Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stupid UC changes

230 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 08:36

So now you have 4 weeks to get a job you could actually do - then you just have to apply for anything/everything.

Every time we have a thread on here about recruitment, the HR wonks pop up and complain about all the "dross" applications from people not qualified for their wonderful opportunities - how will this help?

Rather than punishing people for lack of suitable vacancies it is time the goverment tried to help employers to offer more and better jobs.

OP posts:
BringBackThinEyebrows · 28/01/2022 06:37

@Oldsu so you'll know that your husband's workplace received £1500 for every Kickstart employee they took on, while getting 25 hours government-funded labour each week and that young person earns so little they still have to receive Universal Credit.

Kickstart roles could easily be entry level roles (warehouse, admin, cleaner, support worker etc.). A Kickstart placement lasts 6 months so it doesn't guarantee secure employment. If 'help with a CV' and 'training' are the benefits for Kickstart participants, that's depressing. Adequate training should be provided as standard for all roles.

Oldsu · 28/01/2022 01:04

@Cheekypeach

Hmmm.

If I’m being honest I don’t see any reason for somebody on UC to turn down a job they are capable of doing. I mean, why wouldn’t they take it? Unless I’m missing something?

Because a lot of them are scared to, they have always had the safety net of benefits where they get the same money without having to do much for it, I advise on several benefit boards on FB mainly to help older people but I see where people put up their journals showing what they get, the most common question is how many hours will I be made to work and still get my benefits , a lot are convinced if they work the DWP takes their wages, it takes a lot to convince them that they keep their wages but get less benefits and TBH that's the biggest complaint, although a lot will get a work allowance so they can earn a certain amount without their benefits being affected, most do see their benefits decreased when they work and they don't see why they should work just to get the same amount of money that they would have got in benefits, the people who know benefits on these boards usually do a calculation for them or point them in the direction of someone who can help but once they see financially they are not much better off by working they make it clear they don't want to do it, there is a lot of anger on these boards some (not all) is peoples expectations of what they think they should get.
oviraptor21 · 28/01/2022 00:47

if job centre dotn think you have tried enough can legally withdrawal all Income above your rent. Fab

At which point you request a hardship payment.

Oldsu · 28/01/2022 00:36

@Akire kick start does not work like that, my husbands company uses the scheme and I have seen the criteria, first of all the vacancy can only exist if you take people on the scheme, in other words it cant be a planned vacancy you cant replace an existing worker or cut someone's hours in order to take someone from the scheme, you have to commit to training and mentoring the candidate including helping with CV writing and giving access to training like e learning, my DH company had 9 on the scheme 7 got full time jobs at more than the living wage

purpleme12 · 28/01/2022 00:22

@Tealightsandd

I remember the days when people were trained on the job.

I had a Saturday retail job as a teen. Literally walked in whilst shopping - asked if they had any work going. The manager told me to turn up that Saturday to start working. Just like that.

Later as an office junior temp, I was sent into assignments without any previous experience. Like all the other office juniors and temps, I learnt on the job. Quickly picked it up - and if anybody couldn't get to grips they simply found more suitable alternative work, whilst the employer immediately got in a replacement.

Much simpler and better approach.

I wish this was the case too I don't understand how you're supposed to get your foot in the door for a lot of jobs if you can't get trained in the job if you don't have experience
PickAChew · 27/01/2022 23:57

@Beachbreak2411

There’s tons of jobs in hospitality etc. Why should people sit at home on their arse doing nothing and getting benefits just because they think they are too good to do the jobs availiable? There’s nothing stopping them continuing to apply and interview for the kind of jobs they want! 1000% a great decision by UC.
And a single parent finds childcare for those random evening shifts in Nandos just like that. Of course.
Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 23:51

I remember the days when people were trained on the job.

I had a Saturday retail job as a teen. Literally walked in whilst shopping - asked if they had any work going. The manager told me to turn up that Saturday to start working. Just like that.

Later as an office junior temp, I was sent into assignments without any previous experience. Like all the other office juniors and temps, I learnt on the job. Quickly picked it up - and if anybody couldn't get to grips they simply found more suitable alternative work, whilst the employer immediately got in a replacement.

