Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How many of you have had an encounter like this with a man??

211 replies

RozHuntleysLeftHand · 27/01/2022 13:58

Video in twitter thread linked.
It's a man being fucking EXTREMELY creepy to a 17 yr old girl who's just trying to shop in a thrift store.

I'm betting it's most of us, right?
My first one was when I was 10- FUCKING TEN!
Creepy ice cream man asking all sorts of inappropriate questions, leering at me and asking if I was alone and where my parents were.
Then basically just continued.

I can't even count the amount of interactions like this I had when I was younger.

This is so, so relatable it's painful.

It actually made me feel sick watching, all the fear, panic and not knowing how to get out of it, the fear that if you simply tell them to fuck off or something that they will get aggressive or worse, stalk you when you get out.

Serious serial killer vibes as well trying to get her to come work on his fucking remote property, someone get the sniffer dogs out there.

For fuck sake.

Video here

AIBU to think this is just normal life for so many girls and women?
And AIBU to think why the fuck can't we get this fucking sorted in 2022??

OP posts:
whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 03:54

Reading what others have said about defence starting with attitude I realise I'm guilty of not helping to make my daughters assertive. There are times I tell them to hug their grandparents (in order not to be rude) but what am I teaching them?? Do stuff, even if you don't want to, to make people happy?! I need to get a grip

whatever1980 · 29/01/2022 03:47

Christ on a bike.

She handled that so well.

I was watching my kids swim last week in a gym and much a older guy (appeared to be a regular member) was talking to the young receptionist (21) about horse riding (he brought it up) and if she still had those riding boots and that her friend should also get into horse riding and get those boots. Creepy.

I was thinking "shut the f**k up" but they were all being jovial (probably humouring him) so I didn't say anything. I should've called him out on this in public.

Flickflak · 29/01/2022 03:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 02:57

Men do know what some other men are like, the ones who say they don't are liars, watch them when they are out with a DD DN OH DW they love, they are much more aware

Ponoka7 · 29/01/2022 02:50

@HighlandPony
You've possibly grown up in an area were other men did know your Dad/Brothers/Male relatives, so you've had the protection from inappropriate sexual behaviour from childhood. You are seen then as off limits because you are another man's property, who will react, not because you are respected in anyway.
I'm from a rough bit of Liverpool, you have to be able to hold your own. But it still happens to the 'Psycho gobby bitches', even if you can give out, its still happened. Travel outside your city with your underage DD/DN etc and you'll soon see the behaviour. Yeah you can mouth off at them, but its meant that you couldn't just go about your business and enjoy your day, unlike your male relatives.

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 02:49

@ChargingBuck

I will tell you what a life sentence would do and I mean life, they won't be doing it again.

I will tell you that this will only take ONE man off the streets, Meanwhile with so few assaults even reported let alone prosecuted let alone resulting in a conviction that it's more effective to prevent than focus solely on what you see as a 'cure'.
I don't see a 'cure' in a current set-up that means even the rapes that get reported only result in a 1.4% conviction rate.
Those 98.6% guys are still out & about.

The only remedy is the small societal changes I wrote about upthread - creating an environment where boys are brought up in a more nurturing & less 'boys will be boys' culture, where they are not conditioned into toxic masculinity, are 'allowed' to express their emotions & articulate their problems, so that they grow into men who are comfortable saying "hey dude - not cool" when they witness the "only banter" that you referenced.
That small act, in a society where millions of such small acts are being actively promoted to boys & by men, is what will help stop some, I'd love to hope many, men from "doing it at all" rather than one man doing it again.

Have you really never seen men calling out some of this stuff only to be told not to worry because it's only banter, by other men and women?
Erm ... why are you asking? - it's kinda the main point of my second paragraph in my post you quoted.

Have a noodle around some criminology studies re: cause & effects of prison sentencing for violent males, & you might be amazed at how you change your view about deterrents.

You don't know what my views are about deterrents I'm not even sure I do sometimes, but I am sure when men get away with it more are likely to follow.

I don't know the answers but alienating those few who try to help isn't clever.
I don't see this shouting out of car windows beeping the horn talking shyte to strangers thinking it's manly not crossing the road to put a woman's mind at ease changing in mine or my DC lifetimes

ChargingBuck · 29/01/2022 02:39

@mummykel16

Change for this needs to come from the parent/s and families, which considering who does most the parenting I had hoped would already be bearing fruit.
Eh?

Women have been doing most of the parenting for time immemorial. Change isn't down to mothers. It's down to all of us, family or whoever.

And men are part of that, but as it doesn't affect them so directly, many men don't even recognise that it happens. Try a small survey.

Also - men don't tend to listen to women as hard as they listen to men. So for women to feel real change about eg harassment, it needs to be men that are doing the changing, because they sure haven't stopped yet, no matter how many aeons women have been asking them to cut it out.

ChargingBuck · 29/01/2022 02:33

I will tell you what a life sentence would do and I mean life, they won't be doing it again.

