Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be appalled by nursery funding for children living in poverty

339 replies

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 10:19

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

OP posts:
Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 12:14

@endlesssighing

Where have you got £200,000 from?

My friend's husband owns a dental practice and brings home just over £100,000 and they aren't entitled to thirty free hours.

Both parents can earn up to £100 000 each before they cease to be eligible for the 30 hours funding.

That is why your friend’s husband, the dentist doesn’t get it (is he upset about that, @endlesssighing?).

OP posts:
Chillyseadippin · 27/01/2022 12:12

‘Free’ hours? Not really free if you need childcare for the full year and not term time only (if you have a job for example..)

Our ‘free’ days at actually £28 a day. So £28 a day term time, £60 a day out of term time.

The system is broken at all levels. Let’s not pitch eligible parents against ineligible parents and direct the ranger at the government- who do not value women in the work place.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 12:09

@Kbyodjs

At times for children on child protection plans the places are funded but they should only be on these plans for up to 12 months so then to reduce nursery hours after this isn’t helpful. Also more nursery hours aren’t the solution to it not being safe at home.
Not the solution, no, but I struggle with knowing that children on a Child Protection Plan don’t get (for free) what my child gets for free.
OP posts:
Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 12:05

OfstedOffred
Its childcare though? Why do you need if if you aren't working?

I don’t see it as childcare, actually. I see access to nursery as an opportunity for education and development. You are right that the funding is labelled ‘childcare’, though.

OP posts:
Lolamento · 27/01/2022 12:03

@Crunchyapplez

Re. The Times today:

If you work for less than 16 hours a week on the living wage (ie your children are being raised in poverty), then you get only 15 hours of free nursery hours.

If you are a 3 or 4 year old, living in poverty and on a child protection plan (when a child is regarded as suffering or likely to suffer significant harm), then you are STILL not eligible for more than 15 hours of funded nursery a week - even when it is formally recognised that your home is not always a safe place.

BUT a child whose parents earn as much as £200000 a year is eligible for 30 hours a week, fully funded by the government.

Please vote:
YABU: I find this an acceptable funding structure
YANBU: I find this unacceptable

You are wrong high earners do not get it. However, someone childcare should be available for when parents are working. If you work 16 hrs then that is the childcare you should get.
Itsalmostanaccessory · 27/01/2022 12:02

30 years ago, my mum was a child minder and she had a lot of "looked after" children who were placed with her by social services. She was paid by the council/social services not by the parent. The kids were on protection plans and being monitored by social services, the parents often did not work. They got funded childcare place with a vetted provider to keep the kid safe, so the kid could be checked on and to give the parents respite.
This hasnt changed. They still get that.

thewhatsit · 27/01/2022 12:02

@endlesssighing

Where have you got £200,000 from?

My friend's husband owns a dental practice and brings home just over £100,000 and they aren't entitled to thirty free hours.

I think it’s the point that in the VERY UNUSUAL circumstance that two parents earn 99.9k each you could have a gross income of almost 200k and still be entitled to childcare. Any pay rise at all would remove the childcare entitlement completely. The 100k threshold was set some years a go and quite clearly 100k means very different things in different parts of the country anyway..
funinthesun19 · 27/01/2022 12:01

Sadly increased funding and better opportunities for all won’t happen because there are still plenty of people who think free school meals, holiday meal payments and tax credits should be done away with 🙄.

It’s sad isn’t it? It’s not like it will benefit them if those sources of help are done away with either. It’s a combination of having a big chip on their shoulder, and they just want some satisfaction at seeing struggling people struggle even more. “That’s what you get for not working as hard as me”…

Kbyodjs · 27/01/2022 12:00

At times for children on child protection plans the places are funded but they should only be on these plans for up to 12 months so then to reduce nursery hours after this isn’t helpful. Also more nursery hours aren’t the solution to it not being safe at home.

endlesssighing · 27/01/2022 12:00

However I do somewhat agree.

If the parent doesn't work over 16 hours they don't contribute the full NI and tax. I may be wrong but that's why they offered the thirty hours in the first place wasn't it?

Free childcare encourages parents back to work and therefore increases tax. They're not going to just give free childcare if there's nothing in it for the government.

As far as I'm aware there are however exemptions? At risk children are entitled to the full thirty hours, children of parents with certain health issues, carers etc.

Crunchyapplez · 27/01/2022 12:00

@Notoironing

It’s about the children not the parents.
I am so glad you made this point @Notoironing.

Why are children getting reduced (or privileged) access to education based on what their parents earn? We wouldn’t accept this for primary or secondary school children.

OP posts:
Thefaceofboe · 27/01/2022 12:00

I work in a huge childcare setting and there’s so much I can say on this matter. The children we get through the funding at 2 years very often need to be at nursery, even if it’s just for 1 day a week. I remember one little boy who’s mum told me she didn’t buy toys for him at home as his siblings just broke them so she’s happy he can attend nursery one day a week so he can play Sad

I would never begrudge a child on this opportunity, but it’s very frustrating for working parents who struggle to afford childcare and have to wait till 3.

sanbeiji · 27/01/2022 11:57

Also to add educational achievement in modern times is v different.
In the past, ‘smart’ kids from deprived parents got into uni, ‘not smart’ kids had loads of options. Many started working as teens and worked their way up (quite a few senior staff in my org like this).

