Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this insulting to women

62 replies

groogrump · 27/01/2022 15:29

Name changed as I am a regular poster but wish to remain anonymous.
I have just qualified in the legal profession. I was scrolling Instagram and saw this post from an organisation that promotes diversity in law. Am I unreasonable to find this considerably insulting?! Whilst I'm sure there are some women who suffer with imposter syndrome the vast majority suffer with obstacles not made by them! To say otherwise is insulting, naive and victim blaming. The message has also been seemingly sponsored by a magic circle solicitors firm. I'm so annoyed as someone who tries to promote diversity in law myself to see something so ignorant.

To find this insulting to women
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
C152 · 28/01/2022 11:05

One does not negate the other. Women frequently face barriers put in their way by others, but can simultaneously suffer from imposter syndrome.

lljkk · 28/01/2022 10:41

The fact that there's such diversity of opinion about what IS is, who suffers from it, or why it happens -- tells me that it's not a very useful concept. Bordering on being useless if no one can agree what it is.

Can we go go back to saying "I feel inadequate" or "unworthy" ?

Porfre · 28/01/2022 10:40

I find that pretty insulting, sounds a bit like victim blaming.

Its your own fault. You're doing to it to yourself.

It's annoying its singling out women, although it says not all women, but most would miss that bit and assume all women feel the same.

Wreath21 · 28/01/2022 10:37

It's like 'wellness' grift - all your problems are of your own creation, shop your way out of your misery, sip a green tea and do a yoga... and somehow structural inequality will magically vanish.

mucky123 · 28/01/2022 10:34

It may not impact all but as a female solicitor I suffer from this. It was identified by my male boss about 17 years ago. He said you speak so much more sense than that over-confident Michael why do you let him do all the talking af meetings. He was right and I'm glad he told me although ots taken until middle age to really get to grips with.

HikingforScenery · 27/01/2022 20:34

I agree with you OP. An article was shared at work earlier this week which spoke about how imposter syndrome is used an excuse by done employers as an excuse for just not doing enough for women’s development. I think it was as part of a new book written by a female duo and was in the Financial Times.

Allsorts1 · 27/01/2022 19:53

Everyone saying they’re just highlighting something that happens to some women….. did you read the language they used? “MANY women” “barriers are OFTEN internal”.

I also think imposter syndrome couched as a women’s issue is patronising - imposter syndrome is meant to be something everyone experiences, people imagining they’re not good enough when they are - it’s not an experience particular to women.

By making it a women’s thing it gives the impression that they are brushing off women’s experience of structural inequality in the workplace and the impact of that as “imposter syndrome”.

If they’re talking about lack of confidence in women, that’s not “imposter syndrome” - that’s an issue that has roots in sexism! Which aren’t in a woman’s head (like imposter syndrome is) but are actually real things that need addressing!

It should have read “many people experience imposter syndrome, sometimes barriers are internal as well as external” - keep the women part out of it.

If they were talking about women’s lack of confidence it should have said “SOME women have a lack of confidence and feel like they don’t deserve a place at the table. This is because of external forces and messaging that they’ve experienced from birth. This is something that needs to be overcome through improved systems and culture as well as women themselves pushing past these feelings to break the glass ceiling, insist on a workplace that recognises their experience and value, and support other women to do so too.” - I admit this is less catchy for a social post though Grin

Kudupoo · 27/01/2022 19:25

@TheOrigRights

It's part of it. Feeling like you have no right to be where you are, like someone made a huge mistake somewhere and everyone else is more competent than you. It means you can get a sort of confirmation bias from interactions.

If you didn't have imposter syndrome you might see things differently, if you do it can colour your view and fees into it.

My point was it's not like everyone around you is wonderful and you stubbornly refuse to believe in yourself. It's much more embedded and can be worsened by the environment you're in/obstacles you face.

lljkk · 27/01/2022 19:15

^The quote says "many aspiring female....".
It does not say "all", so you don't need to feel resentful about it.^

At least PP didn't say I can't identify because I lack aspirations...

CayrolBaaaskin · 27/01/2022 19:01

You’re being totally unreasonable. It’s about imposter syndrome and womens lack of confidence being one thing (but only one of many) that can hold them back.

TheOrigRights · 27/01/2022 18:49

@Kudupoo

But imposter syndrome is about our own conviction and confidence in a role - when you’re hired into it, and everyone else thinks you’re up for it, but you are the one questioning it - so I can see how that quote is relevant

I don't think that's always true. Some colleagues and others might doubt your ability or competence or be rude, and express that, and rather than thinking they're an arrogant arsehole or standing up for ourselves we take it to heart and doubt our ability.

I don't think imposter syndrome happens in a world where everyone is decent and has confidence in women and women just think negatively.

