Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind Ex-MIL of ExHs role in parenting?

310 replies

Negative12hoursthenPositive · 27/01/2022 13:58

ExH has contact with DD for 24 hours EOW. He takes her back to his parents despite not living with them, that’s his choice and I never got involved. It has obviously caused issues during lockdowns etc as he refuses to to take DD to his own house.

Both Ex-PILs are immunosuppressed for different reasons. There’s been a huge outbreak of covid in DDs class so I was testing her daily due to that but then been doing extra tests (2 times a day) in the 48 hours before contact.

DD tested positive on Monday at 5am (she’d woken up feeling awful and insisted on a test). I’d tested her less than 12 hours earlier (6pm) when she came back from contact and she was negative, not even a faint line on the test.

Ex-FIL has now tested positive.

Ex-MIL has sent me a huge ranty text telling me I am disgusting, I knew they were vulnerable and yet I still insist on contact for a break from her and I must have known DD was positive before she went to contact. Apparently this is further evidence that DD should be living with them as I can’t “risk assess or think of anyone but myself”.

Apart from the fact that I feel like I hardly see DD in term time due to contact and school and after school activities (that I wouldn’t stop as DD loves them) so would never expect a break from her, WIBU to point out that ExH knew the risks? He’s on the school mailing and test message lists just like me, he gets the same close contact emails and reminders about daily tests as I do. He is also on the class whatsapp group like me and knows that the girl DD sits next to (she’s sat next to the same child for all of Year 1 and since Year 2 started) tested positive on Friday, after DD had sat next to her all day. He knew the risk and has cancelled contact before when he felt the risk to his parents was too high.

There’s a CAO in place, the judge decided the level of contact for ExH not me or ExH. We’ve been back to court once since the order was made over another issue which Ex-MIL also blames me for.

So WIBU to reply to Ex-MIL and remind her of her sons role in all this? I’ve kept more than my side of the bargain when I agreed to test DD twice a day in the 48 hours before contact. I promise she was negative before she went and 12 hours before she tested positive. I would never let my covid positive child go to school/contact/activities.

Also WWYD about this going forwards if I am going to be blamed?

OP posts:
pictish · 27/01/2022 16:32

Fantastic response. Factual, polite and nothing for her to argue with.
She’ll be furious at that text. Hahaaa.
She can get well to fuck eh?

I don’t think you’ve got anything tangible to fear from this combative and stupid woman. Let her create, you stay pleasant and indifferent.

Negative12hoursthenPositive · 27/01/2022 16:26

@Grandville

Good response although I'm sure she will a) take great offence and b) see it as further evidence against you.

You can't argue with crazy.

@Grandville She absolutely will see it as further evidence against me. I don't care at this point, got too much to do like actually raising my DD to bother anymore. She was way worse than this when we first split up.
OP posts:
Booklover3 · 27/01/2022 16:25

Dear Ex MiL,

Piss off and stop enabling your feckless son.

Sincerely,

@Negative12hoursthenPositive

Grandville · 27/01/2022 16:23

Good response although I'm sure she will a) take great offence and b) see it as further evidence against you.

You can't argue with crazy.

AryaStarkWolf · 27/01/2022 16:22

@Alonelonelyloner

Good grief.

She sent you a ranty text blaming you. Just send her one back saying;

'Hi, sorry you have Covid in the house. I test my daughter daily. I have at no point made the decision to send her into your home. Ever. I kindly suggest you take this up with your feckless son. Regards, Disgruntled EXDIL.

Perfect.
PhoboPhobia · 27/01/2022 16:21

I feel for you. I have family members who are estranged from their DIL and Granddaughter and they blame EVERYTHING on their DIL.

The fact they don't see their GD is entirely her fault apparently and nothing to do with the fact that their useless son is a waste of space as a father and will only have contact with his DD once a week, for 2 hours, in her own house.

The fact that she has blocked them on social media so they never see photos of GD is entirely DILs fault and nothing to do with the abusive messages they were posting about her nor the fact that their useless DS doesn't take or send them any photos.

I have been so disappointed in the out and out misogyny from half of my family and have had to massively distance myself from them.

You MILs message has made me rage!! Well done for such a good response and lets hope she gets the message!

KangSaeByeok · 27/01/2022 16:19

I came here to say ignore the 'give both barrels' and posters suggesting inflammatory language. As tempting as it is, the grey rock approach is the way to go. Every time. But you're response is absolutely fine.

RedToothBrush · 27/01/2022 16:17

@Heronwatcher

I think your reply was great. But just to say don’t put up with your ex not keeping to times. And if she sends any more shitty messages I would inform her that you’re keeping printed copies in case you need to commence proceedings for harassment and that should it be necessary you will consider asking the court to specifically order that contact should not take place at her home based on the text message evidence. That would teach the poisonous witch and her lazy feckless son.
To be honest, I would say that given that she is accusing you of being a liar and 'endangering her' that you tell her that you think it better that you don't have any contact with her at all from now on and all contact between her and your daughter will need to be done via her son because of the position its putting you in and the abuse you are getting.

This isn't your responsibility. The decision to take your daughter to the grandparents is your ex's and grandparent rights don't exist. Thank fuck.

BuanoKubiamVej · 27/01/2022 16:13

Yanbu

Dear MIL

The courts have ordered that DD has contact with her father for 24 hours EOW. I have no control over that. Your son chooses to spend those 24 hours with you. I have no control over that either. I am obliged to send DD to school and it is in her best interests to go, I would have no intention of doing otherwise even if I wasn't legally obliged to send her so there's always going to be a risk. It's not my fault that your son chooses to take that risk with your health for his convenience. I have done everything I can to help by doing all the extra LFTs that we agreed but I certainly had no control over the fact that DDs infection was too early to be detected by the tests she took before the most recent visit. I really couldn't have done anything different.

I hope you are all well soon.

Best wishes

Heronwatcher · 27/01/2022 16:09

I think your reply was great. But just to say don’t put up with your ex not keeping to times. And if she sends any more shitty messages I would inform her that you’re keeping printed copies in case you need to commence proceedings for harassment and that should it be necessary you will consider asking the court to specifically order that contact should not take place at her home based on the text message evidence. That would teach the poisonous witch and her lazy feckless son.

Negative12hoursthenPositive · 27/01/2022 16:05

@RandomMess

Please enforce the court order with regards to him returning DD on time. It is so unfair on you and DD that you get so little quality time together.

How are you supposed to have any plans if you can't rely on DD being back in time.

Now she is older perhaps it's time to request EOW for 2 nights for their contact time.

@RandomMess I have EOW with her in term time, and all the school holidays as I only work 3 days a week, it just feels like in term time I don't see much of her because she does 3 activities in the week - I wouldn't stop her activities though as she absolutely loves them.
OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 16:03

Well done OP your reply was perfect.

Even better, you rose to no bait, so she can't even get a little thrill out of seeing your frustration & rage :)

Wine
Negative12hoursthenPositive · 27/01/2022 16:01

@ittakes2

Your ex sounds like twat but I must admit if I knew my daughter had sat next to a covid positive child all day on the friday, I would have pointed this out to her immunosuppressed grandparents if she was seeing them the next day.
@ittakes2 ExH knew she'd tested positive on Friday night, the mum put on the class whatsapp group that she had, and ExH knows DD sits next to this girl in class.
OP posts:
NellieWellietheEllie · 27/01/2022 16:00

Good response!

Allpenguinsarepingus · 27/01/2022 15:59

That was a very measured and calm response OP. Well done.

NellieWellietheEllie · 27/01/2022 15:59

YADNBU but some people are just unreasonable and trying to reason with them leads to madness. Could you just block ex-MIL and just arrange contact with your ex-H? I can't imagine I'd keep in contact with my MIL if me and DH split up.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 27/01/2022 15:55

ittakes2 the OP would have left herself open to accusations of interfering in the ex's contact time and trying to prevent the ILs seeing their gd if she'd done that.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/01/2022 15:53

@ittakes2

Your ex sounds like twat but I must admit if I knew my daughter had sat next to a covid positive child all day on the friday, I would have pointed this out to her immunosuppressed grandparents if she was seeing them the next day.
Which is what the girls father should have done.
ittakes2 · 27/01/2022 15:51

Your ex sounds like twat but I must admit if I knew my daughter had sat next to a covid positive child all day on the friday, I would have pointed this out to her immunosuppressed grandparents if she was seeing them the next day.

Fallagain · 27/01/2022 15:51

@Negative12hoursthenPositive

I went with

"Hi (Ex-MIL), Sorry to hear (Ex-FIL) has covid. (DD) tested negative 5 times between Thursday morning and Saturday morning when (ExH) picked her up from me. She did not test postive until 5am Monday. (ExH) is on the school mailing lists and gets the same information as me Re close contacts, I do not get to decide where he takes DD during his contact times, so it is him you need to discuss this with if you feel you both have been put at unnecessary risk. Kind regards Negative"

Good message.
3scape · 27/01/2022 15:49

None of that is on the op though. The MIL is an idiot.

RandomMess · 27/01/2022 15:49

Please enforce the court order with regards to him returning DD on time. It is so unfair on you and DD that you get so little quality time together.

How are you supposed to have any plans if you can't rely on DD being back in time.

Now she is older perhaps it's time to request EOW for 2 nights for their contact time.

3scape · 27/01/2022 15:49

That's unlikely. Unfortunately it takes a few days for a test to be positive after contracting. But you are infectious before the test picks it up. So it is likely that the DD caught it from her close contact and over the weekend became infectious herself. But that is nobodies fault but the adults who took that risk with the compromised health (so the ex who knew the facts and his parents who still supported overnight visits to someone being exposed regularly to COVID at school).

givemepiece · 27/01/2022 15:47

Perfect response

MananaTomorrow · 27/01/2022 15:47

Sorry missed your update.

Good!!