I will tell you that this will only take ONE man off the streets, Meanwhile with so few assaults even reported let alone prosecuted let alone resulting in a conviction that it's more effective to prevent than focus solely on what you see as a 'cure'.
I don't see a 'cure' in a current set-up that means even the rapes that get reported only result in a 1.4% conviction rate.
Those 98.6% guys are still out & about.

The only remedy is the small societal changes I wrote about upthread - creating an environment where boys are brought up in a more nurturing & less 'boys will be boys' culture, where they are not conditioned into toxic masculinity, are 'allowed' to express their emotions & articulate their problems, so that they grow into men who are comfortable saying "hey dude - not cool" when they witness the "only banter" that you referenced.
That small act, in a society where millions of such small acts are being actively promoted to boys & by men, is what will help stop some, I'd love to hope many, men from "doing it at all" rather than one man doing it again.

Have you really never seen men calling out some of this stuff only to be told not to worry because it's only banter, by other men and women?
Erm ... why are you asking? - it's kinda the main point of my second paragraph in my post you quoted.

Have a noodle around some criminology studies re: cause & effects of prison sentencing for violent males, & you might be amazed at how you change your view about deterrents.

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 02:30

Change for this needs to come from the parent/s and families, which considering who does most the parenting I had hoped would already be bearing fruit.

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 02:15

@ChargingBuck

Some Men do speak out, try listening. And most don't, try paying attention *@mummykel16*

That said it would help if courts gave proper sentences (like life) to people who kidnap women drag em into a van and cause permanent irreparable damage.
Prison is not a deterrent to a man who is prepared to do that.
It might get a perpetrator off the street, but it doesn't heal the woman does it?
Change doesn't come from increasingly draconian punishments from 'above'.
It comes from tiny acts at the grass roots. Education. Small interventions. The kind of small acts of conscious allyship so many men could make every day, but don't - because men are conditioned to think that speaking out against 'just locker room banter' will get them labelled a cissy. We all know what Angry & Controlling men do to women & cissies ...

Also, by "monstering" the men who kidnap women drag em into a van you are playing into the dangerous myth that only monsters hurt women. That the streets are the most unsafe places, & that all VAWG is pre-planned by a stranger predator.
It's bollocks.
Women & girls are at FAR more risk of harm in their own homes. See also relative's & friend's homes, offices, sports clubs, hobby groups. Seeing the pattern yet?
Because the VAST majority of assaults on women are committed BY MEN THEY ALREADY KNOW & should have damn well been able to trust.

So I think piss off with your NAMALT nonsense.
Uncle Geoff at the xmas party is a very much more real risk to girls than your hysterical image of monsters, culled from popular media & popular myth.

PS apologies in advance is 'cissy' now has more complicated connotations, I'm not using it as a perjorative, just a descriptor to indicate how toxic masculinity tends to respond to the non-toxic.
So please don't jump on it, I'm an old bat who can't always keep up with emerging vocab.

I answered a question about why men who aren't like that don't speak out, some do. I will tell you what a life sentence would do and I mean life, they won't be doing it again. Have you really never seen men calling out some of this stuff only to be told not to worry because it's only banter, by other men and women?
ChargingBuck · 29/01/2022 02:13

[quote Mommabear20]@phishy no they're not meaning less statistics to me, but there are countless crimes that women commit on other women or men, and crimes that men commit against men, I simply don't see the benefits of living in constant fear and people. [/quote]
That's the thing though innit @Mommabear20.

I can't speak for you, but I'm not in constant fear of humans.
That'll be because women don't tend to scare me in the least. Because they are not, as a class, scary.
But men are. Because, as PP rightly pointed out, 97% of violent crime is committed by males.

I'm not in 'constant fear' & am irritated by your Straw Man tactic with that. I'm fucking wary though. On my guard. So are the vast, vast majority of women.

Good for you that you are not, maybe that's because you are one of the few lucky ones without horrible experiences. Word of advice though - don't mistake complacency for safety.

thefourgp · 29/01/2022 02:06

I think most of us have been there and it’s horrible. I remember as a teenager getting the bus to college every morning and I had to change my pattern of which bus stop to use because the local street sweeper kept talking to me and hanging about at my bus stop even when I was giving him one word answers and doing my best not to make eye contact/turn away from him. I remember another creep who’d get on the same bus as me at night when I was in my early twenties and kept trying to talk to me and get my attention despite me reading a book with headphones in and clearly ignoring him. When you’re younger you often don’t have the confidence or experience to know how to handle such situations. I remember a drunk male stranger getting too close to my mum in a bus station and I stepped between them and asked him to move away when he tried to put his arm around her. He looked shocked and stumbled off cursing about uptight bitches and just having a bit of fun. It happens so often to so many women.

ChargingBuck · 29/01/2022 02:05

Some Men do speak out, try listening.
And most don't, try paying attention @mummykel16

That said it would help if courts gave proper sentences (like life) to people who kidnap women drag em into a van and cause permanent irreparable damage.
Prison is not a deterrent to a man who is prepared to do that.
It might get a perpetrator off the street, but it doesn't heal the woman does it?
Change doesn't come from increasingly draconian punishments from 'above'.
It comes from tiny acts at the grass roots. Education. Small interventions. The kind of small acts of conscious allyship so many men could make every day, but don't - because men are conditioned to think that speaking out against 'just locker room banter' will get them labelled a cissy. We all know what Angry & Controlling men do to women & cissies ...

Also, by "monstering" the men who kidnap women drag em into a van you are playing into the dangerous myth that only monsters hurt women. That the streets are the most unsafe places, & that all VAWG is pre-planned by a stranger predator.
It's bollocks.
Women & girls are at FAR more risk of harm in their own homes. See also relative's & friend's homes, offices, sports clubs, hobby groups. Seeing the pattern yet?
Because the VAST majority of assaults on women are committed BY MEN THEY ALREADY KNOW & should have damn well been able to trust.

So I think piss off with your NAMALT nonsense.
Uncle Geoff at the xmas party is a very much more real risk to girls than your hysterical image of monsters, culled from popular media & popular myth.

PS apologies in advance is 'cissy' now has more complicated connotations, I'm not using it as a perjorative, just a descriptor to indicate how toxic masculinity tends to respond to the non-toxic.
So please don't jump on it, I'm an old bat who can't always keep up with emerging vocab.

mummykel16 · 29/01/2022 01:39

@dipdye

So why are all these men who are not like that not speaking out.

^

Because basically they don't care THAT much. Not enough to actually do anything about it. Even though they have daughters, wives, mothers, etc etc.

Do they even realise women are humans too?

Some Men do speak out, try listening.

That said it would help if courts gave proper sentences (like life) to people who kidnap women drag em into a van and cause permanent irreparable damage.

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/01/2022 21:29

there are countless crimes that women commit on other women or men

This is proper bollocks.

RestingStitchFace · 28/01/2022 20:44

When I was 15 I had to walk past a building site every day on my way home from school. I was cat-called and whistled at every day. I didn't even understand most of the words they were shouting. I was young for my age and found it terrifying. Every fucking day for 2 months.

I do not know a single woman who has been exempt from this shit...

PleasantBirthday · 28/01/2022 14:55

@Socialcarenope

Yanbu.

(Some) men will say "how are we supposed to start a conversation with women if we aren't even allowed to talk to them" and I can, sort of, see their point BUT the answer is surely to wait until they talk to you, or they give that inviting smile. I believe most people can tell if someone is open to conversation.

I can't see their point at all. Who cares if they don't start conversations with women (or inappropriately young women). I don't see women or girls as existing to facilitate men's chatting.
AsYouWishButtercup · 28/01/2022 14:33

[quote Mommabear20]@phishy no they're not meaning less statistics to me, but there are countless crimes that women commit on other women or men, and crimes that men commit against men, I simply don't see the benefits of living in constant fear and people. [/quote]
Men commit 97% of violent crimes. Women are not ‘commuting countless crimes’ against men.

AsYouWishButtercup · 28/01/2022 14:33

@Mommabear20

I'll continue to see the good in people until proven otherwise! Innocent until proven guilty still stands for me! Or shall we just lock all men up now because 'they could...' and be done with it!
1 in 10 women raped by men 1 in 4 women victims of DV at the hands of men 1 in 5 women sexually assaulted by men 99% of rapists get away with their crime

I’m not sure what other proof you need to see that men, as a class, are a danger

Mommabear20 · 28/01/2022 14:32

@phishy no they're not meaning less statistics to me, but there are countless crimes that women commit on other women or men, and crimes that men commit against men, I simply don't see the benefits of living in constant fear and people.

Scoobydoobywho · 28/01/2022 14:29

@RozHuntleysLeftHand is that the one where he says he has hurt his leg and needs someone to come to his property to help him move something?

phishy · 28/01/2022 14:25

@Mommabear20

I'll continue to see the good in people until proven otherwise! Innocent until proven guilty still stands for me! Or shall we just lock all men up now because 'they could...' and be done with it!
You do you but don't expect women to let their guard down around men.

Clearly the murders of women are just meaningless statistics to you.

Mommabear20 · 28/01/2022 14:17

I'll continue to see the good in people until proven otherwise!
Innocent until proven guilty still stands for me! Or shall we just lock all men up now because 'they could...' and be done with it!

dipdye · 28/01/2022 02:04

So why are all these men who are not like that not speaking out.

^

Because basically they don't care THAT much. Not enough to actually do anything about it. Even though they have daughters, wives, mothers, etc etc.

Do they even realise women are humans too?

PrettyBluebells · 28/01/2022 00:57

Incidentally, I'm in my 50's but I'm a former professional athlete, not a shrinking violet by any stretch of the imagination. Blaming me for not looking hard enough or for allowing a man to make me vulnerable is blatantly ridiculous. Some man see the muscles, the attitude, and see that as a challenge.