Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many of you have had an encounter like this with a man??

211 replies

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 27/01/2022 13:58

Video in twitter thread linked.
It's a man being fucking EXTREMELY creepy to a 17 yr old girl who's just trying to shop in a thrift store.

I'm betting it's most of us, right?
My first one was when I was 10- FUCKING TEN!
Creepy ice cream man asking all sorts of inappropriate questions, leering at me and asking if I was alone and where my parents were.
Then basically just continued.

I can't even count the amount of interactions like this I had when I was younger.

This is so, so relatable it's painful.

It actually made me feel sick watching, all the fear, panic and not knowing how to get out of it, the fear that if you simply tell them to fuck off or something that they will get aggressive or worse, stalk you when you get out.

Serious serial killer vibes as well trying to get her to come work on his fucking remote property, someone get the sniffer dogs out there.

For fuck sake.

Video here

AIBU to think this is just normal life for so many girls and women?
And AIBU to think why the fuck can't we get this fucking sorted in 2022??

OP posts:
FOJN · 27/01/2022 21:16

While it's bad that it happens, it's awful that all men are tagged in the same way! Not all men are like this!

Yes let's concentrate on how this makes men look bad rather than how it makes women feel. NAMALT is shorthand for women STFU, I refuse.

As for the posters who think she handled it well, she did, I've no doubt she's had plenty of practice. But why should she have to deal with it at all?

It made me feel sick watching it knowing she's mentally calculating how much attention will prevent him getting aggressive without giving enough for him to take it as encouragement. She just wanted to shop in peace, it's not an extravagant ask.

I doubt he's so thick skinned he can't tell she wants to be left alone but he's determined to get the attention he wants or as others have said he enjoys her discomfort. I would think many of us have encountered men who have taken great pleasure in frightening or intimidating us whilst maintaining plausible deniability, "I was just being friendly". I had a man grab my hand in a petrol station once whilst giving me change, he was staring straight at me with the creepiest smile ever, he knew exactly what he was doing.

Alayalaya · 27/01/2022 21:15

The video is creepy because it’s a child of 17 being harassed by an adult man. He must know he’s far too old to be hitting on her and yet he persists in being inappropriate. Then he tries to persuade her to accompany him to a garage on his isolated property. This is way more than just the normal sort of unwanted male attention from someone who fancies you, it’s borderline paedophilia and serial killer vibes.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 27/01/2022 21:15

Yeah I had to put up with men's pervy shit from around age 5 and the last time it happened was a month ago. I am 60 years old.
I wish it was legal to carry a baseball bat with nails in.

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 21:15

@Mommabear20

Never had an experience like this!

While it's bad that it happens, it's awful that all men are tagged in the same way! Not all men are like this!

As per Mrs Pratchett's point - google Schrodinger's Rapist.

Just because it's never happened to you, do you imagine that telling people NAMALT makes it better for the vast majority of women who is has happened to? I've never been mugged, or carjacked. That doesn't make me run around crying "not all humans are muggers & carjackers!" ffs.

Unless you can point out to me exactly which men belong to your NAMALT camp, @Mommabear20, I'll reserve the right to view them all with extreme distrust until proven otherwise.

If you want me to change my mind about that, how about you get all these wonderful NAMALT men you know doing the decent thing & calling out harassment when they see it right in front of their noses? Calling out "locker room talk" & "banter" for the bullshit it is, & educate the misogynists in how they are contributing to the continuum that makes up today's rape culture.

Most men turn a blind eye.
Or don't care enough to notice.

The change needs to start with men. Women have been trying to change this dynamic since the dawn of time.

AutomaticMoon · 27/01/2022 21:13

@MrsTerryPratchett 'I've taught her that her body belongs to her, no one gets to touch her without permission and she doesn't have to be polite if they do'

That’s wonderful and I’m slightly jealous of your DD 😃 In south africa I was au pair for a while and in kindergarten they are taught a song ‘This is my body’ in Afrikaans and English. I learned it then, I was 15, that’s when I started to realise the stuff that took place in foster care wasn’t right. But it was too late, it happened again that same year with an adult friend (late 30s) of my cousin (I was her au pair) and my cousin knew what he was like but let me go out with him, I was soooo lonely and vulnerable and he got me drunk and had sex with me which I agreed to cause I was starved for attention but he pretended to use a condom and didn’t, come to find out after that he did this regularly with teenagers and my cousin knew. Then I had to act like everything was normal with his pregnant wife at brunch even though I was terrified I had aids or pregnancy. He secretly gave me money for pregnancy test which was negative thankfully. For years I was convinced I had hiv but only had a test in my 20s 🙄

