Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many of you have had an encounter like this with a man??

211 replies

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 27/01/2022 13:58

Video in twitter thread linked.
It's a man being fucking EXTREMELY creepy to a 17 yr old girl who's just trying to shop in a thrift store.

I'm betting it's most of us, right?
My first one was when I was 10- FUCKING TEN!
Creepy ice cream man asking all sorts of inappropriate questions, leering at me and asking if I was alone and where my parents were.
Then basically just continued.

I can't even count the amount of interactions like this I had when I was younger.

This is so, so relatable it's painful.

It actually made me feel sick watching, all the fear, panic and not knowing how to get out of it, the fear that if you simply tell them to fuck off or something that they will get aggressive or worse, stalk you when you get out.

Serious serial killer vibes as well trying to get her to come work on his fucking remote property, someone get the sniffer dogs out there.

For fuck sake.

Video here

AIBU to think this is just normal life for so many girls and women?
And AIBU to think why the fuck can't we get this fucking sorted in 2022??

OP posts:
BigYellowHat · 27/01/2022 17:34

This is staged though, surely?
I agree there’s so many creeps. When I was her age, I was in a pub once and a man pulled down my boob tube, exposing my breasts to the entire pub! He certainly got his comeuppance when I slapped him in the face though but seriously, what a dick!

HomeHomeInTheRange · 27/01/2022 17:32

And how will this communication serve when the men get aggressive?
Honestly, self defence needs to be taught to girls of high-school age. Self defensive objects should be able to be carried by women.
If these men want something they will just take it, they don't care about what you have to say

Yes, there are men who will get aggressive.

But mostly this sort of encounter takes place under the very guise of 'social interaction' - so in plain sight. We can go to the till or stand by an assistant. On a packed train say 'take your hand off my body now". Go into a shop and say at the till "I do not wish to talk with you", go downstairs on the bus, etc etc.

I have been subject to attempted assault when out and about, alone on the street and it is wholly more scary and WAG do need to have the confidence and know how to effectively push, kick, scrape, etc alongside official self defence moves.

But most people wouldn't go straight for a kick to the balls when approached by a conversationalist creep in a charity shop.

Whatamesssss · 27/01/2022 17:28

@PlumKetchup

That's exactly what popped into my head too, Ted Bundy.

I cannot count the number of times I have been harassed by creeps from age 11. I have been sexually assaulted a number of times and raped once when I was 13 years old.

It isn't getting any better.

TurquoiseBaubles · 27/01/2022 17:28

@lljkk

I didn't find it outrageous situation. She easily handled it. He's really sad & lacks social skills.
ffs. Is there any behaviour you won't excuse?

She shouldn't have to handle it, and she isn't there for him to practice his "social skills".

Women are not support humans for men Angry

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2022 17:27

So much that @ChargingBuck

My kickboxing instructor used to say, "incapacitate them and run". We learned all the fancy spinning back kicks but the useful stuff was the basic 'heel of the hand driven up into the nose' 'stamp as hard as you can on the top of the foot'. Anyone can learn that.

What gets you points at competition isn't what gets you out of trouble.

And my DH is a black belt who trains with an 18 yo female black belt weighing about 7 stone. Any decently strong man could take her if he was prepared and determined. She's incredible but she's still tiny.

Broads93 · 27/01/2022 17:26

@HomeHomeInTheRange

I have had numerous unwanted creepy persistent approaches like this, from aged about 20 onwards.

A BIG problem early on was that I had never been taught to be assertive with adults, and more importantly, thought I must always be polite and obliging to adults. Men take advantage of this.

Let's teach our daughters, and sons, that if someone makes you feel uncomfortable IT IS OK TO SAY SO.

Let's help them practice what to say:

"I am not comfortable talking with you and am stopping the conversation" (and walk to the till!)

"I do not wish to look at your leg, please do not ask me again"

"I am not prepared to talk to you about any of my personal details, and I would like to end this conversation, goodbye"

"This is not a conversation I wish to continue, good afternoon!"

We are so bad (due to socialisation) at communicating confidently and directly, and most people (we see it daily on MN) go straight from uncomfortable 'people pleasing' to "Fuck Off!"

