Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by nursery funding for children living in poverty

339 replies

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 10:19

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 28/01/2022 10:12

Why are children getting reduced (or privileged) access to education based on what their parents earn? We wouldn’t accept this for primary or secondary school children
And yet we regularly have threads about how being a sahm is best for young children and that FT working mums are trying to do their best when they don't have a choice, but ultimately, it's never as good as being at home with mum so which is it?

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:59

How about working more hours so that your children don't live in poverty? Or, you know, do you own childcare of you don't work much?

Because it's that simple 🙄

Why do taxpayers always have to pay for everything?

that's what tax is for.....

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:58

but why 30 hours at 3? Why not 40 or 20. It's essential the school day so makes sense to have the same rhythm.

HomeSw33tHome · 28/01/2022 09:57

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

How about working more hours so that your children don't live in poverty? Or, you know, do you own childcare of you don't work much?
Why do taxpayers always have to pay for everything?

SleepingStandingUp · 28/01/2022 09:55

The kids are entitled to it
Kids are entitled to access to education and all the rest of it but why 30 hours at 3? Why not 40 or 20. Or, as is the case, 15. All children aged over 3 are entitled to 15 hours of education. Beyond that some parents choose to put their children in to childcare for their own personal reasons. The Govt "supports" this by providing extra hours of childcare free where its needed (ie no one else to have them) and things like tax free child care.
Why aren't all children entitled to childcare from 7 am - 7 pm 7 days a week and if we're deeming it something important enough that they should all be able to access to, why don't we make it mandatory?

SleepingStandingUp · 28/01/2022 09:50

in the 24hr nursery place system if she was admitted to hospital in the middle of the night her children could be taken (as if they had family) to a known and trusted care giver until she could collect or visit them instead of into emergency foster care how does this actually work though? You can't have building say open across the country with staff waiting for anyone to call cos they need a midnight babysitter. If it was an on call thing you wouldn't have one person per family because they need time off too. If she was taken into hospital and kept there 24 hours would you expect the same person to keep them and then drop them home at a sensible time or are they passed between people every 8 hours?? That's why WHEN it works well emergency Foster care is better than childcare, because it's a home environment not a creche.

Should people have better access to support? Yes. But I don't see how in reality you can offer everyone 24/7 childcare outside of SS

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:44

It’s not and never should be about wether the parents are entitled to it

The kids are entitled to it

i agree

SomePosters · 28/01/2022 09:42

@ToykotoLosAngeles

I know 3 mums who are SAHM because their husbands earn enough so they don't need to work (which doesn't require a £100k salary as they don't live in Mumsnetland). Should we be funding them for 30 hours as well? If not, what's the salary limit on which families should pay to top up from 16 to 30 hours?
Yes… all children should be entitled

Regardless of their parents circumstances

At the end of the day yea some people will stick their kids in childcare for long hours because they don’t want to bother parenting them

If that’s the case then their kids are better off with qualified Children’s workers who will engage with them, teach them the share nicely and use a spoon, encourage them to paint and express themselves and do all the things their parents should want to do

Because the children deserve these opportunities even is their dad earns 100k and their mum is a lazy sahm and can’t be arsed with her kids so just leaves them to fight and watch tv for 5 years before school

It’s not and never should be about wether the parents are entitled to it

The kids are entitled to it

SomePosters · 28/01/2022 09:37

You can really see on these threads who knows what poverty is really like

There is a grey area between perfect parenting and needing to have your children removed where most of us exist

Many homes don’t need their children taken away in order to be better parents. They just need somewhere to turn to before they break

Take my friend A for example.

She was a care kid herself so didn’t receive the nurturing she is now supposed to know how to demonstrate to her children.

Being a care kid though she’s no family support and like many care kids she had to breed her own family and now she’s permanently over stretched with an older daughter who stil needs her mum, a missile child whose additional needs means he gets 99% of mums attention and a younger child got has got used to this set up.

She loves her kids, keeps her house does her best to be everything they need

But she is one person, with a back injury just struggling quietly along

She doesn’t need her kids taken off her for their outcomes to improve but in the 24hr nursery place system if she was admitted to hospital in the middle of the night her children could be taken (as if they had family) to a known and trusted care giver until she could collect or visit them instead of into emergency foster care

When she has bad pain days and can’t function she could pop them in a taxi to somewhere safe

Having been raising my daughter entirely alone for a decade I have taken her to private medical appts, dentist appts, she has seen me breakdown in tears and running manic highs, I have cared for her when I haven’t slept for three days, when I’ve been up all night with d and v, when Im off my face on post surgery pain meds, I’ve cared for her entirely alone while having to crawl to the bathroom to wee

Not everyone who is struggling has kids who would be better off in care

There could be a better system, kinder to everyone and Thats brings kids out of poverty through education, early years intervention and by directly providing the support that families need.

But who would the posh twats feel superior to then?

randomsabreuse · 28/01/2022 09:37

@ToykotoLosAngeles

Very few of those who choose to be SAHM in those circumstances would use all of the 30h just because it was there. With my older child I used the 15 hours at the local school nursery class then added a couple of afternoons in the final term to help with school readiness for my August born. We did other activities in the afternoons because we had the financial opportunity.

I could afford to have DS in 5 days a week now but have chosen to prioritise a paid music class one morning - and he does other paid activities 2 of the afternoons he's not in nursery, which I wouldn't want to change just because of free nursery hours.

Free universal 30 hours would be unlikely to be heavily "exploited" by the SAHM by choice demographic!

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:36

I still claimed for the 30 hours so the school nursery could get the maximum funding despite not always needing it but it gave me flexibility.

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:35

I often sent mine for 20-25 hours whilst on mat leave or working as I worked 14 hours for a bit (but earned over the threshold). However I only work during term time so feel I have ample time with them!

SleepingStandingUp · 28/01/2022 09:30

I'm not convinced what the take up would be like tbh. Maybe that means it could be offered universally on the assumption uptake for the out of work would be low.

We qualify for the 30 hours from 3, I don't work so can't imagine sending them in that many hours. They'll do half days and that's plenty. I think it's good prep for Reception esp as it'll be at the same school, good socialisation beyond what we already do and I think they'll actually love it. But all day five days is such a lot when I'm not working so am home.

SleepingStandingUp · 28/01/2022 09:24

What you’re doing is assuming anyone who works less than 16 hours is a failure as a parent. Why is that?
Threads about nursery at 2 always seem to end up being about how all those kids are living in poverty with terrible parents who are either thick, disinterested or abusive and kids would be better off away from their parents / lazy, disinterested and send the kids to nursery because they can't be bothered to parent them

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:21

Should we be funding them for 30 hours as well?

Why not? If they are on maternity leave they would get it, or they could set up a business. They won't be receiving any child benefit & they probably wouldn't consistently use the full additional 15 hours anyway.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 28/01/2022 09:09

15, sorry. Typo.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 28/01/2022 09:09

I know 3 mums who are SAHM because their husbands earn enough so they don't need to work (which doesn't require a £100k salary as they don't live in Mumsnetland). Should we be funding them for 30 hours as well? If not, what's the salary limit on which families should pay to top up from 16 to 30 hours?

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 09:04

I’m which case, there is no real issue and the OP is way off base.
how you have extrapolated that? Because the ones that don't qualify will be the ones on lower incomes.

The point is funding wise it's not too expensive as you claim.

BoredZelda · 28/01/2022 08:29

And I don’t think poor children should receive half the nursery that their wealthier peers do.

They aren’t. Their families are receiving less childcare. A child, unless identified as requiring it because of family issues has no need to be in a nursery.

What you’re doing is assuming anyone who works less than 16 hours is a failure as a parent. Why is that?

BoredZelda · 28/01/2022 08:25

The majority qualify for the extra hours as most mothers work & most people don't earn 100k so I don't think if it was universal it would be a huge cost.

I’m which case, there is no real issue and the OP is way off base.

KevinTheKoala · 28/01/2022 08:01

The trouble is the 30 hours are supposed to help parents get back into work but you can't get the 30 hours unless you work certain amount of hours and you can't work a certain amount of hours if you don't already have childcare in place and so really it doesn't help to get people back into work. That's the reason that it would be better to have the 30 hours available to all 3 year olds - those 30 hours would allow for job hunts, interviews, and actually starting work. What I've found is that there are alot of people who will complain about the poorer members of society and their bad choices, but at the same time want to do everything in their power to keep them down.

Spikeyball · 28/01/2022 06:42

"Its not all education at 2 it is childcare first and foremost"

My child went at 2 to get evidence for an ehcp. Otherwise he may have started school without any support.

dorkfink · 28/01/2022 06:22

ask yourself would you have sent them at 2 or 3 if you wasn't 't working though ?

I sent mine for more hours when they were 3/4 despite being at home. I had their younger baby siblings to look after & made sense to me.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 23:53

Its not all education at 2 it is childcare first and foremost

I do agree with you on the 2 year provision @worriedatthemoment. But the excellent Sure Start / Children’s Centre funding, that was designed to target vulnerable/ disadvantaged families as a parent-child unit, was replaced by that 2 year provision.

… but I do believe that nursery at 3/4 is education rather than childcare. My dc’s nursery wasn’t childcare.

And I don’t think poor children should receive half the nursery that their wealthier peers do.

OP posts:
worriedatthemoment · 27/01/2022 23:36

@Crunchyapplez ask yourself would you have sent them at 2 or 3 if you wasn't 't working though ?
I wanted to be at home with mine at that age and only went to nursery/ preschool for some extra mixing
Its not all education at 2 it is childcare first and foremost
Maybe we should look at why parents are unable to provide basic fun education at home
Many schools complain more about children being unable to dress , toilet use cutlery etc as opposed to if they can read or write
I dob't think children need formal education at 2/3 and in many European countries they don't start school until 6 for formal education

Swipe left for the next trending thread