Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stupid UC changes

230 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 08:36

So now you have 4 weeks to get a job you could actually do - then you just have to apply for anything/everything.

Every time we have a thread on here about recruitment, the HR wonks pop up and complain about all the "dross" applications from people not qualified for their wonderful opportunities - how will this help?

Rather than punishing people for lack of suitable vacancies it is time the goverment tried to help employers to offer more and better jobs.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 12:41

@Mumofsend

The biggest issue with many of the suitable for anyone job is the zero hours and expectation of being fully flexible 7 days a week.

Someone who can only worth within the 8-6, M-F childcare hours stands limited chance. Likewise the zero hours element means that you can't realistically just book 50 hours a week childcare if you don't get the hours for it. The whole system is stacked against the very people who are demonised as work shy.

I'm an unpaid carer of two disabled DC and feel a bit scum of the earth and the comments that these news stories break about work shy scum are targeted towards people like me.

Please don't - not everyone is an ignorant arse who thinks you're scum. Sadly there are these types among us - and it often surprises me because they are otherwise reasonable sometimes - they are just lucky never to have been in your situation. I've been lucky and not needed benefits very often - but it was through good fortune not because I am someone special.
OP posts:
VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 12:38

I think you get workers for free then let them go and get new trainee.

I am pretty sure they get paid normally but I think they are getting somekind of sub from the government as well, not sure if that works out as free. if its anything like the last scam (where it was free, they ere classed as work experience for 6 months in the hopes the companies would keep them on after) it worked out as costing the system £250 a week more per claimant then just continuing to pay them their JSA.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 12:28

@ABCDEF1234

Why should the tax payers pay why you continue to search for the job you want. Take any job and then look for the job you want whilst working. I find it crazy that people were ever allowed to wait for a job they want as opposed to any job that pays some bills.
I dont know anything about UC I am on JSA when we fill out our declaration we have to state at least 3 sectors we will apply for and talk it over the with advisor as the declaration is being written up.

i.e shop assistant, office admin, delivery driver.

Mumofsend · 27/01/2022 12:19

The biggest issue with many of the suitable for anyone job is the zero hours and expectation of being fully flexible 7 days a week.

Someone who can only worth within the 8-6, M-F childcare hours stands limited chance. Likewise the zero hours element means that you can't realistically just book 50 hours a week childcare if you don't get the hours for it. The whole system is stacked against the very people who are demonised as work shy.

I'm an unpaid carer of two disabled DC and feel a bit scum of the earth and the comments that these news stories break about work shy scum are targeted towards people like me.

Graphista · 27/01/2022 12:19

The ones giving it "there's loads of jobs"

When was the last time YOU job hunted? When was the last you job hunted when you had certain factors against you - childcare, caring responsibilities, illness and disability, not having a car or good public transport locally, having a learning disability etc?

Then also look PROPERLY at what "all those jobs" are

Are they full time or part time? Are they permanent roles? How good are the employers? What are the pay and conditions? Are they jobs people with childcare etc to consider can do? What are the entry requirements (these seem to have gone INSANE in recent years!)? Are they jobs someone with health issues can do? (Eg me sister and dd cannot do jobs involving long periods on our feet, dd and I cannot do jobs involving heavy lifting this is due to disability)

I had this conversation several years ago with my father when myself, my sister, my dd and my cousin were all job hunting at the same time. We all of course had different skills and qualifications, different availability and other life commitments.

Dad was also merely going off "there's loads of jobs in the local paper"

So I sat with him and went through EVERY job not only in the local paper but the online recruitment sites and pointed out to him why the various jobs weren't ones we could apply for or do or were very unlikely to get if we applied as we didn't have the qualifications/experience the employer was insisting was essential.

He had no idea how zero hours jobs worked. He had no idea how childcare hours worked. He had no idea of how hard it was to get to certain addresses if you didn't drive/have a car (he'd always been a driver) not only for the interview but to do the job going forward, he had no idea how low wages were compared to cost of living, how the benefits system worked etc etc etc

Then as now many of the "loads of jobs" advertised are for just a few hours a week which isn't enough to live on BUT the employers expect employees to be "flexible" aka they don't want to give employees enough CONTRACTED hours to be eligible for annual leave, sick pay etc BUT they really DO want those employees to do enough "overtime" so that in reality they're doing a full time job for poor pay and no rights!

Dad a former union rep but retired at this point and also utterly clueless as to the decimation of employee rights in recent years

Many times when I explained certain things eg zero hours contracts he would exclaim "that cannot be legal!" And I explained to him that unfortunately it now was.