Men creep all over women / young women, because the KNOW they will be too nervous to say very loudly "Could you leave me alone now please?"

I am not victim blaming, but emphasising how hard it is for women to tackle these men. Bit of practice....

And how will this communication serve when the men get aggressive? Honestly, self defence needs to be taught to girls of high-school age. Self defensive objects should be able to be carried by women. If these men want something they will just take it, they don't care about what you have to say.
PlumKetchup · 27/01/2022 17:24

@lljkk

I didn't find it outrageous situation. She easily handled it. He's really sad & lacks social skills.
He wants you to think he's sad and lacks social skills. This is how he reels women and girls in. Does he pretend he's injured in some way? Tick bites? I couldn't hear very well. Anyway, this was Ted Bundy's way of reeling in potential victims.

Still feel sorry for him?

affairsofdragons · 27/01/2022 17:24

@waterlego

She quite clearly tried to shut down his attempts at conversation. My feeling is that he saw and understood those boundaries but felt entitled to try to erode them. The arrogance and entitlement of it is absolutely staggering.
Yep. It was creepy, slimy entitled behaviour. Made me furious to watch it.
RobotValkyrie · 27/01/2022 17:23

When I was younger, people would suggest young women should take self-defense classes.

But now I'm older, I realise self-defense starts with words and body language. I strongly believe all women should be equipped with the verbal skills to push back against creepy men, and the confidence to use these skills. It should
be taught at school, ideally.
And everyone should also be taught how to spot a creep harassing someone, and how to come to their defense. "Interfering" in these situations should be normalised. A bit like you can teach people how to intervene if they witness racist abuse. Lone women shouldn't have to face that crap alone.

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 17:18

@MrsTerryPratchett, I was gonna reply to the martial arts post too, but you have covered it with your usual eloquence.

Maybe the PP already knows all this, & I certainly do not mean to patronise ... but the average woman - even many black belts - is no match for the ill-intentioned male.
Especially when he's close enough to grapple.

I absolutely second everything you wrote & your instructor taught.
The best lesson I took away from martial arts training was - particularly for women - "get in fast, go in hard, don't stop til he's down, & do your bloody circuit training.
Because what is going to save you isn't your fighting skills - that will be your stamina, determination, & functional footwear."

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2022 17:18

Dunno about NAMALT

I'd say AMALT instead

Well too many are. What's depressing is how many men are either not bothered about it or don't believe and don't assist.

I've been helped twice by a man when I was getting harassed. In almost 40 years. One of the helpful men was a stranger who I'm still friends with! Because he stepped in and gave me a safe harbour.

These men do it in public. Why don't more men offer a hand? Offer to call police, or just stand near and make sure nothing happens, or ask if you're OK. They don't need to be in harms way. They don't have to punch the bloke. Just offer a watchful eye.

Minecraftlover · 27/01/2022 17:16

YANBU.

I had a very recent series of incidents where a customer at my work (shop type place) started like this. 'Wow you're so beautiful, are you married (I am), you're amazing'. Started coming down every week, eventually reached the point he would come in and say 'I'm not even here to buy anything, just here to see you'. Turns out he lived over an hour away. I had remained polite at first but got to the point of being absolutely terrified, I would shake and cry when I saw him park up outside. He could clearly see how uncomfortable I was, and I had even told him that the attention was unwanted, but he was so persistent it absolutely terrified me. I have been in a DV relationship years ago and this man's behaviour triggered so many awful memories and feelings from that time, leading to mental health struggles again.

Eventually found the strength to report and glad I did, haven't seen him since, but honestly was having nightmares about him tracking me down and murdering me. I think the most worrying thing is when they can clearly see that they are causing discomfort, but they don't care. That feels psychopathic to me.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 27/01/2022 17:13

I have had numerous unwanted creepy persistent approaches like this, from aged about 20 onwards.

A BIG problem early on was that I had never been taught to be assertive with adults, and more importantly, thought I must always be polite and obliging to adults. Men take advantage of this.

