Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it illegal to kill a wild animal at work?

444 replies

SilverDoe · 27/01/2022 09:57

Posting for traffic. Is illegal/possible to pursue for animal cruelty if someone kills a wild animal in their work place?

I have been googling but I can only find information really regarding livestock and pets.

OP posts:
Cantleave · 27/01/2022 22:45

@SilverDoe

Oh I do hope I end up in court, I really do.

I do not have a habit of this at all, but unsurprisingly to everyone but you, when innocent, intelligent little animals are killed for no good reason, I do have the ability to be angry and feel it should be addressed.

Op you do not want to end up in court. If you do it won’t be for the court to hear your opinion on what happened, but will probably be because you have been charged with slander or something else! I am not trying to get at you, as I am as horrified as you are that a poor bird has apparently been cruelly killed.

I really hope the manager is charged with Cruelty to Animals. However Court cases deal with fact and are not interested in third hand information. They won’t be interested in how you are upset and have contacted the shop’s head office because your husband told you he had heard someone shouting at the staff, who then said that someone else had killed a bird. You didn’t see the bird being killed so you do not have any information (and neither has your dh), that would actually be relevant in this case.

Unfortunately, at the moment there is nothing you can do about this, except refuse to give this store your custom, which is what I would do in your situation! If the manager is found guilty of cruelty, then you could campaign for him to lose his job, but I expect that may happen anyway if he is found guilty!

ScrollingLeaves · 27/01/2022 22:09

The OP’s husband heard the exchange of words.

When my husband tells me what he has heard, I don’t think of it as ‘hearsay’.

So no, I don’t think this is a text book definition of it.

Inspectorslack · 27/01/2022 19:55

Yeah. Mrs so and so at the co op says yer man kills magpies.

It’s the text book definition of hearsay.

Wreath21 · 27/01/2022 19:52

[quote BadNomad]@Wreath21
Um, not really. People self-importantly 'reporting crimes' that they didn't witness, on the basis that they were told someone said something to someone else about it, waste police time and resources and often cause trouble for people who have done nothing wrong.
If you hear something second or third hand which concerns you, the best you can do is mind your business. If you know one of the people supposedly involved (or indeed hurt) in the incident you could, perhaps, offer to support them in making a complaint as that might be helpful.

Is this your opinion about all crimes or just animal cruelty? Because if I heard something from someone else that a 3rd person had abused a child or buried a body somewhere, I would report it. I think most people would. If the person is innocent then they'll still be innocent after being investigated.[/quote]
Do you genuinely think that the police would spring into action if you trotted into the nick and said 'Mr So&so has done this awful thing, some woman at the bus stop told me alllll about it'?
Do you also not understand that for some people, being 'investigated' is life-ruining?

BadNomad · 27/01/2022 19:42

@Wreath21
Um, not really. People self-importantly 'reporting crimes' that they didn't witness, on the basis that they were told someone said something to someone else about it, waste police time and resources and often cause trouble for people who have done nothing wrong.
If you hear something second or third hand which concerns you, the best you can do is mind your business. If you know one of the people supposedly involved (or indeed hurt) in the incident you could, perhaps, offer to support them in making a complaint as that might be helpful.

Is this your opinion about all crimes or just animal cruelty? Because if I heard something from someone else that a 3rd person had abused a child or buried a body somewhere, I would report it. I think most people would. If the person is innocent then they'll still be innocent after being investigated.

MoiraRosefan · 27/01/2022 19:29

To the OP. Please ignore all those who are scoffing at you. I would have definitely complained about this and would follow up if I didn’t receive a response from the company. I would also notify the RSPCA, RSPB and anyone else I could think of. There is never any reason to be cruel to any creature, and the manager is a despicable individual if he killed that magpie because it hopped into his shop.

Lady089 · 27/01/2022 19:24

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

*I’m not sure if you’ll see this comment. I am glad there are people like you around that at least have some compassion. It says something when posters are more concerned about ‘evidence’, than acknowledging the fact this cruel fucker has killed a defenceless bird.*

You can't be serious? Are you genuinely arguing that people should be allowed to accused and report others of "stomping and strangling" animals without any actual evidence? Look at the language you and others are using about the manager; "cruel fucker", "callous bastard", "deserves all he gets", all based the opinion of one person who heard a retelling of a conversation between people who weren't even at the alleged event. It certainly says something about some posters on here, but not what you think.

I might report you to your work for drowning puppies. Why care about 'evidence' when cruel fuckers like you are out killing defenseless animals.

The staff said the manager killed the magpie. You do know that in some cases where a crime has taken place, it’s difficult to obtain actual evidence which is why witnesses are used in many cases.

And yes, OP clearly has way more compassion than many of you that are so focused on the actual evidence than the cruel act instead.