HighlandPony · 27/01/2022 21:11

@AngelinaFibres

It's the fact that women have to think about things that would never enter the head of a man.If I am on a train on my own I don't sit on an inside seat. It traps you with the man who pretends to be asleep and rubs his foot up and down your ankle. You don't take the quickest way back to your car because it's the dark, quiet bit where someone could hide. You don't park in the multi storey when you go to a concert alone, even though that's the closest parking, because it looks a bit grotty and when you get back it may not be lit. You wait for a lift in your hotel. When it arrives there is a man/men in it. You wait for the next one. A group of young men are approaching you so you walk right on the outside of the pavement/in the road rather than risk being hemmed in by the fence on the other side. I am not paranoid, I don't expect to be attacked everytime I go out but , subconsciously I adapt where I am and what I am doing to keep myself away from situations I don't want to be in. I do it automatically after years of stuff happening. My husband would never even think of adapting any part of his plan for the day.
In all honesty I’d never think of having to adapt in that way either. Not sitting where I want on a train incase some fella rubs his feet on me? That would get a swift kick in the gonads and likely a mouthful that would make a sailor proud. Probably end up on sodding Facebook or the like again. Not getting in a lift if there’s a man in it? Or walking to my car in the dark? Nope. Not me either.
AngelinaFibres · 27/01/2022 21:08

@ChargingBuck

*Also- women have been so conditioned that we feel we have to say that we are not young/ gorgeous/slim - as if we will be thought of as big headed if we 'boast' about this harassment !*

You are absolutely right @crochetmonkey74.
And it also demonstrates how male-on-female harrassment/sexual abuse is not about sex.
It's about misogyny, control, & power.

This is why young men break in to the homes of elderly women and rape them. Its not about sexual attraction, its about power and humiliation. Its about knowing that you don't need to kill that person to totally destroy them.
OhWhyNot · 27/01/2022 21:06

So why are all these men who are not like that not speaking out. They see is happening they are aware yet far more often they keep quiet and turn away

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 21:01

Also- women have been so conditioned that we feel we have to say
that we are not young/ gorgeous/slim - as if we will be thought of as big headed if we 'boast' about this harassment !

You are absolutely right @crochetmonkey74.
And it also demonstrates how male-on-female harrassment/sexual abuse is not about sex.
It's about misogyny, control, & power.

AutomaticMoon · 27/01/2022 21:00

Argh not a literal one 🙄

AutomaticMoon · 27/01/2022 20:59

NAMALT is a literal straw man, isn’t it?

crochetmonkey74 · 27/01/2022 20:59

Male feelings are more important than female lives

As always

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 20:59

@phishy

That was definitely creepy. I had the creepy men approach me when I was younger and now in my late 30s I get the aggressive men, who are angry that I exist in what they see as their space.
Ggggggrrrrrrrrr I hear you @phishy.

So glad the catcall & constant harrassment days are decades behind me ... but the personal affront men display for this harmless little grandma just existing in public space is dispiriting & enraging.

Ye Dogs this has made me remember the sexually predatory behaviour hasn't fully stopped even now. Sat at a bar stool in m'local a couple of years back, random man I've never seen in there before gives chummy fellow-pub-person greeting, I respond in kind, & he sidles his bar stool closer to inform me how proud he is to be able to "still get it up" at 60.

Why he felt his hydraulics functionality was of any interest to me I can only speculate, but couldn't be arsed to do more than take the piss so dryly he was unable to quite fathom it (as per PP upthread - when a man's already broken the social contract, you don't know what he's gonna do next ...)
So I replied that that must be gratifying to any bed partner he has, but am unsure why he feels a random bird in a pub needs to know.

As a younger woman, I would have just wanted to scuttle away.
Unless I was pissed so less scared - at 16 I felled a big twat in a pub with an upper cut. Not wise. Suppose I'd misjudged, & got the worst of it?
It takes practice, & it shouldn't have to. By the time women get used to handling this fucking shit, they've been exposed to far to much of it already. Pun intended.

AutomaticMoon · 27/01/2022 20:58

@DrSbaitso Yep, had that too, when I was 7-8, man on the street said that he wants to ‘lick my pussy’ I was terrified but had NO idea what it meant. I wonder if these men could sense that I was abused and a good target. I’ve seen pedophiles describe their favourite targets having ‘sad eyes’ and that’s how they know you’re vulnerable 😞

crochetmonkey74 · 27/01/2022 20:56

@MrsTerryPratchett

And the odd time a man does experience being approached by someone bigger and sexually interested, in a gay club for example, they behave as if it's the most horrifying experience anyone could ever have.

Yes dude, we fucking know. We live with it IN CHILDHOOD.

God yes!!!

You know I never thought of this!

AngelinaFibres · 27/01/2022 20:55

It's the fact that women have to think about things that would never enter the head of a man.If I am on a train on my own I don't sit on an inside seat. It traps you with the man who pretends to be asleep and rubs his foot up and down your ankle. You don't take the quickest way back to your car because it's the dark, quiet bit where someone could hide. You don't park in the multi storey when you go to a concert alone, even though that's the closest parking, because it looks a bit grotty and when you get back it may not be lit. You wait for a lift in your hotel. When it arrives there is a man/men in it. You wait for the next one. A group of young men are approaching you so you walk right on the outside of the pavement/in the road rather than risk being hemmed in by the fence on the other side.
I am not paranoid, I don't expect to be attacked everytime I go out but , subconsciously I adapt where I am and what I am doing to keep myself away from situations I don't want to be in. I do it automatically after years of stuff happening. My husband would never even think of adapting any part of his plan for the day.

