Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stupid UC changes

230 replies

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 27/01/2022 08:36

So now you have 4 weeks to get a job you could actually do - then you just have to apply for anything/everything.

Every time we have a thread on here about recruitment, the HR wonks pop up and complain about all the "dross" applications from people not qualified for their wonderful opportunities - how will this help?

Rather than punishing people for lack of suitable vacancies it is time the goverment tried to help employers to offer more and better jobs.

OP posts:
Graphista · 28/01/2022 19:00

I've had a number of them approach me for advice, to ask if the difficulties they are experiencing are normal (one memorably called me the DAY after she had completed her application querying why she'd not YET had a response!

her reaction when I told her it would likely be several weeks if not MONTHS until she heard ANYTHING and that in all likelihood at that point she would be told she'd not included essential info/evidence and that they wouldn't even look at her claim until she sent that in she was like "what?! That cannot be right you're having me on!" - reader it was 3.5 months before they got back to her! Despite her and I and a welfare advisor chasing!)

At the start of the pandemic before furlough etc became a "thing" there were a number of mn posters posting threads or replying on threads that were having to claim for the first time themselves. They were OUTRAGED that:

They weren't allowed savings above £6k

They wouldn't get their mortgage paid in full

They were expected to cut back on outgoings that Dwp etc would class as luxuries but which they didn't (clothes shopping, leisure activities like kids hobbies etc)

They wouldn't be allowed to just wait until their usual employer resumed business

They had to complete the same application and submit the same evidence as other benefit claimants (eg "why have I got to submit my bank statements?! It's none of their business what I buy")

They were subjected to the same waiting periods

And yes...that if they were now unemployed they were expected to apply for and take any job they were capable of!!

The arguments were quite comically elitist "but I'm allowed to keep savings intended for a house deposit aren't I? That's not included in the savings threshold"

It really was quite something! And yes they mostly DID get their arses handed to them by those of us dealing with this crap for years!!

VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 18:57

So how are these not things that would have been advertised as vacancies before?

" Summary

To apply for this job, you must be claiming Universal Credit and 16 to 24 years old.

EMPLOYER
Juniper Uniform Ltd

JOB SUMMARY
The vast majority of items of school uniform have a logo either embroidered or printed on to them.

Whilst the bulk of our stock arrives already embroidered, we still do a significant amount of this work in-house.

Your job will be to apply embroidery and prints to items of school uniform using commercial embroidery machines and heat-presses.

If you have a creative flair you will also have the opportunity to put this to good use as part of our prospective new area of business.

We are a well-established and expanding schoolwear specialist.

With the exception of a couple of oldies (who are still seriously youthful!) we are a young and fun team.

We are efficient and organised and have a reputation for excellent customer service; we are keen to find someone to join us who will benefit from our knowledge and experience and who will enjoy their time with us.

Schoolwear is a hugely seasonal industry so be prepared for a busy summer!

SKILLS NEEDED
We are looking for someone who is:-

enthusiastic
conscientious
punctual
curious
willing to muck-in
a bit of a perfectionist
happy working as part of a close-knit team
preferably computer-literate but, if not, willing to learn.

An eye to detail is a must!

Grade C GCSE (or equivalent) Maths and English preferential not essential.

No experience necessary as full training will be given.

WORKING HOURS
Flexible days - Flexible hours to be discussed at interview

HOURLY RATE
National Minimum Wage

ADDITIONAL EMPLOYABILITY SUPPORT
You will:-

Learn how to safely use commercial embroidery machines, printer/cutters and heat presses;
Become familiar with specialist software packages to include Wilcom, CorelDraw/Illustrator;
Receive guidance on how to prioritise your time and work efficiently;
Learn how to work as part of a close-knit team.

You will also receive professional, third-party coaching and mentoring and be taught how to write an effective CV. "

VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 18:54

this one too, looks like a job

Summary

To apply for this job, you must be claiming Universal Credit and 16 to 24 years old.

