Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by nursery funding for children living in poverty

339 replies

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 10:19

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

OP posts:
Peasandcabbage · 27/01/2022 21:02

@sanbeiji that's an excellent post I agree

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 21:01

@sanbeiji

OP your argument is that the huge gap between wealthier kids and their poorer counterparts would be remedied by more free nursery hours. That's not the point though is it.

Children benefit the most from being with a SINGLE primary carer. Who tailors their learning etc to their individual needs. All day, every day they're learning.
An extra 15 hours a week of nursery isn't going to close this gap.

I definitely don’t think that extra nursery would ^remedy^ inequality in educational outcomes for disadvantaged children.

But where you have a known gap of 11 months in attainment between a poor child and their wealthier classmate when they start school, I would be focusing on the addressing the issue of disadvantage (rather than exacerbating it by formally restricting access to nursery for those children).

By the way, I am not sure that you are totally correct that the extra 15 hours would not have positive impact (although quality of provision is more influential than hours spent).

OP posts:
Peasandcabbage · 27/01/2022 20:58

@liveforsummer could I please PM you re this? Don't want to hijack thread but I'm at home, with three under three. School being very pushy re nursery hours being increased and I don't want to.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/01/2022 20:55

@dorkfink

Giving 30 hours childcare to everyone working less than 16 hours a week is an expensive sledgehammer

Do you think? It's max about 3.5k per child for the year, so I think it's affordable for children from bad homes personally.

How do you work out which kids get it though? You're saying it's worth it for the kids in bad homes but there isn't enough intervention to know who they all are
Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 20:51

@SomePosters

It doesn’t make economic sense to punish the children for their parents failings even if you do think they deserve it

I find it difficult to understand why parental income is even part of the conversation when it comes to education. And you are right: widening the gap further between rich and poor makes no economic sense.

OP posts:
sanbeiji · 27/01/2022 20:27

@SomePosters

There’s a school of thought that in order for true equality between the sexes there would need to be state funded open to all 24hr child care

When I first heard it my brain revolted but the more I thought about it the more I realised that it would to so much to prevent vulnerable children from being neglected without in anyway challenging the parents

Wether you’re not available to your children because you’re a high flying in demand surgeon or because you haven’t recovered from surgery or a traumatic childhood

It’s every child’s entitlement to have food to eat and to be nurtured, regardless of their parents economic status.

It should be offered to each child not wether or not the parents deserve it but because the child does

Early intervention prevents dysfunction in later life, mental health issues, stress related health issues and crime

It doesn’t make economic sense to punish the children for their parents failings even if you do think they deserve it

That does exist! It's called foster care. Honestly we can go round and round and round but so much of a kids' future is determined by their surroundings.

The only way to REALLY give them equal opportunity is to take them away from damaging parents and put them in boarding school, nurturing environment, but we can't do that can we?

Again this is for vulnerable children.

Not be conflated with 'low-income' families. Many an immigrant family values education highly and push their kids to become high achievers. If the parents aren't abusive/incapable, just don't really know much about all the stuff MC parents do then helping them through things like Sure Start etc would be great

sanbeiji · 27/01/2022 20:23

OP your argument is that the huge gap between wealthier kids and their poorer counterparts would be remedied by more free nursery hours.
That's not the point though is it.

Children benefit the most from being with a SINGLE primary carer. Who tailors their learning etc to their individual needs. All day, every day they're learning.
An extra 15 hours a week of nursery isn't going to close this gap.

SomePosters · 27/01/2022 20:20

There’s a school of thought that in order for true equality between the sexes there would need to be state funded open to all 24hr child care

When I first heard it my brain revolted but the more I thought about it the more I realised that it would to so much to prevent vulnerable children from being neglected without in anyway challenging the parents

Wether you’re not available to your children because you’re a high flying in demand surgeon or because you haven’t recovered from surgery or a traumatic childhood

It’s every child’s entitlement to have food to eat and to be nurtured, regardless of their parents economic status.

It should be offered to each child not wether or not the parents deserve it but because the child does

Early intervention prevents dysfunction in later life, mental health issues, stress related health issues and crime

It doesn’t make economic sense to punish the children for their parents failings even if you do think they deserve it

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 20:08

It wouldn’t be that expensive @BoredZelda.

The IFS estimate that extending the entitlement to disadvantaged 3 and 4 year olds would cost an extra £165 million (the existing 30 hour entitlement costs £735 million).

