resign as its going to have such a big impact on her family life , i mean seriously what on earth did these people do then before covid and they had to go in 5 days a week ?

theres seems to be lots of talk about how they can just leave their jobs and get full time wfh and its all theirs for the picking , but from what im seeing thats not so now , offices are wanting their employees back in at least for a little bit of the week and i think its not unreasonable of them to

Lolamento · 27/01/2022 20:23

Honestly they are being ridiculous! Nobody ever said this was a permanent situation. I feel not sympathy as they are very unreasonable. However, I understand people not wanting to work in offices but there is a choice of getting a job that do not required working in offices.

Whitefire · 27/01/2022 20:21

@MarshaBradyo

On the why would you move house I remember a few threads where people were adamant it was a permanent change

There were some of us saying maybe not

Oh yes I remember them, any suggestions that this may not be a permanent arrangement was loudly (and often aggressively) rebutted.
FreedomFaith · 27/01/2022 20:21

@ABitBesottedWithMyDog

YABU (and it doesn't affect me, I'm freelance and work from home when I want).

If the work can be done from home, why for the love of God insist that people spend hours commuting just to share office space with germ-riddled anti-vaxx rednecks/ perpetual eaters whose crisps packet antics cause interference on your headset/ pinstripe-suited loudmouthed knobheads boring on about themselves and their awful lives?

I work better alone with my potplants, and I know I'm not alone!

You're right, I much prefer working from home too. Some people prefer it and adapt well to it, and companies should give us the right to continue, just the same as allowing those who want to return to do so.

BUT you work for the company and it is their policies you have to follow. If you didn't get a contract upgrade, then that's your problem as far as I'm concerned. Can't blame anyone for it. I am hoping my company will allow us to wfh permanently or come in if we want to, which I don't. But as there are no contract changes, I'm not moving yet. And if if doesn't swing the way I want, I may just leave. Wfh benefits me more, and I can find other companies to work for. I'll make that clear of course beforehand, but I'll leave if it won't be met. I'm dispensable to them, the company is equally dispensable to me.

Mellowyellow222 · 27/01/2022 20:19

I really don’t understand objective to a hybrid working arrangement.

And in your case 2 days a month is perfectly reasonable.

Surely the majority of people who worked form home before Covid still had to go to the occasional meeting or conference or training course?

People seem to think remote working is 100% ata gone and never being asked to leave the house and see another person ever again.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 27/01/2022 20:18

With costs increasing so much I’m surprised it’s seen as economically viable for a business to keep a full sized office just for staff to go in once a fortnight. Seems like an ideal opportunity to make savings either by letting out part of the building or selling downsizing to smaller premises

MissConductUS · 27/01/2022 20:17

A friend of mine is HR for a major US organisation and this has been an issue for them -- especially as there are places in the US where her organisation is not authorised to conduct business, and there are employees that moved there without telling anyone.

I'm an American and this has happened to us for some employees. It's not that you need the authorization to do business in that state, it's that you need to register as an employer so that state income taxes can be withheld and paid to the state tax authority. Payroll processing companies do this routinely, but there is a cost and some time involved. Most states make it fairly straightforward because they love getting new tax revenue.

cushioncovers · 27/01/2022 20:14

Lots of people have worked from home the entire time and done it really well, so it is a bit odd that suddenly you have to go back into the office.

IMO Employers want their employees where they can see them and know what they're up to. It's a control thing.

drpet49 · 27/01/2022 20:13

@ ABitBesottedWithMyDog

Because some people don’t want to spend all their time at home. I would hate to work from home permanently.

LouisRenault · 27/01/2022 20:11

why for the love of God insist that people spend hours commuting just to share office space with germ-riddled anti-vaxx rednecks/ perpetual eaters whose crisps packet antics cause interference on your headset/ pinstripe-suited loudmouthed knobheads boring on about themselves and their awful lives

Well, aren't you delightful.

What about travelling to share office space with people who don't have the space to work at home long term, or who live alone and who really suffered with the isolation during lockdown and who really need to get out of the house and back to face to face working for the sake of their mental health. No-one seems to give a shit about them.

cushioncovers · 27/01/2022 20:11

I have no sympathy for people who moved house, bought a dog or made any other big life decisions based on a temporary pandemic situation. Ridiculous thing to do.