EMPLOYER
Johns&Co Real Estate (services) Limited

JOB SUMMARY
This is a sales role and will involve lots of calling out to databases, some will be warm leads and some cold leads. This role is focused on business and lead generation.

JOHNS&CO- Making you feel at home since 2013.

We are a specialist agent for the premium New Homes and Luxury Real Estate markets who also have a portfolio of more traditional properties. We service Investors, Tenants, Vendors and Buyers in the UK and have international offices and a large presence in Singapore, Hong Kong and Shanghai.

Our people are the core of everything we do and why we have been so successful over the last 8 years. Yes you heard it right, 11 offices in 8 years (we must be doing something right hey?!)

SKILLS NEEDED

  • Confident personality
  • Sales skills
  • Happy to cold call
  • Can speak with confidence
  • Resilient
  • Loves working to targets

WORKING HOURS
25hrs per week. Flexible days - Flexible hours

VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 18:53

This kinda does look like a just a rebranded job. and the GOV website states you get paid and the wage is covered by DWP.

" Summary

To apply for this job, you must be claiming Universal Credit and 16 to 24 years old.

EMPLOYER
PARTAP FASHION FABRICS LIMITED

JOB SUMMARY
Sorting and packing orders. This includes receiving, and handling communication between freight companies and suppliers.
Responsible for the data entry and inventory of all stock.

SKILLS NEEDED
Ability to work in a team, communication skills both written and verbal.

WORKING HOURS
2.5 Days per week"

Oldsu · 28/01/2022 18:28

[quote BringBackThinEyebrows]@Oldsu so you'll know that your husband's workplace received £1500 for every Kickstart employee they took on, while getting 25 hours government-funded labour each week and that young person earns so little they still have to receive Universal Credit.

Kickstart roles could easily be entry level roles (warehouse, admin, cleaner, support worker etc.). A Kickstart placement lasts 6 months so it doesn't guarantee secure employment. If 'help with a CV' and 'training' are the benefits for Kickstart participants, that's depressing. Adequate training should be provided as standard for all roles.[/quote]
@BringBackThinEyebrows did you read my post, my DH company and other companies on the scheme do not get paid and then get government funded labour INSTEAD of recruiting the normal way and paying the staff, they are not allowed to use people on the scheme to fill existing or planned vacancies , the vacancy can only exist for one purpose and that is to take someone on the scheme, nor can they replace existing staff or cut existing staff hours to take people on the scheme and they don't, they are a very ethical company

Why is it depressing that training is given on CV writing, obviously you wouldn't train someone who applied the usual way, but some of the young people on the scheme have never had an interview where they have submitted their CV, actually getting help writing one for these young people is something that actually helps them, and again if you apply for an admin position you should have adequate training for that position, but with DH company the young people are extra to the workforce, therefore they can rotate between different departments and have training in different departments and yes it does help. And I mentioned e learning some of those modules are tough even with my vast work experience I struggled myself with some of them so the training is actually good.

Yes it doesn't guarantee full time work which is why my DH company are rather pleased that they could offer 7 out of 9 young people not only full time work but at a rate which is currently higher than the new living wage coming into force in April, of course they may still have to claim UC, but people of all ages are working and claiming, its a sad fact of life.

ItsCoachBombay · 28/01/2022 14:29

@BringBackThinEyebrows I don't know exactly but she's skilled in Media and Public relations, before she was made redundant she was junior management level. She's just waiting for the jobs that go with her degree to open up again.

CroftPlace · 28/01/2022 14:16

Brexit has impacted.
Schools locally are desperate for support staff - admin, cooks, teaching assistants, cleaners, caretakers. My key staff have returned to Poland.

Wage rises to attract employees can't happen. It is a catch22. These school support jobs are public sector jobs. Tory government is cutting funds to local authorities. School budgets are in deficit. (2/3 schools in my LA). Wages can't rise because the government isn't providing any more funding.

VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 14:15

[quote Acidburn]@daimbarsatemydogsbone are you expecting people on the anonymous forum to let you know the names and home addresses of people who dodge the benefit system? If you never met them personally- it doesn't mean they don't exist. Its just they don't broadcast that to everyone. I personally know the following people:

  • a family on benefits here in the Uk, he works, she is a stay at home mum. They are immigrants. In 10 years they lived here - they managed to buy 2 properties in cheap Eastern Europe and renting them out now
  • a lad who is a self employed kitchen installer, who does not declare his money in full and takes home approx 5k a month. Also lives at his wife's property, while renting out his own house room by room, making approx 3k a month. While his mortgage doesn't allow that. Also he's got a Blue Badge due to his mum being disabled, but he drives the car without her most of the time and obviously parks at Disabled space
  • another self employed lad, he is a plummer. He makes approx 60k a year, but he dodges his taxes in a way that he barely pays any tax return.
All these people brag to me about these things, because I know them closely for years, but obviously not so many people do.[/quote] All the more reason to stop attacking the unemployed and to focus of corporate/business fraud then.
VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 14:12

@LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee

A good number of posters are talking as if most jobseekers were single parents with no family to help and/or children with SN that can’t use school clubs or childcare. Whilst this might be the case for some (and would definitely limit the jobs they could do), I truly believe that most people could work around their partners / ex / parents etc so for example working nights when your partner works days. Or weekends. Or weekdays and your DC go to breakfast club and afternoon club. A lot of working parents have to juggle childcare and find last minute solution for sickness, appointments etc.

As to the jobs available, a huge number of shops/restaurants are advertising vacancies, as soon as someone recommends a cleaner on Nextdoor they have 10+ people saying they are looking for a good cleaner (£12/h), same for handymen.
I really think you should take whatever is available even if it means sacrificing your evenings / weekends and continue looking for a job in your field at the same time.

You cant just walk into a job, stop talking as if people are not trying.
VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 14:07

[quote Acidburn]@VelvetChairGirl Smile I have no intention of leaving, I'm quite good here actually. Also I am not complaining about UC being cut, because I am not claiming any. You, however, are free to go and live elsewhere for a few years just for comparison - just to realise how lucky you are to be born in this country where you have at least some help.[/quote]
very tory of you, when you run out of worse places you can compare us to will you start looking up and trying to improve stuff or continue circling the gutter telling people it could be worse, be grateful your not dead etc.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/01/2022 13:50

[quote Acidburn]@daimbarsatemydogsbone what difference does it make if they work or not as long as they find a way not to contribute into the system?[/quote]
It's still cheating and wrong - no argument from me on that.

What is not is evidence of people sitting around on benefits not working.

OP posts:
Player20868 · 28/01/2022 13:49

@Acidburn I'm very happy it worked out for you. Bit tricky though if you live in a town where neither of those companies operate and where, on a good day, it will take you at least 45 minues each way (and a heck of a lot of pennies) to get to the next nearest town of any size? Still, we've lots of care homes. What could possibly go wrong with forcing people unsuited to care work to take up a post in that industry, I wonder...

@daimbarsatemydogsbone - you have a category of people who just don't want to work full stop. And they never will.
^This always gets trotted out.
It must obviously have a grain of truth - but in reality how prevalent is it?^

There are plenty of them strutting round Westminster at the moment (in the physical or virtual workplace), that's for sure...including the "Honorable" member for Suffolk Coastal....

Having been sitting pretty for the last 12 years with her big fat MP's expenses account she just may not have a particularly clear grasp of the issues facing, y'know, ordinary people...like most frothing-at-the-mouth-poor-people-loathing readers of the Daily Mail/Daily Express (hard to choose between them, they both use the same press agencies anyway).