Chasingaftermidnight · 27/01/2022 20:54

While it's bad that it happens, it's awful that all men are tagged in the same way! Not all men are like this!

Interesting choice of words. You think it’s ‘bad’ that women are routinely harassed, sexually assaulted and worse. But you think it’s ‘awful’ that all men are tagged in the same way (which they aren’t, but whatever).

Male feelings are more important than female lives.

mummykel16 · 27/01/2022 20:48

@crochetmonkey74

mummykel16 What I meant was the men who were harassing/ touching my girls were not even being sneaky- they were unashamed at doing it- out in the open- smirking or grinning when shouted at or slapped
I know, I just meant some men stand against this behaviour.
MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2022 20:47

And the odd time a man does experience being approached by someone bigger and sexually interested, in a gay club for example, they behave as if it's the most horrifying experience anyone could ever have.

Yes dude, we fucking know. We live with it IN CHILDHOOD.

ILoveToads · 27/01/2022 20:45

@Mommabear20

Never had an experience like this!

While it's bad that it happens, it's awful that all men are tagged in the same way! Not all men are like this!

Seriously, just fuck off with comments like that.

What percentage of women compared to men act like this? A seriously higher number of men without doubt.

I have never heard of men complaining that throughout their life they have had to deal this shit from women; unwanted leering through to rape or murder.

It is men that are the highest offenders.

Trotting out the old 'Not all men are like this', of course they aren't.

But it's not just the men you think you aren't capable; it's the nice guy at work who goes home and hits his wife.

The community leader who abuses his daughter.

The 26 year old who 'dated' me at 14, such a nice guy apparently according to his family.

I obviously couldn't legally consent, but led him astray as I must have lied about my age according to them. I didn't, and I looked about 12. I don't know of one of my female friends that would have even contemplated the situation in reverse.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/01/2022 20:44

@AutomaticMoon I wish I could claim that phrase but it was a better woman than I am who coined it.

I forgot something that happened recently at DD's school. I got called because a teacher (not her class teacher) had grabbed DD's shoulder (she wasn't listening natch) and DD turned and said, 'don't touch me' and her class teacher called me, concerned.

I said, 'I've taught her that her body belongs to her, no one gets to touch her without permission and she doesn't have to be polite if they do'. Great female teacher said, 'good for you' and that was that.

HighlandPony · 27/01/2022 20:44

[quote AutomaticMoon]@HighlandPony I was taught as a child to do as adults said. When I was sexually harassed and abused, I just froze. There was nowhere to escape to and I didn’t even know what was happening. I just knew it was really scary.[/quote]
This sort of makes my point. I was never raised like that. I was never raised to do what others said blindly and I was raised firmly in the knowledge that I had back up. Whether at age five or 35. Im sorry for what happened to you I really am but we were raised tough and even though it was borderline poverty it’s stood us in better stead in life

Redannie118 · 27/01/2022 20:40

A few days ago my SIL was driving home in the evening. Shes 40 and drives a small brightly coloured car. She also lives in a very rural area. A man pulled up in a big van behind her and she was blinded by his full beam headlights she flashed her lights to let him know she couldnt see, but he kept on going. Inthe end she pulled over to let him past and off he went. About 3 mins later she saw him in a layby and he started to follow her. She changed direction multiple times but he kept on behind her Bear in mind these are unlit, single lane deserted country roads . Eventually she saw a petrol station and pulled in and he pulled in behind her. She got out the car and told this man who wad in his late 50s that she had phoned the police and had a picture of his number plate and he better not leave. When the police arrived the man admitted to following her and said " I live alone in the countryside, how else am I supposed to meet women? I was going to wait for her to stop and then talk to her !" The police asked if he had done this before and guy says" Yeah loads of times!" By this point SIL is beyond horrified and asks the police what they are going to do about it. Police state" Nothing. Hes not done anything illegal !" and let him go!!!! Then they wonder why we have no faith in the police to keep us safe !

crochetmonkey74 · 27/01/2022 20:39

[quote AutomaticMoon]@crochetmonkey74 ‘I've never been bitten by a dog but I know that some are nasty and crucially, that all of them can and will bite in given circumstances’

Perfectly put! Would you mind if I steal this and use liberally as a stock response to NAMALT?[/quote]
Please do!

I must remember to use it instead of sarcastically rolling my eyes or shouting fuck off

AutomaticMoon · 27/01/2022 20:38

@crochetmonkey74 Same with my sexually harassing coworker, manager said it’s because he’s deaf 🙄 All the more offensive as this is a manager at a care home for deaf people. So to say that all deaf people are like that is disgusting.