Let's teach our daughters, and sons, that if someone makes you feel uncomfortable IT IS OK TO SAY SO.

Let's help them practice what to say:

"I am not comfortable talking with you and am stopping the conversation" (and walk to the till!)

"I do not wish to look at your leg, please do not ask me again"

"I am not prepared to talk to you about any of my personal details, and I would like to end this conversation, goodbye"

"This is not a conversation I wish to continue, good afternoon!"

We are so bad (due to socialisation) at communicating confidently and directly, and most people (we see it daily on MN) go straight from uncomfortable 'people pleasing' to "Fuck Off!"

Men creep all over women / young women, because the KNOW they will be too nervous to say very loudly "Could you leave me alone now please?"

I am not victim blaming, but emphasising how hard it is for women to tackle these men. Bit of practice....

ScarlettDarling · 27/01/2022 17:12

@dipdye

Dunno about NAMALT

I'd say AMALT instead

Don’t be ridiculous, of course they aren’t all like this. The problem is that some of them are. Yes, situations like the video are all too common. Happened to me countless times when I was younger and as a mother of a 14 year old dd I can see that times haven’t changed all that much. It makes me angry and sad in equal measure.
Gumbomambo · 27/01/2022 17:12

Yes. It still happens and I’m 44. I can’t count the times I’ve had my arse or tits felt by a bloke. I even had one wank on me when I was on a very busy train.

CountessOfSponheim · 27/01/2022 17:10

@Socialcarenope

Yanbu.

(Some) men will say "how are we supposed to start a conversation with women if we aren't even allowed to talk to them" and I can, sort of, see their point BUT the answer is surely to wait until they talk to you, or they give that inviting smile. I believe most people can tell if someone is open to conversation.

Also, definitely not with "I think you're one of the most beautiful girls I've ever met" (especially when you haven't met them) and offering to buy them stuff.

Additionally, if there's nothing natural to start a conversation about, maybe just take it as a sign that starting a conversation is a bad idea.

Hypothetically, if you are not a creep but you're in a thrift shop and you want to start a conversation with someone you think is attractive, you can say something like "Hey, have you seen any [item of clothing you're interested in] on those rails?" They'll say yes or no. You can make a conversational remark in reply. If they say something noncommittal that isn't clearly aimed at continuing the conversation, then back off and leave them alone. There you are. You've talked to them. You've opened the door to a conversation, if one was going to happen. You haven't been creepy. It's not difficult.

LaChanticleer · 27/01/2022 17:09

Yes, I so recognise this sort of situation.

I've been that girl (and that woman) who is polite and kind, and doesn't tell the creepy men to Fuck off to the far side of fuck and fuck off some more.

I wish so many many times, I had stopped, looked a creep in the eye and asked him; "What gives you - a complete stranger - the right to talk to me ? Why are you so entitled?"

We are all too kind, and too polite!

lottiegarbanzo · 27/01/2022 17:09

Why should anyone have to 'handle' crap like this?

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 17:08

One of the things inO the video link you can hear the man asking the girl to look at his knees (apparently he was bitten by an insect on one of them and he wanted her to tell him if she could see which one it was). I don't think she did look but wonder if his conversation or actions would've changed had she done so.

Fuuuuuuuuuuck, @UsernameNotAvailableHmm I couldn't hear well enough to pick that up.

Sure they would. "Forced Teaming" & Boundary Testing in one well-rehearsed sentence.

Scary AF. This link is called for, sure you'll already be aware of it UsernameNot, but I'm alarmed at the (thankfully few) PP responding "meh" to that video clip -
www.oomm.live/the-shark-cage-metaphor-spotting-potential-abusers/

