Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stupid UC changes

230 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 08:36

So now you have 4 weeks to get a job you could actually do - then you just have to apply for anything/everything.

Every time we have a thread on here about recruitment, the HR wonks pop up and complain about all the "dross" applications from people not qualified for their wonderful opportunities - how will this help?

Rather than punishing people for lack of suitable vacancies it is time the goverment tried to help employers to offer more and better jobs.

OP posts:
Socialcarenope · 27/01/2022 16:41

@CaMePlaitPas

It's so lazy and dull to say "there's loads of jobs round at the moment". People need to earn living wages, people need security, people need flexibility. These things aren't achieved because you might have seen that Gregg's were hiring on the way to work this morning.

Of course it's the government's job to ensure quality jobs for it's citizens. Jesus, what low expectations you have if you believe otherwise. We've been so let down by this absolute sham of a government that we've become glutton for punishment. Still, as long as Boris has got some nice wallpaper up I guess that's the main thing.

I think it is the government's job to ensure there are opportunities available for people to train for decent jobs. You can't expect companies to take on unsuitable people.
Parsley1234 · 27/01/2022 16:22

The government has completely wasted money buying in provision that is neither useful or fit for purpose. They have taken work away from WCs to outside agencies that are expensive and yes privatised it’s an abomination. Most people want to work a few don’t or can’t whatever put resources into them not onto people who will get a job. These ministers and managers making the rules are idiots complete self serving idiots with an eye on the prize of promotion it’s really sad for the claimants

Akire · 27/01/2022 15:58

If you have 10y experience in decent job and want find similar job all your time and resources will be in looking for that job. After 28 days being told that you need spent 20hours a week also applying for
Jobs at any level/area as well as they ones you are skilled in. How does that help?

Granted at some point in time that has to change but previous rules were by 6 months when most people who were going get new job would have. It’s only ever a small number who stay on benefits longer than this most people bounce in and out quickly. But 4 weeks is short time to waste everyone’s time having to Show you are applying for anything. Or worse getting a job after expense of advertising, time Taken to interview and train you, a uniform going through payroll and then leave after 2 weeks. What a right pain in ass for employers who all lie and say yes I really want this job blah blah and constant repeat.

Cheekypeach · 27/01/2022 15:52

Hmmm.

If I’m being honest I don’t see any reason for somebody on UC to turn down a job they are capable of doing. I mean, why wouldn’t they take it? Unless I’m missing something?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 15:41

That was in the days before you were sanctioned for leaving a job and you could just sign straight back on
When was this? When I had to sign on in 1990 you wouldn't get any dole for at least 6 weeks if you quit or were fired.

OP posts:
ChocolateDigestivesMmmm · 27/01/2022 15:12

@CaMePlaitPas Yes, this. Sure, there are jobs, but just because they exist and just because an applicant is technically "fit" to work doesn't mean they can just take any job, especially if they have commitments like childcare, if the hours don't fit in with that. Or if the wages are too low and the job is only part time, but the person needs X amount to meet their financial commitments. Plus employers are so set on "experience", even for the most basic jobs.

Akire · 27/01/2022 15:06

3 y is different from 28 days!

delilahbucket · 27/01/2022 15:05

I sort of get why they are doing it. When I was on job seekers I would literally have taken any job. As a result I applied for all sorts and ended up getting a job I wouldn't normally have gone for and it turned out I was really good at it and it led to career progression. On the other hand, my then partner was unemployed for three years because he would only apply for 9-5 office based jobs. When we split up, within two weeks he got a job in a pub because his parents said he couldn't live with them unless he got a job. He stayed there for 18 months and got sacked for stealing, rendering himself unemployable once more. That was in the days before you were sanctioned for leaving a job and you could just sign straight back on. He'd moved out of his parents at this point so he went back to only applying for 9-5 office jobs and stayed unemployed for five years until his cousin got him a job in a supermarket.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 14:20

I thought people would do this anyway, at a time with lots of vacancies it should be normal to find a stop gap.

no one wants a stop gap when if your new job pays enough to cover the bills you have 1 month gap to the first paycheck and if (in most cases) it doesn't cover the bills, you have x months wait while your claim is being reassed to change the amount you get in line with the fact you are earning now but not enough to not need benefits.

I dont know what it is for UC but for JSA it was upto 3 months wait for adjustment you got nothing while you waited, back payments mean nothing when the landlord is banging at the door about you being 2 months in arrears.

Pawprintpaper · 27/01/2022 14:14

@ABCDEF1234

Why should the tax payers pay why you continue to search for the job you want. Take any job and then look for the job you want whilst working. I find it crazy that people were ever allowed to wait for a job they want as opposed to any job that pays some bills.
I thought people would do this anyway, at a time with lots of vacancies it should be normal to find a stop gap.
Graphista · 27/01/2022 14:10

Just like YOPs and YTS from the thatcher years.

Yep!!

Op re customer service being shit now - don't even get me started! But it's not the agents at the "bottom of the rung" I blame it's the senior managers and accountants. The entry level staff can't do their job properly without proper training and support.

I'm also sick of the rigmarole it takes to escalate a complaint! You can't even speak to a supervisor at time of calling now it's "someone will call you back in 24-48 hours" except they don't!

I'd genuinely like an explanation of HOW treating employees so dreadfully is cost saving. Surely lack of retention, not being able to do the job properly, employees off with stress etc COSTS money (except of course when employers as I said before employ in such ways as to avoid having to treat employees as human beings!)

This is why EVERYONE working and middle class should be voting tories out! They are not doing you any favours!

I think Kickstarter schemes should be only available to organisations which offer quality work experience that they would be unable to offer without the scheme.

And not allowed to let the incumbent go JUST because the scheme has ended!

I hated Blair he wasnt labour but the difference between the JCP then and now couldnt be anymore stark, We cant get rid of the Tories quick enough I wish more people understood what they are doing.

Totally agree

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 13:45

@Parsley1234

DWP worker here it’s a total joke kickstart complete joke it is the most depressing time to be working in the department our managers have no idea senior managers even less. I took the job because I lost my businesses through Covid and I loved the first year now it’s totally totally awful we have 10 minute appointments what can you do in that time ? We have less than 40% retention of work coach staff taken on in Covid the sickness rates are going through the roof mainly stress and depression total farce
I feel for you, I was signing on back in the blair days it had its problems but there were things I think helped and were good ideas.

fast forward to 2017 I am back in the JCP and theres a few staff I see still there from the blair years, they have told me how awful it is that they are just piling more and more work onto fewer and fewer people and that ultimately they wanted to offload the JCP onto the private sector, but they had no takers so they want to just have everything online and signing on once a fortnight via those signing tablet things, that they want to install in council buildings so they can shut the JCPs and sack everyone. I heard the staff have repeatedly threatened strike action over a lot of the changes the Tories want and that it was an absolute shambles when they integrated HB into UC, with HB offices shut, JC staff getting a tiny bit of training and 1 member of HB staff relocated to JCP offices to act as the HB expert that other staff are expected to consult.

I hated Blair he wasnt labour but the difference between the JCP then and now couldnt be anymore stark, We cant get rid of the Tories quick enough I wish more people understood what they are doing.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 13:37

"Yeah so exactly the same as the Job start scheme here in NI. Employers get £1500 every time they hire someone new on the scheme, they only have to keep the employee 6 months (and then get another £1500 for next employee??) on 25 hours a week and the government cover the wage and the NI contributions. So essentially these employers are getting paid £3000 a year to have someone work for them. I wonder if there is a limit on how many of these employees an employer can have at one time? Theres potentially thousands to be made out of this scheme for employers."

says on that site there is no limit

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 13:34

*Yep...massive scam. You get a few good quality companies joining up and looking to help a young person get a start but for most part, you get free Labour for 6 months.

I work in a warehouse, there are a few young people on the Kickstarter scheme. They get a “special name” but they are doing the same work as every other picker in the warehouse 🙈 And it’s not like the company needs to hire via the scheme, they have agencies always hiring for them - it’s quite clearly a scam.

I think Kickstarter schemes should be only available to organisations which offer quality work experience that they would be unable to offer without the scheme.*

the last time I did something like that was new deal back in the blair days, I got a placement at wh smith, didnt want it, I insisted on charity placements as I knew it was a scam, but they didnt have any.

I spent 4 weeks alone in one of the basements of a store in west london, my entire point of being there was to clear out this store room full of VHS tapes and junk, put the new shelving system in it, and stack said shelving with the new CDs, dvds and games so they could use that room again. once the task was done I was sent back to the job centre who were pissed off that I had not been allowed on the tills or anything.

I hardly ever left the basement, if I went into the staff room for my breaks (hours and breaks were decided by the JSP) I was either alone in there as the staff breaks were different times (staff room was in the basement it was quite a maze down there and considered haunted in one particular area so no one set foot along one stretch of corridor that felt funny and a small storeroom that felt terrifying, the place was over 100 years old and a former theatre ) or if the manger saw me he would quiz me about if I really should be on break and he'd have to contact the JCP to check that.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 13:22

Genuinely want to know how it benefits employers to keep employees guessing at times until day before 1st shift of the week?!
Companies are run by accountants who obsessed with cost saving, which is prioritised above absolutely everything else.
This is also why customer service is so shit, but it makes for fat dividends and bonuses for the wealthy.

