Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

recording without consent

32 replies

thelegalitiesof · 27/01/2022 12:38

The situation:

A young adult doesn't understand most jokes. The carer of the young adult has been heavily involved with the young adult for years and will know them well by now. The young adult claims that their carer has been making jokes during their time together knowing that the young adult doesn't understand most jokes and gets them wound up. The young adult is visibly frustrated but the carer continues and doesn't reveal that it's a joke until they are very wound up and visibly angry. The young adults frustration and anger will draw out for some time even at home. The carer lives with them and has been complaining about their anger and frustration because they are coming across as rude. This has happened on two recent occasions back to back, and they have not been spending time together since because the young adult doesn't like them.

The carer denies winding them up but admits that they were making jokes. If the young adult were to spend time with them again would it be unreasonable for the young adult to record for the duration of their time together without the knowledge or consent of the carer incase they wind them up again and then share that without permission as evidence towards becoming emancipated from the carer.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thelnebriati · 27/01/2022 14:58

If the carer is denying the claim, I think the young adult will have a stronger case if the point of the recording is to show them withdrawing consent for the jokes, and the carer ignoring that. So let the carer indulge in the 'joke', then the YA says 'I want you to stop doing that'.

I dont have a link but have a vague recollection that even tickling can be considered abusive, if it carries on beyone the point at which the recipient finds it funny. I would assume these 'jokes' would fall into that category.

Alpinechalet · 27/01/2022 14:24

This is abuse, I would help the young adult record the behaviour and to report. Whilst there may be legal niceties about whether or not the recording would be permissible in court the reality is a human being is being deliberately provoked utilising the fact their disability means they don’t understand the joke. However, without evidence it’s difficult to prove.

There are many examples of families using cctv etc. to catch carers physically abusing children, vulnerable adults or stealing etc. as a result action is taken.

The priority here is to safe guard the young adult.

Lucinda7 · 27/01/2022 14:04

It's very unkind to deliberately wind a person up by repeatedly making so called jokes that they are unable to understand. The carer is doing the very opposite of caring.

MayThePawsBeWithYou · 27/01/2022 13:41

I would support the y.a to put in an application for extra housing, and encourage them to speak to the local authority or social services to say how unhappy they are in the current situation.

MadeForThis · 27/01/2022 13:17

It sounds more like bullying than making jokes.

newnameforthis76 · 27/01/2022 13:14

What outcome is the young person hoping for? Do they want to move out? Do they want their step-parent to get thrown out? Because if it’s the latter they are hoping for, I don’t think it’s going to be as simple as showing their parent a video of their step-parent being a bit of a dick. It’s going to have to be pretty bad for the parent to end their marriage over.

MayThePawsBeWithYou · 27/01/2022 13:12

Whats your relationship here, are you the parent. Is there any personal care given. Why do they need evidence, if they say the carer deliberately winds them up them the parent needs to tell them to stop. What happens to the y.a. if the carer is banned from that role.

thelegalitiesof · 27/01/2022 13:11

@SeasonFinale

Yes the young adult is looking to move out.
They will need to apply for assisted living. Priority is given to young adults in certain circumstances so obtaining evidence against the step parent would be a good idea

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 27/01/2022 13:09

typos galore^ I assume the young adult is looking to move out?

SeasonFinale · 27/01/2022 13:08

So the young adult basically wants their step parent to no longer receive their carer's allowance. Om the basis the young adult is actually living in the step parent's home I assume the young adult is also looking to kive out? Otherwise I don't see what outcome they are expecting.

thelegalitiesof · 27/01/2022 13:07

@burnoutbabe

I am not the parent or the young adult in this situation
The young adult has reached out to me
The young adult is not believed by their parent

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 27/01/2022 13:04

byt what outcome is wanted?

to get the carer removed so they don't get any money from SS?

Surely reporting to a parent would be enough to get the step parent removed from the role/the house.

stressedy · 27/01/2022 13:03

the poor carer... absolutely not should a recording be taken what a misuse of trust. change the carer if this the case !

AtLeastPretendToCare · 27/01/2022 13:02

Is this person 18 or older? If so what are they asking social services for exactly?

Hont1986 · 27/01/2022 13:01

The young adult doesn't want to raise this with social services etc before obtaining evidence

Even if they do obtain the evidence, what do they think social services is going to with a report of a parent making jokes that their child doesn't understand?

thelegalitiesof · 27/01/2022 13:00

@scaredsadandstuck
That's what I thought. That's why I'm enquiring about recording without consent

OP posts:
Hont1986 · 27/01/2022 12:59

Why have you worded this so cautiously? If this is a parent/child situation then say it, it is relevant.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 27/01/2022 12:58

I honestly don’t know @scaredsadandstuck - I know it’s fine to record, the question of disclosure is a different one altogether. I don’t know if it’s something the ICO could advise on?

thelegalitiesof · 27/01/2022 12:57

The carer is recieving carers allowance for caring for the young adult. So they are not with an agency but are still being payed.

I believe the young adult is telling the truth but they will need a recording to prove the carer has been winding them up as the carer has been denying the claim

OP posts:
scaredsadandstuck · 27/01/2022 12:57

@GingerAndTheBiscuits

The young adult can record whatever they want, covertly or otherwise. The difficulty arises when the young adult wishes to disclose the recordings. Consent to disclose could be overridden if there were safeguarding concerns. But I’m not sure who would make the judgement about disclosure - does the young adult have a social worker? Or advocate?
Would that count if the young adult is disclosing to a parent?
scaredsadandstuck · 27/01/2022 12:56

I would worry that saying up front that they will be recording could drive the apparently cruel behaviour underground so it becomes more sneaky. It's a possibility if the step parent is a nasty piece of work and enjoys being unkind.

LIZS · 27/01/2022 12:56

Has the young adult told the step parent that they do not enjoy being wound up? Or their parent ?

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 27/01/2022 12:55

The young adult can record whatever they want, covertly or otherwise. The difficulty arises when the young adult wishes to disclose the recordings. Consent to disclose could be overridden if there were safeguarding concerns. But I’m not sure who would make the judgement about disclosure - does the young adult have a social worker? Or advocate?

thelegalitiesof · 27/01/2022 12:54

The young adult has capacity and can consent. The carer drives the young adult and cares for them as a parent would ie doing dishes and cooking.

The young adult doesn't want to raise this with social services etc before obtaining evidence as the carer has denied winding them up

OP posts:
WhenTheyComeForYou · 27/01/2022 12:53

If it's just the step parent, and you feel you need evidence of it, then yes I'd record. It's not like they can get you sacked is it.

But if ask yourself why you feel you need the evidence. The young adult has disclosed the situation, do you believe them?