Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t think asking mn if something you did / said was racist should be allowed

146 replies

Gardensparrows · 27/01/2022 16:11

They may or may not be genuine but the comments they prompt are awful.

The thread has been taken down but in 2022 I have reported three people for laughing at the word ‘chink’ and it is completely unacceptable.

OP posts:
Bitofachinwag · 28/01/2022 09:43

@Nocaloriesinchocolate

I'm feeling retrospectively very guilty now. I (white) used to work with a black woman - had done for years.. She was always happy to chat about things like eg foundation colours, which of course would need to be different colours for her as for me. One day I said my DS as a baby had had jaundice so was a funny yellow colour and asked her, simply out of interest, what colour a black baby with jaundice would look like (as yellow would come out differently). She answered quite happily. It's relevant to note that I was in a position of considerable authority and she wasn't but I genuinely don't think that affected her reply, (she was quite happy, eg, when I asked her to photocopy something to say she'd do it when she finished her coffee.)

But now I wonder if she did find it racist, and I feel really bad.

I don't know.. But my son has very olive skin ( I don't) and when he was born midwives told me they would need to start treatment for jaundice because "he was a bit yellow" . I wasn't offended because I knew that they didn't know where his dad was from.
Thingstodotoday · 28/01/2022 09:41

“lljkk
You can't talk about racist words without using the racist words in context. And trying to understand the boundaries, why a chink in the armour is ok & a Chink in the street would be bad. Why a dark-skinned person can say the N-word but as a white person I can't even type it out without being criticised.

I'm leaning towards YABVU.”

FFS 🤦🏽‍♀️

EmmaH2022 · 28/01/2022 09:41

@Nocaloriesinchocolate

I'm feeling retrospectively very guilty now. I (white) used to work with a black woman - had done for years.. She was always happy to chat about things like eg foundation colours, which of course would need to be different colours for her as for me. One day I said my DS as a baby had had jaundice so was a funny yellow colour and asked her, simply out of interest, what colour a black baby with jaundice would look like (as yellow would come out differently). She answered quite happily. It's relevant to note that I was in a position of considerable authority and she wasn't but I genuinely don't think that affected her reply, (she was quite happy, eg, when I asked her to photocopy something to say she'd do it when she finished her coffee.)

But now I wonder if she did find it racist, and I feel really bad.

Is this real?!

And yes, when people at work do this kind of racism - the kind they can easily explain if I reported it - I just do a faux smile because I don't want them to know their tactic worked, their racism did upset me and I know I'm powerless to do anything about it.

This is a faux post though, right?

ShinyHappyPoster · 28/01/2022 09:40

I don't think a blanket ban is a good idea. MN has a reporting system. Threads and posts get deleted for racism. I can't think of any topic that has a blanket ban because such bans are open to abuse by louder, bullying posters determined to direct the conversation and pretend there is homogenous agreement rather than their agenda.

I do think MN should make more posters aware that if they breach the Equalities Act or post comments that could be perceived as hate incidents then MN could release their details to any authority that asks for it.

GrumpyDirector · 28/01/2022 09:35

@Gardensparrows She felt the need to call this woman ‘happy’ four or five times, in a fairly short post. It’s important that we know how happy this Black woman (over whom she had ‘considerable authority) was while dealing with nonsense like this “One day I said my DS as a baby had had jaundice so was a funny yellow colour and asked her, simply out of interest, what colour a black baby with jaundice would look like (as yellow would come out differently)”.

Yeah, I bet she was singing with bloody joy. Seriously, what the actual fuck is the matter with some people?

Gardensparrows · 28/01/2022 09:33

and asked her, simply out of interest, what colour a black baby with jaundice would look like

You are correct @Saysama

What the fuck Confused

OP posts:
Gardensparrows · 28/01/2022 09:29

[quote Saysama]@Gardensparrows Are you a Black woman? As I am and I assure you that nothing Nocaloriesinchocolate has related sounds like normal contextual conversation to me.[/quote]
My apologies if I misread, @Saysama

I thought she was saying the woman volunteered info.

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 28/01/2022 09:28

But equally it may be the only place some people feel safe to ask questions - and they may genuinely not understand why what they said was racist or offensive and so need clarity on it - so it's useful to have a forum for that. And then just stringently delete any individual responses that are racist / against MN guidelines, as MN mods do

I don’t think there’s anything equal about it honestly. MNHQ are generally as blind as the users are and picking out genuine ignorance with a willingness to understand from thinly disguised inflammatory statements that sail very close to the edge of offensiveness without overtly breaching any social or forum niceties comes down to the judgement of a person with the same unknowns. MN is on a par with 4chan in some respects but with a different demographic.

Of course there are some very well thought out and informative posts but there is no way to separate between those and ones that are pure bs or touting concepts that are outdated, offensive or just plain wrong. The reader is consciously or subconsciously being educated/influenced by words with an unknown bias.

Forums are no different from gossip or playground rumours and we know enough to know how flimsy and unreliable word of mouth is for an education. At least with old fashioned ways of communicating you had the context of knowing something about the individual talking.

Anonymous forums are entertainment at best and no substitute for communicating with people willing to attach their opinion to their identity. You have no way of telling the agenda of the people your communicating with and therefore your ability to judge the quality and trustworthiness of the information you’re processing is severely impaired.

Saysama · 28/01/2022 09:27

@Gardensparrows Are you a Black woman? As I am and I assure you that nothing Nocaloriesinchocolate has related sounds like normal contextual conversation to me.

Saysama · 28/01/2022 09:25

@Nocaloriesinchocolate Jesus Christ, what is wrong with you?! She almost certainly did. You sound awful and you should feel bad.

This is the kind of garbage we have to put up with every bloody day, and it’s not okay.

Gardensparrows · 28/01/2022 09:08

There are times, @Nocaloriesinchocolate, when the subject of race, or where you originate from (or your family) come up naturally in context.

Imagine a group of people are chatting in the office lunch hour about (say) punishments their school had and someone says ‘I didn’t grow up in England and my school was really strict - corporal punishment was still legal there.’
Someone else says ‘oh wow, really, where’s that?’
‘South Africa.’
‘Oh, that’s a beautiful country, were you born there or did you move?’

That’s called a normal conversation.

However (as, tbh, I think you know) grilling someone about where they are from is not.
‘Where are you from?’
‘Leeds.’
‘Yeah but like - where are you FROM?’

And with your story, that was a normal and contextual conversation. Grilling someone with a black baby on a bus about it wouldn’t be.

I must admit even just typing this is making me roll my eyes.

OP posts:
Nocaloriesinchocolate · 28/01/2022 09:04

I'm feeling retrospectively very guilty now. I (white) used to work with a black woman - had done for years.. She was always happy to chat about things like eg foundation colours, which of course would need to be different colours for her as for me. One day I said my DS as a baby had had jaundice so was a funny yellow colour and asked her, simply out of interest, what colour a black baby with jaundice would look like (as yellow would come out differently). She answered quite happily. It's relevant to note that I was in a position of considerable authority and she wasn't but I genuinely don't think that affected her reply, (she was quite happy, eg, when I asked her to photocopy something to say she'd do it when she finished her coffee.)

But now I wonder if she did find it racist, and I feel really bad.

Allycott · 28/01/2022 08:42

What did you say exactly?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 28/01/2022 07:18

@wombat1a

I think the sooner we drop BAME as the catch all for everyone non-white the better. Some of the people I work with already refer to it as BLAME as in people who blame others for everything. It's a bit of an unfortunate choice of letters- oh and the majority of these using BLAME instead of BAME jokingly are in fact asian.

Why a dark-skinned person can say the N-word but as a white person I can't even type it out without being criticised.

And this to me is the crux of the issue, if we are supposed to be sensitive to certain words then anyone and everyone using the N word should be called out on it, when words are reserved for some groups to use and if used by other groups they are castigated then what we have is division. We will never overcome racism if we support division at all, if a word if 'banned' for one it must be banned for all in order to break down barriers between us. But of course the fact they we treat everyone as equal is probably seen by some as a racist view by some.

I think the sooner we drop BAME as the catch all for everyone non-white the better. Some of the people I work with already refer to it as BLAME as in people who blame others for everything. It's a bit of an unfortunate choice of letters- oh and the majority of these using BLAME instead of BAME jokingly are in fact asian.

Cool story bro

And this to me is the crux of the issue, if we are supposed to be sensitive to certain words then anyone and everyone using the N word should be called out on it, when words are reserved for some groups to use and if used by other groups they are castigated then what we have is division. We will never overcome racism if we support division at all, if a word if 'banned' for one it must be banned for all in order to break down barriers between us. But of course the fact they we treat everyone as equal is probably seen by some as a racist view by some.

So a word used to subjugate, humiliate and terrorise generations of people for nothing more than having a different skin colour to their own and that those people who have claimed this word as their own and reminds them of their shared ancestral struggle should not be allowed to use that word because some white people cant use it and be extra special blunt racists?

wah wah wah aww there there little racists

wombat1a

username checks out though Hmm

CorsicaDreaming · 28/01/2022 05:07

@Cornettoninja

I read your title and my first reaction was YABU but actually I agree with you. I don’t think an anonymous text forum is the place for the types of discussion you describe. It’s not that I don’t think these conversations shouldn’t happen at all but this is an inappropriate place for them.

There is a freedom and potential for abuse on a forum that’s anonymous and places little accountability on the users.

But equally it may be the only place some people feel safe to ask questions - and they may genuinely not understand why what they said was racist or offensive and so need clarity on it - so it's useful to have a forum for that. And then just stringently delete any individual responses that are racist / against MN guidelines, as MN mods do.

wombat1a · 28/01/2022 05:00

I think the sooner we drop BAME as the catch all for everyone non-white the better. Some of the people I work with already refer to it as BLAME as in people who blame others for everything. It's a bit of an unfortunate choice of letters- oh and the majority of these using BLAME instead of BAME jokingly are in fact asian.

Why a dark-skinned person can say the N-word but as a white person I can't even type it out without being criticised.

And this to me is the crux of the issue, if we are supposed to be sensitive to certain words then anyone and everyone using the N word should be called out on it, when words are reserved for some groups to use and if used by other groups they are castigated then what we have is division. We will never overcome racism if we support division at all, if a word if 'banned' for one it must be banned for all in order to break down barriers between us. But of course the fact they we treat everyone as equal is probably seen by some as a racist view by some.

baroqueandblue · 28/01/2022 00:12

My use of the word in the thread that this thread is partly about was in its context of the cleft that a narrow beam of light can shine through, for the record. I used it with the word 'hope' instead of light. I've spent a lot of the day since then feeling like a twat. Some people think that's extreme. But if I don't take my mistakes seriously, I don't learn from them.

What some other posters on the deleted thread then did with the same word was highlight it to get laughs and/or a rise out of people.

Tsuni · 27/01/2022 23:40

So this is a TAAT and you've "repeated" a racial slur? Some would say that MN shouldn't allow this.

Mother87 · 27/01/2022 23:37

And no apologies if I've offended any racist fookwits out there😬

Mother87 · 27/01/2022 23:36

Cannot believe there are utter morons out there that excuse/defend and even try to explain why the use of "ch*nk/y" has EVER been in any way acceptible - because "they've always said it" or are of a certain age?!

Yes I'm of Singaporean Chinese heritage - and have been around many adults who've told me that I shouldn't be offended as it's just a "turn of phrase" or a "type of takeaway" Fookwits

EeeICouldRipATissue · 27/01/2022 23:32

That's just it, isn't it? It wasn't clear to me to be fair whether the Dad had stopped using language like that after being pulled up on it.
If he was told after using it that it was and carried on doing it anyway, that definitely is not giving a shit and racist.
I have the same problem with my Dad if so - love him lots as Dad but fuck me I do not agree with him on the shit he comes out with re immigration or the derogatory terms he has used to describe people who are black.

Pumperthepumper · 27/01/2022 23:25

[quote watchtheglitterdustswirl]@sadpapercourtesan Oh I don't know about that.

My Dad, who is actually not of English heritage himself and would be horrified to be thought of as racist frequently uses the term 'let's go for a ch*nky' when he means let's go for a Chinese takeaway. It's just what he's always called it. I have him an absolute bollocking for saying it in front of my children a few weeks ago. Luckily they didn't hear or if they did they didn't notice.

He's 60. So not old, by any means. [/quote]
He is racist though. He uses language he knows is racist. He knows because you told him, and he still does it. He’s a racist.

EeeICouldRipATissue · 27/01/2022 23:25

My (not-white) DH said, when I read him this thread, that he's happy to answer people's questions if they're genuinely trying to avoid offending someone/trying to learn what is the acceptable word for something or what is non-offensive behaviour
That's just it, isn't it, sometimes it is innocent.
The fact that so many times it isn't though and it's faux innocence most of the time is what gets people questioning or being hostile as they've seen it all before.

thepeopleversuswork · 27/01/2022 23:14

@Sirzy

Part of educating yourself though is surely talking to people from those communities (if they are happy to do so). You can read multiple books and official resources but sometimes actually hearing from people at the forefront is as valuable if not more.

As someone who lives in an area with very little diversity I do find that reading things like threads on here can be an eye opener to things I would never normally consider - obviously I don’t include the word used in the example on this thread there - which is all part of developing.

I wasn't on this thread but I would agree with this. I've read a little bit around the "official" position on racism and racist language but I have probably learned more about why language can be aggressive or hurtful or excluding on MN than from some official forums.

As a white person, all of the really important stuff I have learned about racism has come from having conversations with non white people. It enables you to see through a lens you hadn't seen through before.

I accept that its not the "job" of non-white people to educate white people on how racism impacts them. But I also think learning directly from non white people has an immediacy and an impact that you won't get from books.

One side effect of this is that you will get a lot of ignorant - in the true sense of the word -- people piling on looking for validation of what are essentially racist positions. It's always going to be a trade off and I can totally understand non white people seeking not to engage. But, at least from a white person's perspective, I think ultimately discussions like this help increase understanding.

Flutterflybutterby · 27/01/2022 23:12

It isn't a crime to simply ask questions. Being asked a question by someone isn't "forcing them to educate you". People ask many questions about many topics. Of course we shouldn't introduce a blanket ban on questions like this. Otherwise how will people learn? My (not-white) DH said, when I read him this thread, that he's happy to answer people's questions if they're genuinely trying to avoid offending someone/trying to learn what is the acceptable word for something or what is non-offensive behaviour. So you shouldn't speak on behalf of everyone either.