OP posts:
PickAChew · 27/01/2022 13:20

[quote VelvetChairGirl]oh.....

so it is that old chestnut again.

kickstart.campaign.gov.uk/[/quote]
Just like YOPs and YTS from the thatcher years.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 27/01/2022 13:17

This policy was announced today as part of a continuing strategy of redirecting people's anger towards those at the bottom rung of society rather than the immoral criminals in government

Yep, and I'm not falling for it. They need to stop being cowards and face the music. It's so desperate that it's making me cringe.

Parsley1234 · 27/01/2022 13:12

DWP worker here it’s a total joke kickstart complete joke it is the most depressing time to be working in the department our managers have no idea senior managers even less. I took the job because I lost my businesses through Covid and I loved the first year now it’s totally totally awful we have 10 minute appointments what can you do in that time ? We have less than 40% retention of work coach staff taken on in Covid the sickness rates are going through the roof mainly stress and depression total farce

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 13:11

@Seb342

Personally I think this is excellent news. As a retail manager hopefully it will cut down the time wasters that just turn up for an interview so they can tell the job centre they've attended but have no intention of actually taking the job. It's extremely frustrating when this happens and it happens a lot more often than people would believe so now they have to actually be in work after 4 weeks maybe they'll think twice about applying for positions they don't want and instead apply for something they can do and do actually want.
Good luck with that - from where I'm sitting it looks as if you'll get more time wasters.
OP posts:
RogerDodger · 27/01/2022 13:08

[quote VelvetChairGirl]oh.....

so it is that old chestnut again.

kickstart.campaign.gov.uk/[/quote]
Yeah so exactly the same as the Job start scheme here in NI. Employers get £1500 every time they hire someone new on the scheme, they only have to keep the employee 6 months (and then get another £1500 for next employee??) on 25 hours a week and the government cover the wage and the NI contributions. So essentially these employers are getting paid £3000 a year to have someone work for them. I wonder if there is a limit on how many of these employees an employer can have at one time? Theres potentially thousands to be made out of this scheme for employers.

Graphista · 27/01/2022 13:05

Posted too soon!

They sound very enthusiastic on the phone and get invited for interview but they don't turn up.

Some may be less than stellar and I agree they SHOULD call to cancel but I think it's possible

They got another job
They couldn't get or afford childcare or transport costs
They couldn't source suitable interview attire
Their confidence is shot from their experiences

Ultimately anyone can work in a pub

Nope!

Would you seriously expect someone disabled to do this job? Or someone with the experience of living with a violent alcoholic? Or if evening hours a single mum who can only get daytime Mon-Fri childcare? Or someone who can't access transport to the location? Who can't get home safely after an eve shift?...

Shocked to them read you @AlternativePerspective say YOU couldn't do a bar job so you KNOW not everyone can

ESA is no longer granted unless you’ve paid national insurance within the past two years who told you that?! I'm on ESA

Help to get disabled people into work is virtually non existent

On this we agree! The conversations I've had with work coaches who are supposedly experts in this have been so bad it's comically so!!

It traps people in a cycle of crap unstable jobs instead of being able to improve their circumstances yep

This policy was announced today as part of a continuing strategy of redirecting people's anger towards those at the bottom rung of society rather than the immoral criminals in government.

Exactly

"Don't look at us being morally corrupt bastards, look at the poor sods living on poverty levels of income who can't get a job"

Hmm

Tesco turned me down - I was available for immediate start, have no health issues etc but I couldn't pass their online selection questions (multiple choice).

I've had similar experiences

I don't know if it's the governments job to create the jobs

It is - as part of running a healthy economy

The myth of tories being good for the economy LONG since debunked

but I was shocked that there was no support.

How long ago were you dealing with all this?

some people are completely oblivious to how difficult it is to find work that fits around children when you're a single parent. I hope they never find themselves in that situation, but christ would it be an eye opener to them if they did.

Ohhh yes

Anyone who says it's a job be grateful needs to go and work in these places.

Yep!

But you don't just live on that UC tops your wage up so you're better off in work.

You actually been in this position?

Personally I think zero hours contracts should be illegal but unfortunately I don't see that happening

Not while a Tory govt keeps getting voted in for damn sure!

15 and 16 year olds looking for part time work are made to jump through hoops - assessments, 3 hour online workshops, 3 different interviews, presentations etc etc just to fucking work part time.

Yep and remember adults applying subjected to the same crap!

They're not job interviews they're stamina contests!

purpleme12 I'm so sorry you have that hanging over you

mintjulia you have a mortgage to pay - bully for you! Most on benefits can only DREAM of owning their home. It's a lot harder to get someone out of their owned home than a rented one!

Shelter estimates HALF of working renters are 2.5 pay days away from homelessness - god knows what the stats are for those not in employment!

Do you REALLY think those on benefits aren't ALSO anxious about paying their bills?!

Plus it's always a damn sight easier to get a job with current/recent work experience the longer you're out of work the harder it is to get a job

I think you get workers for free then let them go and get new trainee.

Yep this happens a lot. Also youngsters being "let go" when they hit a new nmw rate. Dd has just started a new job as previous let her go for spurious reasons we strongly suspect as she is due to turn 21 next month. She's been there 3 years without a single issue until now!

The whole system is stacked against the very people who are demonised as work shy

Yep, even my mum who is generally better at understanding how life works currently had a conversation with me about pub work. In her day pubs had mums working for them in the day shifts back then licensing hours meant pubs were only allowed open in the day for short periods of time - these times fit neatly within most school hours so perfect for mums. That culture has LONG gone. The pub industry now expects you to work whenever they ask you to! Days, evenings, weekends, split shifts, 7 days one week one the following... she's long been out the pub trade and didn't realise how much it had changed.

Personally I don't understand why employers don't want employees doing the same shifts each week surely it allows for greater reliability and less time spent poring over shift rotas trying to ensure coverage! (I've had roles where shifts had to be organised it's a pita to create shift rotas!) why on earth not have it mums can do school hours in day, students cover eve and weekends etc

Genuinely want to know how it benefits employers to keep employees guessing at times until day before 1st shift of the week?!

seb342 you do know those applicants were forced to apply and this is going to make that MORE the case not less shockingly naive and ignorant of you

the job centre really dont care if your applying for a drivers position when you dont have a license etc exactly!

Stop falling for the divide and conquer bullshit! This govt don't give a toss about you any more than they do for the applicants you're criticising!

Ever heard "there but by the grace of god"?

You're working now

Take it from me an accident, illness, bereavement, divorce etc can happen to ANYONE!

At 30 I was a healthy very fit (ran half marathons etc) married mum working in a well paid role with opportunities for progress...

At 35 I was a disabled single mum on benefits desperately applying for hundreds of jobs a week and getting nowhere!!

CaptainMarvelDanvers · 27/01/2022 13:04

[quote VelvetChairGirl]oh.....

so it is that old chestnut again.

kickstart.campaign.gov.uk/[/quote]
Yep...massive scam. You get a few good quality companies joining up and looking to help a young person get a start but for most part, you get free Labour for 6 months.

I work in a warehouse, there are a few young people on the Kickstarter scheme. They get a “special name” but they are doing the same work as every other picker in the warehouse 🙈 And it’s not like the company needs to hire via the scheme, they have agencies always hiring for them - it’s quite clearly a scam.

I think Kickstarter schemes should be only available to organisations which offer quality work experience that they would be unable to offer without the scheme.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 12:58

@Seb342

Personally I think this is excellent news. As a retail manager hopefully it will cut down the time wasters that just turn up for an interview so they can tell the job centre they've attended but have no intention of actually taking the job. It's extremely frustrating when this happens and it happens a lot more often than people would believe so now they have to actually be in work after 4 weeks maybe they'll think twice about applying for positions they don't want and instead apply for something they can do and do actually want.
they have to apply for positions they dont want or cant do there is a quota system I think on avarage they are expected to apply for 10 a week.

I get treated more leniently as I am a single mum of a sen kid I am expected to apply for 3 to 4 a week.

the job centre really dont care if your applying for a drivers position when you dont have a license etc they have applications targets to meet.

I always write my available hours on my cover letters now after getting a right bollocking from some recruiter in Co-op who treated me like shit and didnt understand why I had even applied if I couldnt work 7am to 11pm 7 days a week (said nothing of the hours in the advertisement except the over all number). if employers dont accept cover letters or have space to write availability in their application forms thats their problem, we all have our own lives.

Seb342 · 27/01/2022 12:51

Personally I think this is excellent news. As a retail manager hopefully it will cut down the time wasters that just turn up for an interview so they can tell the job centre they've attended but have no intention of actually taking the job. It's extremely frustrating when this happens and it happens a lot more often than people would believe so now they have to actually be in work after 4 weeks maybe they'll think twice about applying for positions they don't want and instead apply for something they can do and do actually want.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 12:43

oh.....

so it is that old chestnut again.

kickstart.campaign.gov.uk/

Swipe left for the next trending thread