Uninvolved parents didn’t do THAT much damage. Sure, their kids might not have achieved their ‘full potential’ as research scientists or whatever. But they could make something of themselves.

These days many of those paths are closed. Evening classes etc are expensive. You can’t get an entry level job without a degree.

Time and effort would be better spent on re-opening said paths instead of forcing everyone onto an academic hamster wheel.

I’m not saying that kids shouldn’t be supported : of course they should. Free extracurricular activities, and ensuring that kids have decent literacy levels. Facilities like laptops at school so kids can watch science videos etc.

However for ‘exams’ richer ‘C’ kids are tutored and tutored until they get A’s and B’s. There’s not a lot of ‘naturally bright’ people and everyone getting A’s helps nobody.

endlesssighing · 27/01/2022 11:57

Where have you got £200,000 from?

My friend's husband owns a dental practice and brings home just over £100,000 and they aren't entitled to thirty free hours.

Thefaceofboe · 27/01/2022 11:55

God forbid working parents are entitled to help with childcare

OfstedOffred · 27/01/2022 11:55

Handsoffreturns
I'd rather see minimum wage substantially increased than focussing on expanding tax credits. Wages are way too far out of sync with cost of living. People should be paid decently.

Iwonder08 · 27/01/2022 11:55

Complete nonsense. First of all high earners won't have any 'free' childcare until 3 and even after that it is only 15 h rather than 30. Also in your example if parents don't work/work very little they should need any childcare.
I think this country can afford free childcare for everyone like they do in France. The idea of penalising higher earners by reducing the allowance even further is simply ridiculous as it will inevitably impact women's ability to continue her career. Let's also not forget that the high earners are the ones paying overwhelming majority of tax in this country.

Polyputthekettleon · 27/01/2022 11:55

The funding is for childcare. So if you are working less than 15 hours then you don't need childcare for more than that. If a home is not safe for a child to live the child should be removed, not just put in childcare for an extra few hours and returned back to an unsafe home. So yes, YABU.

RandomUser10093 · 27/01/2022 11:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

OfstedOffred · 27/01/2022 11:52

Early Years Education should be state owned and universally free for all children aged over 2

It is. 15 hours a week is the amount of education 2,3,4 year olds benefit from. They don't actually need more than this. They also benefit from time at home with family.

funinthesun19 · 27/01/2022 11:51

My daughter couldn't start preschool until she received her funded hours at 3 years and 3 months because I work so she wasn't entitled to 2 year old funding and I couldn't afford to send her. That doesn't seem fair to me either. So then being able to do the 30 hours allows children like mine to catch up on the year they missed out on due to having a mother that works!

The 2 year funding isn’t for the parents to have a break while they’re not working. It’s free education for children from disadvantaged backgrounds to help close the gap.
I understand your frustration as your dd missed out, but I don’t think it’s right to begrudge those 2 year places for children who will benefit so much from them.

When my DS was 2, he got the funding because of his disability and was nothing to do with my work status. The way his speech came along after he started was truly amazing.
A few years later, after becoming a newly single parent, my DD then qualified for the 2 year funding. This time it was because of my work status. She thrived more than she would have done if she didn’t go.

Most of us are just trying to do the best for our children. If taking advantage of free education helps children then I’m all for it.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 11:50

@NorthSouthcatlady

Who needs more childcare than that if they don’t work? They could care for their children, what else have they got to do?!
Look for work in accordance with your decoration with the job centre,
VikingOnTheFridge · 27/01/2022 11:49

I think 2 x £99,999 earners is a bit of a red herring here, for how common that's going to be. The important point is that DC on child protection plans are often not entitled to the free hours, and yes that absolutely seems like a bad idea. These are DC who would likely benefit more from greater access to nursery. That argument is sufficient in itself.

sanbeiji · 27/01/2022 11:49

@Hospedia

I agree too that early years education should be universal.

For everyone querying why "childcare" is needed if you're not working, the 15hrs funding is not childcare, it is early years education. Children from specific groups - low income families, children with disabilities and/or SEN, and looked after children - are more likely to start school developmentally and educationally behind their peers and that gap widens. Studies show that early intervention improves outcomes which is why the 15hrs funding exists. Access to 30hrs would improve outcomes even further and I think you would need to be a special kind of selfish to begrudge a child access to opportunities that could improve their long term attainment.

Thats just an assumption. 15 free hours was to bring all kids up to a minimum. More hours might make them prepared ‘above’ the minimum s But No matter how much ‘early childhood dev’ is given kids will fall behind in school if parents do nothing at home.
OfstedOffred · 27/01/2022 11:49

Children’s access to early year’s education should be universal just like throughout the rest of their education and not dependent on their parent’s working patterns.

Its not education.

15 hours of it is education because there's a benefit to the child of receiving that many hours in a good quality setting.

Long hours in childcare can actually have less benefit. For children with working parents the government funds it to provide childcare for the parents benefit - it's a reflection of the fact that in reality we need affordable childcare to allow parents to earn enough to stay afloat. The government knows that women who take years and years out of work because they can't afford childcare struggle to eventually get back to employment so they are trying to help parents remain in the workforce and retain skills etc.