And anyone who'd like to see what the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions thinks of us peasants only needs to look at her voting record www.theyworkforyou.com/mp/24771/therese_coffey/suffolk_coastal/votes

Personally I miss the days when you could study a City and Guilds or other vocational course at FE colleges to help better yourself, as my dad did - oh look, something else the Tories got rid of. God knows, I loathed Thatcher with a passion, but I'm coming to the conclusion that this lot, and their devoted supporters, must be a bunch of aliens, they seem to hate the rest of humanity so much.

Acidburn · 28/01/2022 13:45

@daimbarsatemydogsbone what difference does it make if they work or not as long as they find a way not to contribute into the system?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/01/2022 13:36

[quote Acidburn]@daimbarsatemydogsbone are you expecting people on the anonymous forum to let you know the names and home addresses of people who dodge the benefit system? If you never met them personally- it doesn't mean they don't exist. Its just they don't broadcast that to everyone. I personally know the following people:

  • a family on benefits here in the Uk, he works, she is a stay at home mum. They are immigrants. In 10 years they lived here - they managed to buy 2 properties in cheap Eastern Europe and renting them out now
  • a lad who is a self employed kitchen installer, who does not declare his money in full and takes home approx 5k a month. Also lives at his wife's property, while renting out his own house room by room, making approx 3k a month. While his mortgage doesn't allow that. Also he's got a Blue Badge due to his mum being disabled, but he drives the car without her most of the time and obviously parks at Disabled space
  • another self employed lad, he is a plummer. He makes approx 60k a year, but he dodges his taxes in a way that he barely pays any tax return.
All these people brag to me about these things, because I know them closely for years, but obviously not so many people do.[/quote] And where the examples of people who don't want to work in nay of that? Sure people are fiddling - but none of those are sitting on their arse claiming benefits all day dodging work which is the claim I was actually talking about. You're talking about different issues.
OP posts:
Acidburn · 28/01/2022 13:28

@daimbarsatemydogsbone are you expecting people on the anonymous forum to let you know the names and home addresses of people who dodge the benefit system? If you never met them personally- it doesn't mean they don't exist. Its just they don't broadcast that to everyone. I personally know the following people:

  • a family on benefits here in the Uk, he works, she is a stay at home mum. They are immigrants. In 10 years they lived here - they managed to buy 2 properties in cheap Eastern Europe and renting them out now
  • a lad who is a self employed kitchen installer, who does not declare his money in full and takes home approx 5k a month. Also lives at his wife's property, while renting out his own house room by room, making approx 3k a month. While his mortgage doesn't allow that. Also he's got a Blue Badge due to his mum being disabled, but he drives the car without her most of the time and obviously parks at Disabled space
  • another self employed lad, he is a plummer. He makes approx 60k a year, but he dodges his taxes in a way that he barely pays any tax return.
All these people brag to me about these things, because I know them closely for years, but obviously not so many people do.
D1n0F0uraus · 28/01/2022 13:22

Let's face it some people are lazy !
Not everyone has caring responsibilities

I know people that don't work, for whatever reason

It is always easier to get another job, when you are already employed or are flexible

Acidburn · 28/01/2022 13:15

@LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee i agree with every word. If people look for reasons why they can't do something - they will always find them, that is a fact.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 28/01/2022 13:06

A good number of posters are talking as if most jobseekers were single parents with no family to help and/or children with SN that can’t use school clubs or childcare.
Whilst this might be the case for some (and would definitely limit the jobs they could do), I truly believe that most people could work around their partners / ex / parents etc so for example working nights when your partner works days. Or weekends. Or weekdays and your DC go to breakfast club and afternoon club.
A lot of working parents have to juggle childcare and find last minute solution for sickness, appointments etc.

As to the jobs available, a huge number of shops/restaurants are advertising vacancies, as soon as someone recommends a cleaner on Nextdoor they have 10+ people saying they are looking for a good cleaner (£12/h), same for handymen.
I really think you should take whatever is available even if it means sacrificing your evenings / weekends and continue looking for a job in your field at the same time.

RaininSummer · 28/01/2022 13:05

This 'change' has not been reported well. Hardly any people have a 13 week permitted period to look for a particular job. It only applies to those with a strong work history in a niche sector really.