Then there are the stats where it's not simply the number of vacancies available but the number of unemployed people in comparison.

At this time I checked and learned that there were approximately 3.5 times more people looking for work than vacancies available - and that was all vacancies inc 4 hours a week nonsense. That was also Tory govts own figures the real figures were worse because they weren't including under 21's, the disabled, sahp with children under 5 years old...basically they were only including those on benefit solely for the reason of being unemployed.

It's really really not as simple as "there's loads of jobs out there"

Once I had broken it all down for dad he understood what a nightmare it was and was far more sympathetic and less critical and bless him tried to find info on jobs that we could do.

It wasn't a case of us being "fussy" we were all applying for any and every job that we could physically do, that we had the basic entry requirements for and could get to, we weren't only looking locally either we were looking as far afield as nearest big city which is about 30 odd miles away and would have involved a hell of a commute!

easily three quarters of the shops/ cafes/ restaurants had signs up asking for staff.

These are jobs only the very physically fit can do. They all also involve hours that are outside those normally covered by childcare. They also are usually part time temporary positions - a lot of employers also now do this sneaky thing of hiring on a temporary basis, releasing employees at the end of that contract, hiring someone else on a temporary basis for the same job, then releasing them at end of contract and then I think it's after a 6 month period of not employing them they can re-hire the 1st employee - again on a temp contract and the cycle repeats.

This means they aren't having to invest in training "new" people but also aren't having to again meet the costs of providing sick pay etc. it also means IF the role becomes redundant they aren't having to pay redundancy pay.

Where I live this is common practice so employees rotate around 3-4 different employers in order to stay in work - but they aren't getting any employee rights! So if they take sick/get pregnant etc they're screwed!!

Obviously I know it's not everyone's first choice but it's a start

It's not just a matter of choice. Older people not yet at retirement age and the disabled cannot physically do those jobs.

I've done all kinds of jobs over the years! Never been fussy everything from production line and waitressing (when I was fit for it! I loved waitressing and WISH I could do it now!) to healthcare to admin to call centre to civil service to childcare... (another role I would LOVE to be able to do now)

There simply aren't enough jobs available to meet the needs of all those that are unemployed/economically inactive.

This means it's an employers market they're the ones being fussy!

I've seen shelf filling and waitressing roles advertised as requiring MINIMUM education of highers (roughly equivalent to a-levels) which is just stupid! These are jobs I was doing at 14 perfectly capably! I know people doing those roles now who agree that such high requirements of applicants is unnecessary and is merely a way of limiting numbers of applicants.

Again to those saying "there's loads of jobs" some of the online sites show how many applicants per job (and bear in mind often the ONE job is advertised across multiple platforms) and locally to me most jobs the number of applicants is mostly in the hundreds and occasionally in the thousands!

Since I started I have noticed a huge increase in the amount of jobs that are “job start scheme” only. Which is a great initiative for those aged 16-24. But means everyone 25+ can no longer apply or be considered for those jobs.

I'm guessing this is because the employers get some kind of financial reward from the govt for focusing on employing youngsters? Over and above the fact that nmw is lower for youngsters I mean - which should also be illegal!

If you're doing the same job you should get the same pay!

Part of the problem is that people looking for jobs don't have the right skills for the jobs available- so I think more training opportunities and support for people retraining would be more helpful

Govt cuts mean many college courses and even whole colleges have vanished! My local one is hanging on by the skin of its teeth, down to 1/3 of the courses they were offering 10 years ago

When I suggested voluntary work or a training course not provided by them I was warned that I might not qualify as 'available for work' and may have benefits cut

Yep! Been there! Ludicrous!

So if you're unemployed and fit for work you're being asked to look for work?

More accurately if you're unemployed and fit for work you're expected to apply for jobs you've no chance of getting wasting both the applicants and the recruiters time, fit for work assessments are being done by people unsuitably qualified for the role - and that's before you even get into the outright LIES told by assessors on official reports, quotas for getting people off benefits (especially disability benefits) etc

On any given thread about benefits the claim about people being on them for years and not bothering to work is always made.

Yep

Yet to actually come across this in real life on more than very very rare occasions and even on those occasions knowing the people concerned I suspect there are undiagnosed health issues at play. One man I know supposedly like this is barely literate! I suspect possible learning disability.

it becomes extremely hard to find 35 hours worth of job searching activity to do

Yea there comes a point where you've already applied for all the jobs you could do.