What you're describing is not imposter syndrome.
BlackberryandNettle · 27/01/2022 18:45

Ynbu OP. It's unbelievably patronising. Also, to be patronising in return, I'm pretty sure that's an incorrect use of the word 'yourself'

Kudupoo · 27/01/2022 18:24

But imposter syndrome is about our own conviction and confidence in a role - when you’re hired into it, and everyone else thinks you’re up for it, but you are the one questioning it - so I can see how that quote is relevant

I don't think that's always true. Some colleagues and others might doubt your ability or competence or be rude, and express that, and rather than thinking they're an arrogant arsehole or standing up for ourselves we take it to heart and doubt our ability.

I don't think imposter syndrome happens in a world where everyone is decent and has confidence in women and women just think negatively.

BowerOfBramble · 27/01/2022 17:51

Overcoming imposter syndrome is usually about doing the hard grind of telling yourself "all those things other people have said about you and people like you are wrong" and making yourself believe it. Easy to say, not easy to do.

I've been lucky enough to have a supportive family, kind teachers, good friends and educational opportunities. But does the fact that people of my sex were literally banned from most professions until comparatively recently, and that no previous generation of my family has been educated past the basics or had the opportunities of education or wealth affect me? Damn right it does. When you know the people around you have generations of money and university and connections and no-one has ever assumed they can't do something just because of who they are.

Does it hold me back? Fuck knows, I hope not. I don't sit here shuddering going "oh no not little me". But does it limit my expectations, contacts, confidence in applications and at interview? Sure. And that's not something I've brought upon myself.

Warblerinwinter · 27/01/2022 17:45

Less common for men Than women I should say

Warblerinwinter · 27/01/2022 17:44

Imposter syndrome is not the cotton ceiling…that’s discrimination placed on women, imposter syndrome is the feeling you don’t deserve to be in room, in role etc and fills you with self doubt. I’ve known men to have it but much less common with women.

So yes, yabu …the comments are recognising that it comes from within
But there again why do some people feel this? Low confidence in there ability, not being listened to, not being given credit, not being recognised for what they can do…all sorts of things usually building up from early in career if not while still in education.
This is something that you can fix for yourself with help. It is about building confidence and recognising that other folks in the room aren’t somehow more deserving to be there than you, The glass ceiling you have no control over as it is other peoples prejudice

TheOrigRights · 27/01/2022 17:40

@Tilltheend99

Wow. If I were you, I’d contact the company involved and complain citing your own experiences. You are not wrong, that quote is both patronising and gaslighting.
Just because the quote doesn't mention any of the other barriers which women might face, doesn't mean this one is wrong.

It's not saying that the only thing standing in the way of women is IS and that only they can fix it.

It's saying that MANY women have IS and that often it's something they can do something about themselves.

MananaTomorrow · 27/01/2022 17:37

Tbh I’m in a profession where you have mainly women.
We are all more or less self employed so have build out work around our life so don’t have the pressures mentioned above re having to fit a certain male standard.

And will myself and my colleagues are suffering from imposter syndrome.

I think it’s often coming from the fact we don’t have an over inflated ego and we are aware of what we don’t know (whereas men tend to think they know it all iyswim).
It’s not always a bad thing.

TheOrigRights · 27/01/2022 17:35

@lljkk

As one of those who never had IS, I resent it being implied I must suffer from IS merely because I'm female ! Dreary annoying assumption.
The quote says "many aspiring female....". It does not say "all", so you don't need to feel resentful about it.
MananaTomorrow · 27/01/2022 17:34

Imposter syndrome affects primarily women. It is well known that it stops women from progressing as well as they could be.

This doesn’t mean that they are not affected by other things and there aren’t other barriers that affect women specifically.

But having barriers that stop women from progressing doesn’t mean that there is nothing else that is a hindrance either.

YABU on that one.

Tilltheend99 · 27/01/2022 17:21

Wow. If I were you, I’d contact the company involved and complain citing your own experiences. You are not wrong, that quote is both patronising and gaslighting.

PurpleCarpets · 27/01/2022 17:17

I don't feel insulted. Just because they are highlighting one barrier faced by women, they are not denying others.

RobotValkyrie · 27/01/2022 17:16

Insulting victim blaming. YANBU.

Back in the real world, the main obstacle to most women's career is that it's almost impossible to make it work around family commitments.
All professional jobs are built around a "traditional male model" of career (full time, working stupid hours) where all these vital commitments are handled by somebody else.

My (futile?) attempts to strike a sensible work/life balance makes me an impostor, whether I feel like one (I don't) or not.

Eddielzzard · 27/01/2022 17:14

Very insulting

JuergenSchwarzwald · 27/01/2022 17:11

I know the firm Allen & Overy by the way and they pay lip service to diversity. But their lawyers are mainly white (and Asian) and their support services are Asian and Black. And as for social mobility - well, most of their lawyers come from reasonably privileged backgrounds.