Much simpler and better approach.

C152 · 27/01/2022 23:41

@thinking123

I know UC is hard and sanctions don't work, but, I walked round my town yesterday and I would say that easily three quarters of the shops/ cafes/ restaurants had signs up asking for staff. So there is work out there besides care work.

Obviously I know it's not everyone's first choice but it's a start

I agree that needs must and many of us have to take jobs that we don't particularly want in order to make ends meet.

However, it drives me nuts when people talk about, for example, the retail industry crying out for staff. They may very well be crying out for staff, but only experienced staff. I'd be willing to bet that 100% of the jobs you mention require industry-specific experience. Lots of new cafes have opened in my area and stuck a sign in the window advertising for staff (as have existing cafes / restaurants that managed to survive COVID) - I went in every single one to enquire about the position and was told every single time that they only wanted people with experience.

Allsorts1 · 27/01/2022 23:01

It’s absolutely terrible and cruel - three months is a sensible amount of time to give someone to search for a new role. 4 weeks is NOTHING! People pay tax so that they can be supported in times of need. This rule is just punishing and counter productive.

Beachbreak2411 · 27/01/2022 22:59

Nope.. I claimed UC (still do) and work in hospitality while I look for a job in what I really want to do.

BringBackThinEyebrows · 27/01/2022 22:57

@ItsCoachBombay

It's a very unfair system. Skilled workers being forced in to unskilled work or worse people who don't want to work being put in care jobs.

A friend of mine figured out a workaround, she took a 0 hour contract in a factory. UC were happy with this. She then really does stick to the flexibility of the contract, so she declined to work night shifts or shifts that didn't work for her. They couldn't fire her because that is the point of 0 hour contract, she literally now has like 1 shift a fortnight or 2, because they never put her on rota unless they really have to. She refuses to quit because she can't go through the palava of "job seeking again" But she gets her full UC claim paid without issue, UC work coach leaves her alone, and to be fair she seems to be doing ok.

What sector is your friend skilled in?
VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 22:57

*of

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 22:56

@Tealightsandd

Separately with jobseekers. Many employers discriminate against CV gaps and/or disablity/chronic illness. Also candidates are passed by for being 'overqualified' - plus age discrimination for the over 50s.

If the government genuinely wants to get people into work, they might have to consider introducing some form of positive discrimination. Obviously only for when the applicant meets the required qualifications and skills. Perhaps a quota.

As for the insecure lower paid jobs. The answer is obvious. These jobs are often essential but simply not valued enough. They need to improve pay and working conditions.

Finally, many people receiving UC are in full-time work. There's only so much an employer (particularly a smaller business) can afford to increase wages by, before going bust.

We need to deal with the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

More genuinely affordable housing (including to rent), and then people wouldn't need ever rising (but still not enough for rent/mortgage) wages.

they wont do that, they are a bunch o landlords.
KurtWilde · 27/01/2022 22:55

@Tealightsandd perfectly put.

Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 22:52

Separately with jobseekers. Many employers discriminate against CV gaps and/or disablity/chronic illness. Also candidates are passed by for being 'overqualified' - plus age discrimination for the over 50s.

If the government genuinely wants to get people into work, they might have to consider introducing some form of positive discrimination. Obviously only for when the applicant meets the required qualifications and skills. Perhaps a quota.

As for the insecure lower paid jobs. The answer is obvious. These jobs are often essential but simply not valued enough. They need to improve pay and working conditions.

Finally, many people receiving UC are in full-time work. There's only so much an employer (particularly a smaller business) can afford to increase wages by, before going bust.

We need to deal with the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

More genuinely affordable housing (including to rent), and then people wouldn't need ever rising (but still not enough for rent/mortgage) wages.

gogohm · 27/01/2022 22:49

@CaMePlaitPas

My dp has had no applications for a job paying £38k plus bonus (nor the other t2 vacancies bar one 17 year old with no qualifications who didn't even proof read her cv!) It's no just poorly paid work that's struggling to recruit.

He needs someone willing to travel and needs to be in the office because working from home didn't work, that seems to be the issue

KurtWilde · 27/01/2022 22:42

@XenoBitch it was only a matter of time before someone turned up to support these changes. I wonder if they're even affected by them?

These changes will essentially force people into jobs they're wholly unsuitable for. I've just been reading this evening that because of the vaccine mandate babies and new mothers may find their Health Visitors are replaced by people who aren't trained in that particular sector, so safeguarding and health issues may be overlooked as they won't have the knowledge to spot these things.

Now we have the DWP forcing people into roles - many of which will be care home jobs as they're in the most need of staff - that they have no previous experience and zero interest in doing. I have elderly relatives in care homes and I most certainly don't want them cared for by people who've only taken the job because they were forced into it or suffer sanctions.

The government is making some serious mistakes and yet here we have people defending it! The mind boggles.

Tealightsandd · 27/01/2022 22:39

If the government wants people in work, they need to put in place simple and easy infection control mitigations. (Masks, vaccine passes, good ventilation). Or else there will be an ever growing number of newly disabled Long Covid sufferers.

ItsCoachBombay · 27/01/2022 22:39

It's a very unfair system. Skilled workers being forced in to unskilled work or worse people who don't want to work being put in care jobs.

A friend of mine figured out a workaround, she took a 0 hour contract in a factory. UC were happy with this. She then really does stick to the flexibility of the contract, so she declined to work night shifts or shifts that didn't work for her. They couldn't fire her because that is the point of 0 hour contract, she literally now has like 1 shift a fortnight or 2, because they never put her on rota unless they really have to. She refuses to quit because she can't go through the palava of "job seeking again" But she gets her full UC claim paid without issue, UC work coach leaves her alone, and to be fair she seems to be doing ok.

VelvetChairGirl · 27/01/2022 22:33

@Beachbreak2411

There’s tons of jobs in hospitality etc. Why should people sit at home on their arse doing nothing and getting benefits just because they think they are too good to do the jobs availiable? There’s nothing stopping them continuing to apply and interview for the kind of jobs they want! 1000% a great decision by UC.
why is it always on the job seeker?

do you really think every employer out there is throwing contracts at everyone who walks in the door?

its the employers who choose to give jobs to people or not and obviously 99.9% of the time they choose not to.

XenoBitch · 27/01/2022 22:31

@Beachbreak2411

There’s tons of jobs in hospitality etc. Why should people sit at home on their arse doing nothing and getting benefits just because they think they are too good to do the jobs availiable? There’s nothing stopping them continuing to apply and interview for the kind of jobs they want! 1000% a great decision by UC.
Invariably said by someone who has never claimed UC or worked in hospitality in their life.
KurtWilde · 27/01/2022 22:29

@Beachbreak2411

There’s tons of jobs in hospitality etc. Why should people sit at home on their arse doing nothing and getting benefits just because they think they are too good to do the jobs availiable? There’s nothing stopping them continuing to apply and interview for the kind of jobs they want! 1000% a great decision by UC.
Oh get a clue.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 22:12

@Beachbreak2411

There’s tons of jobs in hospitality etc. Why should people sit at home on their arse doing nothing and getting benefits just because they think they are too good to do the jobs availiable? There’s nothing stopping them continuing to apply and interview for the kind of jobs they want! 1000% a great decision by UC.
Have you read any of the previous posts or did you just copy and paste from ignoramus handbook?
OP posts:
Beachbreak2411 · 27/01/2022 22:07

There’s tons of jobs in hospitality etc. Why should people sit at home on their arse doing nothing and getting benefits just because they think they are too good to do the jobs availiable? There’s nothing stopping them continuing to apply and interview for the kind of jobs they want! 1000% a great decision by UC.

TerraNovaTwo · 27/01/2022 21:53

The only reason there are 'loads of jobs going' is because of Brexit. A skilled worker shouldn't be forced into unskilled work just because the government can't frigging sort out the job market. The economy is screwed.