I was told I was over qualified and asked why I had applied in the first place

This is a major issue for me. I hold 2 degrees but my health means I'd really be best off with a basic admin assistant role but employers think I'm at it and will be off as soon as I can get "something better"

I'm actually very loyal as an employee and providing employer is a decent sort will stick with them through thick and thin and go above and beyond wherever I can - my refs back this up. But either I miss the degrees off my cv and it looks like I have 3 huge gaps on my cv (the 3rd gap being health related) OR I mention the degrees and they see me as "overqualified won't stay"

Then there's the health stuff - Mh mostly so if I mention it the stigma and lack of understanding usually works against me (even with employers that CLAIM to be disability and even mental health welcoming) OR I don't mention it and they notice the gap in dates again!

In addition do you know that this govt has done precious little to work with our industries to CREATE jobs?

That the elimination of certain employee rights mean that even those in full time employment are doing the work of 2/3 people - if employee rights were reinstated and regulated then situations like this would mean 1/2 vacancies were created

I suspect people saying "there's loads of jobs" and "just take any job" haven't actually been in this position in recent years.

Exactly my point

*They sound very enthusiastic on the phone and get invited for interview but they don't turn up.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 12:16

@MintJulia

I think they are saying 'take a job as a supermarket driver or admin while looking for the right job for you.'

In 2020 after 30 years in tech marketing I found myself furloughed and then out of work. No conferences, no need for a conference organiser. After months searching, during which I applied for 70 jobs, I took a public sector admin role on 1/2 normal salary. I was lucky. I worked 1 day, went home and found I had been offered a great job so I switched. But at least I was willing to give it a go.
And my mortgage needed paying. No one was going to pay it for me which focuses the mind somewhat.

And as I mentioned - after many years as an IT contractor and IT systems worker I ran out of luck/work during Covid.

I applied to Tesco several times and was rejected.

I was willing and able to work any/all hours, physically fit etc.

It's really not that easy to 'take a job as a supermarket driver or admin while looking for the right job for you.'

I started the application process for a local council job but the form didn't allow for self employment and no-one could help me.

OP posts:
VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 12:12

@nansbigpants

Part of the problem is that people looking for jobs don't have the right skills for the jobs available- so I think more training opportunities and support for people retraining would be more helpful than just punishing people by cutting benefits.

The BBC article on this mentions that job seekers will get more time with a 'work coach'. Unless things have changed a lot over the last few years this is pointless. I experienced having to claim benefits when I unexpectedly lost my job and had no savings and 2 young children. I was willing to take just about anything that was feasible with the constraints of available childcare times (so not night shift etc) but despite being highly qualified for my previous (very niche) job I was turned down for numerous jobs because other applicants had more relevant experience. The only training on offer was aimed at people who needed help with basic literacy/numeracy/computer skills and my work coach sessions consisted a member of staff reading their list of vacancies with me and asking which I thought I could do (on every occasion I had already applied for anything vaguely sensible). When I suggested voluntary work or a training course not provided by them I was warned that I might not qualify as 'available for work' and may have benefits cut. On one occasion I got quite upset with the situation and my 'coach' basically told me I should think myself lucky as she'd love a bit of time off like I had, but had already used all her holiday allowance going to Australia earlier in the year.

I started signing on at the start of 2017, had plenty of interviews but it all goes back to the same thing, I have to take my SEN son to school in the morning and pick him up in the afternoon, I cant do early mornings or after 3pm.

the work coaches just told me not to worry about it and concentrate on looking after my son and hopefully he will get more independent in time so I can increase my available hours.

like you I was warned off doing any further education or anything outside of their mandated training/work experience/job search classes as doing anything off my own back that would eat into the time I had available to look for work would be considered making myself unavailable to work and I could be sanctioned.

if you tell the job centre you are looking for a job 9 to 5 they expect you to use that time 9 to 5 to look for work, not do anything else

Northernsoullover · 27/01/2022 12:06

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons

I think some vacancies expect far too much. 15 and 16 year olds looking for part time work are made to jump through hoops - assessments, 3 hour online workshops, 3 different interviews, presentations etc etc just to fucking work part time. They can’t get experience cos they don’t have any cos they can’t get a job cos they can’t get through the bloody over indulgent interview / assessment/ group work interviews. I understand that some people claiming job seekers have completely outlandish and unrealistic goals in terms of the work they will do /look for ( I have years of experience in this area) and I think there comes a point where those expectations have to be managed as they will never come to fruition. But if employers treat every single vacancy like it’s a once in a lifetime opportunity to become the next mission impossible, then what chance do people have? I’ve known people DESPERATE for work, applying for everything they come across, qualifies or not, and still can’t get anywhere.
I work in a huge stadium. We can never get enough casual waiting staff. So my 16 year old applied via the agency we use. I thought they would bite his hand off. Nope, as you say its a 3 stage process just to hand over pre-poured pints.
Akire · 27/01/2022 12:04

@VelvetChairGirl

I am JSA, jobs dont want to employ people with limited available hours (i.e have kids) regardless of skills, they still think the company owns the employee and they should be available 24/7, they need to change.

also 90% of the jobs advertised by the job centre are this kickstarter scam I dont know what the incentive is to the companies to sign up for it but its totally ageist as it means tonnes of entry level vacancies are locking out everyone over the age of 24.