PleasantBirthday · 27/01/2022 20:09

I have colleagues who still don't have wrap around care offered by the school due to covid.

Yeah, I mean, we kept our breakfast club/afterschool on the whole time but at the moment, they can't offer breakfast club due to staff shortages so I have to do the school run. Luckily, I don't need to be back in the office yet, but people are having these kinds of issues where services just aren't as available because there is still a high rate of infection. I think it's possible to be too rigid and dismissive about people's circumstances.

DaisyMum40 · 27/01/2022 20:08

I can't believe anyone would be that stupid to go to the effort and expense of moving house (and thereby taking them away from a reasonable commute) based on a temporary working arrangement that wasn't contractually agreed?! I mean.... really?!

NeedAHoliday2021 · 27/01/2022 20:07

@dorkfink we ditched childcare - cm resigned and after school club was full but dh working from home and dc being aged 8 and 11 in 2020 meant it was okay ish. Now dc are 13 and 10 (almost 14 and 11) so no childcare needed. Even if dh returned to the office full time, dc could let themselves in and not need childcare. I guess the timings worked for us.

SilentNoMore · 27/01/2022 20:06

Where I work working from home works well, because we all knew our job role inside out. The management say we are more productive from home, but they want us back.
They have been very open that the reason is we won't work for them forever so they need us to train our replacements, pass on our skills. I learnt from my predecessor. It makes sense. So op yanbu

NeedAHoliday2021 · 27/01/2022 20:03

Dh has colleagues who moved 4-5 hours away based on wfh. His organisation always said it wasn’t permanent although they hoped to keep some level of flexibility/hybrid wfh and office based. We have a dog (bought puppy in 2020) but dh office means he can get home at lunch and dc get in from school at 3pm plus I do some wfh. Puppy now 18 months old and fine when left for a few hours. We’ve deliberately got him used to this as dh could end up in the office more. We’re baffled by the people who made massive life changes without any thought about the pandemic being over at some point. You can’t plan or foresee everything but this is bonkers.

Blankscreen · 27/01/2022 20:00

Lots of people have worked from home the entire time and done it really well, so it is a bit odd that suddenly you have to go back into the office.

We got a dog in lockdown and have always been and are prepared to pay for doggy day care.

I moving miles away is utter madness and isn't easily resolved. It's not a problem you can just chuck money at

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:56

WFH is one thing but making huge moves and ditching childcare arrangements presuming it’s going to be the norm is another.

Did everyone ditch childcare though? I have colleagues who still don't have wrap around care offered by the school due to covid.

Hugasauras · 27/01/2022 19:56

YANBU as it's very silly of them, but I do think a lot of people are waking up to the realisation there's a way to have a better work/life balance and having experienced the 'alternative' are understandably reluctant to go back. Obviously silly to make lifestyle changes based on a temp situation, but I imagine for some people it's been a wake-up call into how else their life could be.

BoodleBug51 · 27/01/2022 19:55

I'm very glad that we were never able to work remotely. We actually stopped using one of our main wholesalers last year as their entire admin team were working from home. Between broken mobile signals on every phone call, losing access to the system and errors being made right left and centre but no one taking responsibility....... we gave up.

There's absolutely no consideration for the end users of these businesses, who at the end of the day is why the business exists. It's all me me me.

ABitBesottedWithMyDog · 27/01/2022 19:54

YABU (and it doesn't affect me, I'm freelance and work from home when I want).

If the work can be done from home, why for the love of God insist that people spend hours commuting just to share office space with germ-riddled anti-vaxx rednecks/ perpetual eaters whose crisps packet antics cause interference on your headset/ pinstripe-suited loudmouthed knobheads boring on about themselves and their awful lives?

I work better alone with my potplants, and I know I'm not alone!

Newmum738 · 27/01/2022 19:53

YANBU. However, they can submit a flexible working request and it would be hard for an employer to refuse unless there has been a performance issue. Also, the law is changing and may have changed already so FW is a given and the employer has to make a case to refuse it which they are unlikely to have after 2 years.

AlDanvers · 27/01/2022 19:52

Yanbu.

I can see people giving up childcare if, say, their kids are 10 and don't need to be supervised in the house, but aren't old enough to get themselves home, let themselves in and be hone alone. But what you were planning on doing if/when you are due back should gave always been a consideration.

People who have moved without having it confirmed are just ridiculous imo.

Swipe left for the next trending thread