Rainbowshine · 27/01/2022 17:07

That is a creepy video. It reminds me of when I was 19 I did some volunteering in a charity shop. We’d had shoplifters so the manager was busy talking to a police officer at one end of the shop, and this bloke came up to me with a skirt and said “you’re the same shape and size as my wife and I need you to model this for me so I can decide if I want to buy it”. I said no that’s not what we do, you can return it with the receipt within so many days”. He then clocked the police officer as they were coming back up the shop, looked sheepish and ran out of the shop. The officer said that he was well known to them locally as a problem and he went around all the charity shops doing this. We had a panic alarm and the manager put the guy’s photo up from the CCTV so if he entered the shop we’d be hitting that button which meant any available colleague should try and get onto the shop floor. I didn’t encounter it again but it stayed with me and I have thought about how I could have been bolshier and shouted out “it’s a creepy man here” or whatever, but then what if he’d turned violent? You can’t win, because whether you do the polite way the person in the video did or get assertive, you can bet it will be criticised as being the wrong thing to do as a victim, because the world seems set on making it a woman’s fault that she suffered from shitty behaviour by a man.

ikeepseeingit · 27/01/2022 17:05

ergh, I definitely found it to be at its worst around 16-19. I feel bad that this is still happening, but I have no idea how to stop it. Once at about 19 a guy tried to reach/stick his hands between the window and my boob on the seat behind me on a coach. When I got up to get off his fucking wife was sitting next to him. I hate that I freeze. My partner was right next to me too but I was too scared to speak even with him there. I just ended up squished to one side instead. Disgusting.

I do tend to freeze less now if they're talking to me. I'm far less polite but I'm also 24. Maybe age helps? I think part of it is children being conditioned to be polite to adults and as we grow up particularly being women, we tend to not let go of that and men know it. That's why they pick 17-year-olds.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2022 17:05

@EishetChayil

Yep.

This is why my daughter will be training in martial arts as soon as she's old enough.

Unfortunately, martial arts won't cut it. It's not really about the ability to fight back, although that helps. It's boundaries, deescalation skills, conflict management, MH and addictions training, fighting socialisation a whole host of things.

I got self defence training as a teen from an ex Forces (there was a lot of nudge nudge it's the SAS type of chat) bloke. The most important thing he taught wasn't the fighting skills. It was the attitude. I remember him being asked 'what if someone tries to steal my musical instrument?' And him replying, 'your instrument is a weapon'. He also told us to just move if we felt uncomfortable, assume a man was a bad bloke if he sat next to us if there were empty seats, if we were touched without permission it was assault. He was great. Almost like he gave us permission to be rude and aggressive if we needed to.

He also gave us an extensive list of 'weapons' like steel combs, hairspray and hat pins we could carry without it being suspicious. Top bloke.

Chasingaftermidnight · 27/01/2022 17:01

My daughter is TEN and has begun to experience this already. Needless to say I'm teaching her very explicitly about her own boundaries and again will go to the relevant authorities whenever we need to. It makes me so upset as I would have hoped things would have changed for this next generation

I’m not suggesting that any girl or woman of any age should have to put up with this shit, but it APPALLS me how early it starts. I vividly remember my first encounter like this, aged 11. It was absolutely terrifying and it still makes my skin crawl thinking about it quarter of a century later. It’s paedophilia in plain sight and it’s just viewed as something girls have to tolerate.

UsernameNotAvailableHmm · 27/01/2022 17:00

Unfortunately this is very common behaviour. I don't know anyone who hasn't experienced the like.

I was around 12 when it first started, and even as a sixty something year old woman, this type of behaviour still happens. Whatever their intentions are, I get the impression they enjoy the discomfort it produces.

nOne of the things inO the video link you can hear the man asking the girl to look at his knees (apparently he was bitten by an insect on one of them and he wanted her to tell him if she could see which one it was). I don't think she did look but wonder if his conversation or actions would've changed had she done so.

Utter predatory creep.

JustDanceAddict · 27/01/2022 16:51

I think every woman has experienced sexual harassment and I don’t know what the solution is.
My worst experience was being assaulted at 14 on way home from school. I was about a minute from my house & the only person I told for years was my best friend at the time. No-one else knew for years - I told dh, but only about 5 years ago. My late mum never knew.
Thankfully the boy (he was in school
Uniform so was only a teen), didn’t get far cos he heard people coming, but I so wish I reported it at the time - I could’ve easily identified him, but I didn’t want to bring worry on my parents (my dad prob would’ve gone out and beaten him up!) and I was ashamed.