I think you get workers for free then let them go and get new trainee.
Northernsoullover · 27/01/2022 12:02

@CaMePlaitPas

It's so lazy and dull to say "there's loads of jobs round at the moment". People need to earn living wages, people need security, people need flexibility. These things aren't achieved because you might have seen that Gregg's were hiring on the way to work this morning.

Of course it's the government's job to ensure quality jobs for it's citizens. Jesus, what low expectations you have if you believe otherwise. We've been so let down by this absolute sham of a government that we've become glutton for punishment. Still, as long as Boris has got some nice wallpaper up I guess that's the main thing.

My friend works in a Greggs. They constantly chop and change her hours. UC are at her to up her hours all the time. She'd love to. Where she lives there are very few jobs and she doesn't drive. She'd also love to drive but can't afford to learn.
CHIRIBAYA · 27/01/2022 12:01

This is the problem when you have millionaires and billionaires making decisions about lives that are totally unrelatabe to them. I used to work on the database that underpins the benefits system in this country (it's huge) and this change will necessitate a massive amount of work and cost just to update the system. Business analysts, developers, testers, architects, DWP stakeholders etc etc all need paying and this is a LARGE piece of work. I couldn't stomach the job in the end because none of it was about doing the right thing for the 'end users', it was all about manipulating statistics for political point scoring.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 11:59

I am JSA, jobs dont want to employ people with limited available hours (i.e have kids) regardless of skills, they still think the company owns the employee and they should be available 24/7, they need to change.

also 90% of the jobs advertised by the job centre are this kickstarter scam I dont know what the incentive is to the companies to sign up for it but its totally ageist as it means tonnes of entry level vacancies are locking out everyone over the age of 24.

MintJulia · 27/01/2022 11:25

I think they are saying 'take a job as a supermarket driver or admin while looking for the right job for you.'

In 2020 after 30 years in tech marketing I found myself furloughed and then out of work. No conferences, no need for a conference organiser. After months searching, during which I applied for 70 jobs, I took a public sector admin role on 1/2 normal salary. I was lucky. I worked 1 day, went home and found I had been offered a great job so I switched. But at least I was willing to give it a go.
And my mortgage needed paying. No one was going to pay it for me which focuses the mind somewhat.

itsgettingweird · 27/01/2022 11:22

Yeah turns out Boris announcement yesterday about new initiative to get people back into work is simply - make them take any job available.

Whilst I can understand the idea that you should earn a living. It's too simplistic.

How does someone with kids take any job without childcare?

How does someone on a limited public transport link take a job with any hours?

There needs to be some middle ground.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 11:20

@PearlclutchersInc

What it said was "in your preferred sector" after that you need to apply for anything you're capable of doing.

Doesn't mean to say that if you apply for these crap jobs that you don't want to do that you'll actually get one. Hmm

Indeed - so it's fucking pointless.
OP posts:
PearlclutchersInc · 27/01/2022 11:15

What it said was "in your preferred sector" after that you need to apply for anything you're capable of doing.

Doesn't mean to say that if you apply for these crap jobs that you don't want to do that you'll actually get one. Hmm

Akire · 27/01/2022 11:07

Sanctions sound like detention or lines, it’s removing your entire income for 14 days or 28 up to 96 days. Even in workhouse you got gruel after a days work. You still need to be fulfilling all your job seeking requirements as sanction applies for past weeks “failings”.

purpleme12 · 27/01/2022 11:05

I'm so terrified of losing my job
I think they're trying to get rid of me at mine. I guess you'd call it manage me out?
I've worked there for years
But it's a legitimate concern
And I'm terrified
It's just me and my child and I can't take anything as I don't have another adult here
I'm so scared

shouldistop · 27/01/2022 10:57

As I mentioned before - independent studies have shown benefit sanctions don't work.
Initiatives like this are political, not practical, they are just playing to the narrative of "workshy scroungers" - simplistic sloganising for the hard of thinking.