OP posts:
HighlandPony · 27/01/2022 20:02

It doesn’t really matter. Those of us on lower incomes get very little benefit from those free funded hours anyway. We mostly work antisocial hours. Nurseries typically run 8am-6pm. That’s not helping if you’re on a till a Tescos till 10pm or pulling pints till midnight or on the nightshift in a packing factory or starting work at an Amazon depot at 6am.

liveforsummer · 27/01/2022 19:55

I'm in Scotland where everyone gets 30h. I work in a school in a very deprived area who offers this. Apart from those actually suffering neglect or in abusive homes I don't think this is what's best for them if being at home is an option. Lots of the nursery staff agree

RobotValkyrie · 27/01/2022 19:55

In more civilised countries, "childcare" for 3 to 5 year old kids is in fact called "education" (nursery school), so everyone gets the same number of hours for free.

randomsabreuse · 27/01/2022 19:48

The more universal something is the more likely the it is that those who need it will be willing to access it - universal free school meals in KS1 springs to mind.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:41

The additional 15 hours (on top of the initial 15) is for the benefit of the family as a whole - so that the parents can work and provide for them.

It's also a benefit for the tax man, as it keeps women in work.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 19:39

Giving 30 hours childcare to everyone working less than 16 hours a week is an expensive sledgehammer

Do you think? It's max about 3.5k per child for the year, so I think it's affordable for children from bad homes personally.

BoredZelda · 27/01/2022 19:21

It’s about getting the kids world experience outside of their dysfunctional family bubble

Not all children of families who work part time are dysfunctional.

It’s a good way to keep a closer eye on then and improving their chances of turning into functional adults

And there are other ways to identify and support these families individually. Giving 30 hours childcare to everyone working less than 16 hours a week is an expensive sledgehammer and means there is less funding available for those who actually need it.

BoredZelda · 27/01/2022 19:16

Just wanted to say I think this is fantastic idea. Not that you should have to do it though and these things should be easy for her to access in the future.

I am very fortunate I am in the situation where I can do it!

My DS’s DLA is currently up for renewal and I can’t describe how stressed I am about it.

It is so stressful! We also have a motability car as we need adaptions and something big enough to carry her stuff. If we lose DLA, we lose the car and that would be a big problem for us. We hold our breath every time and this last one took them 11 weeks to come back to us!

Eggmcmuffin · 27/01/2022 18:58

I'm pretty sure here in Wales there is paid childcare for 2 year olds related to being on certain benefits too. Any free childcare when you don't work seems pretty good to me

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/01/2022 18:47

I agree child protection is another thing. Sadly those children most in need won’t be sent to anything that isn’t mandatory.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/01/2022 18:46

Children don’t need 30 hours education at that age though. The additional 15 hours (on top of the initial 15) is for the benefit of the family as a whole - so that the parents can work and provide for them.

The initial 15 hours is enough to meet their needs for interaction and education - or at least that’s the decision that’s been reached.

My kids didn’t get it either as at the time I was self employed and worked in an industry with very high overheads - it was based on gross not net, but my gross was equivalent to a much lower gross salary for an employer person.

Anyway I’ve since left that highly stressful industry!

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 18:16

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

It's an incentive which brings in more tax then it costs a family like the above. However I think kids from certain home lives should be eligible regardless of hours worked

SomePosters · 27/01/2022 18:10

@FateHasRedesignedMost

Childcare isn’t charity. The funding for 2 year olds allows disadvantaged children to access nursery, while other parents (who may work but just miss the threshold) have to pay for their own childcare. Nursery can’t make up for a child living in poverty, and if they offered FT nursery places to these children it would be even less incentive for the parents to work and fund their own childcare!

Working 30 hours a week doesn’t mean a family can afford childcare; without that funding a lot of women would be unable to re-enter the workforce full time (or at all). People often pay hundreds a month in childcare and use the 30 free hours to top it up to full time.

More needs to be done to tackle poverty, neglect and children being raised in unsuitable housing, but more free nursery hours won’t solve anything.

It’s not about the parents paying for their own childcare

It’s about getting the kids world experience outside of their dysfunctional family bubble

It’s a very successful preventative measure and social services have been giving out free full time nursery places for kids who they deem need it

It’s a good way to keep a closer eye on then and improving their chances of turning into functional adults

SleepingStandingUp · 27/01/2022 18:01

DTwins will be in 15 hours next Jan. School only does half days. No way to get a job around that unless I can pay for private nursery until I get the 30 hours free but also the extra costs that those hours don't cover as I also have an older DS. So needs to be term time part time or will cost a fortune in wrap around for him. I get the logic of why it works how it does but it does feel counterintuitive unless you've got a lump of savings to get through those first months before free hours and UC childcare stuff is paid

trunktoes · 27/01/2022 18:01

15 hours a week is enough to provide an education. As others have said 30 hours is to help parents get to work. What you are trying to do here is plug the gap for bad parenting but you couldn't do that even with 30 hours free child care. The gap in attainment is down to what the parents are doing with their child at home - educational activities, reading stories etc - there is no way to make up for that and I am not sure that is the tax payers responsibility either

Alayalaya · 27/01/2022 17:21

‘ you don't get the 30 hours until you're already ready to start that job, but the nurseries and childminders in my area have waitlists until September.’
This is a huge problem. If you get a job the childcare isn’t available for months. And lots of nurseries won’t let you use just the free hours, they insist you must top up to full time even if you can’t afford it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread