Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this insulting to women

62 replies

groogrump · 27/01/2022 15:29

Name changed as I am a regular poster but wish to remain anonymous.
I have just qualified in the legal profession. I was scrolling Instagram and saw this post from an organisation that promotes diversity in law. Am I unreasonable to find this considerably insulting?! Whilst I'm sure there are some women who suffer with imposter syndrome the vast majority suffer with obstacles not made by them! To say otherwise is insulting, naive and victim blaming. The message has also been seemingly sponsored by a magic circle solicitors firm. I'm so annoyed as someone who tries to promote diversity in law myself to see something so ignorant.

To find this insulting to women
OP posts:
JuergenSchwarzwald · 27/01/2022 17:09

@Sparky888

I agree with you. I think most of the barriers are not out there by women!
I also agree. I think a lot of women do need more confidence in their abilities but the workplace is still largely run by men for men, especially in the legal profession. Men are allowed more cock-ups than women are, and women have to be better than men.

It is well worth reading this book: gillwhittycollins.com/why-men-win-at-work

Leftbutcameback · 27/01/2022 17:08

It’s from A&O, about what I’d expect from a magic circle firm.

Leafstamp · 27/01/2022 17:08

It's not ideal, I agree.

However, there are a great many things wrong with the legal profession when it comes to women, and this is not the biggest of them IMO.

I blame Stonewall Membership for a lot of the problems affecting women in law.

MimiDaisy11 · 27/01/2022 17:05

I think some women’s lack of confidence (which results in an imposter syndrome) comes from misogynistic experiences. It’s not just there by fluke. That time you’re mistaken for a secretary or someone assumes you’re in a more junior position than you are, even if these are done unintentionally, can plant seeds in your brain that you don’t belong.

hoorayandupsherises · 27/01/2022 17:00

@OrangeCinnamonCroissant

There was a very good article about this recently in Harvard Business Review 'Stop Telling Women They Have Imposter Syndrome' (Tulyshan and Burey) , Brene Brown interviewed theauthors on her podcast recently...

Would this slide have been produced if it wasn't an event aimed solely at women?

I've been trying to find the article to post on here, thank you!
SeasonFinale · 27/01/2022 16:57

@MerryPoppings

To me, the underlying message reads "stop complaining women, the barriers you complain about are your own fault for not being as assertive and confident as men." So next time you hear a woman complain about misogyny and patriarchy just remember she probably brought it on herself.
Whereas I take from it the opposite. I take don't let imposter syndrome prevent you from asking for that project, raise or promotion like many others before you have. Believe in you and go for it. It is actually opening the door for women to put themselves forward in situations where they may not have otherwise!!
BowerOfBramble · 27/01/2022 16:50

It's not a made up thing by women. Imposter syndrome is a RESPONSE to anti-female and anti-femininity socialisation & conditioning we experience from birth.

This is beautifully put. Thank you.

OrangeCinnamonCroissant · 27/01/2022 16:44

There was a very good article about this recently in Harvard Business Review 'Stop Telling Women They Have Imposter Syndrome' (Tulyshan and Burey) , Brene Brown interviewed theauthors on her podcast recently...

Would this slide have been produced if it wasn't an event aimed solely at women?

LaChanticleer · 27/01/2022 16:40

Whilst I'm sure there are some women who suffer with imposter syndrome the vast majority suffer with obstacles not made by them

Totally agree @groogrump

The obstacles may be in some women's heads/thinking - but they are not created by the individuals concerned. The obstacles which make for 'imposter syndrome' are created by a society which tells girls and young women - from birth onwards - that they are (my off the top of my head list - there is more!):
less robust,
of less worth,
less strong,
more out of control in their emotions,
their voices are too soft
their voices are too high
their flesh is distracting to others
they are too thin
they are too fat
they are not important in & for themselves, only important in their relationships

I'm sure we could all add to this list.

It's not a made up thing by women. Imposter syndrome is a RESPONSE to anti-female and anti-femininity socialisation & conditioning we experience from birth.

Most of us manage to recognise our value, but we are rarely helped by the society around us.

BowerOfBramble · 27/01/2022 16:38

It's incredibly crass, it implies that many female lawyers face imposter syndrome and therefore they can imagine it out of the way in order to soar higher in the profession.

No question of WHY a lot more women, people from immigrant or not white families and people from poorer backgrounds feel this way. It's not magically put upon is, it's a consequence of, oohhhhh I dunno literally centuries of systematic oppression and exclusion from careers.

Perhaps they think it's just coincidence that the young, privileged male lawyer who can look at a gallery of former judges and see thousands just like him often has more confidence than a young black man or an Asian woman who - if they did rise high in the profession - might be the first person like them ever to do so in this country.

Ohyesiam · 27/01/2022 16:36

But it’s saying that is what imposter syndrome is. It’s not saying there is no glass ceiling. Women have internal and external barriers to success and IS is one of them.

Men have imposter syndrome too.

FFSFFSFFS · 27/01/2022 16:34

Of course its insulting.

Two key things - WHY do some women have imposter syndrome? Because of the culture including the culture in law which is sexist.

Secondly - my view is that rather than women changing to be over confident dickheads maybe men should try being a little bit less overconfident.

ie often imposter syndrome actually means behaving in a reasonable and rationale way

Blossomtoes · 27/01/2022 16:24

@Useranon1

But imposter syndrome is about our own conviction and confidence in a role - when you’re hired into it, and everyone else thinks you’re up for it, but you are the one questioning it - so I can see how that quote is relevant

Except the barriers of imposter syndrome are a product of the patriarchy, not something millions of women have simultaneously created for themselves

They’re not. Unless you think men can’t suffer from imposter syndrome - which they most certainly can.
lljkk · 27/01/2022 16:23

As one of those who never had IS, I resent it being implied I must suffer from IS merely because I'm female ! Dreary annoying assumption.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 27/01/2022 16:23

I think it's right that imposter syndrome affects a lot of women, women in business are often less confident than men eg less likely to ask for a pay rise.

But its ignoring why this is the case, and ignoring what law firms or other businesses can do to recognise and overcome this. It's not just up to women to fix this.

Telling unconfident people who are like that because of the way society have always treated them, to 'just be more confident' is completely pointless

MerryPoppings · 27/01/2022 16:10

To me, the underlying message reads "stop complaining women, the barriers you complain about are your own fault for not being as assertive and confident as men." So next time you hear a woman complain about misogyny and patriarchy just remember she probably brought it on herself.

Rosesareyellow · 27/01/2022 16:08

It’s not been written well. Imposter syndrome is common in women but it’s not exactly something you can just snap out of and the reason behind women suffering with it probably has sexist roots in itself. I think external and internal barriers are closely linked. Many men grow up believing they can do anything no matter how incompetent they are… while women grow up learning to question themselves. Men are much more likely to go for jobs that they are not qualified for than women. And in some women that feeling develops into imposter syndrome. But it all starts with how girls are taught to view themselves. So in terms of external or internal barriers it makes no difference in my opinion.

lljkk · 27/01/2022 16:05

Except the barriers of imposter syndrome are a product of the patriarchy, not something millions of women have simultaneously created for themselvesf

How does that work when white males mention they have had imposter syndrome (Matt Damon told a story about it when he got an Oscar nomination). ... I dunno, imposter syndrome is a very specific thing, I thought, it's literally all about the mental barriers we ourselves project.

In spite of being female & a lifetime living in "the patriarchy", I never have had IS so probably should stop commenting there.

KimDeals · 27/01/2022 16:03

@Useranon1

But imposter syndrome is about our own conviction and confidence in a role - when you’re hired into it, and everyone else thinks you’re up for it, but you are the one questioning it - so I can see how that quote is relevant

Except the barriers of imposter syndrome are a product of the patriarchy, not something millions of women have simultaneously created for themselves

Fair point. You’re right. It is more important to look at why you’ve come to feel like that, then to stop the enquiry at “you’re lacking confidence”.
MsTSwift · 27/01/2022 16:01

Agree with you op. No examination as to why is is that numerous reasonable smart women might feel this way 🙄.

Pluvia · 27/01/2022 16:00

You're being unreasonable. Good for you that you haven't struggled with impostor syndrome but lots of women do — and it's often the most intelligent women who seem to be getting on the best who suffer worst.

The quote doesn't say that all women suffer and it's made by an organisation that has a lot more experience of women in law than you do. Come back in a few years' time and see if you feel the same then.

Useranon1 · 27/01/2022 15:59

But imposter syndrome is about our own conviction and confidence in a role - when you’re hired into it, and everyone else thinks you’re up for it, but you are the one questioning it - so I can see how that quote is relevant

Except the barriers of imposter syndrome are a product of the patriarchy, not something millions of women have simultaneously created for themselves

lljkk · 27/01/2022 15:58

I guess it depends which strategy you think will help the most disadvantaged / minority groups.

Recognising that there truly are external barriers: good.

Recognising that as individuals we can be too resigned to accepting the barriers & not challenging what we think might be barriers and thus remove the obstacles: bad.

Allsorts1 · 27/01/2022 15:57

Yes I agree - very poorly worded. It’s possible that whoever was doing the social media has just royally effed up by taking the wrong line from the quote that really doesn’t work without the full context.

A better way to word this in relation to the topic of imposter syndrome would be that “women face barriers and SOME of them are internal, if they are dealing with imposter syndrome”.

The “often” in this sentence makes it seem like barriers are imagined most of the time - which is definitely not what I think Allen & Ovary would like to say.

Aimee1987 · 27/01/2022 15:55

I think it was meant as a positive ( believe in yourself) without actually fully understanding the issues which lead to imposter syndrome.

Swipe left for the next trending thread