You're right that benefit sanctions don't work and should be illegal tbh. Maybe I've missed the point but how will the job centre know if you haven't applied for a CEO post that you saw? As long as you're doing the work related activities and making note of them.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 27/01/2022 10:56

I think some vacancies expect far too much. 15 and 16 year olds looking for part time work are made to jump through hoops - assessments, 3 hour online workshops, 3 different interviews, presentations etc etc just to fucking work part time. They can’t get experience cos they don’t have any cos they can’t get a job cos they can’t get through the bloody over indulgent interview / assessment/ group work interviews. I understand that some people claiming job seekers have completely outlandish and unrealistic goals in terms of the work they will do /look for ( I have years of experience in this area) and I think there comes a point where those expectations have to be managed as they will never come to fruition. But if employers treat every single vacancy like it’s a once in a lifetime opportunity to become the next mission impossible, then what chance do people have? I’ve known people DESPERATE for work, applying for everything they come across, qualifies or not, and still can’t get anywhere.

shouldistop · 27/01/2022 10:54

@Rosebel

I'm sick to death of hearing people say take any job Okay so if you were offered a zero hours minimum wage job would you take it? No most people won't. Not because they are lazy scroungers but because you can't live on 2 hours work a week on minimum wage. IMO the minimum wage needs to increase a lot and training opportunities need to be made available for all The lots of jobs argument might be true but it's care work (which shouldn't be used as a stop gap but because you actually love the job) or it's retail which is shit pay and conditions. No wonder people don't want to do it. Anyone who says it's a job be grateful needs to go and work in these places. I have done care work and still work in retail and they are by far hardest jobs I've ever had. It's disgusting to cut people's benefits and say tough. Do we want really want families starving and freezing? (Obviously Boris does but I mean apart from him).
But you don't just live on that UC tops your wage up so you're better off in work.

Personally I think zero hours contracts should be illegal but unfortunately I don't see that happening

RogerDodger · 27/01/2022 10:50

Totally @KurtWilde. When my son was smaller I used to have to bring him to work with me during school holidays as he couldn’t attend normal summer schemes. As he grew he didn’t want to sit and be bored while I worked so I just had to stop working when he was off school. I was self employed so I could make this choice but financially it was awful!

Rosebel · 27/01/2022 10:49

I'm sick to death of hearing people say take any job
Okay so if you were offered a zero hours minimum wage job would you take it? No most people won't.
Not because they are lazy scroungers but because you can't live on 2 hours work a week on minimum wage. IMO the minimum wage needs to increase a lot and training opportunities need to be made available for all
The lots of jobs argument might be true but it's care work (which shouldn't be used as a stop gap but because you actually love the job) or it's retail which is shit pay and conditions.
No wonder people don't want to do it.
Anyone who says it's a job be grateful needs to go and work in these places. I have done care work and still work in retail and they are by far hardest jobs I've ever had.
It's disgusting to cut people's benefits and say tough. Do we want really want families starving and freezing? (Obviously Boris does but I mean apart from him).

KurtWilde · 27/01/2022 10:47

@RogerDodger

As a whole I think that if you need a job you will take most jobs whether those be in bars or supermarkets until you can find what it is you ultimately want to get back into.

Bars and supermarkets that require you to be “fully flexible” on a 4 or 8 hour contract. Which for a lot of people just isn’t possible. one of my DC has SEN which mean he needs an adult to supervise him at all times but only qualifies for low rate care element of DLA. I’m a lone parent so there is no other adult to look after him. I’m still obligated to work for 35 hours a week. Which is fine if I can find those 35 hours a week to fit in Monday - Friday 8-5 (when he is at school) but supermarkets and bars want you to be available early mornings, late evenings and weekends too. I simply can’t take those jobs.

@RogerDodger some people are completely oblivious to how difficult it is to find work that fits around children when you're a single parent. I hope they never find themselves in that situation, but christ would it be an eye opener to them if they did.
RogerDodger · 27/01/2022 10:32

As a whole I think that if you need a job you will take most jobs whether those be in bars or supermarkets until you can find what it is you ultimately want to get back into.

Bars and supermarkets that require you to be “fully flexible” on a 4 or 8 hour contract. Which for a lot of people just isn’t possible. one of my DC has SEN which mean he needs an adult to supervise him at all times but only qualifies for low rate care element of DLA. I’m a lone parent so there is no other adult to look after him. I’m still obligated to work for 35 hours a week. Which is fine if I can find those 35 hours a week to fit in Monday - Friday 8-5 (when he is at school) but supermarkets and bars want you to be available early mornings, late evenings and weekends too. I simply can’t take those jobs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread