Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by nursery funding for children living in poverty

339 replies

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 10:19

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

OP posts:
Crunchyapplez · 28/01/2022 13:27

@vivainsomnia

Nursery isn’t statutory, but schools leaders are increasingly worried that children are not school ready, and nurseries are instrumental in addressing that issue Then the funding should go on educating the parents being better educators instead of paying for their kids to attend childcare whilst they get to be at home, childfree, for themselves. How is this going to encourage them to consider a job when the child goes to school?
Funding did used to go on this (SureStart and Children’s Centres), and we were beginning to see evidence that these interventions were effective. Funding for antenatal, parenting support and services for 0-2 children has been significantly cut.

In the context of these cuts, David Cameron pledged the extra 15 hours of funded childcare for working families (in 2016).

I agree with you that very early intervention supports better outcomes for families (… and I also question why such a socially divisive policy needed to be implemented at nursery age).

OP posts:
ToykotoLosAngeles · 28/01/2022 13:26

How in any way are the children of working parents ‘rich?’

I know - check me out rolling in it with my £10 an hour job, before tax, when nursery is £5 an hour.

I am going to have to massively disagree with those of you who think that families earning £85k with one SAHP should not pay the £5 an hour for any extra above 15 hours that they want. Sorry.

randomsabreuse · 28/01/2022 13:09

It's a misconception that the "successful Scandinavian" countries go to school later - they have a universal high quality state nursery system where the children do a lot of pre learning skills. Like core and finger strength developing play etc.

In France it's the Ecole Maternelle from 3. Not completely compulsory but funded and expected.

If it's about enabling work then reducing the hoops to jump through enables work. All the hoops do is increase administration expenses.

BoredZelda · 28/01/2022 13:04

Basically, what I have learned from this thread is that a lot of people view ‘nursery’ as ‘childcare’, and that ‘nursery’ is unappreciated as an educational setting.

A lot of people, like, Scottish Government who call it "Funded early learning and childcare (ELC)"?

Or UK Gov who call it "Free education and childcare for 2-year-olds"?

It is a combination of both.

BoredZelda · 28/01/2022 13:01

Limiting or extending a child’s access to educational opportunity should have nothing to do with parental income or working status. Government policy should not have drawn this line.

And it doesn't. All Children get 15 hours of education from the government. Parents who need additional childcare get additional hours.

They chuck them in to school ridiculously early aged 4 in England no matter what your economic status. It is laughable to pretend this is a policy excluding "the poor"

BoredZelda · 28/01/2022 12:58

by primary carer I didn't mean a SAHP. I meant an individual who knows the child intimately, and caters to their strengths weaknesses

Source?

Sofiegiraffe · 28/01/2022 12:52

@SleepingStandingUp @vivainsomnia

Completely agree with you both.

vivainsomnia · 28/01/2022 11:58

Nursery isn’t statutory, but schools leaders are increasingly worried that children are not school ready, and nurseries are instrumental in addressing that issue
Then the funding should go on educating the parents being better educators instead of paying for their kids to attend childcare whilst they get to be at home, childfree, for themselves. How is this going to encourage them to consider a job when the child goes to school?

SleepingStandingUp · 28/01/2022 11:51

@Crunchyapplez

It should be abhorrent to us that rich children are entitled to more nursery education than poor ones, though (shouldn’t it?).
But the 30 hours is income based, it's employment based because THOSE EXTRA hours are childcare led. If me and DH both work 16 hours, we'd get the 30 hours, even if it's in minimum wage. If DH earns £47k and I don't work we won't. Because my child needs 15hours of education, which it gets, but doesn't need the extra hours of childcare.

And no it's obv not that explicitly cut (OK Bin, you've done 15hours of learning, go eat play Dough) but the principle behind those EXTRA hours is providing care for a child who has no one at home to care for them, essentially

And no, I'm not MC and privileged before you ask. We got the free hours for DS, won't for DTwins, actually do qualify for 30 hours but will only use 15 as I'm not in work (carer)

SleepingStandingUp · 28/01/2022 11:45

@Rosesareyellow
Basically, what I have learned from this thread is that a lot of people view ‘nursery’ as ‘childcare’, and that ‘nursery’ is unappreciated as an educational setting.
But is it in part. If I work, I send my child to nursery because I need them cared for. Bums changed, fed, kept entertained. It doesn't explicitly matter if they learn, why matters if they're looked after.
At a certain age, there's an expectation that PART of this time will be of educational value. But up until compulsory school age, it is still optional and therefore some parents will use it because they need their child cared for whilst they do something else

sanbeiji · 28/01/2022 11:23

Again the point is not NO help.
The point is any help given by external sources won't generally yield results without home reinforcement, or someone else supporting emotionally. Of course 'some' people escape a bad home life. Like any challenge it makes 'some' angry, hungry and hardy, but demotivates others.
There hasn't really been any sort of study done as to whether more people are in the first or second group.
It's like trying to fill a jug, with holes. Pour as much water as you want, it'll still leak out.

granny24 · 28/01/2022 11:22

@Rosesareyellow

Basically, what I have learned from this thread is that a lot of people view ‘nursery’ as ‘childcare’, and that ‘nursery’ is unappreciated as an educational setting.

Literally no one has said anything even remotely like that. You may as well have a conversation with yourself OP if you’re just going to interpret bollocks out of what everyone is telling you.

Several posters have referred to childcare.
Crunchyapplez · 28/01/2022 11:20

@endlesssighing I agree.

I have a similar concern about the more explicit identification of children as ‘poor’, (who are grouped by this policy, potentially stigmatised for it, and given limited access to educational opportunity because of it).

Limiting or extending a child’s access to educational opportunity should have nothing to do with parental income or working status. Government policy should not have drawn this line.

OP posts:
sanbeiji · 28/01/2022 11:19

@HighlandPony

Most of us who have been in foster care will tell you it’s not. No real sense of family, shifted to another home just when you start to feel settled, most Foster parents haven’t got a clue about life from your background, never really fitting in, always being different, always waiting on some overworked or can’t be bothered social worker to approve this or do that. Nope. Foster care is no picnic.
Apologies I wasn't trying to insinuate that foster care was great. My point was that well-off children are advantaged because of the highly individualised care they received from their parents. The only way to close that gap would be to give similar to kids, but you can't take people away from their parents just because they're not 'engaging' them. In extreme cases where there is an issue then kids are sent to foster care.. which as you said isn't a picnic.

@BoredZelda by primary carer I didn't mean a SAHP.
I meant an individual who knows the child intimately, and caters to their strengths weaknesses.
Even with two working parents + nursery, it's the parents' job to figure out what their kid needs, how best to engage them. Again normally one parent is more hands on but it doesn't need to be a 'single' parent, could be both.

Take my DP for example. Very good at what he does, having been exposed to it from a young age. But he's autistic, got into a practical uni course on the strength of his own projects. Wouldn't have gotten in with his A-levels.

If he had been born in a different family with less resources he'd have been fucked over completely. Yes, school gave him a lot of help, but that was only 9-4, it took his parents trying lots of things, encouraging his special interest etc etc.

For 'poor' but well meaning parents it's about poverty of aspiration, and chances. Like the sure start centers,lots of parents taking their kids. My grandmother couldn't read but she valued education, sat next to me when doing homework and insisted I draw straight lines, and please the teachers.

For neglectful parents, or SEN kids it's a different story.

Sofiegiraffe · 28/01/2022 11:13

@endlesssighing

I'm with you. We are also both working parents earning above the national average who are by no means "rich"! I wish! A huge proportion of our income is wiped out by childcare for our 9 month old. And that's with the 20% tax free childcare amount, too.

endlesssighing · 28/01/2022 11:07

Rich children?

How have you jumped from parents working full time to rich children? We both work full time and our children were entitled to the nursery hours.

We would have had to sell our home if I couldn’t go back to work after maternity. At times despite working full time before the free hours at three I was left with £380 a month that wasn’t spent on childcare. Not bills, not mortgage, not council tax, not food, not clothes, not savings, not holidays - childcare.

How in any way are the children of working parents ‘rich?’

Crunchyapplez · 28/01/2022 10:55

Have you read the thread @Rosesareyellow? I wouldn’t go so far as to say my interpretation was ‘bollocks’, but thank you.

You aren’t quite right about the two years provision, by the way. Children who are eligible for the two year provision do not then become eligible for the 30 hours. Depending on birthdays, there will be many wealthier 3/4 year olds who will have been entitled to far more by the time they have started school.

OP posts:
Tanith · 28/01/2022 10:54

"in the 24hr nursery place system if she was admitted to hospital in the middle of the night her children could be taken (as if they had family) to a known and trusted care giver until she could collect or visit them instead of into emergency foster care"

Or with a childminder, who will also provide this service.

In fact, no-one seems to be considering childminders, who often offer the same funding and are working to the same curriculum as the nurseries.

Rosesareyellow · 28/01/2022 10:39

Basically, what I have learned from this thread is that a lot of people view ‘nursery’ as ‘childcare’, and that ‘nursery’ is unappreciated as an educational setting.

Literally no one has said anything even remotely like that. You may as well have a conversation with yourself OP if you’re just going to interpret bollocks out of what everyone is telling you.

Crunchyapplez · 28/01/2022 10:38

@vivainsomnia

Why are children getting reduced (or privileged) access to education based on what their parents earn? We wouldn’t accept this for primary or secondary school children And yet we regularly have threads about how being a sahm is best for young children and that FT working mums are trying to do their best when they don't have a choice, but ultimately, it's never as good as being at home with mum so which is it?
Nursery isn’t statutory, but schools leaders are increasingly worried that children are not school ready, and nurseries are instrumental in addressing that issue.

I was a SAHM until my children were nursery age. That doesn’t have any bearing on my view that dc’s friends, who had ‘poor’ parents, got less nursery than my dc did.

OP posts:
Rosesareyellow · 28/01/2022 10:34

When government policy treats rich and poor children differently in the same educational setting, what do you think that looks like?

But they are not being treated differently at that point. All children are entitled to 15 hours early years education from the age of three. All parents who work certain hours and earn a certain amount are entitled to 30 hours free childcare. They are two separate things. All children need an education, but not all parents need childcare. 3 year olds don’t need to be in an educational setting 30 hours a week, few people choose to put them in nursery or preschool for that long if it isn’t necessary. It is in most cases simply because they need childcare.
Children in poverty are actually the ones who receive the ‘extra’ education (as they should to balance out some of the inequality they face) because they’ve been entitled to it an entire year from the age of two before the other three year olds.

Crunchyapplez · 28/01/2022 10:31

It should be abhorrent to us that rich children are entitled to more nursery education than poor ones, though (shouldn’t it?).

OP posts:
dorkfink · 28/01/2022 10:24

If you don't work, you should get nothing.

Yes that's great for society as a whole! Some people aren't capable of work.

Lots of people work but aren't net contributors anyway, should they get nothing?

SomePosters · 28/01/2022 10:24

So best get those toddlers back up those chimneys

Think I found boris on mn

HomeSw33tHome · 28/01/2022 10:17

@dorkfink

How about working more hours so that your children don't live in poverty? Or, you know, do you own childcare of you don't work much?

Because it's that simple 🙄

Why do taxpayers always have to pay for everything?

that's what tax is for.....

Oh yeah, not that simple 🙄 Lazy people always want more handouts. They feel entitled to it, because "that what tax is for". Let someone else work and provide it with that tax, while they spend their time watching netflix and moaning how hard they have it. If you don't work, you should get nothing.
Swipe left for the next trending thread