Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by nursery funding for children living in poverty

339 replies

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 10:19

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

OP posts:
Snaketime · 27/01/2022 23:29

I get 15 hours free for my son, but he does 16 hours at nursery so I have to pay for that extra hour, add that to having to pay for my DD's school lunches it is crippling.
I dont think it is as much the rich vs poor that is causing the attainment gap, more the parents that care/don't care.

KittyKel · 27/01/2022 23:22

Not true, if one person earns over £100k you are both ineligible

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 23:11

This is better for the government because they're getting taxes off 2 people as oppose to just 1 person.
Exactly, but people think the gov are just being nice & generous 😆

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 23:09

@Snaketime

YANBU in what you say, YABU only complaining about this now. That has been the way it is for years. The idea is that it is because working parents NEED the childcare whereas parents that aren't working full time dont.
It is only really now that the impact of the policy can be considered. In the summer, the Sutton Trust did a report on this called ‘A Fair Start’, where they found evidence to suggest that this policy was widening the attainment gap between the children of poor and wealthier families.

There was an article on it in The Times today (‘Early Years Provision is a Mess’), which is why I started the thread @Snaketime.

OP posts:
Pinkrose1111 · 27/01/2022 23:06

@Crunchyapplez Well the idea behind it is to incentivise both parents to work. So they can tax both parents. And If it was £100k per household and say 1 parent is earning £80k and the other is earning £20k, but childcare is £1k+ per month, then parent 2 may aswell not work. Because there salary is pretty much going to childcare. But with the 30 hour funding, both parents can work put their kids in nursery for pretty cheap. This is better for the government because they're getting taxes off 2 people as oppose to just 1 person.

isit right? No, but these policies are put in place majority of the time for the benefit of the government and not the people.

Porcupineintherough · 27/01/2022 23:03

@felulageller required for what though?

Snaketime · 27/01/2022 23:00

YANBU in what you say, YABU only complaining about this now. That has been the way it is for years. The idea is that it is because working parents NEED the childcare whereas parents that aren't working full time dont.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 22:59

Basically, what I have learned from this thread is that a lot of people view ‘nursery’ as ‘childcare’, and that ‘nursery’ is unappreciated as an educational setting.

I sent my dcs to a state maintained nursery. It wasn’t childcare. It was a school (… an excellent one).

At the time, I didn’t realise that other families only got half the provision that my dcs received because they were poor. This is so clearly unacceptable to me, but not so with over half the people voting on here.

Basically, if you think ‘nursery’ is ‘childcare’ then you see the practicality of allocating extra hours to working families and it all makes sense. If you see it as ‘education’ then you might think that this policy disadvantages the already disadvantaged (… and find that unacceptable).

OP posts:
felulageller · 27/01/2022 22:55

Everyone should have a right to 24/7 childcare as required.

Funding should be generous with small contributions from those who can well afford it.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 22:47

@Pinkrose1111

this is not true. Someone earning £100k+ is excluded. And the idea is, if you're working less than 16 hours a week, why would you need 30 hours of childcare???
Both parents can earn up to £100 000 each @Pinkrose1111 before they cease to be eligible.
OP posts:
Pinkrose1111 · 27/01/2022 22:25

this is not true. Someone earning £100k+ is excluded. And the idea is, if you're working less than 16 hours a week, why would you need 30 hours of childcare???

parkstrife · 27/01/2022 22:19

@Crunchyapplez

I am surprised that few MNetters on this thread find the divisive nature of the policy unacceptable.

When government policy treats rich and poor children differently in the same educational setting, what do you think that looks like?

Would the answer be to have GP/SS/HV recommendations for 30 free hours for children who would benefit from it? It would then target the children who need it? There will be children who are better off at nursery for more hours than at home, due to their family situation. Sometimes primary carers are not able to provide the level of care needed.

It needs to be about the best interests of the children, not down to whether the parents "deserve" another 15 free hours of childcare. If it's better for some children to get the 15 extra hours, they should get it. Economically, it's cheaper to invest in their futures.

sqirrelfriends · 27/01/2022 22:16

I don't understand why 30 hours would be needed if the parents don't work.

I understand the sentiment but I think the council deal with exceptional cases on an individual basis.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 22:04

I am surprised that few MNetters on this thread find the divisive nature of the policy unacceptable.

When government policy treats rich and poor children differently in the same educational setting, what do you think that looks like?

OP posts:
worriedatthemoment · 27/01/2022 22:04

I wouldn't of wanted my kids in for 30 hrs at 2 or 3 whilst I was at home

jlg22 · 27/01/2022 21:48

Sessions outside of “education hours” are also not covered so pre 9am lunch times and post 3pm so the majority of families using nursery for full days pay for all these hours plus subsidies for a higher hourly rate than the government pay.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 21:48

@qualitygirl ime there are dc that would benefit because not all "bad" homes/parents are as you say.

Plus there are plenty of parents who are engaged but don't qualify because they don't work enough hours & working more it's not cost effective or practical for them

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 21:45

However my point was extending it to kids already known to be in need would not be expensive

qualitygirl · 27/01/2022 21:44

@dorkfink I think you are assuming that children from "bad" homes have parents who will care about even getting them to childcare...a lot of them don't. They wouldn't be bothered sending them if it required work on their part. By that I mean...waking them, dressing them, walking/driving them to nursery. They are too selfish for that. Their children are an inconvenience...that's the reality.

dorkfink · 27/01/2022 21:44

But giving to to everyone isn’t just giving it to children from “bad homes” is it?

If we give it to everyone, that includes those who don’t need it. I’d rather provide more for the kids who really need it.

The majority qualify for the extra hours as most mothers work & most people don't earn 100k so I don't think if it was universal it would be a huge cost.

BoredZelda · 27/01/2022 21:32

Children benefit the most from being with a SINGLE primary carer.

Source?

BoredZelda · 27/01/2022 21:31

Do you think? It's max about 3.5k per child for the year, so I think it's affordable for children from bad homes personally.

But giving to to everyone isn’t just giving it to children from “bad homes” is it?

If we give it to everyone, that includes those who don’t need it. I’d rather provide more for the kids who really need it.

liveforsummer · 27/01/2022 21:30

@Peasandcabbage welcome to pm. I've no idea how it works as never done so before, assume will get a notification?

HighlandPony · 27/01/2022 21:19

Most of us who have been in foster care will tell you it’s not. No real sense of family, shifted to another home just when you start to feel settled, most Foster parents haven’t got a clue about life from your background, never really fitting in, always being different, always waiting on some overworked or can’t be bothered social worker to approve this or do that. Nope. Foster care is no picnic.

Peasandcabbage · 27/01/2022 21:05

@sanbeiji your post re foster care.

Swipe left for the next trending thread