Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remind Ex-MIL of ExHs role in parenting?

310 replies

Negative12hoursthenPositive · 27/01/2022 13:58

ExH has contact with DD for 24 hours EOW. He takes her back to his parents despite not living with them, that’s his choice and I never got involved. It has obviously caused issues during lockdowns etc as he refuses to to take DD to his own house.

Both Ex-PILs are immunosuppressed for different reasons. There’s been a huge outbreak of covid in DDs class so I was testing her daily due to that but then been doing extra tests (2 times a day) in the 48 hours before contact.

DD tested positive on Monday at 5am (she’d woken up feeling awful and insisted on a test). I’d tested her less than 12 hours earlier (6pm) when she came back from contact and she was negative, not even a faint line on the test.

Ex-FIL has now tested positive.

Ex-MIL has sent me a huge ranty text telling me I am disgusting, I knew they were vulnerable and yet I still insist on contact for a break from her and I must have known DD was positive before she went to contact. Apparently this is further evidence that DD should be living with them as I can’t “risk assess or think of anyone but myself”.

Apart from the fact that I feel like I hardly see DD in term time due to contact and school and after school activities (that I wouldn’t stop as DD loves them) so would never expect a break from her, WIBU to point out that ExH knew the risks? He’s on the school mailing and test message lists just like me, he gets the same close contact emails and reminders about daily tests as I do. He is also on the class whatsapp group like me and knows that the girl DD sits next to (she’s sat next to the same child for all of Year 1 and since Year 2 started) tested positive on Friday, after DD had sat next to her all day. He knew the risk and has cancelled contact before when he felt the risk to his parents was too high.

There’s a CAO in place, the judge decided the level of contact for ExH not me or ExH. We’ve been back to court once since the order was made over another issue which Ex-MIL also blames me for.

So WIBU to reply to Ex-MIL and remind her of her sons role in all this? I’ve kept more than my side of the bargain when I agreed to test DD twice a day in the 48 hours before contact. I promise she was negative before she went and 12 hours before she tested positive. I would never let my covid positive child go to school/contact/activities.

Also WWYD about this going forwards if I am going to be blamed?

OP posts:
TurquoiseDragon · 27/01/2022 15:21

@saraclara

"I didn't send DD to you. I make her available for court-ordered contact with Ex-H, and he decides where to take her during that time. He receives all the information available from DD's school about Covid exposures. I suggest you take this up with your son."

So far I like this one best. It's very concise, clear and unemotional. There's nothing to argue with in it at all.

I would send one factual response, simply for the paper trail, then block. I like this one, clear, concise and witout emotion.

The one response for the paper trail is simply because of the comments about DD living with them. No court is going to side with them, it's just handy to have that paper trail.

Aderyn21 · 27/01/2022 15:19

I'd send the reply that contact is court ordered so dd can see her dad and that it's up to ex h what happens during that time.

Then I'd stop testing dd before contact. Twice before each visit is too much and if they do get covid from dd then so what? Fuck em!

ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 15:18

@AuntieStella

I'd keep it very short and factual

"I made DD available for contact with her father as specified in the court order. She tested negative negative twice in the 48 hours befor his contact. It is not up to me to decide how XH uses his contact time. He receives the same information as I do from the school. I suggest you ask him about the decision to bring her to your house during his contact time"

Some great suggested replies by PP, but @AuntieStella's is the one I'd go for - it covers everything, keeps all the emotion out & is unimpeachably "Court-friendly", should things ever come to that again ...
DreamerSeven · 27/01/2022 15:15

@LannieDuck

I would say.

"I didn't send DD to you. I make her available for court-ordered contact with Ex-H, and he decides where to take her during that time. He receives all the information available from DD's school about Covid exposures. I suggest you take this up with your son."

I’d send this word for word. Keep it factual and don’t justify yourself by explaining the testing you’ve done etc.
SituationCritical · 27/01/2022 15:11

Also agree with the AmandaHoldensLips answer. Short, to the point and factually correct. I'd block after that so she can't have the satisfaction of another reply. Strange how blind some people can be to the uselessness of their offspring (usually male). I suppose it's also your fault that you broke up, poor lad Wink

Fallagain · 27/01/2022 15:07

@ClawedButler

You don't need to explain anything.

Never wrestle with a pig. You both get covered in sh1t, but the pig likes it.

What an amazing phrase!
ChargingBuck · 27/01/2022 15:07

Ex-MIL has sent me a huge ranty text telling me I am disgusting, I knew they were vulnerable and yet I still insist on contact for a break from her and I must have known DD was positive before she went to contact. Apparently this is further evidence that DD should be living with them as I can’t “risk assess or think of anyone but myself”.

Jeeze, OP. Thank Dog you are (mostly) out of that awful dynamic.
Yeah, I think you need to clear it up with her as Ex may be telling her porkies. Something like:

MiL, I don't allow DD to spend 24 hours at your house each fortnight because I want to. I do so because it is Court-ordered. Where her father decides to take her for this 24 hours is also not my decision, so I'm at a loss to understand why you are asking me about it, rather than your son, who is obviously more intent on handing off childcare to you than protecting your health by having contact at his own house.
Very sorry to hear that FiL is poorly, so trust you will talk to your son now about the importance of him testing both himself & DD, & of course not visiting you if he is positive or has any kind of infection.
Regards, Negative.

If she comes back at you with any more nonsense - don't bother to reply. You have given her the basic courtesy of the facts, no need to bother engaging further.

AuntieStella · 27/01/2022 15:07

I'd keep it very short and factual

"I made DD available for contact with her father as specified in the court order. She tested negative negative twice in the 48 hours befor his contact. It is not up to me to decide how XH uses his contact time. He receives the same information as I do from the school. I suggest you ask him about the decision to bring her to your house during his contact time"

Goldbar · 27/01/2022 15:05

I would keep it short and simple.

'Please refer these comments to your son/ the judge. It's up to him what he does during his parenting time which is court-ordered. Nowt to do with me.'

Hope ex-FIL is better soon.'

LookItsMeAgain · 27/01/2022 15:04

@AmandaHoldensLips

"Please direct your angry message at your useless son who brings daughter to you because he cannot be bothered to spend time with her on his own. And I don't need a "break" from my daughter. It is her contact time with her father."
I don't know if you've responded yet @Negative12hoursthenPositive, but if you haven't, I think what @AmandaHoldensLips has said is nearly bang on.

I'd have to tweak the last bit about the contact time with her father by saying something like "It's the court-ordered contact her father has with her. I suggest that you take it up with him if you're not happy with what he's doing with that"
or something along those lines. Point out really clearly that it's court-ordered time, not "mum wants time to get her hair and nails done" time, or a "girls boozy afternoon session time".

He's probably given her a misguided impression of what that time is supposed to be for.

ClawedButler · 27/01/2022 15:03

You don't need to explain anything.

Never wrestle with a pig. You both get covered in sh1t, but the pig likes it.

Enough4me · 27/01/2022 15:02

I wouldn't reply, having nothing to attack presents her a blank wall. You do not need to defend yourself, you do not need to reply.

An argument cannot exist if you back away. I'd simply let your ex know that you are not entering into communication unless it specifically refers to DD, e.g. pick up and drop off times.

Strongerthanyouthink · 27/01/2022 15:02

I would completely ignore the message. They sound just as lovely as my ex in laws! You won't be able to change their perspective whatever clever reply you send. It's not worth the energy!

ClawedButler · 27/01/2022 15:02

"Dear MIL. Lol you're so funny. Kisses, Negative12"

Mummyoflittledragon · 27/01/2022 15:02

You should address your anger to your useless son. I don’t want a break from my daughter and contact is court ordered. The school inform all parents of the covid numbers and close contacts. Armed with this information, he still chose to bring my daughter to your home. She tested negative before collection. What happens after that point is not under my control.

ClawedButler · 27/01/2022 15:01

Yes the ex-MIL in question was well and truly hoist by her own petard on that one. Thought she'd be malicious and ended up doing my friend a massive favour!

Isaw3ships · 27/01/2022 15:01

Wouldn’t even give it headspace - ignore her and don’t reply. She’ll either calm down and realise that ExDH is responsible for your DD being at hers not you or continue to blame you because that’s they way things work with them.
Either way there’s nothing to be gained by engaging with her.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 15:00

@LannieDuck

I would say.

"I didn't send DD to you. I make her available for court-ordered contact with Ex-H, and he decides where to take her during that time. He receives all the information available from DD's school about Covid exposures. I suggest you take this up with your son."

this.

when dealing with arseholes its best not to give them ammo, only facts.

Belladonna12 · 27/01/2022 15:00

YANBU. I'm not sure that this is your exes fault either though. They choose to see your DD knowing that she could easily get infected at school. I don't necessarily disagree with that choice but they shouldn't blame other people for their decision. Many ECV have children at school and they just have to live with the risk. At least there are antivirals now and presumably your FIL is eligible for them.

Blossomtoes · 27/01/2022 14:59

Just ignore her. She’s stressed and lashing out. No good will come of escalating it.

TrufflesAndToast · 27/01/2022 14:58

@ClawedButler

I know of an ex-MIL to a friend of mine. Totally blind to her son's faults, thought the mother (my friend) was unfit etc. The MIL reported my friend to social services. Social services turned up, took one look at the living situation and agreed that yes, the child had an unfit parent - the father. Divorce is proceeding uncontested. The father has been granted access to his son IF he can provide negative drug tests. So far, he hasn't managed it once in a year.

Every day we thank heaven for his deranged mother - it got my friend out of a horrible situation that she thought she couldn't afford to escape.

Blimey I bet she didn’t plan that Grin
saraclara · 27/01/2022 14:58

"I didn't send DD to you. I make her available for court-ordered contact with Ex-H, and he decides where to take her during that time. He receives all the information available from DD's school about Covid exposures. I suggest you take this up with your son."

So far I like this one best. It's very concise, clear and unemotional. There's nothing to argue with in it at all.

ClawedButler · 27/01/2022 14:56

I know of an ex-MIL to a friend of mine. Totally blind to her son's faults, thought the mother (my friend) was unfit etc. The MIL reported my friend to social services. Social services turned up, took one look at the living situation and agreed that yes, the child had an unfit parent - the father. Divorce is proceeding uncontested. The father has been granted access to his son IF he can provide negative drug tests. So far, he hasn't managed it once in a year.

Every day we thank heaven for his deranged mother - it got my friend out of a horrible situation that she thought she couldn't afford to escape.

Fletchersromancing · 27/01/2022 14:55

AmandaHoldensLips
"Please direct your angry message at your useless son who brings daughter to you because he cannot be bothered to spend time with her on his own. And I don't need a "break" from my daughter. It is her contact time with her father."

I would use this reply and then block the ex in laws.

Winniemarysarah · 27/01/2022 14:55

I’d put ‘it looks like we’re both sorry that your son is too lazy and incompetent to take care of his own child twice a month. x was tested before he took her to your house and she was negative. And contact was ordered by the court for her to spend time with her dad, not for me to ‘have a break’. If it’s too much and you and your son think I should have less ‘breaks’, then by all means let me know and we’ll have the order changed and I’ll have her 100% of the time. Hope you’re all feeling better soon.