Wreath21 · 27/01/2022 19:22

@BadNomad

It's not for the OP to provide evidence. If she suspects a crime has been committed then she has every right to report it to have it investigated properly by the people with authority to do so. Those "it's just hearsay" or "none of your business" attitudes is why so many bad people get away with doing bad things for too long.
Um, not really. People self-importantly 'reporting crimes' that they didn't witness, on the basis that they were told someone said something to someone else about it, waste police time and resources and often cause trouble for people who have done nothing wrong. If you hear something second or third hand which concerns you, the best you can do is mind your business. If you know one of the people supposedly involved (or indeed hurt) in the incident you could, perhaps, offer to support them in making a complaint as that might be helpful.
NEUserNamesNotTakenJeez · 27/01/2022 19:13

If you feel comfortable, maybe casually ask someone who works there what happened to the bird (either play dumb you don't know it's been killed or mention you overheard something about it) and see what else you might be able to find out.
I'm an animal lover too and I've seen some vile ways people have killed rats and such. Personally, I can totally understand your frustration, which would make me want to find out more. Beaten to death with a broom is abit ott but something which may have happened. Wringing it's neck, as far as I'm aware, would be a more humane way (as much of a shame it is to lose an intelligent wild animal 😞)
I'd simply have to know more, from a shop assistant or the manager himself.... '...especially if the kids have been asking where Mr Magpie has gone...' (if you wanted to be subtle about your view kinda thing 😉)

isadoradancing123 · 27/01/2022 19:11

Magpies are a pest, they are wild birds and i certainly wouldnt want one in a shop or near my shoelaces.

Wreath21 · 27/01/2022 19:06

[quote starsaligned]@Wreath21 but the op hasn't named and shamed him. She's made a report to the company so that they can investigate and search for this evidence that you are so keen on. If she'd plastered his name and alleged crime all over Facebook you might have a point but that isn't what happened.

Based on a reasonable level of suspicion - I.e having heard staff discussing it, the bird being gone etc - do you not think this should be at least looked into? If the guy is proven innocent then it'll work in his favour as he can dispel the rumours with facts. If he's found to have done it then he should be punished accordingly. That's the point in an investigation which the op has asked for.

No idea what the bizarre caps are for in your post...Confused[/quote]
While you're right that OP hasn't identified the man, other posters on this thread have been encouraging her to do so, telling her to go on local social media, phone the papers etc, and it is those posters I am referring to more than OP.

jacquettalux · 27/01/2022 18:59

I would be really upset by this too, OP. You don't deserve a hard time over this. Be kind to yourself.

BadNomad · 27/01/2022 18:57

It's not for the OP to provide evidence. If she suspects a crime has been committed then she has every right to report it to have it investigated properly by the people with authority to do so. Those "it's just hearsay" or "none of your business" attitudes is why so many bad people get away with doing bad things for too long.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/01/2022 18:55

I’m not sure if you’ll see this comment. I am glad there are people like you around that at least have some compassion.
It says something when posters are more concerned about ‘evidence’, than acknowledging the fact this cruel fucker has killed a defenceless bird.

You can't be serious? Are you genuinely arguing that people should be allowed to accused and report others of "stomping and strangling" animals without any actual evidence? Look at the language you and others are using about the manager; "cruel fucker", "callous bastard", "deserves all he gets", all based the opinion of one person who heard a retelling of a conversation between people who weren't even at the alleged event. It certainly says something about some posters on here, but not what you think.

I might report you to your work for drowning puppies. Why care about 'evidence' when cruel fuckers like you are out killing defenseless animals.

starsaligned · 27/01/2022 18:54

@Wreath21 but the op hasn't named and shamed him. She's made a report to the company so that they can investigate and search for this evidence that you are so keen on. If she'd plastered his name and alleged crime all over Facebook you might have a point but that isn't what happened.

Based on a reasonable level of suspicion - I.e having heard staff discussing it, the bird being gone etc - do you not think this should be at least looked into? If the guy is proven innocent then it'll work in his favour as he can dispel the rumours with facts. If he's found to have done it then he should be punished accordingly. That's the point in an investigation which the op has asked for.

No idea what the bizarre caps are for in your post...Confused

DrFoxtrot · 27/01/2022 18:52

@Wreath21 I haven't had time to read the whole thread, I could tell there were tensions.

I agree that there is a lack of evidence but it's worth OP speaking to a professional body who can advise her further. It might not go anywhere but at least she can feel she went down the correct route.

Wreath21 · 27/01/2022 18:46

[quote DrFoxtrot]I think it needs reporting somewhere, there was a case local to me where a McDonalds employee killed a seagull hanging around the bins and he was prosecuted. Maybe speak to the RSPCA for advice.