People are indeed expected to apply for anything they can do but this includes working around barriers such as health and childcare if after school and nursery can't be used.

I don't think it's unreasonable to be asked to make finding a job your main focus if being out of work and able to work is why you claim public money . Get a job then look for a better job is surely what you do if needing to earn.

Acidburn · 28/01/2022 13:04

@VelvetChairGirl Smile I have no intention of leaving, I'm quite good here actually. Also I am not complaining about UC being cut, because I am not claiming any. You, however, are free to go and live elsewhere for a few years just for comparison - just to realise how lucky you are to be born in this country where you have at least some help.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 28/01/2022 12:57

Plus - you have a category of people who just don't want to work full stop. And they never will.
This always gets trotted out.
It must obviously have a grain of truth - but in reality how prevalent is it?
All I ever see are sketchy stories about "someone I know" or "people around here" - I personally don't believe there are significant numbers of people doing this.

OP posts:
Doggydreaming · 28/01/2022 12:56

A few years ago I was made redundant at the end of my maternity leave. I signed on to contributory JSA. At my last appointment, I told them I had a job lined up in 10 days time and was asked 'what are you doing to find work in the meantime?' Errr. Nothing? I'm spending the next 10 days settling my child into childcare and trying to scrape together a work wardrobe before I start my new job (that you cunts did nothing to help me get).

I was told that I had to look for temporary work during this 10 day period or I would lose my benefits!

I've been working full time ever since in my full time, stable, civil service role, claiming no benefits! The only reason I coul get such a role is because I had a whole 5 months to look for something suitable rather than taking the first job I saw!

VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 12:54

@Acidburn

So much outrage, it's hilarious. Do people actually realise that lots of other countries don't even have benefits enough to survive? That if you are disabled / single parent / carer and have legit reasons not to work - you are on your own? It is absolutely tragic, but it is a reality for many. And here you've got thousands of people who think they are entitled to any state help just because they would have to properly rearrange their life in order to facilitate working. I once lost my high paying job and the next one would only start in 4 months time. So meanwile I had to work 2 minimum wage jobs, one from 7am to 11am, and another from 12am to 10pm. And I have a Masters degree from a prestigious uni. But I had to do it, because I needed money. Meanwhile in the restaurant where I worked - there was a 24 year old girl with a kid, who only worked 16 hours a week so they don't cut her benefits. Her mum was watching the kid everyday, plus her boyfriend lives with her pretty much the whole time, in her lovely 2 bed council flat - but of course she never declared that. So on paper - she was a poor single mum who hardly gets by, but in practice- she had a great secure housing, free childcare, minimum work and money coming into her bank account weekly. Why would she want to work more?
No they think they are entitled to state help because that is how our system has worked for over 80 years and is what we and our parents and grand parents before us both voted for and pay our taxes for.

as they say if you dont like it, leave.

and its not state help, its social security, the state works for us, thats how its meant to be, thats how its written up.

Doggydreaming · 28/01/2022 12:48

YANBU. It would be much better for the DWP to help people find secure, suitable, long term work than just force people to take the next zero hours, minimum wage shite that will have the government propping up their wages with benefits/ back in the dole queue in a few weeks. It's short term thinking.

Ask the older generation and they will tell you of a time when the job centre actually shock HELPED you find a job. Not just applied sanctions to people for being unemployed.

VelvetChairGirl · 28/01/2022 12:46

@D1n0F0uraus

As a tax payer myself, I want other people to work if possible (not including poor health) Work is not just about money, but social interaction too

I've walked or cycled to work, when I had no transport

I've worked 3 different jobs at once

no you did not work 3 jobs at once.

I walk to my sons school in the afternoon it takes 45mins, train takes 10mins, imagine how much money you lose when you have restricted hours you are available to work because you have children.

and then people wonder why women are putting off having kids later and later and having less children, its because we know we will be screwed over by the world of work once we become mothers.