Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it illegal to kill a wild animal at work?

444 replies

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 09:57

Posting for traffic. Is illegal/possible to pursue for animal cruelty if someone kills a wild animal in their work place?

I have been googling but I can only find information really regarding livestock and pets.

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 27/01/2022 13:44

This thread is fucking mad!

Should people who own pets or eat meat (not illegal) not be able to report suspected wildlife crimes?

And do people think illegally killing animals that eat other animals fine and dandy. Bonkers.

And a magpie going into a shop us unhygienic, but someone killing a live animal in a shop is fine? 🤨

OP, I'd ignore the people obviously looking for a fight. I agree with PPs who have suggested talking to the lady at the school and then reporting to the RSPB as a suspected wildlife crime.

Reporting a suspected crime is always ok. Even if you dont have all the evidence. The responsibility for evidence collecting doesn't lie with the person reporting the crime.

Moonmelodies · 27/01/2022 13:43

Perhaps he feared a corvid pandemic.

Mayorquimby2 · 27/01/2022 13:43

What a thread title.

Nothing further to add

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:42

@PossiblyDreaming

I totally agree with *@Wreath21*. It’s not hatred to think that complaining to someone’s employer when you don’t know the facts is completely out of order. This shouty woman could have just decided that the shop guy killed the magpie while the shop guy had done it completely above board with a pest management company. She could still hold him responsible and be yelling that he killed the bird when he’s done nothing wrong other than stop his shop being closed due to vermin on the produce.
I think you're getting confused, I do not care if some internet randomer "hates" me, I am saying that accusing me of a "hate campaign" is completely batshit.

If it was all above board and pest control was involved then that will be very easily provable for the poor manager then, won't it?

OP posts:
SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:40

@Inspectorslack

But you don’t actually know why or how the bird was killed?
If you knew the wider context of the situation and the behaviour of the bird and the people in the days leading up to this, you would understand why it is so painfully obvious.

Obviously I did not see with my own eyes someone killing the bird. But it is honestly so clear that the bird has been killed, it's actually boggling my mind how hard some people are finding this to believe. I have stated many times a pretty clear version of events as to what has happened.

OP posts:
LizzieSiddal · 27/01/2022 13:39

The magpie was not hurt, the manager killed him because he considered him a nuisance by hopping into the shop - despite the fact that he wasn't bothering or harming anyone. He also did not stay in the shop for long periods.

Hmm except the bird was probable shitting all over the place. You obviously have no idea re health and safety in a food shop.

Also get your facts straight before you make a complaint or you’ll end up looking very foolish.

PossiblyDreaming · 27/01/2022 13:39

I totally agree with @Wreath21. It’s not hatred to think that complaining to someone’s employer when you don’t know the facts is completely out of order. This shouty woman could have just decided that the shop guy killed the magpie while the shop guy had done it completely above board with a pest management company. She could still hold him responsible and be yelling that he killed the bird when he’s done nothing wrong other than stop his shop being closed due to vermin on the produce.

AuntyBumBum · 27/01/2022 13:38

Yes it is, depending on the animal.

Inspectorslack · 27/01/2022 13:37

But you don’t actually know why or how the bird was killed?

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:36

@Inspectorslack

But neither you nor your partner know exactly what happened?

And if the bird was coming in to the shop it was shitting everywhere and potentially spreading disease.

Does not make it okay for him to take this into his own hands and kill the bird.
OP posts:
SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted as it quotes a deleted post.

Inspectorslack · 27/01/2022 13:35

But neither you nor your partner know exactly what happened?

And if the bird was coming in to the shop it was shitting everywhere and potentially spreading disease.

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:30

There is also a useful GA (guaranteed analysis) calculator on the hamster hideout website where you can work out the macronutrient percentages of your hamster's diet to ensure they are getting sufficient protein. I hope this is helpful!

OP posts:
Wreath21 · 27/01/2022 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:27

@pinkpirlie

I was on your side (and still am re the magpie) but then you said you keep your hamsters on a vegan diet. Hamsters need a diet with insects as they form a large element of their diet in the wild. I'm vegetarian and I still feel my hamsters live insects because this is what is natural to them, and vital for their enrichment and health. Just because they can survive without them doesn't mean that they are not being negatively affected, surviving doesn't mean thriving. If you aren't willing to feed your hamsters insects, I would question whether they are the right companion for you.
I have never read any literature anyway that says hamsters are anything other than scavenger feeds that are primarily granivores (meaning they live on a diet based on seeds and grains) but who will also eat meat opportunely. This does not mean that they need meat like a cat, an obligate carnivore, needs meat. They also do not make up a large part of the diet. Even wild hamsters diets primarily consist of various wild grass seeds, which is in line with their hoarding nature.

While of course it is not harmful to feed hamsters meat, some hamsters, particularly Syrians, are less fond of meat - dwarves usually love mealworms, especially roborovskis who need more protein than the average hamster anyway.

Seeds, some grains, and legumes are actually great sources of protein. All of my hamsters have an enriching, scatter fed diet and have lived longer than average lives by quite a way.

I do not neglect my pets. Like humans, hamsters are more than capable of going their entire lives without eating meat. As long as their diet is balanced and nutritious, they will thrive. If your hamster likes meat like chicken and mealworms, that is absolutely your prerogative to feed. But it does not mean hamsters actually require meat as an essential part of the diet.

OP posts:
FurryAntiWaxer · 27/01/2022 13:26

The manager probably did kill the bird, but I'd talk to the shouty lady and get more information before launching a crusade.
Did she see its body or see it being killed? Did anyone get any pictures etc?
Get your proverbial ducks lined up first.

starsaligned · 27/01/2022 13:26

@SilverDoe well in that case I would still report the matter stating all the facts you've listed here and request that the store checks CCTV inside and out so it can be looked into? I'm presuming he unalived it either on or around the premises so hopefully he will be caught. That might be the evidence needed.

Agree that @Wreath21 sounds aggressively over invested. Do you work for Co op by any chance?

Whammyyammy · 27/01/2022 13:24

I would imagine you would get into trouble if you were a zoo keeper.....

slashlover · 27/01/2022 13:22

Shop being next to the school is irrelevant. Did your DH actually hear the manager saying he killed the bird, or was it just 'obvious'?

I used to get the odd person ranting at me for things that never happened or where they had got the wrong end of the stick.

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:18

At the school* not at the store. In case you missed it this shop is right next to a primary school (which my DC attends)

OP posts:
SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 13:18

@starsaligned

Yanbu OP. Yes the magpie shouldn't technically be in the store but the fact that this untrained person chose to dispatch of it himself rather than go down the proper channels means that the poor thing probably suffered unnecessarily. That's not ok. On that premise alone I would complain definitely.

Without going into detail can I ask how you know it's dead and how you know it was this person who did it? Was it witnessed? Sorry if this has already been answered.

Hiya,

Yes my partner overheard a conversation with a local lady and the store staff. Though it is not clear of the method used, and though I can't quote verbatim because it was not heard by me, my partner has explained to me that it is very obvious that the bird was killed, it was killed in the shop, it was killed by the manager.

Although there is a poster on this thread whose spirit apparently communed with the shop at the time and will inform you I have no evidence, the conversation, while dominated by the lady complaining, was very clear on the fact that the bird was killed in the shop and by shop staff. There was no denial of this, the bird is obviously dead as it is gone, and despite what said poster may say, lady works at the store and is not a nut job, so sincerely doubt she would have been so upset had she not had reason to believe what she was saying was correct.

It also lines up with the fact that the bird had been around for ages, and then within days of entering the shop for brief periods, has now been unalived.

I rest my case.

OP posts:
slashlover · 27/01/2022 13:17

[quote SilverDoe]@Wreath21 you are actually unnerving me with your aggression and spite. I get it, you don't agree, but honestly what the fuck is your problem? It's beyond strongly worded dissent now.

Is there a way to block users on here?[/quote]
The problem is that you have put a man's job at risk on ZERO EVIDENCE.

slashlover · 27/01/2022 13:15

@Hoplesscynic

Hi OP, I understand your frustration and I don't get people on here looking for excuses, making you feel bad etc. That shop manager is a despicable person - to kill a defenceless, friendly bird? I bet he got a kick out of it, that he could do this to the poor creature, probably thinking nobody would care about a bird and no consequences for him. Yes, I do think he'd got a kick out of it, else why the violence? As you pointed out there were many, many other ways to deal with the bird. And I dont believe for a second it was a mercy killing due to an injury. How could he assess whether the bird could be saved/could recover or not? Surely he would have called RSPCA or the wildlife hospital you mentioned. People like him make my blood boil. I am also a vegetarian/mostly vegan and hate the suffering we put animals through in general. Sadly, I dont see much happening here. Although you never know - I'm really glad you sent that email though, and perhaps your DH/other people outraged over this can email too... Not sure about the legalities but this WAS a very cruel and wholly unnecessary act. I hope the poor birdie's soul rests in peace.
We don't know he killed the bird. If he did, we don't know there was violence. Now you're assuming he enjoyed it and got a kick out of it even though we don't know what happened?

You're saying it WAS very cruel on no evidence. Zero.

Newfluff · 27/01/2022 13:15

I wonder what Wreath does for a living. manages the Co Op

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/01/2022 13:15

@SilverDoe

And please stop saying nobody knows what happened. The conversation made it very clear the bird HAS BEEN KILLED. He's fucking GONE. This is absolutely ridiculous at this point. I will not be engaging further with you *@Wreath21* your attitude is disturbing me.
You say this, but you have been asked specifically what was said and have yet to tell us the words.