I've skim read OPs posts and gather there is tension on the thread and questions re hamsters. But sticking to the OP, I agree seek further advice from a body like the RSPCA or council.

www.blackpoolgazette.co.uk/news/crime/fleetwood-mcdonalds-worker-killed-seagull-in-violent-attack-because-he-was-sick-of-its-daily-visits-3023746[/quote]
Well, that's a very unpleasant story and the man was quite rightly prosecuted for cruelty to wild animals. However, there was an eyewitness at the time who called the police - unlike in the alleged incident described by OP (and what she-says-her-H-heard could equally turn out to be referring to the manager having called a pest control company who legally despatched the bird as it could to an account of him having killed it himself, perhaps with unnecessary violence).

But the main thing that is concerning about this thread is the number of posters who appear to think that due process is never necessary, that it's fine to 'name and shame' people on the basis of overheard gossip and that WAAA some crimes are so BAWWW hideous that BOOHOO conviction on the grounds of accusation is perfectly acceptable. I have seen this sort of dangerous self-righteousness elsewhere and it is never going to end well for anyone. Particularly when people who are MORE HORRIFIED THAN ANYONE start insisting that even asking about evidence, proper procedures, witnesses etc means you probably commit similar crimes yourself on a daily basis or (most terrible of all sins) you 'don't CAAAAAARE'.

derxa · 27/01/2022 18:31

Weirdly, I'm in Scotland and wear a mask for up to 8 hours per day with no glasses steaming and never see anyone stumbling around. Well done

slashlover · 27/01/2022 18:29

@derxa

Oh FFS, there’s always one on every bloody thread - the obligatory reminder that we are still ‘IN A PANDEMIC’ 🤣 I'm in the Socialist Republic of Scotland where masks are mandatory. Nicola demands that I stumble around shops wearing steamed up glasses. If a magpie popped into the shop, I'd probably step on it because I can't see a bloody thing.
Weirdly, I'm in Scotland and wear a mask for up to 8 hours per day with no glasses steaming and never see anyone stumbling around.
DrFoxtrot · 27/01/2022 18:28

I think it needs reporting somewhere, there was a case local to me where a McDonalds employee killed a seagull hanging around the bins and he was prosecuted. Maybe speak to the RSPCA for advice.

I've skim read OPs posts and gather there is tension on the thread and questions re hamsters. But sticking to the OP, I agree seek further advice from a body like the RSPCA or council.

www.blackpoolgazette.co.uk/news/crime/fleetwood-mcdonalds-worker-killed-seagull-in-violent-attack-because-he-was-sick-of-its-daily-visits-3023746

Inastatus · 27/01/2022 18:27

@derxa 😅😂

Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat · 27/01/2022 18:26

Oh no, how awful. I'm not surprised you're upset.

Wild birds are protected under the The Wildlife & Countryside Act 1981 in the UK and it is against the law to intentionally kill one.

You can report it to the RSPB via the online form at the bottom of this page:-

www.rspb.org.uk/birds-and-wildlife/advice/wildlife-and-the-law/wildlife-and-countryside-act/

You can also report it to the Police.

Might be worth seeing if you can get any more evidence to back it up.

I would absolutely report him. Until people are pulled up on shit like this they will continue to do whatever they please. It's awful.

The farm shop down the road from us has a resident robin. He sits up in the rafters and sings his head off! The staff say he is a nuisance but he absolutely makes my day whenever I see him so I totally get where you are coming from!

derxa · 27/01/2022 18:19

Oh FFS, there’s always one on every bloody thread - the obligatory reminder that we are still ‘IN A PANDEMIC’ 🤣 I'm in the Socialist Republic of Scotland where masks are mandatory. Nicola demands that I stumble around shops wearing steamed up glasses. If a magpie popped into the shop, I'd probably step on it because I can't see a bloody thing.

Inastatus · 27/01/2022 18:13

@derxa

At our Coop the workers are too busy to engage in loud conversations. We're still in a pandemic. Customers are in and out as fast as possible. No sign of any wildlife.
Oh FFS, there’s always one on every bloody thread - the obligatory reminder that we are still ‘IN A PANDEMIC’ 🤣
starsaligned · 27/01/2022 18:12

@Inspectorslack it's clear that you don't agree but repeatedly coming back to have a pop even when she's said she's leaving the thread while ignoring genuine questions from others just makes you look like you're getting at her for the sake of it.

I also don't like birds in shops however I'm sensible enough to realise that they don't exactly have any concept of wrongdoing and therefore don't deserve to be killed inhumanely, if that is what happened.

The op has hardly launched the mass attack others are suggesting. She's emailed the company and posted on an anonymous forum. It absolutely should be looked into so any actual evidence can be established. If the manager has done nothing wrong he'll have nothing to worry about will he.