Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by nursery funding for children living in poverty

339 replies

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 10:19

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

OP posts:
Peasandcabbage · 27/01/2022 13:22

Scotland here

Every child gets 30 hours term time or the equivalent hours spread over fifty weeks. From age three. Some two year olds are also eligible, and now under the give them time campaign many five year olds will also get an additional year.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2022 13:21

I think if you’re thinking of this as a safeguarding concern then these children won’t necessarily be sent anywhere even if they do have funding

Precisely - we always see "improve the funding/provision" on these threads, and then the excuses about why it "can't" be accessed, but the situation's far more complex than that and can come down to what parents simply don't want to do

Much the same happened locally with holiday clubs set up so children could continue to get their FSM. Even with transport offered the take-up was pathetic, because too many just wanted the money - and too often to spend on anything but the children

PrincessNikla · 27/01/2022 13:20

@Crunchyapplez
PrincessNikla

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are only working up to 16 hours, then you have time to spend teaching your child by going to groups, and other activities.

Or, you could work more hours and take the advantages that that offers

You’ve solved inequality @PrincessNikla !

Not seeing your point there. I work full time, and still made time for the learning opportunities for me DC - less than 16 hours a week, is not even 2 days out of 7 - what is stopping people using some of those other days / hours with their own dc if they choose not to be in work? If there are reasons for not working, then fair enough but for the majority of people out there, there is no reason why they cannot work more hours

Peppapigforlife · 27/01/2022 13:19

@Liverbird77

If you're not working and are at home with the children full time, there are lots of free things to do to complement the 15 hours.

I am a stay at home mum, luckily not disadvantaged financially, but we still do lots of free stuff each week (and could do more if it was the only option).

Examples:
Library story time, plus weekend events at the library e.g. Lego/coding/classical association.
A "prepare for school" weekly free two hour session run by SureStart at a local primary school. Free fruit is also provided.
Two free Little Superstars sports sessions per week.
All of these can be used alongside the 15 hours.

My son goes to a preschool at an independent prep. 15 hours equates to 1.5 days there. They don't specify a minimum number of hours, so that could indeed be totally free with no top up.

What I am saying is that there is a lot out there.
The problem lies with those people who will not engage. An extra 15 hours is not going to mitigate for that.

Not every area has this. In my city the sure start centres are oversubscribed and the spaces go on the day they announce them. I got invited to a forest school group that's £8 per session! The only group I've found that I can afford is once a week. The library here does a 20 minute sing a long per week and that's it. Also buses cost a fortune. It's a fiver to go anywhere. If you're on UC that fiver every day is a lot. Plus if your nursery only has certain hours available, they might clash with the groups running and you then have an afternoon of nothing to do as you can't afford swimming, or the yummy mummy groups. I've moved from a more deprived area, where my daughter could only do morning sessions as the afternoons were almost empty and she wouldn't have had anyone to play with and all the local groups there were, were in the morning. So we had nothing to do all afternoon. Libraries only recently re opened but even when we went back, they were only open on certain days and closed for big chunks part way through the day.
ConstanceL · 27/01/2022 13:18

@OfstedOffred

I think the issue is confusion over the extended hours. Those are to promote people working. 15h/week is enough in terms of early years education.
Yes this ^ It is to support parents being able to work full-time. You will get free full-time education the academic year they turn 5 but if you are working part-time, you don't need full-time childcare up until then right? Or am I missing something?

I agree the £100k threshold seems quite high though.

parkstrife · 27/01/2022 13:17

@Hospedia

Library story time, plus weekend events at the library e.g. Lego/coding/classical association.

Not much good if your local library is closed, on vastly reduced hours, or not within easy travelling distance.

A "prepare for school" weekly free two hour session run by SureStart at a local primary school.

Again not available in all areas. SureStart was decimated by this government, many of the centres are either closed or operate restricted services.

Two free Little Superstars sports sessions per week.

See above.

All of these can be used alongside the 15 hours.

Only if you can access them.

There are some cheap activities, just not as many as there used to be, especially after Covid. All the £££ activities started up as soon as they could, the cheap or free sessions either didn't or started later. Many Sure Starts have closed and the rest often have less sessions. There are some, it's just not as easy as it used to be to access them.
limitlessval · 27/01/2022 13:15

In addition to this our childminder won’t even do the 15 hours, despite the fact our child is eligible as it’s not cost or time effective for her (which I get) so have to wait until a preschool place becomes available. We are very out of pocket at the moment.

Gemini6 · 27/01/2022 13:14

@funinthesun19

My daughter couldn't start preschool until she received her funded hours at 3 years and 3 months because I work so she wasn't entitled to 2 year old funding and I couldn't afford to send her. That doesn't seem fair to me either. So then being able to do the 30 hours allows children like mine to catch up on the year they missed out on due to having a mother that works!

The 2 year funding isn’t for the parents to have a break while they’re not working. It’s free education for children from disadvantaged backgrounds to help close the gap.
I understand your frustration as your dd missed out, but I don’t think it’s right to begrudge those 2 year places for children who will benefit so much from them.

When my DS was 2, he got the funding because of his disability and was nothing to do with my work status. The way his speech came along after he started was truly amazing.
A few years later, after becoming a newly single parent, my DD then qualified for the 2 year funding. This time it was because of my work status. She thrived more than she would have done if she didn’t go.

Most of us are just trying to do the best for our children. If taking advantage of free education helps children then I’m all for it.

I understand your situation however I didn't say I wanted free childcare while I was working. I said my daughter was disadvantaged due to me working. Which I think is unfair. It doesn't mean I begrudge your children from it, but think its unfair that my daughter didn't get the same access to early education because I couldn't afford to be a stay at home Mum. In fact I would have sent her while I was at work so that I could still spend as much time as possible with her, not used it for a break so I could sit around doing nothing!
funinthesun19 · 27/01/2022 13:14

If this were 'childcare' it could perhaps be acceptable. But it is NOT. It is early education. It's SO important for children born in more deprived circumstances to have the benefit of this from age 2.

I agree with you. I think my post got lost in the busy thread, but I explained why my children benefitted from it.

When DS was 2 he got the 2 year funding because of his disability and not because of my work status.
A few years later, DD qualified because of my circumstances at the time.

Lo and behold, both of them benefitted from that time at nursery immensely.

Some people can’t see past the the parents though and don’t even realise what the 2 year funding is for/ don’t care.

limitlessval · 27/01/2022 13:13

I’m retraining, so currently a student, I’m flat out with written work and on a placement for the NHS but as it’s not paid work we only get 15 hours. We live off my partners salary which is very tight. It really doesn’t work for our circumstances.

Socialcarenope · 27/01/2022 13:12

@Itstime1

Just to say you’re not eligible for the free hours if you earn over 100k.

Which is annoying as everyone assumes you are but your not. You also don’t get the tax free childcare.

Not complaining as we are fortunate enough to plan for this but still!

It's not that cut and dry, there are things you can do that continue your entitlement like up your pension contributions. It's not a simple case of £100k cut off.
Liverbird77 · 27/01/2022 13:11

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Peppapigforlife · 27/01/2022 13:10

If I was allocated the 30 hours from the get go, I'd be in work by now or growing a business and my daughter would be occupied all day with other children and group activities instead of stuck at home watching TV because I'm too poor to take her anywhere!

qualitygirl · 27/01/2022 13:09

I'm in Ireland and EVERY Child gets free (and I mean free) 15 hours nursery in the two years before school starts. Surely the U.K. could do similar. When I say free, I didn't pay a cent for my kids to go. 9:00 -12:00 daily from the age of 3-5 (started school at age 5)

Peppapigforlife · 27/01/2022 13:08

The issue for me personally I'd that the system of nursery hours makes it almost impossible to find a decent job. I've got my 15 hours, which is great if I want to find a few hours of minimum wage work, but if I want to find a better paid full time work, it's impossible, because you don't get the 30 hours until you're already ready to start that job, but the nurseries and childminders in my area have waitlists until September. There's no job out there that would let me start in September and when September comes, I won't be able to take one of those 30 hour funded places without already having secured a job. I have to wait until my DD is in school. Then the funded hours are only in term time.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 13:08

‘People are getting confused and not understanding the funding or purpose of funding.’

@MaryShelley1818 it was an election pledge from David Cameron. That was its purpose.

The two years’ provision replaced funding for Sure Start / children’s centres. Those children who get the two years’ provision (with a purpose of closing the gap of educational disadvantage, don’t then receive the same hours’ as their more affluent peer (widening the gap still further)).

OP posts:
endlesssighing · 27/01/2022 13:06

@Crunchyapplez

Why would they be 'upset?'
30 free hours of childcare is a tax credit, not an entitlement. They don't need the assistance therefore they pay for it. He's more upset he doesn't see his children as much as he'd like but so is life. He himself was raised in abject poverty like the children you are referencing to and he doesn't want that for his own children, so why the sneering?

You've stated nursery is not 'just childcare' and you are correct. Every child age 3+ (parent, working or not) is entitled to fifteen hours free early years education. That's 2+ when said child meets a 'disadvantaged' criteria. The additional 15 hours is to assist parents who are working and many preschool schedules have fifteen hours a week directed learning with the rest free play so yes - 'childcare'.

If your argument is that ALL CHILDREN are entitled to free childcare and the education that comes with it then that should include children whose parents earn £200,000.

According to Nuffield Health three year olds who access childcare do marginally better than their peers in certain tests but that the educational benefits are temporary and wear off by the age of five.

The argument could additionally be made that children who attend nursery for fifteen hours a week are at a greater advantage than those who attend nursery full time.

Children who attended a low quality childcare facilities full time (which are RIFE) have statistically been found to make delayed social, emotional and cognitive progression in comparison to their peers, regardless of economic background.

If there is an increase of ALL children 2+ attending nurseries full time then spaces are going to become even more scarce than they already are. Additionally that draws into the question of what legislation and governing bodies are then going to be enforced to ensure that an equal standard of care will be provided to avoid this?

MrsR87 · 27/01/2022 13:05

The 15 hours are more for the child than the parent.
If you are working less than 16 hours a week why would you need more hours?

Everyone will have their own ideas and stories but I feel there should be more to help full time working parents who have one year olds. I am at my place of work from 7.30-5pm every weekday, sometimes longer and the nursery fees for my one year old are a lot more than my mortgage! I’m lucky that I earn a good enough wage to still bring home a reasonable amount but for the amount of work I do ( I also have to work at home at weekends to complete my duties) it makes me question whether it is all worth it.

Booboobibles · 27/01/2022 13:05

The government should not be providing funding for rich families to become even more rich.

If they provided free places to poor people who are not working, maybe it would give those people a bit of time and space to improve their lives.

Alayalaya · 27/01/2022 13:03

‘ If you're not working and are at home with the children full time, there are lots of free things to do to complement the 15 hours.’
That assumes you’re capable of doing them. Depending on your reason for not working, you may be unable to do those things. If you’re an addict, depressed, uneducated, etc - you aren’t going to be able to engage with that. You’re also assuming the activities are within walking distance, which is rarely the case, and people with difficulties probably don’t have money for bus fares.

Wam90 · 27/01/2022 13:03

I think YABU.
Yes the child shouldn’t suffer because they live in poverty but what about the children that are suffering who don’t. They don’t see their parents all week because they’re working full time to provide for them and they may still only be in nursery for 17 actual “free” hours a week because it’s based on school terms so the parents are still having to pay for 20 hours of childcare a week to actually be able to work in their full time jobs.
It’s not the children’s fault but it’s all messed up. Work 16 hours a week or less and you get lots of financial support in other ways.
I think if you’re thinking of this as a safeguarding concern then these children won’t necessarily be sent anywhere even if they do have funding.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/01/2022 12:59

... a separation of ‘childcare’ from ‘education’ in terms of culture and attitudes

While I don't disagree, OP, I suspect that one might be a struggle
In a culture where some insist that even school is childcare, and when it's become a verbal shorthand for so much, it could be very hard to row back now

Alayalaya · 27/01/2022 12:59

‘ What do you need childcare for if you're not employed? ’
Think about why people might be unemployed. It could be due to physical and mental disability, lack of education, drugs or alcohol, living in poverty, etc. In such circumstances it’s better to remove the child from the home and send them to nursery. The parents don’t need childcare - it’s for the benefit of the child, to get them away from the parents.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 27/01/2022 12:55

There’s the usual disparagement of high earners on this thread. Earning 100k a year people are paying a lot of tax, which is used to fund the childcare places and all the other support vulnerable children need. I don’t think there should be an upper limit on childcare places.

MaryShelley1818 · 27/01/2022 12:55

[quote EllieQ]You’re conflating funding for two different things.

Every child from the age of 3 is eligible for 15 hours funding for early education. As studies have shown that children in low-income families are already behind (educationally) when they start school, this was extended to fund children age 2 from low income families. Think of the stereotype of children who get very little interaction at home/ don’t get taken to activities or playgroups for whatever reason - the government thinks that being a nursery will improve things for these children (learning letters and numbers, being ready for school).

The additional 15 hours was brought in a few years later with the aim of reducing childcare costs for families where both parents work. It is term-time only and didn’t cover all our nursery costs (we still got charged extra per day), but was a great help.

The assumption is that if you’re working